View Full Version : Lana's Goodbye video/ Farewell Clana
Alexander III
05-14-2008, 06:58 PM
Lana, you will be missed. BYE BYE!! :D
Razzle
05-14-2008, 06:59 PM
it was a good run but it was good how they showed that at least Lana matured up a bit and realized clark has to get his head out of his ass.
Dark_Superman
05-14-2008, 06:59 PM
No... no it won't be missed lol
Superman of Krypton
05-14-2008, 07:04 PM
She'll be back for her 4 contracted eps.
Clana will return then go away again!
Same crap.
http://www.sarawebsite.com/anims/smallville026.gif
BadToad
05-14-2008, 07:06 PM
Or maybe Lana will return next season having changed her mind, and hoping to reconcile. And it will be Clark that will say no.
I actually thought they would do this, but I think it could actually work for a short Lana arc next season.
Razzle
05-14-2008, 07:09 PM
she prolly has to get her belongings and decides too wait few days to screw around with Kent more.
Superman of Krypton
05-14-2008, 07:12 PM
It will prolly be a Tess/Clark/Lana triangle! TPTB love those -_-
Super_Kara_2007
05-14-2008, 07:26 PM
Lana will be back in Season 8 so it's not even Goodbye. It's just a cliffhanger for 4 months.
redeem147
05-14-2008, 07:26 PM
I liked the foreshadowing, when Clark was watching Lana's video (apparently her break-up tool of choice) and Lois quietly came into the frame.
aqgalaxy
05-14-2008, 07:29 PM
She sais "Don't come look for me" or somethng to that effect yet we know she returns to the farm. It's the same damn thing she said somewhat in Phantom.
Alexander III
05-14-2008, 07:30 PM
She'll be back for her 4 contracted eps.
Clana will return then go away again!
Same crap.
http://www.sarawebsite.com/anims/smallville026.gif
No she won't, and stop laughing u evil witch.
----- Added 3 Minutes later -----
Or maybe Lana will return next season having changed her mind, and hoping to reconcile. And it will be Clark that will say no.
I actually thought they would do this, but I think it could actually work for a short Lana arc next season.
By then it'll be too late coz Clark will be Lois's b!tch.
hugesmallvillefan
05-14-2008, 07:46 PM
i'm so glad Clana is finally over. Now clark can move on to his destiny lois lane.
globalbudd3
05-14-2008, 07:47 PM
What a sad day it is!!! No more loft scenes, no more bedroom scenes, no more stolen kissess, no more longing glances....What will we do....this is the saddest couple in history next to Romeo and Juliet! The gods are cruel and the fates are impassionate. The sad day has come as the the shadow of doom has covered the world of Clana into darkness...sniff...sniff
Alexander III
05-14-2008, 07:54 PM
What a sad day it is!!! No more loft scenes, no more bedroom scenes, no more stolen kissess, no more longing glances....What will we do....this is the saddest couple in history next to Romeo and Juliet! The gods are cruel and the fates are impassionate. The sad day has come as the the shadow of doom has covered the world of Clana into darkness...sniff...sniff
It's ok, they'll find their own true love. Clark will live alot more happier w/ Lois while Lana ...will live happier marrying Peter (not sure if you call this happiness) but oh well. Clana is not meant for each other! :o
Superman of Krypton
05-14-2008, 07:59 PM
The question is how did Lana get a Camera, DVD burner and a blank DVD while in the hospital??
globalbudd3
05-14-2008, 08:04 PM
The question is how did Lana get a Camera, DVD burner and a blank DVD while in the hospital??
It is called the magic of television...LOL...suspend your beliefs...if not you will shred and criticize everything about the show...
kryptonaidxh
05-14-2008, 08:12 PM
She'll be back for her 4 contracted eps.
Clana will return then go away again!
Same crap.
http://www.sarawebsite.com/anims/smallville026.gif
:(Oh I afraid so..., and that evil laugh must be because she knows she will return to tourture and making us suffer..., but it´s probably she just comes to back her damn stuff and say goodbye to everybody, so that evil laugh won´t last so long you witch!:lol:, cause you´re leaving soon.:lol::lol::lol:bye bye
minerva73
05-14-2008, 08:13 PM
The question is how did Lana get a Camera, DVD burner and a blank DVD while in the hospital??
Well maybe since she's stayed at Smallville Medical Center ever since she's been in Smallville, they gave it to her as some kind of incentive. ;)
I'm glad that they ended it like this though. I just watched one clip and I'm still loving Lana Lang. I had a feeling that she'd say that she didn't want to hold him back and she just did it so well IMO. I don't really know how to explain it, lol. Best Clana scene ever (next to "Wrath"). :D
For me, it sure beats the whole "We Need You, I Need You" speech by Chloe in "Apocalypse". :rotfl: So even though it's over, I'm glad that it ended that way.
SuperKyptonGirl13
05-14-2008, 08:20 PM
Well maybe since she's stayed at Smallville Medical Center ever since she's been in Smallville, they gave it to her as some kind of incentive. ;)
I'm glad that they ended it like this though. I just watched one clip and I'm still loving Lana Lang. I had a feeling that she'd say that she didn't want to hold him back and she just did it so well IMO. I don't really know how to explain it, lol. Best Clana scene ever (next to "Wrath"). :D
For me, it sure beats the whole "We Need You, I Need You" speech by Chloe in "Apocalypse". :rotfl: So even though it's over, I'm glad that it ended that way.
THAT WAS NOT THE ENDING OF CHLARK!!!! :(
But besides that i agree , this sounds like a great scene :)
minerva73
05-14-2008, 08:22 PM
THAT WAS NOT THE ENDING OF CHLARK!!!! :(
But besides that i agree , this sounds like a great scene :)
I know and I know exactly why Chloe said that. It's reasonable that she said that too because she helped Clark realize that he was needed. I only said that it beat that speech because I'm well...deprived of Kristin Kreuk. :( *anxiously waits to see KK's face on the eppie tomorrow* I'm sure that there'll be lots of great Chlark scenes in the future. :o
SuperKyptonGirl13
05-14-2008, 08:34 PM
ok then , sorry i normally don't jump on someone that quickly but i kind have been on a short rope with some things people have been saying on the forum :( :)
Super_Kara_2007
05-14-2008, 08:45 PM
Clana is Not over. Lana wil be back in S8 we all know that.
Alexander III
05-14-2008, 08:51 PM
Clana is Not over. Lana wil be back in S8 we all know that.
Lana will be back, but ...Clana won't be back! :(
Super_Kara_2007
05-14-2008, 08:55 PM
Lana will be back, but ...Clana won't be back! :(
We don't know that for sure. If Lana isn't still with clark, then she has no other reason to stilll be in Smallville.
aqgalaxy
05-14-2008, 08:55 PM
Lana will be back, but ...Clana won't be back! :(
We said the same thing in season 4, 6 and 7
AngelaV
05-14-2008, 08:56 PM
I do have to admit my eyes welled up. Couldn't stand seeing Clark look so heart broken! Then Lois hugged him. :)
Super_Kara_2007
05-14-2008, 08:58 PM
I do have to admit my eyes welled up. Couldn't stand seeing Clark look so heart broken! Then Lois hugged him. :)
Yeah the Clois hug is great becuase Lois is there for Clark through his some what breakup (timeout) just like Clark was there for Lois through her breakup with GG in "Siren".
Alexander III
05-14-2008, 09:04 PM
Yeah the Clois hug is great becuase Lois is there for Clark through his some what breakup (timeout) just like Clark was there for Lois through her breakup with GG in "Siren".
And they'll make a wayy better couple, better than Clana or Chlark (if that ever happens)
Ilovebeinglost
05-14-2008, 09:05 PM
No more Clana was the best part of this boring finale
minerva73
05-14-2008, 09:07 PM
We don't know that for sure. If Lana isn't still with clark, then she has no other reason to stilll be in Smallville.
She knows that the world needs him. Since the world needs Clark and if he's in danger, she's still able to extend her hand out and help him. They're really close friends either way, she just doesn't want to hold him back in life because he's so focused on making her happy.
Alexander III
05-14-2008, 09:11 PM
Yes, Lana finally realizes that, thank god!
Super_Kara_2007
05-14-2008, 09:20 PM
Yes, Lana finally realizes that, thank god!
Actually, Lana told that same eact thing about not wanting to e the one holding him back from a greater calling in "Action". Clark said, "I have everything that I've ever wanted and it's right here on this farm with you."
Alexander III
05-14-2008, 09:24 PM
Actually, Lana told that same eact thing about not wanting to e the one holding him back from a greater calling in "Action" but Clark said, "I have everything that I've ever wanted and it's right here on this farm with you."
That Clark's quote means nuthing at all now :lol:, the love of his life is gone. He should be happy for her tho, his life is too complicated for Lana and if he really loves her, he has to let her go. Let her live a normal life. :o
Super_Kara_2007
05-14-2008, 09:31 PM
That Clark's quote means nuthing at all now :lol:, the love of his life is gone. He should be happy for her tho, his life is too complicated for Lana and if he really loves her, he has to let her go. Let her live a normal life. :o
Are you kidding me?!? If Clark can be with Lois and live a double sided life, then he can surely be with Lana and do the same. I see no difference between the 2 at all.
RepairmanBob
05-14-2008, 09:36 PM
Lana will be back, but ...Clana won't be back! :(
How many times has that been teased? How many times has Clana been ended becasue lana has a new guy? Seasons 3, 4, 5-6? It just will not die.
I voted no, because it is not over. KK has the episodes next season (anyone know how many yet?), and I am sure they will be just as filled with angst, loft scenes and Clana as ever. More importantly, the post-strike episodes show me that Clark is quite capable of moping about Lana when she is not on screen.
The Clana is not gone, it is just in remission.
Liarma
05-14-2008, 09:38 PM
Chloe is staying and Clana is over? Smallville has just gotten so much better! go season 8! still a shame that Michael Rosenbaum has gone :(
BadToad
05-14-2008, 09:41 PM
Maybe I'm being foolish, but I actually believe that romantic Clana is done. I do believe there will be angst of some sort when she reappears next season. But I don't think we'll see a reunion. With any luck *fingers crossed* we'll see Clark confirm to Lana that she did the right thing, and they're better as friends.
Alexander III
05-14-2008, 09:43 PM
Are you kidding me?!? If Clark can be with Lois and live a double sided life, then he can surely be with Lana and do the same. I see no difference between the 2 at all.
Well, look at Clana now, are they still together? :rolleyes:
----- Added 45 Seconds later -----
Chloe is staying and Clana is over? Smallville has just gotten so much better! go season 8! still a shame that Michael Rosenbaum has gone :(
MR...don't make me cry :(
Twitch
05-14-2008, 09:44 PM
Maybe I'm being foolish, but I actually believe that romantic Clana is done. I do believe there will be angst of some sort when she reappears next season. But I don't think we'll see a reunion. With any luck *fingers crossed* we'll see Clark confirm to Lana that she did the right thing, and they're better as friends.
I'm hoping for this as well, no more Clana angst, I want to see them break it off nicely and remain friends.
BadToad
05-14-2008, 09:46 PM
I'm hoping for this as well, no more Clana angst, I want to see them break it off nicely and remain friends.
