Rate this episode: Loved it? Hated it?

[chlarkfan333]

Rate this episode.

[svfan50]

Haven't seen as yet!!! O....For the time zones...how was it????

[superhippie2000]

I hope this episode is good. looking forward to the chloe stuff. looked intresting in the trailer.

[kal-el_superman]

hmmm...considering it hasn't aired yet, Im speculating it will be a whopping 10.9 on the richter scale....too bad i"m one of those guys with the CW channel...

[Brock Solid]

Wow.....this thread's been around for about four and a half hours and no one has rated it yet? What happened to the ten or so people who pre-rate the episode before it airs we get all the time?

[kismet]

so far it's looking promising.... i'm saving my rate for the very end!

[kavalier]

So far this episode kicks total a##!! Back at Subterannean I thought this season was heading completely downhill, but ever since Hydro it has been turning out to be the best one yet.

[redraven]

^^I agree!

I rated a 10!

[jimmyolsenblues]

I loved it.
Great evil lex.
Great clark superpowers.
Great chloe and clark and clark and lana scenes.
I loved it.

[Brock Solid]

Oh. My. God.


That was amazing.

[MidgardDragon]

10/10, no contest, solid the whole way through and I was grinning ear to ear for all the super-powers shots.

[Ginx]

I have to say that I really liked this episode - it had a little bit of everyone in it and covered a lot of various topics. Even name dropped Ollie as a tie-in.

Clark also used multiple powers in small portions to get the various jobs done. And Lana seemed to be on Clark's side and Lex seemed to as evil as ever. 'Swear on the soul of my unborn child that I had nothing to do with it' wow......super evil Lex.

Plus the end scene with Clark and Chloe was just great - that he's her personal bomb squad/defuser. I thought that was a touching scene between the two characters.

[xHerox]

I really, really liked this episode! There was a little bit of everything in it, from Clana to Chlark to Evil Lex to intrigue, meteor freaks, and more. I really think this is one of the best of the season, even better than "Justice".

[LuckyStar]

Perfect 10. The ending was great! Way to go MR!

[Jaded Wolf]

I loved this episode! First Tom Welling shows he can direct and then Michael Rosenbaum slams us with a good one. TPTB should just let these two direct from now on.

Good use of Clark's powers here. The Superbreath returned as well as Chloe forcing Clark to hone his heat vision to microscopic precision. It's about time.

I like Lana playing this double agent and I really think she is putting two-and-two together about Clark. I wonder if secretly Lex is pissed she went behind his back and thwarted Tobias' execution.

What was also cool was Clark calling up his old friend Oliver Queen to take Tobias away. The League is truly coming into fruition with Clark accessing them more and more.

Stellar episode! I love how Lex looked in the camera in the end after ordering the continual monitoring of Chloe. Which brings me to an angry point. I am like Jimmy and if anything happens to Chloe not even Superman will be able to stop me!!! Anwyays, great episode and I dare anyone to say otherwise. :D

[Mackdaddy]

This episode was the best I've seen in while! It had everything Chlark, Lexana, Clana, Chimmy, I might have seen some Mork&Mindy in there;) A 10 all the way:D

[ITIMAN]

Last week I griped about not enough SuperPowers!

Wow, I got them tonight!!

AWESOME EPISODE!!!!!

[niki]

I gave it a 9/10.
I didn't really like the beginning, but it really picked up and all the superpowers made me happy.

An awesome episode!

[Supermansthebest]

Good job Michael Rosenbaum! Excellent episode …Clark used all his powers, X-ray vision, Heat ray, super strength and speed and breath! Lana had a brain…catching onto everything, loved all the Chlark scenes! Teased by the mention of star city and Oliver Queen. I can’t believe Chloes a freak though…loved the end! Totally worth watching…had fun!

[spideyfan]

Great episode.
I give this a 9/10 when I thought this was gonna be a filler...

Pros:
I was able to stomach Lana
Chlark
Lana is now confused about Clark
Lex is a bad bad mofo
Chlark
MR directing

Cons
Chloe = freak...I dont think we needed that

[bball44j]

Great episode because it started slow and picked up really fast as it went along. Great directing by Michael Rosenbaum and great acting by allthe characters. I gave it a ten.

[Deana]

It was good, but now I'm just annoyed that Lois and Martha didn't even get a mention.

[Markd329]

Ever since "Hydro", the show has been on a serious roll with the storyline and character developments taking giant steps.

On of the nice things about "Freak" is Clark starting to use his smarts [swiping the computer at super-speed], ans using his other powers on offense rather than on defense. Also, watching Lana play both sides was incredible, and guess what? SHE KNOWS, but cannot put everything together yet. Chloe telling Clark to use his heat vision on her was an act of sheer bravery, and her trust that he won't incinerate her took a lot of brass ones.

Mike and Tom are maturing into great directors, they know what to do with the characters in "Smallville" and how to get the best out the story and the actors. Hope they get to do more directing.

All in all, "Freak" was a fan-frakin-tastic episode.

Remember, we get "Justice" again [I will watch it until the tape beaks], and the show keeps on rolling!

[Rachel B]

Really good episode. Michael Rosenbaum did a great job directing, and I think all the actors were on tonight.

[Darth Pipes]

Really good episode. The storyline with Chloe is very intriguing and I look forward to seeing where it goes from here. Lex's descent into evil is continuing with great effectiveness as well. Nice to see Ollie still involved somewhere.

Rosenbaum did a good job with the direction of this episode. It had a dark, creepy atmosphere to it.

[meteor_phreak]

I gave this episode a 10.

it simply had everything i want. It gave me Chlark hope. It gave me an angst and anger free clark and lana. It gave good acting performances by everyone. it gave perfectly evil lex. it gave all the lexana angst that i've been waiting for. Man, this episode had it all.

[chole_fan]

I gave it a 10. For some reason, I wasn't exactly looking forward to this episode. But, man... It completely blew me away. I loved it:D Clark and Lana interacted like actual adults! And, it had a great little Chlark scene! Can't wait to see where they take the Chloe freak story.

And I agree, Rosenbaum did a great job directing.

[SuperFan85]

so now why is Lex all of a sudden kidnapping various Meteor Freaks, implanting them with GPS devices, and then having them killed, instead of locking them up in 33.1 for good like the others?

[Shadowlord367]

I never though season six could redeem its self after the first ten nine episodes. But the last six episodes have had that wow factor to them. When will this rampage of incredibility ever stop? I hope never. But still, the question remains:

Why cant smallville be like this all the time.

They were all just killed because incriminating information was found on the stolen laptop. That wasnt always the plan.

[trying2b]

Originally posted by Supermansthebest
Clark used all his powers, X-ray vision, Heat ray, super strength and speed and breath!

Don't forget about the superhearing.

Wow did I like this episode. This one was really well written. I'm going to go watch it again.

[Metropolis Hero]

Loved it! Gave it a 10! Some really neat scenes. Nice to see Clark actually use his super breath for a change :)

[ginnyfan]

I gave Freak an 8. It was really good. There were some unexpected twists and turns. The FOTW was the most normal person in the episode! Apart from his ability that is. I liked how he marvelled that so many of the people he knew from High School were coming to visit him. LOL!

The heat vision surgery was AWESOME!

Clark used most of his powers which was wonderful. I find it weird that Chloe's a freak. I wonder what her power will be. This could be fun. LOL!

Lana and Lex were creepy this episode. Especially Lex.

[Supermansthebest]

I cant remember who said it but someone mentioned how mature Clark and Lana were in this episode...totally agree. This is where a show should be after thoroughly establishing their characters over 6 yrs.

[SteveS]

That was an excellent episode, if they kept up that good work, this whole series would move up a notch or two.

No needless stupid statements and immature humor, no needless T&A, and no lois. Hmmm, seems like there is something related there somewhere.

[seraphim]

This was a really good episode! As some has mentioned, MR did an excellent job in directing!! Way to go Michael!!! I loved the hospital scene with Clark and the doctor. The only thing I couldn't figure out was when Chloe was talking to Lana and then the next scene she's missing?! I just probably didn't pay enough attention but all in all I gave it a 9.

[AndyBear1980]

Wow, I really REALLY enjoyed this episode!

[BadToad]

Really good, solid episode. I'm not sure how I feel about Chloe being meteor infected, but the revelation was played out for good dramatic effect. And made for some wonderful, heartfelt interaction between Clark and Chloe.

I still don't get the Lexana relationship, but it was good to see a flat out evil, lying Lex, and a proactive, protective Lana. So, good character growth for both of them...apart from each other.

And AWESOME use of Clark's abilities. Finally!!!!!

I give it a 9

[coasterprincess]

Totally impressed. Like most (from what I've seen so far) I wasn't expecting too much out of this week. Exceeded my expectations and then some.

The Good
~Clark- all those superpowers finally coming together. Nothing crazy and over-the-top and well done in general.
~Lex- swearing on the soul of his unborn child....ooo that bit gave me chills
~Chloe- she went from normal "oh this is just another adventure" to holding a knife to her chest to vulnerable and scared so well....plus her being a meteor freak adds a bit of fun to this season
~Jimmy- oh I love that guy. He didn't overshadow the story, but had his own little bit to do and still made me smile (seriously...find jimmy...send him my way)

The Neutral
~Lana....clearly her brain was working this week (must be a day that starts with a T) The whole "oh we're best friends" thing at the bowling alley was kindof lame....but I wasn't as annoyed as I usually am with her
~Tobias- for your classic FOTW he wasn't bad at all. Would have liked him to be a little more on top of what was going on (and check out baby Luthor) but it wasn't as bad as it could have been.

Overall....quite happy 9/10

[kkjdt]

ok i have to say I loved it it had Chlark moments!!:D

[jack1487]

Awesome show I gave it a 10, for the use of Clark's powers to the evil Lex everything was just right.. Had to LOL when Tobias told Lana the Clark was the most normal guy he has ever met.

Tom did a great job with the script in fact they all did and it was an enjoyment to watch. Seem's that all of the actors gave better preformances when one of thier own is doing the directing of the episode.

Great going everyone, keep it up....

Jack

[Plbrock1s]

Loved it. No complaints.10

[xrayvision]

Perfect 10. The best episode of the season, no doubt.

[lillie_poo_pod]

10 this episode was better than Justice, IMO. I have absolutely nothing to b!tch about. Not even Lana or the Clana.

The Clana in this episode was great and I can't believe I just typed that. It shows me that they are on their way to a healthy FRIENDSHIP! Which is awesome.

The Lexana scenes didn't even get to me.

Jimmy, I can't stand him but I just love him all of a sudden. I was about to cry just looking at him when he was worried about Chloe. That bastid

Lex was just.... WOW! I have been waiting for this Lex all season. Lying, manipulating, bastid. The end shot with his eyes was, I swear I almost pissed my pants. Made me shudder

I enjoyed the Chlana in this episode. That's how we need to see their friendship cuz at the moment I'm not buyin all these girls nights out stuff. But it was really nice.

Tobias was really good in this episode too. I wasn't expecting too much from him but he did tha damn thang tonight.

Last but not least.... CHLARK! OMG I LOVEDDDDDDDD THE CHLARK! Their last scene was just so touching. Made my tummy tingle.

I LOVED that they didn't forget about the Superbreath. YAYA!!! And the heat vision surgery was great. Everyone did an awesome job in this episode. It was solid all the way through. Kudos to MR. he did an awesome job. His directorial debut was better than TW's.

My only gripe is that we did not get any Lionel. Where tha hell is he?!?!
Overall Best episode this season.

[RMF]

Look! Superpowers! Clark actually got to use superpowers!

*faints*

But seriously, it was a throwback to the good old days when Clark used his powers to help solve problems instead of having to stand to the side while other people did stuff. I especially liked the superbreath/superspeed swipe of the laptop. I have read so many articles about loss of classified data when intelligence agents or government employees lose laptops that compromising Lex's operations this way seemed perfectly apt. It's also a good setup for Chloe gaining information for a 33.1 expose.

Bowling? With only one other person? That has got to be the worst bachelorette party I've ever heard of. When Lana said she thought of going out in a limo with a bunch of friends but this was more special, I just laughed. Lana, you have no other friends.

There was one real WTF moment early on, though. Chloe asks Clark whether he's going to the Lexana wedding. When Clark sensibly asks why in the world he'd do that, she explains that it would be a way to show the world and himself that he's moved on. WHAT? After all the stuff that she and Clark know that Lex has done, including the human experimentation, she actually expects him to bless this wedding with his presence? I can't even figure out why Chloe's still involved in this wedding herself, because it's no sign of friendship to shut up and play along while your friend marries a megalomaniacal monster. In her shoes, I'd tell Lana even if she didn't want to hear it and back out because I couldn't go along with it.

I liked how Lex was portrayed in this episode, as very much in it up to his neck, but very careful to put some distance between himself and those who did the actual dirty work. He's also wonderfully cold and self-righteous in talking to the doctor about how he's suffered at the hands of the meteor freaks. I also liked his ruthlessness in cleaning up after the security breach, but it made no sense that he spared Chloe if he didn't like loose ends. Lexana was also more entertaining here than it was during all that unbelievable schmoopy and passive-aggressive crud we saw in the first half of the season. They are two-faced, manipulative, and lying to each other while being outwardly sweet and smiling. This is what I expected from Lexana this season rather than all that boring claptrap we had to sit through earlier. That being said, though, it doesn't make a whole lot of sense that Lana is still willing to go through with the wedding.

It was also a nice moment when Lana learned that Tobias didn't see anything when he looked at Clark. She was completely weirded out, which was fun. She has finally put two and two together about all the miraculous, unexplained saves in the past five-odd years and lets Clark know she knows. It is an interesing scene that is civil on the surface, but Clark is obviously taken aback that Lana knew all about Tobias, and I wonder where that doubt in her will lead. She also tells him that if he had been meteor infected, he'd still be the same Clark Kent. That sounds like enlightenment on her part, but it also seems like she's saying this just because it's him. She did, after all, sanction Level 33.1 earlier in the season "if it existed". Apparently it's okay to experiment on meteor freaks as long as they're no one she cares about.

The one real negative about this episode is the revelation that Chloe is a meteor freak. This is justified by the sudden and convenient disclosure that there have been other meteor freaks who didn't manifest their powers for years. One of the engaging things about Chloe has always been her openness to fringe possibilities, exemplified by the Wall of Weird and her enthusiasm at the prospect of meeting an alien. Making her a meteor freak recasts all this as a sort of subconscious self interest and takes away from the specialness of her acceptance of Clark and the broad-mindedness it represented. Now she has no choice but to throw in with the fringe types, and I think that's a betrayal of the character.

[All about Clark]

I'm going with 8.5. It was an enjoyable solid episode.

Maybe Chloe's meteor power is her computer hacking abilities.

The only negative was that Clark should have told her he's met good meteor freaks, like Kyle and Kevin and I think there was one other, can't remember now. But that could have seriously eased her mind.

[LuckyKrypto]

I thought tonight's episode was great! I really enjoyed it. All of the actors were great, loved the characters as well. I agree we are seeing much more mature characters and I like that. I really like seeing Clark use his powers and we got a lot of that tonight. Lex is totally becoming darker and darker with each episode in my opinion which I like. And after all this time I was so glad to see what Lana has thought was up with Clark. I think it was cool to hear her say what she did to Tobias about meteor freaks that help people, but then for him to throw her that curve about Clark being normal, that totally caught me off guard. I like this of watching Lana getting closer and closer each week to finding out Clark's secret.
Just a great episode all the way around.

[Son of Kal-El20]

This episode was terrific! The acting by Tom Welling and Allison Mack was exceptional. That scene with Clark and Chloe in the apartment is one of the best acted scenes I've seen all season. And the plot never had a dull moment. It always kept you interested.

I have to say that this is one of the best episodes this season( if not the best). I give it a 10/10.

[InLove_with_Chloe]

It was OK, I guess...
I don't like when they use Chloe as a plot device. Which they clearly did in 'Freak', IMO...

[lkrfn5283]

Episode was great! Apparently the actors from Smallivlle can direct!!!! Who's next......Mr. Glover perhaps??? (ponders on how great that would be) Chloe being a meteor freak caught me off guard, but it intrigued me. Lana finally coming to the realization (more of an assumption actually) that Clark has powers and is using them for good made me want to scream "About damn time!" lol Great episode.

[Crazy4Smallville]

Crazy4Smallville's Weekly Review 6:14 & 15

I didn't post a review last week, mostly because I was disheartened, so I thought I'd combine it with this weeks.

I'm not sure where TPTB are going to go with the Lana story. I actually like this new role she's playing, but I abhor the Clana they keep insisting on shoving down our throats. It really makes me twinge every time it comes on the screen. I've really become disheartened with the story. But, I don't want to get onto another Clana rant.

Just what is Clark Kent supposed to be doing? He didn't join up with the Justice League because he was on a mission to round up the remaining Phantom Freaks, yet I haven't seen mention of any since then. He's been too busy doing the Lana dance. It's like the show has shifted from Clark's mission to Lana's mission and her quest to discover the truth about Clark. She's resorting to manipulations, lying, snooping and being down-right underhanded, but for what purpose? She's pregnant with a child that she hasn't SHOWN any interest or concern with, she's engaged to a man she clearly doesn't trust and she claims to be best friends with someone who doesn't trust her or her fiance and is hiding the one secret she's after. Come on - do they really think we're going to buy that she's even remotely innocent. Lana doesn't act like someone in love and is about to have a baby. She's on a mission - and that mission (to find out Clark's truth) trumps EVERYTHING else in her life. She's no different than Lex, because she's become consumed in her obsession.

I think this story line started a couple of seasons back with the emergence of the crystals, her witnessing the spacecraft and the two Krytponians and then her dealings with Zod and now Lex. She believes Clark is meteor infected, but now KNOWS that he's not - how much longer will it take her to put together that he's an alien? As Chloe said - she's been orbiting this secret for so long - she can't help but soon make a landing. I also think Clark knows this, but his apparent 'fear' of her discovering the truth is starting to dissipate. Is it because he's moving on and it doesn't matter as much as it used to, because he doesn't have as much to lose - or because he believes that it truly wouldn't make a difference and she'd accept him anyway?

You have to wonder what Clark thinks of Lana now. He still loves her, but his perfect perception of her isn't the same. She's fallen off that pedestal and perhaps that is what makes all the difference. I'm hoping that he's letting down his guard, because he's becoming more confident and secure in who he is - and isn't ashamed of it. Either way, he has to realize that Lana isn't the same sweet girl-next-door. He doesn't believe she loves Lex, yet he knows she's with him.

BTW - don't you notice that every time Lex and Lana lie to each other, they always follow it up with a kiss on the cheek and delivered with a smile? I'm starting to pick up on the tell-tell signs.

Now, onto Clark and Chloe. I nearly choked up when Clark told Chloe that she should consider him her personal bomb protection. That's LOVE. That's the Superman I know. That's the kind of relationship I love to see. It was a touching moment. Probably one of the sweetest moments I've seen yet. It showed the true heart of Clark Kent.

Now, what is Chloe's ability??? I've always suspected that she was somehow infected, but always hoped it was just who she was - the way Bart is just fast, Oliver is just good, Aqua is just ... a fish? I hope she doesn't turn out to be meteor affected, because what I've noticed over the past six years (and she has too) is that meteor freaks are a mutated version of greatness. While it gives the wielder an ability, its one that they can't handle and instead is the very thing that destroys them. They change - transform into the extreme - and like Chloe said - most end up either dead, on level 33.1 or in Belle Reve. Not a good outcome for Chloe, especially since she already fears the asylum due to her mother's mental history. BTW - has Chloe been visiting her mother? After that one episode, we haven't heard anything else about it.

There is a lot that's happened over these past couple of episodes. My biggest problem isn't what's happened, but trying to determine which path TPTB are leading us down. I just hope it's the right one. If Smallville can't do right by Chloe, then the CW should create a spin-off series centered around her - The Chloe Chronicles. I'd watch it! But, I'm really hoping they get back to the story of Clark Kent and him embracing his destiny.

Till next time,
~Crazy4Smallville

[superman2001]

I thought The Episode was Terrific, I liked the Scene where Lana is trying to protect Clark Secret, and I also liked seeing Clark using his SuperBreath to get the Computer from The Doctor, and it was also great to see Clark use his Heat Vision again, I thought it was great when Clark took The Bullet, in front of Lana and she did not even see him, and I also like The End of The Episode, where Lex is telling somebody to keep a close eye on Chloe, I can't wait to see The next New Episode, it is going to be great, This is the Best Season yet.

[Kryptonian-Ronin]

I am hoping that Chloe being infected will somehow "humanize" meteor freaks and make Lana realise that 33.1 is 100% wrong.

[DeesRyche]

There was lots of positive parts of this epi. and WOW on MR's directing debut.

You could almost see char. moving forward...it gives me hope.

[Jaded Wolf]

Originally posted by Kryptonian-Ronin
I am hoping that Chloe being infected will somehow "humanize" meteor freaks and make Lana realise that 33.1 is 100% wrong.

Actually, just the opposite. It was Lana telling Chloe that there were some good meteor infected people because Lana thought Clark was one of them. It's Chloe who fears she will become a ticking time bomb.

[superpal1]

This episode was excellent. There is not one criticism I can make about it. Clark used everyone one of his powers in taking care of the situation. Allison Mack was amazing in her scenes, esp, when trying to convince Clark to take out the GPS device. Lex was pure evil in this episode, esp the end scene with Lana and swearing on the baby. I even liked how Clark thanked her for trying to protect him. No anamosity toward each other. Lana has really seemed to stopped hating Clark. She has seemed to realize that he needs to keep his secret, esp. with the way she knows Lex is using Meteor Freaks. The Ollie connection was cool. Michael really nailed his directorial debut.

[Jack-El49]

Terrific episode all around. The directing was superb, the character development was superb, and the acting was just plain awesome. The cat and mouse game being played out between Lex and Lana is excellent - leading viewers to wonder whether Lana will realize all the truths (or at least the most important ones) about Lex BEFORE she marries him.

I see Lana developing an understanding for meteor-freaks that she never previously had. And the closure of this episode - just plain wow! Who was Lex communicating with and what is Chloe's power that would lead Lex to want to continue keeping a close eye on her?

The only disappointment for me, and it was clearly a minor one, dealt with the spoilers for this episode. If you don't read them, then you wouldn't be disappointed but in the spoilers, it said that Tobias would reveal something shocking to Lana about her baby. That was appearently either cut or written out of the final script. I would have liked to see Tobias say something to her. That would hasten her realization of what Lex really is.

[Super Maverick]

i only gave it a 7 because there was no lois :[

wait a minute... thjis eppy was directed by michael rosenbaum?

[chlarkfan333]

It is for this kind if episode I continue to watch Smallville. I gave it a 10.

Likes -

- Top of my list was the fact that we finally SAW Clark use every single one of his powers. About damn time!

- Clark's quick thinking when he swiped the laptop. We need more scenes like that.

- Lana piecing the Clark puzzle together.

-A Clana scene that was mature - always hoped that day would come.

- Evil Lex who finally has Chloe in his crosshairs.

- Chlark, of course. Every single scene exemplified how special that relationship is.

Dislikes -

- The episode seemed a bit choppy to me.

- Chlimmy. I am getting annoyed with JO's constant 'girlfriend' references. Also, the relationship seems one-sided to me. Chloe should either commit to him fully or break it off.

- The Doc was first portrayed as sort of a decent guy (caught in a tight spot) and in the end he became the villian.

[margroks]

It was good and there were two really dynamite scenes with AM and TW. They continue to have fantastic chemistry. Their touching is always sweet and completely natural in sharp contrast to Clark and Lana scenes. Both of them were incredibly intense, especially when Chloe insisted Clark remove the tracking device. It's obvious once more that AM is a superior actress and both AM and TW always bring out the best in each other when they're on screen together.

MR did a really good job, too!

It was, however, a total retcon of Chloe being infected by meteors since we have never seen so much as a hint that she was in the six years we've known her. Her one exposure to gas that contained a Kryptonite elemenst was never portrayed as having any lasting effect and was seen to be cancelled by the antidote Clark gave her. Nor has there ever been any discussion of some people who were exposed not developing abilities right away. That, too, was a retcon.

If anyone is meteor infected it would have to be Lana who wore the Kryptonite necklace for thirteen years and was once infected by Kryptonite in that gas explosion in Obscura. It's Lana who would be naturally affected not Chloe.

Likewise, it's a total retcon to try and force us to believe Lana is all accepting now of those who are different when we previously saw that was not at all the case. This nonsense, first shoved down our throats in Reckoning, is not what Lana Lang is really like. If Lana claims it would be okay for someone to be different it's only because there would be something in it for her; she is the same self-centered, manipulative girl she's always been. Nor is she trustworthy at all; she runs to Lex and mouths off about things with no thought for the harm that might do.

She remains the kind of girl the hero should avoid at all costs. Not at all to be trusted, as we and even Clark plainly say in Tresspass last week. SHe is far worse than Chloe ever was at snooping and Lana lies like a cheap rug and I long to see Lana put in her place and kicked to the curb by both Clark and Chloe. She deserves it and the audience wants to see it. Soon.

OVerall, due to the tremendous acting by TW and AM, this was a great episode and it's past time TPTB gave us some Clark and Chloe in a romantic relationship.

[jonatankent]

it was a lot more better than I expected! actually the episode was really great!

[Blong]

This was the best episode in a looooong time. In my opinion this is the first time Lex appears to be the main villain in the story (not just ploting in the background). In the past it was mostly about Clark fighting meteor freaks. That story line was starting to wear real thin.
The plot needed a kick in the pants and Lex needed to step up to the plate becoming the true villain we all love to hate. I hope the writers stay on this path. If they do Smallville could become even more poplar (I'm talking #1 show on TV). Look out American Idol, Grey's Anatomy and House.
In my book there are only two things remaining for this series to be perfect... Flying and the super suit. It's getting kind of strange for Superman to be this old and not be able to fly. It's like saying Spiderman doesn't shoot webs.

[Martin le Magicien]

Wow... just wow.

I'm the first one to criticize Smallvilles's numerous flaws. But I'm ready to forgive everything when an episode is THAT good.

I was intrigued, entertained, and left wanting more, which didn't happen in a LONG time with Smallville.

There was action, good special effects, drama, great writing, a angst-free Clana, a sweet Chlark, a normal Lana, and a real Lex, with the evil, plotting side and all. What could I ask more ?

All of Clark's powers were used, including super-breath ! And in a smart way ! Clark actually used his brain !

He used his brain again ! He deflected the bullet, saved Tobias, and disapeared !! Another smart move, instead of staying there, with most people wondering when he got there and how did miracles happens while he was around.

Of course, they had to kill the good doctor.Why do that, and make Clark half-guilty, when let's say, Clark could have "absorbed" the energy, or pushed the doctor on the floor ? But at the very least, he saved people, didn't kill anyone directly, and didn't throw anyone around. He also super-speed out in front of Jimmy. A line of dialogue like "I'll go look around", and super-speed after Jimmy saw him leave wouldn't be that hard to do. Also, he didn't run to save the people who were killed by the doctor when he realised they were in danger. But still, I can understand he wanted to protect Chloe.

Those are minors complains, and like I said I'm ready to forgive everything when an episode is so great !!

All scenes with Chloe were terrific. A lot of great drama. It's a good change from those angst-based situation. Even the Clana was good ! And Lex was awesome ! Good work, as an actor and a director Michael !

This should be the standard for the rest of the season. If they keep doing that, I'll take my Smallville poster out of the garbage for sure.

[quietone]

Very good episode. Nice to see Clark use his powers. Wonderful Chloe/Clark interaction and Jimmy was adorkable. Also good to see lying,evil Lex. Michael Rosenbaum did a great job directing. Too bad he and Tom cannot direct any more episodes.Only nitpick: No Lionel.

[LoisL]

I actually thought the episode was only mildly interesting. It felt to me that alot of time was spent in having one character explain Tobias to another, who would then regale the Tobias story to another character, who then would tell another character about Tobias, until that character would tell Tobias about Tobias, who would tell another character about the character who told Tobias,,,,etc.

Otherwise, it was good. The only standout to me was the Lana change. The question of Chloe being a freak just didn't seem addressed that much more in depth than in the trailer.

[Bosrudorfer]

I gave it 10/10. I thought it was AWESOME! As good even maybe better than Crimson which I also loved!

All the characters are finally coming to their form, Lex is becoming evil, Lana is finally turning good and finding out Clark's secret, Clark is more confident of his power, etc.

Cant wait until Promise airs!!!

[MidgardDragon]

It was, however, a total retcon of Chloe being infected by meteors since we have never seen so much as a hint that she was in the six years we've known her.

We never saw a hint that Lex was infected until his scene where he mentioned his possible Super Cells. Didn't hear anyone screaming retcon then. Also, Chloe mentioned a very important fact: *many* of the meteor freaks have been shown to have had no powers for many many years until their powers showed up later in life. So it can't really be said to be a retcon at all, since meteor powers can lay dormant for an unknown amount of time before appearing.

