Thanks to Vergon6 for bringing up the idea of animated films based on Bryan Q Miller's Smallville Season 11 storylines, I wondered if some day there was to be a continuation of Smallville would people here watch it and what form would they like it to be in and am now posting this thread with a poll to gauge the interests of the users of Ksite.
I'd like to throw out some ideas about forms such an undertaking can have:
1. Periodic releases in the forms of other DC comics based films like Batman: Under The Red Hood, Batman: The Killing Joke, Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Superman: Doomsday, etc.
2. A prime time animated series featuring 1 hour episodes with adult themes (violence, blood, etc) much like Smallville was in its 10 season tenure.
3. An animated program with tamer plots that kids could watch that would be shown on weekends or weekday afternoons with episodes that are either 30 min or 1 hour
My personal pick would be #2, but I realize that animated series cost a lot these days unless they look like the horrible stuff you see on certain kid targeting networks, stuff like Teen Titans Go, ugh. I doubt we can ever get animation of the quality of Batman: TAS or those DC/WB films based on comics storylines on a weekly basis. So with that in mind, I wouldn't mind #1.
The main thing is, would it still have appeal? Has it been too long since the end of the series to revive it in such a way? My own gut instinct tells me that Smallville will never be revived in any form, but I guess stranger things have happened. I think they brought back a Full House sequel series on Netflicks and that show had been off the air for way longer. I do think that it it ever does happen it would be on Netflicks or some similar service.
If a return would happen, what would they even call it? My guess is if it returned as an animated series with 1 hour episodes, it would continue as season 11 where some storylines could be taken from the season 11 comics, but I'm betting not all the stories in the comics would be carried over to TV, so it would also have new plot elements that were never seen in the comics because they would have to cater to shippers (if they would even want to watch an animated series). If it would be brought back in periodic films that would be released, then they would probably just name the films based on certain storylines from the season 11 comics as opposed to calling them Season 11 Part 1, Season 11 Part 2, and so on.
What do you guys think? Would you even be interested in a continuation of the series? Which form would you prefer to see it in? Like I said, I have no hope or expectations of this happening but instead just wondering what others here want/think about this.
I'd like to throw out some ideas about forms such an undertaking can have:
1. Periodic releases in the forms of other DC comics based films like Batman: Under The Red Hood, Batman: The Killing Joke, Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Superman: Doomsday, etc.
2. A prime time animated series featuring 1 hour episodes with adult themes (violence, blood, etc) much like Smallville was in its 10 season tenure.
3. An animated program with tamer plots that kids could watch that would be shown on weekends or weekday afternoons with episodes that are either 30 min or 1 hour
My personal pick would be #2, but I realize that animated series cost a lot these days unless they look like the horrible stuff you see on certain kid targeting networks, stuff like Teen Titans Go, ugh. I doubt we can ever get animation of the quality of Batman: TAS or those DC/WB films based on comics storylines on a weekly basis. So with that in mind, I wouldn't mind #1.
The main thing is, would it still have appeal? Has it been too long since the end of the series to revive it in such a way? My own gut instinct tells me that Smallville will never be revived in any form, but I guess stranger things have happened. I think they brought back a Full House sequel series on Netflicks and that show had been off the air for way longer. I do think that it it ever does happen it would be on Netflicks or some similar service.
If a return would happen, what would they even call it? My guess is if it returned as an animated series with 1 hour episodes, it would continue as season 11 where some storylines could be taken from the season 11 comics, but I'm betting not all the stories in the comics would be carried over to TV, so it would also have new plot elements that were never seen in the comics because they would have to cater to shippers (if they would even want to watch an animated series). If it would be brought back in periodic films that would be released, then they would probably just name the films based on certain storylines from the season 11 comics as opposed to calling them Season 11 Part 1, Season 11 Part 2, and so on.
What do you guys think? Would you even be interested in a continuation of the series? Which form would you prefer to see it in? Like I said, I have no hope or expectations of this happening but instead just wondering what others here want/think about this.
Comment