Me too. And while Lana got this one, I'd like to see Clark be the one to firmly close the door, permenantly.
Alaska Young
05-14-2008, 09:48 PM
As a die hard Clana fan:D, I do not blame Lana for the dear john video. She knew she wouldn't be able to break it off with him in person because she loves him too much to bring herself to that and he wouldn't have let her.
I never blamed Lana for holding Clark back. I ALWAYS blamed him.
Clana will come back next season but probably in a different way. I think they will be over but they'll still have a lot of love for each other but Lana would have to force Clark to accept his destiny and move on without her.
I am sad Clana has ended but I love the way Lana spoke to him in the break up unlike what he's done to her in the past...
Hypnotic or Exodus anyone?:mad:
minerva73
05-14-2008, 09:48 PM
Maybe I'm being foolish, but I actually believe that romantic Clana is done. I do believe there will be angst of some sort when she reappears next season. But I don't think we'll see a reunion. With any luck *fingers crossed* we'll see Clark confirm to Lana that she did the right thing, and they're better as friends.
I don't really see where the angst could come from, though. If Clark realizes that she made the right decision, then they're bound to be friends. Lana may still love Clark, but publicly (sp?) profess her love for Clark everytime they come back. IMO, I think that Lana should tell Clark to stay clear of this new Tess character, but Clark refuses. I guess there's where the angst could come from.
----- Added 2 Minutes later -----
As a die hard Clana fan:D, I do not blame Lana for the dear john video. She knew she wouldn't be able to break it off with him in person because she loves him too much to bring herself to that and he wouldn't have let her.
Exactly. Lana knows how important Clark's destiny is and she probably wouldn't be able to live with herself knowing that she's forcing Clark to juggle making her happy and having to save the world without thinking twice about it. So if she didn't make the video, then she'd still be in a relationship with Clark, but she'd have second thoughts (especially if there are eppies when he gets hurt).
BadToad
05-14-2008, 09:55 PM
I don't really see where the angst could come from, though. If Clark realizes that she made the right decision, then they're bound to be friends.
I can see potential angst in 2 places. One way would be if Lana returns, having changed her mind, only to find that Clark had made his peace with her decision and is moving on. The second way would be if she comes back, and Clark is interested in someone else.
Alaska Young
05-14-2008, 09:57 PM
I highly doubt Lana would return and change her mind about the break up. If that did happen, I would have to question the Smallville writers credibility because there would be no point in bringing Lana/KK back just to have her change her mind and want Clark back again.
BadToad
05-14-2008, 09:58 PM
I highly doubt Lana would return and change her mind about the break up. If that did happen, I would have to question the Smallville writers credibility because there would be no point in bringing Lana/KK back just to have her change her mind and want Clark back again.
Actually, hasn't that been the Clana pattern?
Sounds to me like vintage SV.
But, I guess we'll have to wait and see.
colonyofcells
05-14-2008, 10:00 PM
The quickie end was disappointing and was done this way probably bec. at first, they were not sure if Kristin will be in season 8 or not.
The Clana romance should be redone in season 8 and then do the break up if Kristin is not coming back for season 9 or if the series ends. If the series ends, no break up needs to be shown at all.
Alexander III
05-14-2008, 10:07 PM
The quickie end was disappointing and was done this way probably bec. at first, they were not sure if Kristin will be in season 8 or not.
The Clana romance should be redone in season 8 and then do the break up if Kristin is not coming back for season 9 or if the series ends. If the series ends, no break up needs to be shown at all.
Series must end at 8, no way they should go to 9 for god's sake :eek:. I just hope to see Clois more in 8 :p
Alaska Young
05-14-2008, 10:09 PM
Well, when Clark took off for Metropolis in season 2/season 3, I could understand why Lana would want Clark back because he technically didn't break up with her when he left:rolleyes: and she loved him. Plus, they were in high school and if my boyfriend just took off like that, I'd still go looking for him and try to patch things up which is what Lana did.
At the end of season 4, Lana left because she needed space from Clark and she needed a new outlook on the world given all the weird crap she had to go through before hand. But she came back and she was with Jason and the only reason she returned wasn't because of her love for Clark but because of her new tattoo.
In the beginning of season 5, Clark and Lana were happy and lovable but he pushed her away which forced her to turn to Lex because he listened to her unlike Clark. I know that so many ppl tried to warn her about Lex but she thought he had good in him because I believe that is who she is. She sees the good in ppl despite what some haters might say.
Then in season 6, she just wanted a little fling type thing with Lex IMO but was still very much in love with Clark. Then she started to put the pieces of the puzzle together which ultimately led to her finding out part of his secret. She married Lex to protect Clark and she "died" and fled to China to protect herself and Clark. When she came back, she obviously wanted the secret free relationship with him that she has always wanted so I don't blame her for wanting to be with him again.
I know Lana has kept her fair share of secrets this season but Lex really screwed her up so I never blamed her for wanting to kill the guy or for spying on him. I mean, he was an ass to her and he was sick with that whole fake baby thing. This season was Clana's chance to really realize that they are not meant to be but that they do and will always love each other.
In the past I understood Clana's on again off again relationship but I truly don't believe that Lana would want him back next season. I know she'll always want to be with Clark but she knows she can't have him and she'll step aside. Actually, she already has stepped aside.
Do you get where I'm coming from?
colonyofcells
05-14-2008, 10:16 PM
I think Lana should find ways to support Clark's mission instead of running away.
Alexander III
05-14-2008, 10:45 PM
Well, when Clark took off for Metropolis in season 2/season 3, I could understand why Lana would want Clark back because he technically didn't break up with her when he left:rolleyes: and she loved him. Plus, they were in high school and if my boyfriend just took off like that, I'd still go looking for him and try to patch things up which is what Lana did.
At the end of season 4, Lana left because she needed space from Clark and she needed a new outlook on the world given all the weird crap she had to go through before hand. But she came back and she was with Jason and the only reason she returned wasn't because of her love for Clark but because of her new tattoo.
In the beginning of season 5, Clark and Lana were happy and lovable but he pushed her away which forced her to turn to Lex because he listened to her unlike Clark. I know that so many ppl tried to warn her about Lex but she thought he had good in him because I believe that is who she is. She sees the good in ppl despite what some haters might say.
Then in season 6, she just wanted a little fling type thing with Lex IMO but was still very much in love with Clark. Then she started to put the pieces of the puzzle together which ultimately led to her finding out part of his secret. She married Lex to protect Clark and she "died" and fled to China to protect herself and Clark. When she came back, she obviously wanted the secret free relationship with him that she has always wanted so I don't blame her for wanting to be with him again.
I know Lana has kept her fair share of secrets this season but Lex really screwed her up so I never blamed her for wanting to kill the guy or for spying on him. I mean, he was an ass to her and he was sick with that whole fake baby thing. This season was Clana's chance to really realize that they are not meant to be but that they do and will always love each other.
In the past I understood Clana's on again off again relationship but I truly don't believe that Lana would want him back next season. I know she'll always want to be with Clark but she knows she can't have him and she'll step aside. Actually, she already has stepped aside.
Do you get where I'm coming from?
U just did a recap of whole 7 seasons, good job :D
Ilovebeinglost
05-15-2008, 12:00 AM
Great scene when Lois gives Clark a huge hug and he really hugged her. ;)
Alexander III
05-15-2008, 12:08 AM
They could have made out just for the heck of it :lol:
BWOracle
05-15-2008, 12:17 AM
I don't think we'll see Lana in Season 8. Two points, the info that she would be back for the first third of Season 8 was a while back (I think even before the announcement was made that AlMiles were leaving)...the new TPTB may not decide to bring her back so they can start with a clean slate.
Secondly, we have seen in the past where CW press releases have not always ended up being 100 percent accurate.
I think this is the best way to end her character and move forward. I can't think of a compelling reason to bring her back. It's consistent for her character as it's the same way she broke up with Whitney.
Timester
05-15-2008, 05:07 AM
A little self love in Clark is all I ask next season.
Thrill_Seeker
05-15-2008, 05:54 AM
We all know that eventually clark will love on to lois....
But, I REALLY REALL REALLy think that TPTB, should really have lana move on, and be genuinely happy and finally fall "out" of love with clark. Its important to him that she is happy, and even me I hate clana but I DO want lana to be happy. I do wish her the best, she should now start to mend her broken heart, and be with someone who really loves her (CK did, prob more than anyone) but there is someone else out there for her.
clark will always obviously have a tiny little piece of him in her heart that she may never be able to let go, but I think she can move on (I mean how do you get into a relationship, and say to the dude, my ex-boyfriend was an alien and has superpowers) obviously you dont say that, but for her, maybe it'd seem like a step down, maybe to what normal (most) humans feel. I think a very good way to end lanas journey is with another man, although that'd be really tricky to put together.
but TPTB, this is your job !!! so even if it is hard, you need to try harder,
season 7 has still be spectacular, btw
jesslang
05-15-2008, 07:18 AM
what!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! lana gone!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
----- Added 2 Minutes later -----
Lana will be back in Season 8 so it's not even Goodbye. It's just a cliffhanger for 4 months.
this is true.
----- Added 27 Minutes later -----
on to clois!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! yay
Lara Lane
05-15-2008, 09:18 AM
We all know that eventually clark will love on to lois....
But, I REALLY REALL REALLy think that TPTB, should really have lana move on, and be genuinely happy and finally fall "out" of love with clark. Its important to him that she is happy, [...] I DO want lana to be happy. I do wish her the best, she should now start to mend her broken heart, and be with someone who really loves her (CK did, prob more than anyone) but there is someone else out there for her.
I agree with you. I think that Lana's few episodes for next season should be wisely used to give her character a proper closure, and manage to make Lana become the good friend of Clark she is supposed to be. I don't think we'll see her fall in love with someone else though...
Or... just imagine her final scene, she is in Metropolis and enters a coffee shop where she starts musing about her life and Pete is there and is happy to see her and goes to her, invited her a cup of coffee and Lana smiles sweetly to him, and we're left at that... :p
petitemimi
05-15-2008, 10:24 AM
I don't think we'll see Lana in Season 8. Two points, the info that she would be back for the first third of Season 8 was a while back (I think even before the announcement was made that AlMiles were leaving)...the new TPTB may not decide to bring her back so they can start with a clean slate.
I can't think of a compelling reason to bring her back. It's consistent for her character as it's the same way she broke up with Whitney.
I wish you're right.
Since Clana is essentially for Lana fans, if she comes back for a few epis next year, SHE will have moved on as she did after the many break-ups, but Clark of course, won't have moved on and will pursue her, to make her look good. It's been the pattern for 7 freakin' years, so I don't see why this should change.
colonyofcells
05-15-2008, 10:37 AM
I hope Kristin comes back for lots of episodes in season 8. There should be more Clana romance in season 8 so there will be more fun competition between Lana, Chloe, Lois and Tess.
jojojones
05-15-2008, 10:47 AM
IMO, Clark and Lana had, by far, the best "chemistry" of all of the characters. That may have been a mistake by the originators of the show but it the Lois/Clark chemistry doesn't even come close. However, the story needs to come to some conclusion with Clark/Lana. A "non-angst" type situation that was alluded to in Apocalypse, where Lana goes to Europe and Clark is happy for her, is best. It will probably end that way in S8 for Lana.
Lara Lane
05-15-2008, 10:47 AM
there will be more fun competition between Lana, Chloe, Lois and Tess.
I'd rather not see that. Can we better have character development, solid plots and CK actually becoming Superman?
Twitch
05-15-2008, 10:48 AM
I'd rather not see that. Can we better have character development, solid plots and CK actually becoming Superman?
Yeah I agree, no love pentagons please! :lol:
colonyofcells
05-15-2008, 11:16 AM
I think Clark will develop his character and prove that he is really Superman if he can survive a love pentagon with devious Lana, hacker Chloe, grabber Lois and voluptuous Tess.
Twitch
05-15-2008, 11:29 AM
I think Clark will develop his character and prove that he is really Superman if he can survive a love pentagon with devious Lana, hacker Chloe, grabber Lois and voluptuous Tess.
Well here's to hoping you never get a job as a Smallville Producer... No offense. :p
P.S. You should have left it as hugger Lois. ;)
darkone
05-15-2008, 12:52 PM
After seeing Clark's reaction I don't quite understand why people (aside Lana fans) want that Clark for their respectively favorite female character.I don't think this breakup is going to help at all in regards how Clark's going to like what's in his future.Infact it wouldnt be surprising if he's going to loathe his 'destiny' even more than before.I do like that Lana took the initiative in pushing Clark into the right direction but the timing is ridiculous imo.I hope they get a proper ending next Season.
LoveHurts38
05-15-2008, 01:19 PM
He is going to stay single next season I have a feeling ..like he did in S4 and S6.
petitemimi
05-15-2008, 02:59 PM
^^ I would love to see him happily single, which wasn't the case in S6.
Alexander III
05-15-2008, 06:45 PM
He is going to stay single next season I have a feeling ..like he did in S4 and S6.
No he won't! He's going to marry Shelby for the second time and this time it's for real!
HowardFilms
05-15-2008, 06:47 PM
Funniest damn thing I've seen since weepy Hilary Clinton.
Kudos to Lana for actually putting Clark's destiny first though. Shame she's gonna ruin it next year probably.
alienkinfolk
05-15-2008, 06:47 PM
Yes, Thank you Lana for this gift of farewell. who's with me in doing the happy dance
HowardFilms
05-15-2008, 06:48 PM
Happy Happy Joy Joy!
Alexander III
05-15-2008, 06:50 PM
R.I.P Lana. [Mod Edit]
Happy Happy Joy Joy!
my sentiments EXACTLY !!!! :D:rotfl:;)
regex_1
05-15-2008, 06:50 PM
That seemed a little out of place. Why would she just come out the coma and decide something like that. I would think there would be more pressing issues.
shy175223
05-15-2008, 06:52 PM
I was kind of hoping that Clana would end in a mutual decision...the way it ended kind of sucks.
clana4everfan2
05-15-2008, 07:01 PM
Bad Clana ending for Clana fans with no closure.
TECHWON
05-15-2008, 07:02 PM
I'm Not Shocked This Happen Just Kinda Good Its Over Now He Can Become The Man Of Steel
Krypton935
05-15-2008, 07:10 PM
I felt so bad for clark but I think that was a good ending to it. it was so sad when lois walked in
HowardFilms
05-15-2008, 07:12 PM
I Like To Capatilize Every Letter Too. Let's Be Friends, Kay?
lovingtom
05-15-2008, 07:13 PM
did lana say on the video "don't look for me" or "don't come after me"? it's weird she just got up and left, i think because she was still in thailand filming.
ATruthForever
05-15-2008, 07:16 PM
Finally! 7 years of Clana is just too damn mean..Now maybe Clark can concentrate more on other important things...such as his Destiny!!! (and Lois)
Ardiem3
05-15-2008, 07:16 PM
After Lana broke up with Clark, I wonder how theyre going to explain her reappearance next season. Are they going to get back together because thatd be like taking a step forward and then taking two steps back.
lovingtom
05-15-2008, 07:19 PM
i know she probabby still filming her movie, but i think she's supposed to be back next season for 3 eposides.
erikamichelle614
05-15-2008, 07:20 PM
im sure she'll be around, but nothing more. i hope.
minerva73
05-15-2008, 07:21 PM
That seemed a little out of place. Why would she just come out the coma and decide something like that. I would think there would be more pressing issues.
It's probably been on her mind for a while, though. She also saw how much time Clark devoted to her when she was comatose and how he could have been doing something to further his destiny instead of spending endless nights with her. I think that she probably started feeling this in "Traveler".
WickedJenn
05-15-2008, 07:21 PM
After Lana broke up with Clark, I wonder how theyre going to explain her reappearance next season. Are they going to get back together because thatd be like taking a step forward and then taking two steps back.
I'm going to say no partially based on the appearance of Tess alone, with the spoiler mentioning a "mutual attraction" between she and Clark.
spideyfan
05-15-2008, 07:21 PM
I dont care how it ended, just that it ended
shy175223
05-15-2008, 07:22 PM
destiny and other things before Lois.
jordeant1200
05-15-2008, 07:22 PM
it was so sad ur so mean i cried because of that scene quit being so rude
jpoeling
05-15-2008, 07:22 PM
Lana had a lot of time to think about things in her catatonic state.
AlwaysRight
05-15-2008, 07:24 PM
I hate Clana as much as the next person and this isn't a Lana bash but the producers might have just been better saving the breakup till next season. Sort of like a cliff hanger(not that i really care). The video came off cheesy and would have been better to wait till next season to do it face to face although as a Lois fan it was great for us.
lovingtom
05-15-2008, 07:24 PM
too bad she left, it's good, clark destiney is waiting for him, it will hurt him but lois is there for him..
madcatlady
05-15-2008, 07:25 PM
I did think that was kind of sad....it would make more sense if she stuck to this resolve next season.
Weepy Lana? Try Weepy Clark. That kid is way too emotional.
hatie123
05-15-2008, 07:26 PM
I'm Not Shocked This Happen Just Kinda Good Its Over Now He Can Become The Man Of Steel
Some of you forget that Lana made the comment about holding Clark back first in Action. His response was that he did not care, he just wanted to live on the farm with Lana.
Well just because Lana was in the coma, she did know what was going on and the only person that could save the world is Clark. So I think she did the right thing because as long as he worries about her, Clark will never leave to fulfill his destiny.:(
minerva73
05-15-2008, 07:29 PM
I think that she'll come back and finally end it properly with Clark. I don't think that the video was her proper break-up with Clark, but it was just to show him that she was ready for him to move on (while they still remained friends).
If she had approached him, then they wouldn't have broken up because as soon as Clark kissed her or hugged her (because she's cured) she would have thought that she couldn't let someone as great as Clark go away so easily.
Clana4Life
05-15-2008, 07:29 PM
The breakup was lame and very un-Lana like. Not to mention that she got a camcorder and DVD burner from underneath her hospital bed. Whatever. THe writers could have done a better job than that.
kanamekun
05-15-2008, 07:31 PM
She broke up with Whitney when he was fighting overseas with a video letter! And now she broke up with Clark with a video message on a CD... that's kinda cold.
I guess it's nicer than faking your death with a car bomb?
AlwaysRight
05-15-2008, 07:34 PM
I think that she'll come back and finally end it properly with Clark. I don't think that the video was her proper break-up with Clark, but it was just to show him that she was ready for him to move on (while they still remained friends).
If she had approached him, then they wouldn't have broken up because as soon as Clark kissed her or hugged her (because she's cured) she would have thought that she couldn't let someone as great as Clark go away so easily.
As a Clana hater i am actually glad they did it this way(short and sweet) but i just think it would have been better for Clana fans to not have the video be the way it was done. I understand why they did it(her filming Street Fighter) but it definantly could have been done better if Clark only mentioned her name something like she is alright and they focused on it season 8 episode 1(that is me viewing it as if i was a Clana fan).
I do agree when she comes back we will get more of it. I also have to give KK and TW props for great acting.
She always could have pulled a Mallrats and written him a letter. Seriously though, she needs to knock off the passive break-up thing, I mean the only time we've seen her actually break up with someone in person was when Clark initiated it.
mjohn89
05-15-2008, 07:37 PM
was it just me or does lana in that video look like Micheal Jackson lol
minerva73
05-15-2008, 07:38 PM
Lana knew that she wouldn't be able to break-up with Clark if she saw his face again and she felt the need to break-up with him (or else he'd be held back even more).
So would you rather have her stay in a relationship with Clark until more angsty problems arise or have her break-up with Clark via video and then come back later and settle things once and for all?
Insight
05-15-2008, 07:38 PM
should have happened last year.
Minela
05-15-2008, 07:40 PM
That was so lame of her, but I couldn't really hear anything she was saying because I was too focused on Lois in the background. :D
Oh believe me, I'm glad to be rid of the angst, we were merely commentating that it sucks for the respective guy when she pulls crap like that.
Jephael
05-15-2008, 07:41 PM
You gotta keep in mind though, she did the break-up video for Whitney back when she was still in high school and it was obviously the only way she could since she couldn't just go see him. Her break-up with Clark was clearly more emotional for her since she got to know him so well over the years, even before she learned his secret. They were both similar situations but different circumstances!
superspider02
05-15-2008, 07:42 PM
yea it was pretty bad she broke up with him via dvd, but she did explain why she couldnt do it in person. But since we know she is showing up for atless 3-5 episodes for season 8 they can probably have a better ending to their relationship then.
kanamekun
05-15-2008, 07:42 PM
She didn't really have to break up with Whitney over video... she could've just waited for him to die. It worked out for her with Jason Teague and Adam Knight...
Clana4Life
05-15-2008, 07:43 PM
I would rather Clark had stepped up like Jimmy and proposed already. But I'm not going to get that unless I read some fanfic. ANyway, it took Clark two minutes to get to Lana's facility from killing Brainiac. He went to see Lana first and the writers are trying to tell me that Lana had time to make get a camcorder, set it up, record her speech, find a DVD burner, buy a DVD and burn it and the hope on a plane or run to wherever she went. This is SO unbelievable. And I don't think Lana would have broken up with Clark. I don't think she would have suddenly had an epiphany that she needed to break up with him for the world.
Jephael
05-15-2008, 07:43 PM
Last year? But they weren't even together then. She was still married to Lex!
TECHWON
05-15-2008, 07:44 PM
She broke up with Whitney when he was fighting overseas with a video letter! And now she broke up with Clark with a video message on a CD... that's kinda cold.
I guess it's nicer than faking your death with a car bomb?
i completely forgot about that she did didn't she damn she couldn't face him prolly because clark was/is being too selfish
MetropolisGirl4SV
05-15-2008, 07:44 PM
Yeah... the break up was pretty cheesy, but the acting was excellent;)...I'm gonna miss KK...Not Lana that much. And yes Lana you have been holding him back ...l:lol:
I feel bad for the hard core Lana fans. I wonder if Lana ran away to Paris...
Hmmm it would be cool to see Lana come back and sense that Clark has growing feelings for Lois. Both L-L's ( Lana Lang and Lois Lane) in battle for CK:rotfl:
minerva73
05-15-2008, 07:45 PM
Oh believe me, I'm glad to be rid of the angst, we were merely commentating that it sucks for the respective guy when she pulls crap like that.
