Claire vs. Elle

[Alexander III]

It looks like they're gonna have a catfight next episode. Who will win? :D

My vote is on Elle...she's gonna fry her deep!! But Claire won't die...geez.

[Lexgirl33]

Well...Claire of course. Its a little harder for Claire to die.

[STFanatic]

Well, if Claire could hold up to the heat and radiation from Ted till she looked like a steak forgotten on a grill, and endure the pain from the toe snip, then a steady stream of zapping wouldn't hold her back too much.

But BOY would she have the frizzies later. :p

[warriorrenegade]

Elle would win. Come on here. She works for the company and is the "Executioner". So I'm sure shes had the practice.

[Mello Penelo]

I'm sure it would be a standoff. Claire would be in too much pain from constant frying. Elle would be too tired from frying Claire constantly.

[closetclana]

I got to say Claire. Elle seems to have a big weakness. Wasn't it implied by tonight’s episode that if Elle was shooting sparks and thrown into a pond she would fry herself? But Claire can take a lick’n and keep on tick’n.

[Mello Penelo]

Originally posted by closetclana
Wasn't it implied by tonight’s episode that if Elle was shooting sparks and thrown into a pond she would fry herself?

It shouldn't have even needed to be implied. Electricity and water don't mix.

[Alexander III]

Originally posted by STFanatic
Well, if Claire could hold up to the heat and radiation from Ted till she looked like a steak forgotten on a grill, and endure the pain from the toe snip, then a steady stream of zapping wouldn't hold her back too much.

But BOY would she have the frizzies later. :p

Duuuuuuuuuude ur avi ROCKS!!
I want some potpie man!! Santa Linderman, please give me some!! :D

[STFanatic]

Originally posted by Alexander III
Duuuuuuuuuude ur avi ROCKS!!
I want some potpie man!! Santa Linderman, please give me some!! :D


Thanks :D

[krpto]

all claire would have to dom is throw elle in a pool then elle would either drown from lack of swimming lessons since I am sure the company wouldn't want her near water with the electric powers or she would fry herself by losing her temper and using her powers while in the water.

[STFanatic]

Two words.

Super Soaker :p

[Praxis]

It would be a long fight; Elle would keep zapping Claire, Claire would keep going down and getting right back up. Eventually either Elle would run away or Claire would get in a lucky punch.

[Xanderman]

I say Elle. Technically she can fry Claire's brain to the point of no return if she wanted to. :lol:

[Ginx]

I say Elle, she's just more street wise than Claire and although Claire can regenerate, Elle would be able to take her down. I mean she was around for when they took Adam down - she knows how it's done.

[spicyblark]

Claire can't die and Elle is an idiot. It's not really a question, Elle could fry her, but it wouldn't do anything. Claire would live and Elle would pout.

[Praxis]

It looked like Elle was on the beach where Claire was dumping some kind of ashes...perhaps the same beach Noah "died" on. I think that the things Noah told Elle will sink in and she'll switch sides at some point.

[superman07]

Claire cant die but what can she really do to a girl who has electrical powers? I say a draw

[Xanderman]

Claire can't come back from anything, there are limits. If her brain is totally fried, it will be inoperable, and healing won't happen. The brain must be able to function without hindrance for regeneration to occur, as we've seen last season for both Claire and Peter.

So Elle can definitely kill Claire with a sustained electric shock to her brain, frying it beyond human recognition. Destroying the brain in this way will kill Claire.

[flying_girl]

it would take alot to fry a human brain. after all the brain works through electricity. thats how neurons work. im not sure that elle can fry brains

[trying2b]

I go with Claire for the pure fact that I just love her. In the preview it looked like Claire was about to kick her ass. IMO Claire is one tough little sister.

[krpto]

I say claire would win but it would be a long fight elle keeps shocking her well they fight claire destracts her by pointing at peter then pushes her into a pool or some other area filled with water and elle shocks herself to death.

[STFanatic]

We know that Claire can resist tremendous pain and regenerate pretty fast from what we saw with the heat/flame/radiation from Ted and the toe snipping event.
We don't know if she can resist being hit by constant zapping from "Tazer Girl", if it effected her nervous system the fight would be over in seconds, if she could resist, Elle's batteries may run out before she could take out Claire.

Maybe in the future we will get to see.

[krpto]

punch Zap punch zap punch zap.

Claire:Oh Look elle theres your boy toy and my uncle peter
Elle: Really? (turns to look)
Claire:HaHa stupid elle (pushes elle into a nearby pool)

that would be my take on it though With writters anything could happen.

[Xanderman]

Originally posted by flying_girl
it would take alot to fry a human brain. after all the brain works through electricity. thats how neurons work. im not sure that elle can fry brains The brain can only tolerate so much electric current/charge. The levels I'm talking about would melt her pretty face like butter, and fry her brain to a crisp. lol


Originally posted by STFanatic
We don't know if she can resist being hit by constant zapping from "Tazer Girl", if it effected her nervous system the fight would be over in seconds, if she could resist, Elle's batteries may run out before she could take out Claire. Yes it all depends on how powerful a charge she can generate and how long she can sustain it. If powerful enough and long enough, Claire's brain will be destroyed and that will be her end, as even if her blood grows back another brain, her memories/knowledge would be completely gone -- the new brain would basically be a blank slate.

