R.I.P. Clana (Merged)

[maplecelt]

Originally posted by monstra
LOL! This is SO not the end of Clana.

If you really think it is, you missed the point of the entire episode.


agreed. if anything this is only the beginning of clark and lana

[KryptonScouse]

^^^ Word.

[Fly by guy]

Everyone has an opinion so here is mine. Without Lana, SV wouldn't have lasted a season and no I don't think she is the star of the show but very important since episode one until now.

[KryptonScouse]

I think she lost importance at the end of season 3, and since the end of season 5, she's been working her way back up to the Lana we knew.

[jazel]

Originally posted by maplecelt
agreed. if anything this is only the beginning of clark and lana
beginning ? lol
Clana is like a sorry case of herpes.
You may have flare-ups, but you can go years without one.
Lana is Clark's STD case of herpes......lol
the cure is Lois, and we're just waiting on approval from the FDA, :D

[BrodyBear]

This isn't the end of Clana at all, what this episode has done is set up for Lex to eventually become truley evil. Lex can't be happy and have Lana, do you not remember the flashback with the warning from his mom?

Lex has his happiness for a moment, but it's all going to come crashing down on him when Lana loses the baby and eventually finds out what he did. The Lex will turn evil and it's then we will see the real evil Lex.

I also think Lionel's days are numbered now as he has a hold over Lex and I believe when everything comes to a head, Lex will murder his own father, lose Lana and turn to the dark side....

This episode was great IMO. We finally saw lana act mature and do something for the man she truely loves. Also, this is about Smallville, even though the writers have brought in Lois etc, there is no way her and Clark will get together for years yet, so I wish people would stop going on about how they want Clark and Lois together, it's not going to happen.

Clana will return, but I think it will play out where in the end they both know they can only be friends. Also now that lana knows Clarks secret, i actually don't see Chloe remaining around much longer either.

[jazel]

U contradicted yourself in one sentence.....lol
Clark and Lois won't get together for years, and then you say it won't happen.....lol
SV has changed the Canon, who's to say, they can't or will not, change the ultimate love story.
think it is safe to say, that nothing good comes from the Clana pairing.
Jonathan died.
Lana's actually a killer, killing Jason's mom. Can you see Clark with a killer ?
Lana would have killed recently, if Clark didn't intervene.
Anybody who commits murder should do jail time.
Maybe at the end of this season, that will finally come out. :D

[chlark=destiny]

Originally posted by BrodyBear
Also now that lana knows Clarks secret, i actually don't see Chloe remaining around much longer either.

Actually, SDK CONFIRMED that Chloe WILL NOT BE KILLED OFF on his myspace blog:D. . .He said that everyone LOVES her character TOO MUCH. . .PLUS, Chloe's character has been bought by DC COMICS, making her an official part of the superman mythos:D. . .ALSO, as far as Chloe and Clark are concerned, Clark WILL NEVER ditch Chloe for Lana, since she NOW knows;). . .HE WILL ALWAYS BE THERE FOR HER:D. . .PROTECTING HER AS HER PERSONAL BOMB SQUAD:D

[maplecelt]

Originally posted by jazel
U contradicted yourself in one sentence.....lol
Clark and Lois won't get together for years, and then you say it won't happen.....lol
SV has changed the Canon, who's to say, they can't or will not, change the ultimate love story.
think it is safe to say, that nothing good comes from the Clana pairing.
Jonathan died.
Lana's actually a killer, killing Jason's mom. Can you see Clark with a killer ?
Lana would have killed recently, if Clark didn't intervene.
Anybody who commits murder should do jail time.
Maybe at the end of this season, that will finally come out. :D

lana was possessed and acting in self defence.

also clark and pete were directly involved in a death in season 3 and if caught would have been charged with manslaughter.

[chlark=destiny]

Originally posted by jazel
comic book Lana, was a minute character correct ? LOL :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:


Originally posted by maplecelt
agreed. if anything this is only the beginning of clark and lana

Yeah, it's the beginning alright:rolleyes:. . .THE BEGINNING OF CLANA FRIENDSHIP:lol:

[jazel]

self defense ? lol
if that makes her sleep at night.
she could have hurt the woman, not murder her, jeeeeeez :p
could have washed off the blood on the stone too....lol

[chlark=destiny]

Originally posted by KryptonScouse
I think she lost importance at the end of season 3, and since the end of season 5, she's been working her way back up to the Lana we knew.

AGREED:D. . .Lana/CLANA DOES NOT MAKE SV SUCCESSFUL;). . .Fans have different reasons for watching the show:). . .Put it this way. . .Promise was one of the LOWEST rated episodes of the season:), and this episode revolved around CLEXANA;). . .Freak had the SECOND HIGHEST RATING OF THE SEASON NEXT TO Justice :D and that episode focused on CHLARK:p. . .So, NO, CLANA DOES NOT MAKE THIS SHOW SUCCESSFUL;). . .SV will SURVIVE, when CLANA are JUST FRIENDS;)

[BrodyBear]

I didn't contradict myself, I was merely stating that Lois & Clark getting together in this show will not happen, not that it will never happen period.

Even though the Mythos has been hung drawn and quarterd, Smallville still has the main foundation of Clarks life in his Smallville years and that was his love for Lana.

As much as Chlark & clois fans hate Clana, end of the day this is what the show is purposely about.

[Clana4Life]

Clark and Lana just friends? I don't ever see that happening. These two have been in love since they were babes in the womb. j/k but you get the point. I don't see their love embers dying down to friendship. She either has to die for Clark to somehow get over her or Lex has to at least make Clark & the rest of the world think that she is dead while he keeps her locked up somewhere. Sounds like something Lex might do with his "if I can't have you, no one can" line of thinking. Okay, those are just my ideas for what would make a great show, but I don't think Clark + Lana will ever equal platonic friendship. SV was never written like that. THey just keep making these two love each other more and more and they can't seem to get over each other - ever, no matter what. So, IMO there's only one way for Clark to move on (perhaps that's a better way of saying it than saying "get over" her.) He won't ever "get over" her but if she dies, he might one day move on. Well, we know he ultimately does move on.

[Bonita_LovesSuperman]

Originally posted by chlark=destiny
:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:



Yeah, it's the beginning alright:rolleyes:. . .THE BEGINNING OF CLANA FRIENDSHIP:lol:

Oh please, Gosh.. it's not our fault that chlark will stay FRIENDS.. and promise had low rating to CHLARK fans.. There are lots of CLANA fans in the world:D thats what i hate about chlark fans they just bag people who go for clana, and i dont see clois fan going on about it, maybe Jazel but we had a misunderstanding:)... do you see me saying crap about chlark... Clana is still on, it's Clark's young Love and it's smallville... and Clois is next:) Chloe and Jimmy deserve each other:D

<3Boniita ^^^And welcome Newbie another clana on our list:D, dont worry about the chlark fans:D:D

[jazel]

BrodyBear, disagree that Smallville is ultimately about Clana.
Smallville is the universe, where we see the pre-Superman.
It was intended to show us, how a young Clark Kent grows
into his role, as the planet's savior and hope.
Sorry, but no relationship, should shape who you
ultimately are. To place so much importance on Lana, Chloe, or
even Lois, is a disservice to Superman and Clark. Really do
miss Jonathan. He and Martha, are a bigger part of Clark, than
Lana will ever be.
Said it once and I'll say it again, Lana should have died
in Reckoning.
Engaged to Clark, and one phone call has her running
to Lex. That's NOT the true love, or loyalty Clark deserves.
The fact that she more or less gives Clark's secret away,
within minutes of meeting Lex, proved Clark correct, in him
NOT trusting her.
I just wish Clark would wake-up, and examine ALL that
a little more thourghly. Believe he will, one-day soon. :p


Bonita I respect everybody. Doesn't matter which ship you
are supporting. It's all a matter of opinion ;)

[Kal_El_clone55]

Did anyone find the reappearance of the Clana engagement ring a bit odd?

Remember (in Episode # 100) he took Lana and a lump of coal to the cave & the fortress and made the diamond there.

When he went back in time, he had a lump of coal again.

So, when did he "re-make the ring" or did someone screw up the timeline?

Your thoughts?

[Bonita_LovesSuperman]

Originally posted by jazel
BrodyBear, disagree that Smallville is ultimately about Clana.
Smallville is the universe, where we see the pre-Superman.
It was intended to show us, how a young Clark Kent grows
into his role, as the planet's savior and hope.
Sorry, but no relationship, should shape who you
ultimately are. To place so much importance on Lana, Chloe, or
even Lois, is a disservice to Superman and Clark. Really do
miss Jonathan. He and Martha, are a bigger part of Clark, than
Lana will ever be.
Said it once and I'll say it again, Lana should have died
in Reckoning.
Engaged to Clark, and one phone call has her running
to Lex. That's NOT the true love, or loyalty Clark deserves.
The fact that she more or less gives Clark's secret away,
within minutes of meeting Lex, proved Clark correct, in him
NOT trusting her.
I just wish Clark would wake-up, and examine ALL that
a little more thourghly. Believe he will, one-day soon. :p


Bonita I respect everybody. Doesn't matter which ship you
are supporting. It's all a matter of opinion ;)


yeah ok then, but isnt it true the your love for someone will help you... But i respect your opinion:D But clana has one more in them... and that is true Martha and Jonathan, are a big part of his life... But isnt it friends will always help you on the way:)

[jazel]

yup friends do help.....lol ;)
but there are people in this world, who can affect
you negatively, if you allow them to.

[Bonita_LovesSuperman]

^^^ Yeah that's true... but you have to choose the right one;)

[jazel]

yup, ultimately it's your choice........
sadly for Clanaers, Clark has proven time and
time again, she's NOT the one ;)

[DeesRyche]

And yet they insist on trying to recruit us...

Anyway, I ship Clois I know it's the end game and I dream of the day when Clana is dead.

I have said it before and I will say it again give Clark some alone time, bring in a fun angst free ship..have him start seeing Lois in a new light..something but yeah long past due to bury Clana...please...

[Bonita_LovesSuperman]

yeh but for smallville she is:) just give us Clana one more time... I think Clana attract young people and thats what there doing:)... Chlark will remain good friends, else relationship will wreck them... and then it would be clois turn:) Don't you just want one more proper relationship from them... Gosh i do, and there would be no lies and crap:D SO ROMANTIC

[myankskent]

I love what you have written right above your avatar, Bonita_LovesSuperman.

[Bonita_LovesSuperman]

:D :lol: umm are you a chlark fan... :D

[myankskent]

Originally posted by Bonita_LovesSuperman
:D :lol: umm are you a chlark fan... :D

Now why would you think that when I told you that I love what you have written above your avatar? I wasn't being scarcastic.

[Bonita_LovesSuperman]

oh :lol: thats cool... well they will and never more then that:) sorry about that myyankskent thought you were being sarcastic:)

[myankskent]

It's all good B_LS.:)

[jazel]

Originally posted by Bonita_LovesSuperman
yeh but for smallville she is:) just give us Clana one more time... I think Clana attract young people and thats what there doing:)... Chlark will remain good friends, else relationship will wreck them... and then it would be clois turn:) Don't you just want one more proper relationship from them... Gosh i do, and
there would be no lies and crap:D SO ROMANTIC

Sorry honey, but the Clana was never proper or normal.
Mortal showed us, how quickly Clark wished, he had his
powers back, when he lost them.

Don't understand why, you keep bringing up Chlark (yeah they're great friends, everybody knows that).......technically
it's Chimmy (he's awesome BTW,lol). So Chloe doesn't
factor, into Clark's romantic equations.

Now Lana has chosen Lex, is still pregnant w/ his child.
How can you possibly hope for a Clana reunion ?
Lana told it to Clark the best...."you just can't see me in
the same way".....why would he even TRY to go there?:o :o :o

[Bonita_LovesSuperman]

Chlark... because all the chlark fans are everywhere and they want Chlark to romanticly happen... chimmy is cute i agree with that.

Clark wanted his powers back because someone is going to pay the price for his life.. he was so happy when he had no powers with Lana. and Lana wanted to go with Lex trying to hide feelings for clark and try to get over him.. Because clark is the one who broke it off. She said yes to Lex because of the baby and when that baby goes, no stopping Clana... and she will realize how liar lex is:D

[jazel]

why Lex ? why couldn't she be on her own, for awhile ?
obviously your a bit naive, about relationships (don't take
offense)
but even if the baby is no more, the fact that she married Lex for love (so told him, don't know how many times), doesn't mean
she'll leave Lex right away.
Lana went into the marriage suspious of Lex.
Clark can't possibly EVER she her, in the same way.

[Absolute Kingdom]

Originally posted by myankskent
I wasn't being sarcastic.

Sometimes its hard to tell with you :D

[myankskent]

Originally posted by Absolute Kingdom
Sometimes its hard to tell with you :D

:lol: I know, I like to be like Lionel Luthor and remain ambiguous to keep people on their toes. I'm sneaky like that.:D

[Bonita_LovesSuperman]

Originally posted by jazel
why Lex ? why couldn't she be on her own, for awhile ?
obviously your a bit naive, about relationships (don't take
offense)
but even if the baby is no more, the fact that she married Lex for love (so told him, don't know how many times), doesn't mean
she'll leave Lex right away.
Lana went into the marriage suspious of Lex.
Clark can't possibly EVER she her, in the same way.

Well maybe lana is a type off person that doesnt like to be alone. I didnt take it in a bad way, calling me naive:D but ill probably made is sound that way. Well clark knows there is something wrong because she told him, that she loved him and didnt want to marry Lex. she started crying when she said she loved lex... and clark could sense there was something wrong... she didnt marry lex for Love married him because of the baby, she didnt want the baby to go without a father.... but i have to see that epi again. Im just saying Clana needs to happen again, a better proper one with no secrets and lies... Something to remember for the clanas:D

[jazel]

most people who are fans of Superman, are praying the
the Clana is DOA.....she died in Reckoning :)
Lana needs to hightail it, out of Smallville. Clark needs
to embrace his destiny, and she is NOT it :p

[Bonita_LovesSuperman]

Yeh but it aint superman returns yet... There alot of people that want clana to come back... But i said again maybe clana is aiming at younger people..... He doesnt have a destiny yet and when he goes to training then he will no his superman then goes with Lois:D Lois wasnt even suppose to be in smallville:D

[jazel]

okay, think their (tptb at SV) aim is off.
even young people aren't watching.
EVERYBODY, young and old alike, are tired
of the Clana merry-go-round.
people have had enough.....they both need to move
on....maybe Promise is the TRUE start of that.

[Bonita_LovesSuperman]

Ummm there is alot of people my age, aint sick of Clana, because maybe its like a teenage thing... Just a fall in love thing for us... like you experience everything being a mum and all... Like for us teenagers, we fall in love, nothing can stop us... and to see Clark fall in love with Lana again and so deeply in love... You just wish there was a guy like that. If you know what i mean..

Well just One more Clana im begging. then i'll shut up then, and let the smallville do it's works:D

[jazel]

Originally posted by Bonita_LovesSuperman
Ummm there is alot of people my age, aint sick of Clana, because maybe its like a teenage thing... Just a fall in love thing for us... like you experience everything being a mum and all... Like for us teenagers, we fall in love, nothing can stop us... and to see Clark fall in love with Lana again and so deeply in love... You just wish there was a guy like that. If you know what i mean..

Well just One more Clana im begging. then i'll shut up then, and let the smallville do it's works:D

This will be my last post to you, addressing this subject !

Clana is DEAD....may it RIP and NEVER rear it's ugly head !

Now I think like a teenager, because honestly teenagers
think they know it all. As an ADULT I know what's what.

I married as a teenager, and have more happy years, than
you could wrap your head around. I married a Clark Kent, my
husbands personality wasn't shaped by any whiny, needy female.

Clana won't happen in the sense that you want, too much
baggage there, for it to be romantic or sweet. Lana's a
killer for Christ's sake.

You have to let the fantasy go, it'll be less painful for
you in the long run ! :)

Wish ya well, kiddo ;)

[Bonita_LovesSuperman]

Mate.. The show is Fiction. I can dream if i want:D and my mums is an adult and she always tell me off that we no everything, and i dont need you too lecture me. And if you were a adult why would you watch smallville if you didnt like Clana or something or complaining about it.. well this is my last post too.. my heart aint going to break if Clana doesnt happen.. ;) damn married as a young teenager, maybe when your were 19 or something... damn long time. well Clark kent is respectful, Hot young man, but its a fictional chracter. well im not going to say anything more, you sound angry so bye bye..Hope you and your husband goes well and respectful to you and faithful:D:D

Wish you well too:D

[jazel]

lol Tom will be 30 in a month
just frustrated at your lack of sense
didn't start watching SV until Lois came on board, don't
care about Lana :p
sometimes I don't understand what you are saying,is
English your 2nd language ?

[cotton candy girl]

Originally posted by jazel
okay, think their (tptb at SV) aim is off.
even young people aren't watching.
EVERYBODY, young and old alike, are tired
of the Clana merry-go-round.
people have had enough.....they both need to move
on....maybe Promise is the TRUE start of that.

I'm sorry but Clana still has many fans.

[emily feist]

I think there will be one last shot at romantic Clana in the last season. I really don't think Lionel will survive and he's the only thing coming between them now. Once he's gone and she finds out the truth about Lex and the baby, she'll tell Clark about everything that she knows. I don't ship them and I don't have any hatred toward them like others. After seeing them together in the beginning of season 5, I can see why people like them together. The last time around will have an ending that is more natural and has nothing to do with lies or other people, it will just be them realzing their on different paths. I do hope that if they don't rekindle their romance that he can atleast have some happiness with Lori Lemaris, if they choose to bring her on next season. I really just want Clark in a happy relationship before he leaves Smallville.

[Absolute Kingdom]

Originally posted by myankskent
:lol: I know, I like to be like Lionel Luthor and remain ambiguous to keep people on their toes. I'm sneaky like that.:D

Not more than me :rotfl:

[bad3appels]

R.I.P??
this will bring them even closer :lol:

[jazel]

Originally posted by bad3appels
R.I.P??
this will bring them even closer :lol:
didn't see the epi.
but how is the Lexana marriage, and baby gonna
bring Clana back ? LOL

[redraven]

^^It's the reason that Lex and Lana married....Lana married him to protect Clark, not because she was in love with Lex.

And the baby...well there's a whole lot of possiblities to bring Clana back with the baby scenario.

[bad3appels]

Plus now,she knows.
and when clark will found out that she did that for him...
damn...he will love her even more.

[Absolute Kingdom]

That's not all. When he finds out that she wasn't even pregnant .... I smell Clana from a mile away. :D I dont like it, but it seems that's the direction they're taking.

[Nightingale20]

Originally posted by Absolute Kingdom
That's not all. When he finds out that she wasn't even pregnant .... I smell Clana from a mile away. :D I dont like it, but it seems that's the direction they're taking.

Yep, sadly I can see it happening. A few episodes this season have hinted towards Clana so I wouldn't put it past them to show it again. :\

[uselessuses]

Word

[Absolute Kingdom]

Originally posted by Nightingale20
Yep, sadly I can see it happening. A few episodes this season have hinted towards Clana so I wouldn't put it past them to show it again. :\

Yep, grab your tissues people, we're in for another Clana ride. God help us all :D

[jazel]

understand Clark will always, be protective of Lana.
but the Clana everybody is hoping for, won't happen. ;),

[maplecelt]

they can't used lois and clark in love because of the movie, so lana and clark have to get back to together at least once to drag smallville through a 7th season

[jazel]

didn't say anything about Clois, but Clana can never be, too many factors are now in play :p

[Bonita_LovesSuperman]

Originally posted by jazel
lol Tom will be 30 in a month
just frustrated at your lack of sense
didn't start watching SV until Lois came on board, don't
care about Lana :p
sometimes I don't understand what you are saying,is
English your 2nd language ?

Mate is that suppose to be racist because i was born in Australia, and my dad is aussie.. I was talking about you getting married, you said you were married when you were a teenager and i just said 17, and i also said it was a very long time.. My mate is here and she didnt have trouble.. I think you need glasses:rolleyes:
Well Do you Understand me? I wish i knew a different language:) i only no english BUDDY:) NOW DO YOU UNDERSTAND... or you want me to by you a dictionary:D And Clana will happen woohooo:D, One More Clana:D

[Nightingale20]

Originally posted by Absolute Kingdom
Yep, grab your tissues people, we're in for another Clana ride. God help us all :D

It wouldn't be bad if it didn't sacrifice characters especially Clark. But yeah Promise seemed to have a it's baaaack vibe. *cue the Jaws theme song*

[jazel]

Originally posted by Bonita_LovesSuperman
Mate is that suppose to be racist because i was born in Australia, and my dad is aussie.. I was talking about you getting married, you said you were married when you were a teenager and i just said 17, and i also said it was a very long time.. My mate is here and she didnt have trouble.. I think you need glasses:rolleyes:
Well Do you Understand me? I wish i knew a different language:) i only no english BUDDY:) NOW DO YOU UNDERSTAND... or you want me to by you a dictionary:D And Clana will happen woohooo:D, One More Clana:D

Awe hun, I'm not racist, lol
some of my family, lives in Sydney :)
know mate means friend...lol ;)
my vision is 20/20, thanks for your concern :D
sometimes the way you phrase things, gets me
confused...lol
that's why I thought English, could be your second language.
:o if you say so....lol

[Absolute Kingdom]

Originally posted by Nightingale20
It wouldn't be bad if it didn't sacrifice characters especially Clark. But yeah Promise seemed to have a it's baaaack vibe. *cue the Jaws theme song*

OK, now you're just scaring me. :D

[knotnamed]

The more I look at Promise, and the things that TPTB have said in the past (Reckoning, Hypnotic) the more I really come to believe that Mortal and the first 2 minutes of Hidden are all the Clana happiness we are ever going to get from Smallville. One-and-a-half episodes in 7 years. It is sad for romantic Clana fans, but I'm convinced that romantic Clana is done.

What is more sad is that TPTB would settle for that for their creations. It's sad that they couldn't muster the faith in love itself to even let fictional characters in a story have a fair chance at it. That is truly tragic, for TPTB as human beings. I pity them, because that kind of love does exist, and they can't see it, can't believe in it. If the highest expression of love you can come up with is the angsty, longing, "sacrificial" crap they've been giving us, then they have no idea what real love is.

Maybe they will quote me Jesus' "Greater love hath no man than he lay his life down for another." Okay, great. But you know what? Jesus sacrifice ensured that his people would be with him forever. Not separated from him. He made His sacrifice the very vehicle that brought him together with the objects of his love. Not put him apart from them. You wanna quote Jesus to me, TPTB? Then take your example all the way down to the floor or shut up. All you gotta do is believe.

The greatest emotion I will take away from Smallville is that of pity for it's creators. They have destroyed something beautiful because they couldn't bring themselves to believe it could really exist.

Somebody convince me I'm wrong.

[jazel]

really do feel bad, for all the people, who
were Clana followers......NOT cool, how they played
you all. to put that much time, into a show, and be
so dissatisfied ! at this point, whatever they do over there,
maybe a little too late for a lot of fans. ;)