Who's to say that she won't be back again, though? Clark may be upset, but he knows how much Lana means to him. Lana won't just let Clark go so easily after all they've been through, so she's bound to come back to end things with him properly.
She didn't want to give Clark and herself the illusion that their relationship would be perfectly fine along with Clark having to save the world, so the video just gave Clark some kind of reality check (if that makes any sense). IMO at least.
jimmyolsenblues
05-15-2008, 07:48 PM
this video was a dumb idea. i would have rathered her not appear than doing the video. it was a cheesy moment.
Jephael
05-15-2008, 07:49 PM
Well clearly they wanted Kristen to appear in the episode somehow!
RobynAdele0406
05-15-2008, 07:50 PM
All break ups are emotional. She could have done it face to face, said her last goodbyes. Damn.
And I always knew they'd have Lana leave with a "the world needs you, laterz!" farewell, but it just didn't fit in with the storyline. At all.
She just woke up from weeks of torture and pain and the first thing she thinks is... "I have to break up with Clark because the world needs him"? Um, no, I'm thinking her thought process would be way more believable as "Your enemies keep using me to get at you, and I can't let them use me against you like that, because I know you'll give in to them. So I must say goodbye."
Or even "damn, being with you hurts like a *****! I gotta go!"
Bleh.
Clana4Life
05-15-2008, 07:51 PM
I don't think she would sense his feelings for Lois. I don't think he'll have them. Seems like they are pushing more of a Clark and "the new female villain" storyline. Clois will have to wait until post-training or until the Superman movies. :) As for Lana, she'll be back, I don't know for how many episodes. No one knows. Some say 3, some say 5. I even heard 8 or 11. I don't know that Clana is over, but I think that sense she is coming back, this break up was a bad idea. This whole leaving and coming back junk is getting old. "I came back Clark because I love you." I hope they have her come back because something major happened. Maybe she has to testify at Chloe's trial and when she sees Clark she can't bear to leave again. It just needs to be something good, like testifying against Lex. Please don't just have her come back because she has a change heart. Don't make Lana flakely. That she is not.
Who's to say that she won't be back again, though? Clark may be upset, but he knows how much Lana means to him. Lana won't just let Clark go so easily after all they've been through, so she's bound to come back to end things with him properly.
Yeah but that's because we already know she's making a short return appearance next season, Clark obviously hasn't been keeping up with the latest SV news so he thinks she's gone for good. I mean, how pissed would you be if some girl broke up with you with a DVD? I know I would be.
I would rather Clark had stepped up like Jimmy and proposed already. But I'm not going to get that unless I read some fanfic. ANyway, it took Clark two minutes to get to Lana's facility from killing Brainiac. He went to see Lana first and the writers are trying to tell me that Lana had time to make get a camcorder, set it up, record her speech, find a DVD burner, buy a DVD and burn it and the hope on a plane or run to wherever she went. This is SO unbelievable. And I don't think Lana would have broken up with Clark. I don't think she would have suddenly had an epiphany that she needed to break up with him for the world.
Welcome to Smallville.
redraven
05-15-2008, 07:53 PM
LOL at anyone thinking Clana's seriously over from some 'dear john' video from Lana. Please. If KK wasn't in Thailand that wouldn't have happened. The writers needed to do something, and what else is there besides go back to the Clana circle of breaking up, getting back together, etc.
I'm still really mad about it though.
WickedJenn
05-15-2008, 07:54 PM
I would rather Clark had stepped up like Jimmy and proposed already. But I'm not going to get that unless I read some fanfic. ANyway, it took Clark two minutes to get to Lana's facility from killing Brainiac. He went to see Lana first and the writers are trying to tell me that Lana had time to make get a camcorder, set it up, record her speech, find a DVD burner, buy a DVD and burn it and the hope on a plane or run to wherever she went. This is SO unbelievable. And I don't think Lana would have broken up with Clark. I don't think she would have suddenly had an epiphany that she needed to break up with him for the world.
Yeah that was mighty quick :lol:
Clana4Life
05-15-2008, 07:54 PM
Exactly RobynAndele0406. Your first thought wouldn't be let me make a break up DVD. In fact, let me pull all of this equipment from under my bed and do it really fast, cause I know he's on his way. This was lame, and this was unbelievable. Would have been better to say, "your enemies use me to hurt you. I can't let them do that to you and I have to protect you."
AndiGirl
05-15-2008, 07:55 PM
Kristin did an amazing job in the video...but I agree, it was lame. Apparently Lana cant break up with anyone face to face. I understand...she new it would be hard to let clark go if she had to look in his eyes. But come on...the guy deserved more then a video goodbye. She says she's doing it for him...but it just seemed like a cop out.
mkbus27
05-15-2008, 07:57 PM
Umm with out clark and lana, the show would have been done after season 2
redeem147
05-15-2008, 07:59 PM
The breakup was lame and very un-Lana like.
Really? She's done it before.
RedKalEL
05-15-2008, 08:00 PM
lana and done and a bonus clois hug *does the carlton banks dance*
Clana4Life
05-15-2008, 08:03 PM
Not like this and not because "the world needs him more".
Kreukie
05-15-2008, 08:05 PM
I have no idea why the writers felt the need to have Kristin in this episode if they knew she was coming back next season! It was stupid to have Lana in this episode for two minutes via a video, to break up with Clark when they have at least four episodes worth with Lana next season to do it! :lol:
minerva73
05-15-2008, 08:05 PM
All break ups are emotional. She could have done it face to face, said her last goodbyes. Damn.
And I always knew they'd have Lana leave with a "the world needs you, laterz!" farewell, but it just didn't fit in with the storyline. At all.
She just woke up from weeks of torture and pain and the first thing she thinks is... "I have to break up with Clark because the world needs him"? Um, no, I'm thinking her thought process would be way more believable as "Your enemies keep using me to get at you, and I can't let them use me against you like that, because I know you'll give in to them. So I must say goodbye."
Or even "damn, being with you hurts like a *****! I gotta go!"
Bleh.
If that happened, then it would completely destroy and reverse all progress that Lana made this season. Just because she's comatose for a couple of weeks, so she feels that being with Clark is a threat to her life? In "Action", she could have died when she was thrown off the building. But she stayed with Clark after that. In "Blue", she could have gotten seriously injured when Zor-El threw her across the room, but she stayed with Clark after that.
In "Wrath", Lana said to Clark that she was perfectly fine with living the new life. In "Siren", she realized that being with Clark had a couple of problems, but she was still dedicated to their relationship. In "Traveler", Lana realized how much trouble she had to go through just to help save Clark. But she did it anyways. Having Lana say something like that would retcon (unsure if that word would fit in this scenario) all of her progress thus far.
Can we truly say that Lana just thought about this, though? She's realized that the world needs him more ever since "Action". And after living with Clark for a while, maybe it began to kick in and the Brainiac incident made her realize that the world does need Clark. So she was probably thinking in her mind (while still being comatose) about how much time Clark devoted to being with her instead of doing something more productive.
----- Added 5 Minutes later -----
Kristin did an amazing job in the video...but I agree, it was lame. Apparently Lana cant break up with anyone face to face. I understand...she new it would be hard to let clark go if she had to look in his eyes. But come on...the guy deserved more then a video goodbye. She says she's doing it for him...but it just seemed like a cop out.
Biggest theme of Season 6: Lexana. In "Phantom", Mrs. Luthor clearly went up to the mansion, walked into Lex's office, stepped up to his face, told him about all the things he did to her, and said, "This marriage is over". She confirmed this by saying that what they (Lex and Lana) had in Season 6 was all over when she spoke to him in "Wrath". Lana also showed Clark that she could stand up to him and faced him directly when she said that she couldn't take another Clark Kent apology in Season 5.
Why is it that all of these moments when Lana breaks up with someone directly are ignored now, but they seemed to be the topics that most people were talking about in the sections for these episodes. :\
Jade4813
05-15-2008, 08:09 PM
LOL at anyone thinking Clana's seriously over from some 'dear john' video from Lana. Please. If KK wasn't in Thailand that wouldn't have happened. The writers needed to do something, and what else is there besides go back to the Clana circle of breaking up, getting back together, etc.
I'm still really mad about it though.
I'm not thrilled about what they did, either, but I don't think this video is what they "HAD" to do. If they'd wanted to have Lana in the episode, they could easily have done so and not had her break up with Clark via video. It's not like it wasn't the season finale so they didn't have a little time to work around her movie in Thailand.
They could have just as easily have shown her lying in a bed and her eyes shoot open and clear up. And that'd be it.
If they just wanted to do something, they could have done that. If they wanted to have a cliffhanger, that would have been a cliffhanger too (about as much as this one was. Because it really wasn't). We could be left wondering, is she really okay? Is it still the same Lana? Was she permanently damaged or affected by Brainiac?
Do I think they'll necessarily resist doing Clana next year? I hope so because I'm over it, but I'm not betting the farm on it. I think they won't go back to Clana, but it's possible I suppose.
But, come on, breaking up Clana wasn't exactly something they HAD to do in the finale for any reason that has anything to do with KK's movie. They did HAVE to do it in the way they did it, though, if they wanted to have Clana break up. So it's not exactly a guarantee that Clana will be back (if they did want the breakup), so I don't think it's absurd to speculate that maybe it won't be back.
A_Chloe.S._Fan
05-15-2008, 08:09 PM
how unoriginal. she dumps him through a video. deja vu anyone?
jacques
05-15-2008, 08:11 PM
Yea, yea, yea, yea, yea. Oh did I forget to say yea. (Stands up from the computer and dances around. Pauses... A little too much?)
HowardFilms
05-15-2008, 08:12 PM
Are you kidding me? That was sad? If by sad you mean pathetic, then definitely.
TPTB: We need you to come in this week and film a scene with Clark saying goodbye.
KK: Forget that, I'll just use my webcam and whip something up.
Haha. Now THAT I would believe.
RobynAdele0406
05-15-2008, 08:12 PM
Can we truly say that Lana just thought about this, though? She's realized that the world needs him more ever since "Action". And after living with Clark for a while, maybe it began to kick in and the Brainiac incident made her realize that the world does need Clark. So she was probably thinking in her mind (while still being comatose) about how much time Clark devoted to being with her instead of doing something more productive.
You make a good point, that she may have been muling that over for all these weeks. But it would have been nice to see her feeling that "the world needs Clark more than I do and I have to let him go". Because even before her Brainiac coma, I just didn't see that.
minerva73
05-15-2008, 08:15 PM
You make a good point, that she may have been muling that over for all these weeks. But it would have been nice to see her feeling that "the world needs Clark more than I do and I have to let him go". Because even before her Brainiac coma, I just didn't see that.
I agree with you. They should have shown some signs of that before she left for Thailand. In my opinion, "Traveler" would have been the perfect place for her to realize that Clark means a lot to the world. Maybe she could have walked in on Patricia and Clark's conversation by accident and then start thinking about it. But unfortunately, we didn't.
PriiNceSs_62
05-15-2008, 08:16 PM
It makes sense writing wise, because with everything else going on having Lana there and leaving would be so distracting to Clark. This way she is always gone and there is nothing she can do. But seriously, another video break up?! Didn't she learn from the last time when Whitney DIED after seeing it, and she regretted it?
STFanatic
05-15-2008, 08:25 PM
The question is how did Lana get a Camera, DVD burner and a blank DVD while in the hospital??
She still has a lot of that 10 million bucks left I reckon ;)
Jade4813
05-15-2008, 08:27 PM
I would have bought her reacting as she did after Stompy the Horse a bit better. After all, with the agony she was supposed to be in, I think it would have been natural for her to have woken up and been like, "Um...dude. Give me some time. Because being around you...? Not always so much with the fun."
Or at least saying she had to go to think about whether she was strong enough to take that kind of risk. Something like that.
WickedJenn
05-15-2008, 08:27 PM
She still has a lot of that 10 million bucks left I reckon ;)
:lol:
It goes a long way!
TheLeague
05-15-2008, 08:32 PM
[Mod Edit]
Kreukie
05-15-2008, 08:41 PM
[Mod Edit]
Good thing the report button is...
<<<<< this way. :D
dimeo782002
05-15-2008, 08:42 PM
Im happy it's over but a freaking dvd video breakup ... come cut the f$#@!%^ cheese already this made me mad the break up should have been face to face . For the dvd thing was immature and cheesy. I understand she could not look into his eyes because she would not be able to break up with him but UGH ! whatever did not like it but am i happy clana is over yes i am because Clark and Lana have been ripping eachothers hearts out for too long and it was getting boring. Clark should have boinked Chloe but that will never happen neither . Atleast Lana and Clark can move on now, and i would like to say that i saw a thread saying Tom W is a bad actor because he could not cry when he saw the dvd.
Well i would like to say WHATEVER !!!!!!!!!!! TOM WELLING IS A VERY GOOD ACTOR AND AFTER HE SAW THE VIDEO I FELT WHAT HE FELT AND I FELT ALL THE EMOTION YOU SHOULD FEEL SO FOR ME TOM DID THE JOB AND HE ALWAYS DOES THE JOB , ALSO I DID SEE TEARS AND IF HE CRIED TOO MUCH OR TOO HARD IT WOULD HAVE BEEN STUPID I THINK TOM GAVE JUST THE RIGHT AMOUNT OF EMOTION. now he can move on and get the hell over Lana !
Minela
05-15-2008, 08:43 PM
Or maybe Lana will return next season having changed her mind, and hoping to reconcile. And it will be Clark that will say no.
I actually thought they would do this, but I think it could actually work for a short Lana arc next season.
I hope that is what happens. I hope Lana changes her mind (once again), but in the mean time Clark has matured and grown up and tells her how it is and finally finally finally gets over that unhealthy relationship.
WickedJenn
05-15-2008, 08:44 PM
I hope that is what happens. I hope Lana changes her mind (once again), but in the mean time Clark has matured and grown up and tells her how it is and finally finally finally gets over that unhealthy relationship.
I actually wouldn't mind that...would make things interesting.
SteveS
05-15-2008, 08:52 PM
I can see potential angst in 2 places. One way would be if Lana returns, having changed her mind, only to find that Clark had made his peace with her decision and is moving on. The second way would be if she comes back, and Clark is interested in someone else.
ClarkMan was the dumpee, not the dumper, he will be the one most prone to missing his first love, Lana, and will likely be the one most interested in hooking-up when and should she return.
Minela
05-15-2008, 08:53 PM
[Mod Edit]
:rotfl:
AndiGirl
05-15-2008, 08:55 PM
I hope not!
I mean...Clark, make up your freaking mind! When she slept with Bizzaro..you were more then willing to let her go. Then you take her back...
Then...the whole time they are together, it's obvious the spark is gone....
Now FINALLY, Lana steps up and says "this isn't right...and we both know it." Which...I have a lot of respect for her right now (though...I think she could have done it in person) and if the BDA wants her back at the beginning of the next season...I will lost all respect for him.
How else do they need it spelled out?? It wont work...get over it!
Chloe_is_my_Hero
05-15-2008, 09:09 PM
I doubt it is over.
SmallTownSuperHero
05-15-2008, 09:37 PM
Wow, so during next season, we could have, for at least four episodes, a Clark/Lana/Chloe/Lois/Tess mess. Yippee!
I'm thinking -- Clana had its time, was sweet, but Lana finally stepped up, for the first time in a long time in the series, to the truth and did the right thing. I'm hoping they don't ruin it by once again bringing back that whole mess.
myankskent
05-15-2008, 09:40 PM
I really don't understand why TPTB had to have this scene in this episode. KK is coming back next season so IMO, there is no point in having Lana break up with Clark over a video. Then if she decides to come back next season and Clana do have one final go at a relationship, suddenly this video becomes a waste of time as well. I have to wonder if this was a decision made by Al/Miles. Perhaps this is their way of ending Clana since they are not returning next season and the new TPTB can reverse some things next season if they need to.
minerva73
05-15-2008, 09:45 PM
I really don't understand why TPTB had to have this scene in this episode. KK is coming back next season so IMO, there is no point in having Lana break up with Clark over a video. Then if she decides to come back next season and Clana do have one final go at a relationship, suddenly this video becomes a waste of time as well. I have to wonder if this was a decision made by Al/Miles. Perhaps this is their way of ending Clana since they are not returning next season and the new TPTB can reverse some things next season if they need to.
It would open up a plot hole if they hadn't had the break-up via video IMO. When Clark went back to the hospital, the nurse said that she made a full recovery. If there wasn't any video, then we'd be expecting Clark to run around the world to find her because he cares about her so much. If Clark didn't go out searching for her, then it would seem completely un-Clark like because he's shown that he cares about her so much. By showing the video, Clark didn't have to go out of his way to find Lana because he knows that she doesn't want him to be slowed down by her.
Jade4813
05-15-2008, 09:51 PM
Maybe they broke it off this way just because next year they want to have Clark already have dealt with the breakup so we don't have to see him mope for half a season? Just a thought.
Brizzle
05-15-2008, 09:53 PM
This was horrible written and come on Al miles basically ********ted this, Lana wasn't holding Clark back, Clark was holding himself back, when will you guys finally realize this?
shadow25
05-15-2008, 09:54 PM
Hopefully when "Lana" comes back, some of her acting will get better. lol I like Kristian though, but seriously, that eppy with the gif one of ya'll posted was priceless. When she was a "witch". lol
----- Added 34 Seconds later -----
Clana will be back for one epi, than break-up for good. Me thinks.
RepairmanBob
05-15-2008, 10:03 PM
Maybe they broke it off this way just because next year they want to have Clark already have dealt with the breakup so we don't have to see him mope for half a season? Just a thought.
<!-- / message -->On this show? I find it more likely he will mope until KK cmes back for sweps, mope more while she is around, then continue moping after she leaves.
Becasue the writers know everyone loves to see Superman mope.
Jade4813
05-15-2008, 10:05 PM
On this show? I find it more likely he will mope until KK cmes back for sweps, mope more while she is around, then continue moping after she leaves.
Becasue the writers know everyone loves to see Superman mope.
I CAN DREAM!!!! :p
MackLove
05-15-2008, 10:53 PM
Thank el!
svtwamedfan05
05-15-2008, 11:07 PM
I'm so relieved its over. Hopefully Clark will be able to move on with his life instead of dwelling in the past. He's already said he can't change the past and its time for him to listen to his own advice now.
SmallvilleMan
05-15-2008, 11:16 PM
She basically Clark'ed Clark.......Instead of Clark breaking up with her to protect her, Lana's breaking up with him to stop from holding him back..........But that video was a COP OUT, big time........The video wasn't even detailed, she just cried, said she was holding him back and bye. There HAS to be more for the show's main couple.....
LexLuv180
05-15-2008, 11:26 PM
He is going to stay single next season I have a feeling ..like he did in S4 and S6.
Yes, moping over his breakup and too reluctant to date. We saw in three seasons where most of the time he was depressed at the thought he would always be alone (rightfully depressed about that anyway and unable to make his move) The only time they've ever shown him move on was with Alicia, but of course they killed her off too quickly so...
----- Added 1 Minutes later -----
This was horrible written and come on Al miles basically ********ted this, Lana wasn't holding Clark back, Clark was holding himself back, when will you guys finally realize this?
No I agree with you, Lana herself doesn't hold Clark back, he's just still not ready to move on from his 'normal' life.
SmallvilleMan
05-15-2008, 11:28 PM
Of course, Alicia wasn't really moving on, because they had no closure and he still loved her.......This video makes no sense, because yet again, it brings no closure. All lana did was the thing Clark always did and the way she did it sucked like he did too. Brings no closure or anything........
xrayvision
05-15-2008, 11:32 PM
I'm glad it's over. When I saw that video, my thoughts were "after all that we were put through with this Clana crap, they end it like this". This was like kicking dirt in our face. All that time wasted for such a crappy fizzled out ending where Clark is the one left behind.
svtwamedfan05
05-15-2008, 11:36 PM
Well what do you expect when Lana's choice of breaking up with someone is a "Dear John" Video. I mean seriously nobody deserves that especially after someone is either fighting for your country or sitting by your side hoping you will get better.
SmallvilleMan
05-15-2008, 11:39 PM
Well what do you expect when Lana's choice of breaking up with someone is a "Dear John" Video. I mean seriously nobody deserves that especially after someone is either fighting for your country or sitting by your side hoping you will get better.
Obviously she felt she had to do this, because Clark would convince her otherwise. Although, we all know the real reason is that even if she wanted to be there, she couldn't be......Thank you writer's stikre........
xrayvision
05-15-2008, 11:40 PM
What it means is that Clana wasn't worth dumbing down season after season. In the beginning when we thought they might do something good with it, I thought it was pretty decent. After this, it would have been better never to have had the character of Lana Lang on this show. They completely failed with the character as they also have with Clark Kent. The real Clark would never need reassurance and mope around in the barn while he knew someone was out to control him. What a pathetic disgrace.
SmallvilleMan
05-15-2008, 11:41 PM
I'm glad it's over. When I saw that video, my thoughts were "after all that we were put through with this Clana crap, they end it like this". This was like kicking dirt in our face. All that time wasted for such a crappy fizzled out ending where Clark is the one left behind.
Think of how it feels to be a Clana fan........At least I can say her reason wasn't as dumb or heartbreaking as I thought it would be. I mean damn, at least she could have talked more.
----- Added 3 Minutes later -----
What it means is that Clana wasn't worth dumbing down season after season. In the beginning when we thought they might do something good with it, I thought it was pretty decent. After this, it would have been better never to have had the character of Lana Lang on this show. They completely failed with the character as they also have with Clark Kent. The real Clark would never need reassurance and mope around in the barn while he knew someone was out to control him. What a pathetic disgrace.
I agree, the failed with both of them and their relationship........Especially during this season, where you had no clue what was happening with them......Although, I do disagree that Clark knew someone was out to control him. Since he left as soon as Jimmy told him where Lex was. He wasn't going to kill Lex before, so there was nothing to do. Besides, it's hurt to take a blow to the heart and go right out like nothing happened.
Jade4813
05-15-2008, 11:51 PM
Think of how it feels to be a Clana fan........At least I can say her reason wasn't as dumb or heartbreaking as I thought it would be. I mean damn, at least she could have talked more.
I actually always figured AlMiles would have Clana break up this way. Only on a hilltop or something. Not via video. But her speech...
The problem was that here, at this point in time, it didn't make a lot of sense. I mean, I could buy it if we'd seen much of her wrestling with the idea for a while. But we really didn't; we got one line in Action and that was it. I would have found it much easier to buy if she'd left because, hey, she'd just been through quite a lot and she needed some time to herself.
And, of course, if the scene had taken place on a hilltop, Clark could have reacted to her comments and there might have been closure. This way...*shrugs* I can only hope that when she comes back next season, we get some ACTUAL closure on the relationship. Because this is just kinda a lame way to end it. I have a hard time seeing, right now, her going off and finding happiness with someone else. And that's a terrible thing to do to both characters.
smallville kb
05-15-2008, 11:54 PM
great ending to lana and lois was their to comfort him, great beginning for what's to come .
LegendaryU2K
05-16-2008, 12:09 AM
Me and my friends almost started crying watching that damn video, it was heartbreaking to see clark in tears, and lana man, that must of hurt her badly. :(
Very sad moment, RIP CLANA.............
Say hello to CLOIS :) , but seriously that was a sad moment, i know i almost cried big time.
Batman/Superman#1
05-16-2008, 01:07 AM
Clark needs to move on. He better next season. This was Lana's second time of telling him the world needs you more.
mrswelling_101
05-16-2008, 03:50 AM
i did love clark and lana but around the middle of season 7 i didnt like them together!
i really like clark and lois now ...i still like clark and lana but the truth is they dont belong together.
i was so angry the way she said goodbye to clark ..you could see the pain in his eyes!
when she comes bck for like 1-4 episodes he will hopfully be in love with lois or at least see her in a diffrent light !!!!!!
queenelizabeth
05-16-2008, 04:26 AM
Lana stated how I feel about Clana in her breakup video: She's holding him back
Cromartiefan
05-16-2008, 05:02 AM
I think they should end it at that. That was the best possible way they could have let Lana bow out - Clark's heartbroken, but eventually he'll realise "Hey, she's right" and embrace his destiny.
Of course, we know she'll be back, but I hope it'll be a cameo and nothing more
carina
05-16-2008, 10:12 AM
she looked awful on that video...
carina
05-16-2008, 10:17 AM
It looks like she sent it from Thailand or Taiwan.How could they put it in show.......
erikamichelle614
05-16-2008, 10:51 AM
They wanted her to look like she just woke up from a month long coma. Is she supposed to be all made up and have shiny hair?
And yes, she's filming in thailand, so they sent it in. i thought it was good.
yoda1138777
05-16-2008, 10:51 AM
It will prolly be a Tess/Clark/Lana triangle! TPTB love those -_-
Actually it will be a Love Trapezoid Tess/Clark/Lois/Lana with Chloe in the middle wondering if her last night as a bachlorette should be with Clark:D
MetroGirl06
05-16-2008, 10:52 AM
When that video played, I was unable to react for quite some time.
I've been waiting so long (years) for that moment, when clana breaks up. And in the video she said all the things I've been saying about clana for the longest time. You put up for something for so long and when its finally gone its like the world lifting off your shoulders and you're left dumbfouded and in a daze. And all I could say was..."Thats it?"
I mean, come on! A video? There was no closure here. I wanted clana to end on both their terms. Now she leaves without having the guts to tell it to his face and leaves Clark as an emotional cripple!
I was very disapointed by this ending.
Not to say that I am relieved as hell that its over. Just the way it ended left me confused as to why I even put up with this crap.
Lara Lane
05-16-2008, 10:56 AM
It looks like she sent it from Thailand or Taiwan.How could they put it in show.......
It WAS sent from Thailand and the woman just woke up from a coma, was she supposed to look glamorous and beautiful?
Ryudo
05-16-2008, 10:56 AM
The problem was that here, at this point in time, it didn't make a lot of sense. I mean, I could buy it if we'd seen much of her wrestling with the idea for a while. But we really didn't; we got one line in Action and that was it. I would have found it much easier to buy if she'd left because, hey, she'd just been through quite a lot and she needed some time to herself.
In Veritas, I am unsure of who actually said it, although I think it was Brainiac, but it was specifically stated that Lana was fully aware of what was going on. I think that's why he made her burn her hand on the pot.
So she DID have time to wrestle with it, it was just all in her whiny insane mind. :) And of course, yet another plot in Smallville wrapped because of action off-screen.
Jade4813
05-16-2008, 11:01 AM
In Veritas, I am unsure of who actually said it, although I think it was Brainiac, but it was specifically stated that Lana was fully aware of what was going on. I think that's why he made her burn her hand on the pot.
So she DID have time to wrestle with it, it was just all in her whiny insane mind. :) And of course, yet another plot in Smallville wrapped because of action off-screen.
Well, I'm not saying that she couldn't have thought about it offscreen. She would have to have done, as we didn't see her wrestle with it on-screen.
We did, however, see her get attacked by Brainiac and be in extreme pain. So if she'd woken up and left a DVD letter saying something like what she said after Stompy the Horse stomped her - "I've realized how much danger I'm in and I don't know that I can deal with it, so I've gotta go for a while." - that would have made more sense.
We SAW justification for believing she was thinking that. We didn't really see justification for believing she was thinking about Clark's Grand Destiny.
And, really, after what Lana went through, which is more BELIEVABLE that she thought about during her time under Brainiac's control?
"OW OW OW OW OW OW OW OW OW OW OW OW OWWWWWWWW! NOT COOL! SO NOT COOL! I am NEVER going through this again!!!!"
or
"Clark has such a huge destiny. And I'm holding him back."
;)
Ryudo
05-16-2008, 11:05 AM
And, really, after what Lana went through, which is more BELIEVABLE that she thought about during her time under Brainiac's control?
"OW OW OW OW OW OW OW OW OW OW OW OW OWWWWWWWW! NOT COOL! SO NOT COOL! I am NEVER going through this again!!!!"
or
"Clark has such a huge destiny. And I'm holding him back."
;)
No doubt a little bit of both, considering that more than once he spent all night with her. :)
Jor'el_Ted
05-16-2008, 11:13 AM
I voted no cause i still love Lana to death and i'll miss her but i'm happy with the way she said goodbye to Clark. It pretty much opens the door for Clois in season 8.
Jaded Wolf
05-16-2008, 11:14 AM
Good riddance. I find it funny she did to Clark what she did to Whitney. A stinkin' video... How spineless...
Drakian
05-16-2008, 11:16 AM
it was a good run but it was good how they showed that at least Lana matured up a bit and realized clark has to get his head out of his ass.
Truer words were never spoken my friend
morphs
05-16-2008, 02:30 PM
Yes. Clark broke up with her and then she turned into a junkie and then married Lex. With all that she got a bit evil.
Time for Chloe and Clark.
smallvillefreak24
05-16-2008, 03:04 PM
I thought it was very nice how they did it with the exception of a few things: I wish this season they would have done clana better-it was extremely crappy that they never had any happy moments I wanted that, we deserved that, and i wish that they could have said goodbye in person... but overall i thought it was nice... Clana was one of my favorite things of smallville and i would have been satisfied with the ending if they didn't eff it up all this season - but bye lana u will be missed
theWatcher
05-16-2008, 04:24 PM
The video was a sad ending to a romantic love, but it was time. There is no denying the fact that the two of them love each other, even Lana told Clark that she will always love him. Lana has been feeling like she has been holding Clark back from his destiny. I feel that after she awoke from her "coma" how much of a reliability she is to him. Yes, I know full well that Lois gets in trouble a lot, but she tends to handle herself a lot better the Lana.
dunlopc
05-16-2008, 04:47 PM
I never hated Lana I just did not like her relationship with Clark. But I must say I shed a tear when she ended their relationship with a video message.
last man of krypton
05-16-2008, 04:49 PM
Two problems I had with the video:
1) The "world needs you more than I do" concept, while true, came out of nowhere. I was expecting a re-iteration of Season 3's "it's too dangerous to be around you", which would've made a heckuva lot more sense.
2) The video reminded me of the "LEAVE BRITNEY ALONE!" YouTube vid. :)
smallvilleluvr07
05-16-2008, 05:21 PM
Clana had a good run in Smallville. But we all knew it had to end sometime; Clark's destined to be with Lois. I'm going to miss Lana, and hope to see her sometime in season 8. Hopefully now Clark won't be so concerned with Lana and he can begin to accept his destiny. My heart broke for Clark when he saw the video, but he and Lana can't go on forever. Lana, you will be missed.
shy175223
05-16-2008, 05:50 PM
Yes. Clark broke up with her and then she turned into a junkie and then married Lex. With all that she got a bit evil.
Time for Chloe and Clark.
yeah, right.:rolleyes:
StrippedSmile
05-16-2008, 06:30 PM
Isn't this Lana's second dear John? LOL. No but it was sad to watch. I respect Lana for realizing she is somewhat holding him back and needs to let him go, just like comic!Lana
ginnyfan
05-16-2008, 06:33 PM
I'm happy that Clana is over. I guess I feel that they could have done better with Clana during Season 7. But yeah, I'm glad it's over. I really won't believe that Clana is over until after the Series Finale. LOL! But AlMiles are gone. Maybe it really is over.
basketballstar23
05-16-2008, 06:42 PM
I'm a die hard clana fan and as much as I hate to admit it, it was a bittersweet goodbye that I'm actually pretty content with :)
supergirl28
05-16-2008, 07:13 PM
Sorry Guys Kristin is coming back next season. I understand Lana's reason for leaving Clark. If she stays in his life he's become a husband instead of the savior. Seeing Clark cry because of her video was sad. I mean Clark only really lets himself cry whan it comes to her.
RJLCyberPunk
05-16-2008, 07:21 PM
Well it seems that the canon character haters got their wish after all and it is now the Chloey show next season. Kara is gone, so is Lana, Louis might as well not exist in the show either and it would not make a difference. With this outlook this episode marks the very last one I'll watch of SV. I'll have to get my Superman/DC comics fix elsewhere from now on as this is the Chloe sullivan show now!
congrats haters and Goodbye...
STFanatic
05-16-2008, 07:28 PM
Who is "Louis"?
WickedJenn
05-16-2008, 08:37 PM
Who is "Louis"?
That's Clark...remember Lois told him that in "Apocalypse" when she clipped her DP name badge on his suit :rotfl:
msleggie
05-16-2008, 08:40 PM
I'm glad that the Clana is over, but I'm not happy about how it ended, in fact I'm a little sad about it.
LegendaryU2K
05-16-2008, 08:44 PM
Lana doesn't look awful. What is it, and its what i have been saying for a few months now. Lana looks different, because of weight loss or whatever. She looked better in the early seasons. She still looks beautiful, but she needs to eat more or something. I gather this will happen because in her new movie, she has to be thick for the character.
Anyways, Did anyone else cry when watching the video?
CLanaF23
05-16-2008, 09:15 PM
CLANA FOREVER <3
thats all i need to say.
PepsiMax
05-16-2008, 09:23 PM
Yay! :d
joel_welling93
05-16-2008, 09:31 PM
Clana should end here.. They both have been thru' so much and need to move on....... Next season should be about Lana becoming one of Clark's closest allies.... Thus synchronizing with the comics; Lana loves Clark till' death but can never have him.... I miss Lana and Lex... And Clana too!!!! :(
SpeedDemon77
05-16-2008, 10:10 PM
Over? Seriously?
Some people are really naive. LOL.
Jade4813
05-16-2008, 10:23 PM
Over? Seriously?
Some people are really naive. LOL.
Or hopeful. It's like we're praying to be shot in the head to be put out of our misery. After seven years of torture (for a segment of fans, at least), we rejoice over the small but present hope that the agony is at an end. Could we be wrong? Sure. But we'll live up these grace period months before we start having to hit the morphine again just to stop the pain.
colonyofcells
05-17-2008, 12:26 AM
If there is still a season 9 and Kristin is no longer available, they can hire a new actress to play Lana so Clana can continue without Kristin.
Angelina2809
05-17-2008, 02:48 AM
i am not so happy that Lana is gone. i know that the most of the fans here hate the clana thing - thery are together, appart, together, appart....
but in my deepest wish i have that dream that calrk and lana will be together forever.
lana loved clark very much! she married evil lex to protect him, she kidnappt lionel to protect him and she left her true love to give him the chance to be the men he must become - superman.
i am not sure if lana was the one holding clark back.
i mean he is together with lois one day and she doesn't hold him back too.
i guess that clark and lois are a nice couple too.
lana was a good part of smallville and she gaves clark much love and happyness! what he needed so much!
j-kent
05-17-2008, 04:21 AM
yeah that was sad but it has to happen
DravenX
05-17-2008, 06:38 AM
She won't be missed. I'm hoping she won't be back.
Lionel The Great
05-17-2008, 08:03 AM
Clana's end is One of the Most Absurd thing in Smallville I have ever heard.
Their love is almost visible since season 1 and now what? Lana left Smallville although she loves Clark !!!
What crap !!!
The writers better Bring Lana back & Send Lois to Antarctica that can never be seen for God's sake !!
shy175223
05-17-2008, 08:21 AM
I agree the ending kind of suck, but but hopefully it will end there..with KK in only a few episodes..maybe they will have Clark FINAL get over lana through a passage of time and when she comes back from wherever she has been, Clark will have moved on with his life..
RJLCyberPunk
05-17-2008, 08:58 AM
Lana doesn't look awful. What is it, and its what i have been saying for a few months now. Lana looks different, because of weight loss or whatever. She looked better in the early seasons. She still looks beautiful, but she needs to eat more or something. I gather this will happen because in her new movie, she has to be thick for the character.
Anyways, Did anyone else cry when watching the video?
No I was angry at the whole thing as I said the canon character haters somehow got the upper hand and next season it will officially be the Chloe Sullivan show...
cybevenom
05-17-2008, 09:04 AM
And now the "specially reserved for Lana Lang room" in the Smallville Medical Centre also can be used for other people as well. Normally i would say lex can take it now but he also said buh bye.:lol:
Ardiem3
05-17-2008, 09:41 AM
If there is still a season 9 and Kristin is no longer available, they can hire a new actress to play Lana so Clana can continue without Kristin.
They wont recast a main character, because if they did, or wanted to, they couldve just replaced Pete. If they cant get someone back, they just write/send them off...
FlashInSV
05-17-2008, 09:58 AM
thank god she's gone! Even though she'll be back for a few episodes, she has already broken up with him -through a videotape, how pathetic!- and she will be part of his past, finally. Now Clarkie boy can move on to greater things, such as turning around and realising LOIS is there, you big dumb alien! Great scene, I have to admit, the one where Clark watches the tape and Lois comforts him.
But noooo, poor Lois Lane is not good enough for the cw. Tess has to come in and have this 'mutual attraction' with Clark. You can keep avoiding it and postponing it all you want, but we all know what's going to happen in the end!
RJLCyberPunk
05-17-2008, 02:12 PM
Clana's end is One of the Most Absurd thing in Smallville I have ever heard.
Their love is almost visible since season 1 and now what? Lana left Smallville although she loves Clark !!!
What crap !!!
The writers better Bring Lana back & Send Lois to Antarctica that can never be seen for God's sake !!
I know but do not expect much from the canon characters this show is officially now the Chloe sullivan only show aznd is just for canon character haters alone everybody else is no longer welcome and we have to move on to better true canon material if availiable...
GuardianAngel
05-17-2008, 02:15 PM
thank god she's gone! Even though she'll be back for a few episodes, she has already broken up with him -through a videotape, how pathetic
Fortunately she didn't break up with him via fax or SMS! Wait, maybe she should have sent him an email or updated her myspace page! :lol:
lucky4ever
05-17-2008, 04:17 PM
Clana's end is One of the Most Absurd thing in Smallville I have ever heard.
Their love is almost visible since season 1 and now what? Lana left Smallville although she loves Clark !!!
What crap !!!
The writers better Bring Lana back & Send Lois to Antarctica that can never be seen for God's sake !!
exactly...
and with lana and lex leaving the show ... i don't know if I'll ever watch the next season !
dimeo782002
05-17-2008, 04:57 PM
Well it seems that the canon character haters got their wish after all and it is now the Chloey show next season. Kara is gone, so is Lana, Louis might as well not exist in the show either and it would not make a difference. With this outlook this episode marks the very last one I'll watch of SV. I'll have to get my Superman/DC comics fix elsewhere from now on as this is the Chloe sullivan show now!
congrats haters and Goodbye...OMG ! IT IS NOT GOING TO BE THE CHLOE SHOW !
although us Ch;ark lovers hope they will get together we all know it most likely is not going to happen ! Seaon 8 will be the last and they mention clark liking some tessmacher chick so chlark will not happen thats a stupid reason to stop watching the show!
I was upset hearing alison may not return but i still would have watched the show anyway !:rotfl:
----- Added 5 Minutes later -----
exactly...
and with lana and lex leaving the show ... i don't know if I'll ever watch the next season !
:rotfl:
RJLCyberPunk
05-17-2008, 05:35 PM
Edit
Super Snipes
05-17-2008, 09:10 PM
I'm happy it's over, but Lana got really screwed in terms of a good farewell. Over a month not on the show and then reduced to a taped cameo goodbye. She deserved more.
Alicia Chipy
05-17-2008, 10:18 PM
I'm in ecxtasy that Clana is over.
But why does she always choose not to face her former lovers?
Sent poor Whitney a dear John video,avoided Jason,faked her death and ran away to China with Lex.
Now poor Clark gets the video replay(probably just edited the name in the Whitney video.)
Lana PLEASE end future relationships personally.Oh wait,she ranAWAY TO METROPOLIS AND STALKED CLARK after her separation from Pete(even leaving her baby behind).:eek:
How can I not rejoyce that this relationship is over?:rolleyes:
dimeo782002
05-17-2008, 10:59 PM
Look at the facts it was Chloe and not Kara who saved Clark in the church after Teague almost killed him. The show is virtually about her now. And you do not care because you arer a certified canon character hater but those of us that watch the show for love of the DC/Superman Mythos and not the stupid teen angst garbage you haters adore won't stand for it...
OK FIRST OF ALL LET ME TELL YOU IM NOT A TEENAGER AND IM NOT A CANON CHARACTER HATER AS YOU PUT IT ! I OWN SOME OF THE COMIC BOOKS AND THE CHRISTOPHER REEVES MOVIES . I CARE VERY MUCH ABOUT THE MYTHOS AND SUPERMAN JUST BECAUSE I LIKE CHLOE SULLIVAN DOES NOT GIVE YOU THE RIGHT THE BASH ME !
CHLOE LEAVING THE SHOW WAS NOT A PROBLEM NOR LEX LUTHOR IT'S ABOUT THE WAY THEY WERE EXITING THE SHOW ! IT SHOULD BE BETTER AND EXPLAINED BETTER ! MY POINT IS I WILL STILL WATCH THE SHOW BECAUSE WETHER THESE PEOPLE LEAVE BECAUSE AT THE END OF THE DAY CLARK BECOMING SUPERMAN IS MY NUMBER ONE CONCERN AND IM NOT HAPPY ABOUT THE FACT THAT THEY CHANGE THE MYTHOLOGY SOMETIMES , BUT SO DOES ALL THE COMIC BOOKS AND ALL THE MOVIES.
In the comic books there are alternate realities where superman is with wonder women and not lois lane so i guess everyone better stop reading the comic books because they don't stick to the historical mytho's. Then there is the new superman comics where superman is stuck in bizzaro world there's hundreds thousands so take your pick on what superman story you are following and come speak to me again later ... because you are the only hater i see , your words are filled with hate and angst you sound like the teenager not me ! do what you want ! you don't phase me ! im also not a lana hater i just don't like clana or the way it has been portrayed since season 5 all the angst and nit picking , clark is a handsome man and even in the real world i feel he would have left her sooner . plus they made lana seem always a victim and at times chloe was a victim as well but her loyalty never failed she has always been there number 1 for clark and for some reason you hate her well go ahead while your at it hate lionel too because he was also created for smallville and he was a great character !
YOU ARE THE HATER .. AND IM NO LONGER RESPONDING TO YOU !:lol:
----- Added 5 Minutes later -----
Look at the facts it was Chloe and not Kara who saved Clark in the church after Teague almost killed him. The show is virtually about her now. And you do not care because you arer a certified canon character hater but those of us that watch the show for love of the DC/Superman Mythos and not the stupid teen angst garbage you haters adore won't stand for it...
what are you so angry about ? the lana video or alisson coming back i do not understand your rage ! oh by the way im 30 years old im not a teenager have a little respect !
----- Added 13 Minutes later -----
No I was angry at the whole thing as I said the canon character haters somehow got the upper hand and next season it will officially be the Chloe Sullivan show...
NOTE TO EVERYONE LANA WILL BE BACK NEXT SEASON !:)
shy175223
05-18-2008, 10:19 AM
But not for very Long...
dimeo782002
05-18-2008, 08:49 PM
But not for very Long...
I know i just wanted to make a point that not all the main. characters were gone.
I know Kristin will only be back to finish her contract but we have a lot to look forward too as well , final closure to there relationship and im positive they will still be friends then there is the new villians and alot more including green arrow's return most likly and lets not forget Clark he will always be there !:D
citizenlen
05-18-2008, 11:15 PM
Everyone knew it was bound to happen, but it was poor writing. I guess, I can't blame them, since KK is out shooting her SF movie and the ba$tard$ wanted to milk the Clana for all they can.
Although, I'm a Clana fan, I'm soooo glad that ship is over. Butt, I want CK to be alone and no lovey-lovey with this Tess character. He really needs to learn on his own. Maybe, with Chloe in Federal prison, he can finally think on his own. Well, it seems like everyone is
growing except for CK. Heck, even Chloe will first wear a suit than Superman, an orange jumpsuit that is.:lol:
Jade4813
05-18-2008, 11:17 PM
Everyone knew it was bound to happen, but it was poor writing. I guess, I can't blame them, since KK is out shooting her SF movie and the ba$tard$ wanted to milk the Clana for all they can.
Yeah, I would have much preferred they keep the breakup until next season, I think. It just feels incomplete this way, with just the video.
Unless next season is going to start after a time jump. And then that will feel slightly awkward with Clark suddenly being over Lana without any kind of wrapup conversation. :\
smallvillelogan
05-18-2008, 11:20 PM
Like most people have written: glad it's over, glad Lana realizes that he is destined for greater things, and wants to help him reach that potential, but weird that it ends through a DVD.
jesslang
05-19-2008, 07:37 AM
i will miss her..but ...idk ...i just hope that this last season of smallville is good .
LoveHurts38
05-19-2008, 07:58 AM
For crying out loud just want Lana say a sweet goodbye next season to Clark nothing romantic....I have a feeling Clark will be single next season.
Welling_is_pretty
05-19-2008, 01:11 PM
I've never been fond of Clana and so am happy we'll be moving on (hopefully, they've fooled us before and Kristin has said...).
shy175223
05-19-2008, 04:19 PM
For crying out loud just want Lana say a sweet goodbye next season to Clark nothing romantic....I have a feeling Clark will be single next season.
well, maybe.
SuperKyptonGirl13
05-19-2008, 06:20 PM
[QUOTE=dimeo782002;3798515]OK FIRST OF ALL LET ME TELL YOU IM NOT A TEENAGER AND IM NOT A CANON CHARACTER HATER AS YOU PUT IT ! I OWN SOME OF THE COMIC BOOKS AND THE CHRISTOPHER REEVES MOVIES . I CARE VERY MUCH ABOUT THE MYTHOS AND SUPERMAN JUST BECAUSE I LIKE CHLOE SULLIVAN DOES NOT GIVE YOU THE RIGHT THE BASH ME !
CHLOE LEAVING THE SHOW WAS NOT A PROBLEM NOR LEX LUTHOR IT'S ABOUT THE WAY THEY WERE EXITING THE SHOW ! IT SHOULD BE BETTER AND EXPLAINED BETTER ! MY POINT IS I WILL STILL WATCH THE SHOW BECAUSE WETHER THESE PEOPLE LEAVE BECAUSE AT THE END OF THE DAY CLARK BECOMING SUPERMAN IS MY NUMBER ONE CONCERN AND IM NOT HAPPY ABOUT THE FACT THAT THEY CHANGE THE MYTHOLOGY SOMETIMES , BUT SO DOES ALL THE COMIC BOOKS AND ALL THE MOVIES.
In the comic books there are alternate realities where superman is with wonder women and not lois lane so i guess everyone better stop reading the comic books because they don't stick to the historical mytho's. Then there is the new superman comics where superman is stuck in bizzaro world there's hundreds thousands so take your pick on what superman story you are following and come speak to me again later ... because you are the only hater i see , your words are filled with hate and angst you sound like the teenager not me ! do what you want ! you don't phase me ! im also not a lana hater i just don't like clana or the way it has been portrayed since season 5 all the angst and nit picking , clark is a handsome man and even in the real world i feel he would have left her sooner . plus they made lana seem always a victim and at times chloe was a victim as well but her loyalty never failed she has always been there number 1 for clark and for some reason you hate her well go ahead while your at it hate lionel too because he was also created for smallville and he was a great character !
YOU ARE THE HATER .. AND IM NO LONGER RESPONDING TO YOU !:lol:
^ ITA with your post
hellnback
05-20-2008, 04:10 AM
first of all let me say that i'm glad Clana is over but i am sad to see KK go. i wasn't happy the way they handled her departure but i've heard that due to the writer's strike and of course her taking off to shoot the new street fighter movie that that was all the writers and the producers of the show could do to finish her story. she'll obviously be back in several episodes and it'll create some kind of tension again between her and clark but i think that by then clark will have moved on. lana will probably just return and save clark's life or come back with information of some kind that he might need. she'll be doing some kind of outside work that will have her away and then back when needed. any way i will miss seeing KK on the show but that part of the story had to end. now on to lois and clark.
WickedJenn
05-20-2008, 07:55 AM
first of all let me say that i'm glad Clana is over but i am sad to see KK go. i wasn't happy the way they handled her departure but i've heard that due to the writer's strike and of course her taking off to shoot the new street fighter movie that that was all the writers and the producers of the show could do to finish her story. she'll obviously be back in several episodes and it'll create some kind of tension again between her and clark but i think that by then clark will have moved on. lana will probably just return and save clark's life or come back with information of some kind that he might need. she'll be doing some kind of outside work that will have her away and then back when needed. any way i will miss seeing KK on the show but that part of the story had to end. now on to lois and clark.
Hey I know you :D
And I also would like to see them settle things properly next season and both move on from being together.
Ryudo
05-20-2008, 08:00 AM
Hey I know you :D
And I also would like to see them settle things properly next season and both move on from being together.
For Clana, "settle things properly" equates to standing awkwardly in silence and making strange facial expressions, whilst opening and closing their mouths much like fish.
I think that when they time jump through the summer or whatever, Lois and Chloe will have helped Clark move on from it. As far as he knows, she has taken off and he'll respect her wishes to not try to find her. I think if it gets played off well, it will be a nice surprise for him to see her next year.
And if they can get Sam Jones back, maybe they can do a guest spot and hint at the Plana relationship (which is canon).
dimeo782002
05-20-2008, 07:07 PM
[QUOTE=dimeo782002;3798515]OK FIRST OF ALL LET ME TELL YOU IM NOT A TEENAGER AND IM NOT A CANON CHARACTER HATER AS YOU PUT IT ! I OWN SOME OF THE COMIC BOOKS AND THE CHRISTOPHER REEVES MOVIES . I CARE VERY MUCH ABOUT THE MYTHOS AND SUPERMAN JUST BECAUSE I LIKE CHLOE SULLIVAN DOES NOT GIVE YOU THE RIGHT THE BASH ME !
CHLOE LEAVING THE SHOW WAS NOT A PROBLEM NOR LEX LUTHOR IT'S ABOUT THE WAY THEY WERE EXITING THE SHOW ! IT SHOULD BE BETTER AND EXPLAINED BETTER ! MY POINT IS I WILL STILL WATCH THE SHOW BECAUSE WETHER THESE PEOPLE LEAVE BECAUSE AT THE END OF THE DAY CLARK BECOMING SUPERMAN IS MY NUMBER ONE CONCERN AND IM NOT HAPPY ABOUT THE FACT THAT THEY CHANGE THE MYTHOLOGY SOMETIMES , BUT SO DOES ALL THE COMIC BOOKS AND ALL THE MOVIES.
In the comic books there are alternate realities where superman is with wonder women and not lois lane so i guess everyone better stop reading the comic books because they don't stick to the historical mytho's. Then there is the new superman comics where superman is stuck in bizzaro world there's hundreds thousands so take your pick on what superman story you are following and come speak to me again later ... because you are the only hater i see , your words are filled with hate and angst you sound like the teenager not me ! do what you want ! you don't phase me ! im also not a lana hater i just don't like clana or the way it has been portrayed since season 5 all the angst and nit picking , clark is a handsome man and even in the real world i feel he would have left her sooner . plus they made lana seem always a victim and at times chloe was a victim as well but her loyalty never failed she has always been there number 1 for clark and for some reason you hate her well go ahead while your at it hate lionel too because he was also created for smallville and he was a great character !
YOU ARE THE HATER .. AND IM NO LONGER RESPONDING TO YOU !:lol:
^ ITA with your post
What does ITA mean LOL ! im a little dumb with computer jabber LOL !:D
STFanatic
05-20-2008, 08:16 PM
[QUOTE=SuperKyptonGirl13;3801826]
What does ITA mean LOL ! im a little dumb with computer jabber LOL !:D
ITA = "I Totally Agree".
Here are some others you might see around here ;)
Acronyms & Abbreviations Decoded (http://www.kryptonsite.com/forums/showthread.php?t=61706)
WickedJenn
05-20-2008, 08:28 PM
For Clana, "settle things properly" equates to standing awkwardly in silence and making strange facial expressions, whilst opening and closing their mouths much like fish.
I think that when they time jump through the summer or whatever, Lois and Chloe will have helped Clark move on from it. As far as he knows, she has taken off and he'll respect her wishes to not try to find her. I think if it gets played off well, it will be a nice surprise for him to see her next year.
And if they can get Sam Jones back, maybe they can do a guest spot and hint at the Plana relationship (which is canon).
I just hope Clark isn't all angsty :\ Hopefully, like you suggest, Lois and Chloe will help him move on.
Super_Kara_2007
05-20-2008, 08:38 PM
I just hope Clark isn't all angsty :\ Hopefully, like you suggest, Lois and Chloe will help him move on.
Actually, it's Tess that will definitely help CK move on. :D
shy175223
05-21-2008, 06:08 AM
I doubt it!
Ryudo
05-21-2008, 11:40 AM
Actually, it's Tess that will definitely help CK move on. :D
We'll see. Not a lot has been said about her.
dimeo782002
05-21-2008, 05:51 PM
[QUOTE=dimeo782002;3803793]
ITA = "I Totally Agree".
Here are some others you might see around here ;)
Acronyms & Abbreviations Decoded (http://www.kryptonsite.com/forums/showthread.php?t=61706)
Thank you soooo much that is very sweet it helped alot ! Thank you !:)
christian_kryptonian
05-22-2008, 12:16 AM
I am REALLY happy with this as her ending believe it or not. I think when she comes back they can do it right without rehashing anything. I think it will all work out if those writers write it right! lol
ginnyfan
05-22-2008, 12:19 AM
There's a lot of continuity in what Lana says to Clark in the video.
Action:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Uxj-0hkD7Q
Arctic:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FdVYK1xPNQs
Serynarpc
05-22-2008, 03:45 AM
I'm happy it's over, but Lana got really screwed in terms of a good farewell. Over a month not on the show and then reduced to a taped cameo goodbye. She deserved more.
I completely agree. Lana has been Clark's 'It' girl for the entire series and she got a three minute video goodbye to 'end their relationship'. Its completely bogus. I'm a Chlark shipper and all that jazz, but even I think Clana deserves more of a ending. Like perhaps- an actual face to face one.
We've seen their awkward fights and showdowns, but theres no excuse for Lana to have left a videotape instead of waiting for him. Clark's been visiting her every day instead of oh- mustering a plan for saving himself from Lex's control and she couldn't wait a few hours? The writers never even gave an explanation besides the perceived 'I wussed out and couldn't bear to face you'.
Lame.
ginnyfan
05-22-2008, 02:44 PM
I don't think that will be the final goodbye.
Genny
05-22-2008, 04:27 PM
I can not handle any more Clana. It's time for Clois. Clois is the future of Smallville. And no Chlark, Chimmy all the way. I hope we get some Clois next season.
redraven
05-22-2008, 04:28 PM
Clois is the future of superman, not Smallville. Lois shouldn't even be here.
ginnyfan
05-22-2008, 04:55 PM
I too am looking forward to more Clois... but KK is going to be in a few episodes next season... so I doubt that the video goodbye will be the final goodbye.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.1.10 Copyright © 2012 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.