[STFanatic]

Then again Adam was fried to a crisp and totally recovered, although we don't know how long it took him to recover.

[bobsuncorp]

Maybe the mudman will get involved and turn the whole thing into a mud wrestling competition....


Sorry, sorry.

[Xanderman]

Originally posted by STFanatic
Then again Adam was fried to a crisp and totally recovered, although we don't know how long it took him to recover. We don't know the extent of the injuries he suffered, do we? What I'm talking about is a specifically directed/targeted attack from Elle, focussed completely on electrocuting Claire's brain. Like if she puts her hands on either side of Claire's ears and then let's the sparks rip for an extended time, at brutal full blast. I think Claire's brain would be completely destroyed by this, faster than her brain can heal to keep up with the damage. And once the memories/knowledge areas are completely wiped out, there's no going back. Any healing that takes place would be brain matter without the additions gained from life/experience, meaning a clean slate, a zombie brain. lol

[STFanatic]

In "Out of Time", Kensi/Adam was totally fried:

http://i91.photobucket.com/albums/k292/Startrekfanatic/Stuff/th_Kensi-Adam-head.gif (http://i91.photobucket.com/albums/k292/Startrekfanatic/Stuff/Kensi-Adam-head.gif)
http://i91.photobucket.com/albums/k292/Startrekfanatic/Stuff/th_Kensi-Adam.gif (http://i91.photobucket.com/albums/k292/Startrekfanatic/Stuff/Kensi-Adam.gif)


And he regenerated, the thing we don't know is, how long it took him to do so.

[taolbi]

Originally posted by bobsuncorp
Maybe the mudman will get involved and turn the whole thing into a mud wrestling competition....


Sorry, sorry.


Do not be sorry...

There is always hope...

[Xanderman]

Originally posted by STFanatic
In "Out of Time", Kensi/Adam was totally fried:

http://i91.photobucket.com/albums/k292/Startrekfanatic/Stuff/th_Kensi-Adam-head.gif (http://i91.photobucket.com/albums/k292/Startrekfanatic/Stuff/Kensi-Adam-head.gif)
http://i91.photobucket.com/albums/k292/Startrekfanatic/Stuff/th_Kensi-Adam.gif (http://i91.photobucket.com/albums/k292/Startrekfanatic/Stuff/Kensi-Adam.gif)


And he regenerated, the thing we don't know is, how long it took him to do so. Yikes I don't even remember that scene.:lol: Can you tell me what happened there? How was it verified that that was in fact Kensei? Lol, because you're right he does look pretty damned close to being ashes there...:lol:

[STFanatic]

That was when Hiro went back and gathered the Kensi armor after the explosion.

[Xanderman]

Couldn't Kensei have just put his armor on some other dude? He likely walked away from the scene of that fire/explosion well before that point. I don't think that was really Kensei's corpse Hiro found.

[STFanatic]

He didn't have time, Hiro offered to teleport him out of the gunpowder room before it exploded, but he refused, Hiro blinked just outside as it exploded, there was no way anyone could have had time to enter and switch armor with him and Kensi/Adam to escape.

[Ireallylikethisshow]

Elle!!!

And Claire doesn't really have a reason to be upset at her anyway, they both are at an odds. Both fathers kidnapped them, and both fathers are alive.

[Xanderman]

Originally posted by STFanatic
He didn't have time, Hiro offered to teleport him out of the gunpowder room before it exploded, but he refused, Hiro blinked just outside as it exploded, there was no way anyone could have had time to enter and switch armor with him and Kensi/Adam to escape. Kensei could have walked about during the fire, walking through the fire, in a state of being burned yet regenerating at the same time at an equal pace. He could have found some dead/dying guy, put his armor on him, then put the body in the same place Hiro left him....right? I don't remember the scenes enough unfortunately to judge if this can be true or not, I'll have to go by your opinion...is this possible? Hiro came back after the fire burned itself out, didn't he? It wasn't immediately after the explosion was it?

[STFanatic]

Well, the fire was still burning, and the body was still smoking, but the explosion was at night and Hiro returned when it was daylight.

[Xanderman]

Meaning plenty of time for Kensei to pull a switcheroo then high tail his ass out of there. Those likely weren't really his remains. He just wanted Hiro, and perhaps history, to think he was dead.

[STFanatic]

Well, IMO, I believe they were supposed to be the remains of Kensi/Adam, thus reminding us that Adam can regenerate, and surprising us (like we didn't see it coming) when he appeared getting his hand zapped by Peter.

[Xanderman]

I still think it's going to come out he faked his death there/planted a corpse...

Adam: You didn't really think those were MY charred remains did you, you stupid boy?

Hiro: Virrin! Virrin!

Adam: That was just the village idiot I put my armor on. You're so easily fooled, Hiro McFool.

Hiro: You a bad man, Kensei! You a very very bad man! Like Jerry Seinfeld!

Adam: Bad man? Could've my mother been wrong?

:lol: