West knows where Claire lives......

[InLove_with_Chloe]

So, he might very well have seen her dad while spying on her.......and therefore know the 'man with the horn rimmed glasses' is her dad.
Duh.

[hansioux]

Originally posted by InLove_with_Chloe
So, he might very well have seen her dad while spying on her.......and therefore know the 'man with the horn rimmed glasses' is her dad.
Duh.

if not, god forbid West from ever going to the copy place.

[InLove_with_Chloe]

Hehe, I was assuming there's more than 1 copy place in that town....... But West pretty much picked Claire up at home, he also has peeked through her window g before.....he must have seen HRG. That's actually pretty obvious, IMO.

[Son of Kal-El20]

Maybe it's not her dad that took him. Maybe it's another guy with glasses. I'm also starting think that West was sent by someone to watch over Claire.

[pycer]

He said man in horn rimmed glasses, HRG, MR Bennett is the HRG, and I dont think hes there watching over her, hes just a creepy pervert thats needs an ass whooping

[ShadowOntheSun]

y'know...now that we've seen the picture with the twelve old heroes... don't you think that HRG may not be the guy that West is talking about??...

I think that I might have been Pa Petrelli, I mean, he kinda looks like HRG in the picture, doesn't he??

[Son of Kal-El20]

Originally posted by pycer
He said man in horn rimmed glasses, HRG, MR Bennett is the HRG, and I dont think hes there watching over her, hes just a creepy pervert thats needs an ass whooping

On this show things are not always what they seem. What you think is a creepy pervert could turn out to be a undercover dude sent to protect someone.

And just because Mr. Bennett has horn rimmed glasses doesn't mean he's the guy who took West. I mean, Mr. Bennett can't be the only guy in the world with horn rimmed glasses.

[KryptonzGirl]

Its pretty natural of everyone to just assume who is the culprit based on the most obvious choice in our minds at the time. I like the theory of the man West is talking about turning out not to be HRG, a nice twist and a suprise that will make everyones assumptions spiral out of control.

[STFanatic]

Actually that is pretty good thinking, another HRG guy. Hmmm...
Very possible.
Since West is very profishent with his power, he could have been "taken" quite a while back.
He could have been as young as Micah.

[ShelbyKent]

Good catch on Pa Petrelli being another guy with horn rimmed glasses.

But, Mr. Bennett is still the dude who's dead in the painting :(

[Son of Kal-El20]

My theory is, he might pull a hero's sacrifice thing. Perhaps he ends up trying to protect Claire and West from someone and ends up dying in the process. What i'm hoping for is that they find a way to prevent what happens in the painting.

But still I do not think he's the guy who took West.

[KryptonzGirl]

Thats another point...HRG may die heroically, not be horribly betrayed or become a villian. OH the possiblities and suspense! *flails*

[ShelbyKent]

The thing with the painting is that they don't necessarily come true, or they don't reflect the entire truth. Perhaps HRG is just injured in the painting and not yet dead.

And For all you know the "Claire" in the painting is a shape-shifted Sylar who's kissing West!

[pycer]

Originally posted by Son of Kal-El20
On this show things are not always what they seem. What you think is a creepy pervert could turn out to be a undercover dude sent to protect someone.

And just because Mr. Bennett has horn rimmed glasses doesn't mean he's the guy who took West. I mean, Mr. Bennett can't be the only guy in the world with horn rimmed glasses.

How many guys wearing horn rimmed glasses do ya think work for one undercover company specializing in abducting people and leaving those exact marks n people? Think maybe its a uniform like Men In Black or something? Guys in horn rimmed glasses? Instead of MiBs its HRGs?

You don't protect people by creeping in the trees and spying on a teenage girl in her bedroom. Around here, thats how you get yourself shot. Several times. In the head. As it should be.


...then shot some more. Just for good measure.

[Son of Kal-El20]

^I'm not sure how many work at the company. Could be three or four guys with horn rimmed glasses. Like I said, things are not always what they seem.

[Selene1212]

I'm pretty sure West would've seen HRG the first day of school when he nearly ran Claire over. He was standing right there.

I also think he's a creep.

[Son of Kal-El20]

Okay, so he's a peeping tom.

[KryptonzGirl]

Thought I think the theory of the man with the horn rimmed glasses is not really HRG. I honestly believe it is...everything is leading up to West finding out.

[ShelbyKent]

[QUOTE]Originally posted by Selene1212
[B]I'm pretty sure West would've seen HRG the first day of school when he nearly ran Claire over. He was standing right there.

Wasn't HRG inside his car when that happened? Or am I imagining things? :confused:

[one of the 12]

Yes, Noah is the HRG that took West. The glasses, the memory loss when he was taken are too coincidental with Noah and the Hiatian's previous work. There aren't any mentions of multiple team in the company that I remember, and when Claude's original partner was removed, he got Noah, then Noah got the Haitian. It's always seemed like there is only the one team. They traveled the world to find people with abilities, if there were more teams they would probably be more localized. The writers like their little plot twists, but his isn't one of them.

Oh by the way, if I was Noah, I doubt that I would jump to the conclusion that Claire's boyfriend killed me. I wouldn't expect my daughter to be standing next to my dead body being comforted by my killer. And as much as Noah knows about he paintings, he should know he can't prevent it from happening. The best thing he could do is to get away from Claire.

Sorry for rambling...

[Son of Kal-El20]

Listen, I'm not convinced that Noah did it. Sure he's the likely culprit but we go to remember that the show is still new and we don't know everything about the members of the company. There could be another dude wth horn rimmed glasses. Perhaps a former colleague of Mr. Bennett and the two didn't like each other.

And West, I'm pretty sure he's working for someone too. And I think he has a second power. The power to sense those who are gifted.