Where have all the heroines gone?

Take a look at television these days. What do you see?  Teenage girls getting pregnant and allowing MTV to capture the train wreck on-camera. “Girls” in their mid-twenties getting drunk on the sand of the Jersey Shore. Perhaps even a Playmate or two — or at least a former playmate who’s trying to make a go of it in Las Vegas.

No offense to the cast of Teen Mom 2, Jersey Shore or Holly’s World, but these women aren’t what most would consider icons. An icon is something different. An icon is a woman who is empowered, intelligent and strives to overcome impossible odds to help others. Not since Sarah Michelle Gellar’s Buffy the Vampire Slayer or Jennifer Garner’s ALIAS have there been women that didn’t just play their characters, but truly embodied them.

Little by little, after the year 2003 or so, the icons disappeared. With the exception of Detective Olivia Benson on Law & Order: SVU, there simply aren’t any women who come close to matching the glory of Sarah Michelle Gellar or Jennifer Garner. Is that a bad thing? Yes — because what’s currently presented to young girls on television just isn’t acceptable.

Bella Swan, quite possibly the most popular female character to young girls in modern culture over on the movie screens, is far from independent and doesn’t even appear to have any redeeming qualities. What is really known about the girl from Forks, Washington, other than her obsession with a sparkling vampire? And this isn’t to say that a female icon must shun romantic partnerships altogether. Sydney Bristow had Michael Vaughn, Buffy had Angel, and aside from when Angel turned into Angelus, both of those relationships were still healthier than most.

Sydney and Buffy loved their men. They accepted their help when it makes sense. But none of these women needed their partners to sustain a meaningful existence.

Based on the paragraphs above, one might think that the current state of women on television is rather unrewarding. Then, seemingly out of nowhere, the rumors began. Online, there was a collective groan from much of the comic fandom regarding the possibility of Wonder Woman returning to television. Could anyone truly upstage the magnificent Lynda Carter? And would the director be able to pay tribute to the source material while updating the mythos for today’s audiences?

NBC is betting “yes.” The pilot is currently shooting in Los Angeles, with Adrianne Palicki in the title role and Elizabeth Hurley as her nemesis. Photos have circulated online of Adrienne in full costume: red boots, blue tights, silver wrist gauntlets and of course, her golden lasso. Reaction to the series thus far has been mixed. A leaked script didn’t help matters either — particularly when it came to certain traits that Wonder Woman (aka Diana Themyscira) now has.

Lip-synching to Katy Perry while using a hairbrush as a microphone? What were the writers thinking?!

And yet, the return of Wonder Woman is an excellent opportunity to put quite possibly the original female icon back on television and in front of the masses. After years of Bella Swan, Snooki and the Kardashian sisters, Palicki could usher in a new wave of female icons to show girls that your sense of self-worth isn’t determined by your hair, clothes, ability to binge drink or, most importantly, whether or not a man likes you.

In order for Wonder Woman to reach today’s audiences, she would need to be strong yet relatable. I’m willing to bet that more than a few girls have lip-synched to Katy Perry at one time or another. And yes, allow Wonder Woman to pursue romantic relationships. Given her character’s god-like strength and extensive fighting training, it’s not as if any mortal man could really pose a threat to her.

In order words, Wonder Woman having a boyfriend would show girls what a healthy relationship is like. The man should not wield all the power. If it takes an Amazon from the island of Themyscira to articulate that to audiences, so be it.

One would hope that the negativity surrounding the series doesn’t prevent its success. Costumes can be augmented, scripts rewritten and consultants from DC Comics hired to ensure that the show remains faithful to the source material. But simply put, young girls deserve better. They need better. Stop giving them Snooki and let them see something inspirational for a change.

And who knows. If Wonder Woman is a success this fall, it very well might change the television landscape for the better. Just as raunch entertainment was ushered in, it can be pushed right back out.

Share.

10 Comments

  1. First Evil on

    Overall I agree with all of your points but you stepped into some hairy areas here. Most of all the Twilight and True Blood fans (though I am neither) wont be too happy about the not so kind words about Bella and Sooki.

    Also you kind of forgot Nina Dobrevs Elena character from the Vampire Diaries. Isnt she a strong female protagonist on Television these days?

    The biggest no no for me however as a die hard Buffy fan is to assume that Angel is “the one” for Buffy. Cause that is hotly debated in the fandom. Because there is another major contender for that role in her life: Spike. It was never made clear in the end who of the both is the one for Buffy. especially if you consider the current situation in the Season 8/Season 9 comic books. Plus Angel was only there for the first three seasons while Spikes story (which eventually became quite a powerful lovestory) was considerably longer on the Buffy-show and in the end Buffy DID love him before he sacrificed himself for her. Also considering how much Spike loved Buffy and what he did for her (getting himself a soul no less!) many see Spike as the true and more worthy love for Buffy then Angel. A recent poll on the site of Dark Horse comics where the subject was Spike vs Angel was won with flying colours by Spike who had several hundred more votes then Angel.

    So as a huge Buffy/Spike-fan for many years it was kind of a kick in the stomach when you declared Buffy/Angel as the no.1 love in the Buffyverse while that subject is very hotly debated in the fandom until this day and its not clear at all if Angel or Spike are the “true one” for Buffy ad its kind of painful that you completely left Spike out in your little synopsis about Buffys most significant romantic relationship. And I just felt I had to point that out because this is a very sensible and delicate subject among the Buffy fandom. And especially us Spike-fans could get kinda enraged by what you wrote.

    Plus Buffys and Angels relationship was indeed unhealthy – which is the whole reason why Angel left her in the end and built himself a new life in LA. his relationship with Cordelia (on Angel) was much more healthy then the one he had with Buffy. And I do think (though thats just my own opinion) that her relationship with Spike on Season 7 was also more healthy then the one she had with Angel. Even her relationship with Riley on Season 4 and 5 was WAY more healthy then the one she had with Angel. Buffy and Angel had an intense,powerful relationship. But I wouldnt really call it healthy.

    Also I´d like to point out that there is another very iconic female character on Buffy which is Willow who was perfectly embodied by Alyson Hannigan. She had to go through some very intense stuff too and was even more powerful then Buffy. And she had some very interesting relationships with Oz and Tara and was teaching the audience about equality by putting her in a gay relationship which was a huge thing back in the day.

    But apart from these things I thought you had some very good points and I agree with a lot of it. Todays TV truly needs female icons again. Even though I believe Buffy was such a unique creation that it simply can never be repeated or replaced.

    As a big fan of Wonder Woman I am very optimistic and hopeful for that show as well to bring that female empowerment back on the little screen.

  2. Bella doesn’t even compare to Buffy. I don’t watch Twilight but from what I’ve read about her character, she is the weakest female heroine ever.

    the portrayal of women is even worse in soap operas (I know, I watch the Bold and the Beautiful and the Young and the Restless). Granted, all the characters are flawed but the female characters never stay alone for very long. before you know it, they’re hitting the sheets with the next available guy.

    then, I see stuff like Gossip Girl and the intrigue of who’s sleeping with who? It could be because high school drama is long past for me in real life — but I really do not care to see it on TV.

    that’s why I’m praying this reboot of Wonder Woman gets the proper treatment. And it’s not, who’s she with this week? I’m sick and tired of that crap. I get enough of that watching my soaps.

  3. oh, you forgot Xena which was on around the same time of Buffy, I believe. she was the Greek heroine — who I believe for a time after the show ended — was a fan favorite for Wonder Woman for obvious reasons.

  4. and if you’re looking into movies, there’s a lot there too. Ripley from the Aliens series. you didn’t want to get into a fight with her. and Sarah Conner from the Terminator series (especially in the second movie).

    and Princess Leia. she wasn’t your typical damsel in distress.

  5. Jason Ginenthal on

    Great points thus far, everyone.

    For the record, I watched Xena and appreciate her place in the grand tradition of female icons. And yes, I’m a fan of Elena (and Bonnie, for that matter!) on The Vampire Diaries.

    The movie world offers a slew of strong women as well. And that’s not to say one needs to be an ass-kicking femme fatale to be iconic. Need I mention Jodi Foster in The Silence of the Lambs? :)

    Keep the comments coming, folks. And feel free to follow & Tweet on me Twitter at @JGinenthal

    Thanks,
    Jason

  6. Great points here but I think you might be losing the overall premise of why television shows nowadays are gearing toward reality train wrecks and that is RATINGS. Personally I do watch Teen Mom 2 and 16 and Pregnant to inform myself of what is going on in the world and how I can teach my female students that this is NOT the way of life you want. Also as a fan of Twilight, I do agree with your opinion on Bella and Edward. All she wants to do is make sure her man is happy…what about her feelings and life? Does that not matter? As I said, great piece here and I am very optimistic for the new Wonder Woman to change the tide of how women are portrayed on current television. Please do not forget Abby on NCIS as well.

    XOXO,
    Danielle
    itisajoiseywayofthinking.blogspot.com

  7. Shows like “The Good Wife” and “The Killing” are full of strong, smart women. Same goes for “”Mad Men” and “Friday Night Lights”. You need to try to expand your television palate.

  8. i tell every one this they lost out on not making buffy no more as the storys in the comic now are amazing . i have also just brought the season 8 motion comic dvd / blu-ray , i just wonder if there started now on a season 8 for tv if theyu would think whoops……… we have made a mistake not doing it sooner as there is still a very high demand for it same as charmed , smallville and other but please please let them BRING BUFFY BACK :(

  9. I think that its not because we don’t have a kick ass heroine like Buffy or Xena on the air, it doesnt mean we don’t have heroines. I just started watcing Body of Proof and Dr. Hunt is a strong heroine. She is smart, confident and the way she acts and talks, even the way she dresses some times reminds me of Buffy. She is not on the streets fighting vampires and demons, she is doing autopsies and investigating crimes but the energy the character carries is very good. So, we do have good heroines, we just need to look better.

Exit mobile version