[khol145]

This episode was awesome...

[emsfan]

Definitely one of the best!!!

[BlueNRed2]

Went into this episode thinking it would be a "meh" filler episode and was shocked at how much i enjoyed it. Great Job for the cast and awsome directing by MR!

[CallMeClark]

Originally posted by emsfan
Definitely one of the best!!!
I agree. We have had all good episodes (minus "Trespass") since "Hydro." We are on a roll!

[greenarrowgal]

It was pretty good, but I'm not into the idea of Chloe being a meteor freak of any sort. However, I think this will set up some serious Chloe/Lex confrontations eventually.

I hope Clark and Lana really become friends again (but just friends). That would be nice and mature of them.

[kidkarmina]

it was indeed one of the best. i even liked lana in this episode - and that's hard for me to say.

only one complaint = no lionel ;)

[Moose360]

I agree with several others; I was expecting a so-so episode, and was blown away. An excellent episode. I gave it a 9. Best episode of the season after "Justice."

Like many others, I loved the fact that Clark used all of his powers. The computer theft was clever. Long overdue use of the super breath. It seems like that power could come in handy a lot more often than is shown in the show.

Clark's dissapearance after making the big save at the end was another long overdue smart move. Not sure why he doesn't do that more often. Unlike a couple of others on this thread, I do not blame him for his redirection of the stun gun. He was doing a lot of stuff in a short span of time, and he did not know what the effect of the gun was. Most stun guns aren't lethal, so if he did have time to plan, it makes sense for him to send the electric charge right back at the villain in order to incapacitate him. Would he have been able to guage the level of the charge just as it touched him? If he just bumped Tobias out of the way, then the Doc could keep shooting, and it might be a lot harder for Clark save Lana and Tobias, and then Superspeed out of there without being seen.

Lana's maturity was refreshing. It was very cool to see her put Clark's heroic activities together in her head, and then try and protect him for a change. Her astonishment when Tobias told her Clark was normal was amusing. Lana's relationship with Lex continues to befuddle me, but I like to see her going behind his back.

Great job by MR. I hope he'll do a few more episodes.

[Chesay]

As I've said before, if you go into the episode expecting little the chances of it being great are excellent. What an exceptional episode! When the episode is as balanced as this one was, everyone wins. The character of Chloe is pivotal to this show. Allison Mack has truly made Chloe outstanding, but the character is perfect in that she intersects every other character and can be used in limitless ways. The heat vision surgery was a moment to redefine the series and what can be done when Smallville is at its best.

Each character was given a good bit in the show and Clark's showed the "super" man and friend he truly is meant to be. The super powers were used in essential and meaningful ways that enhanced the story and moved it along beautifully. I didn't lose interest for a minute and the pace was relentless with surprises and tensions throughout.

The writing staff need to get a lot of credit for their work on this one. They have been hitting the ball out of the park lately which is wonderful and terribly addicting. This one will be hard to top.

Michael Rosenbaum should be very proud of his directing debut. The actors did a spectacular job with a fabulous script and he tied it all together remarkably well. Impressive addition to his resume.

This season has been most surprising in its quality of writing. I have been tempted to feel as giddy about the series as I did when I first discovered it. It is a delightful feeling and I'm enjoying the ride. Keep it going gang...everyone is doing a terrific job.

[AngelaV]

TEN!
I wanted more. I nearly fell off the couch that Chole is a "freak". I for one like that twist! As someone else mentioned it could be her computer skills. Though when she was running away from that van and did that big dive onto a car, rolled off onto the pavement and GOT back UP without a scratch, I thought that was odd. I would think that would hurt like h*ll or even daze a person.
And Lana actually using her brain! It's about time!
Evil Lex. It's going to be fun!

[SuperFan85]

with all the talk in this episode about meteor freaks being kidnapped and then being given a mind wipe, it made me think that perhaps Lex now has the Haitian from "Heroes" on his payroll lol

[Blue screen of death]

wow! unbelievablely great episode. Clark used evrey power except for leaping great distaces and flying ofcourse. Loved the X-ray - heatvision combo for 'surgery'. Clark really does have superbreath WOOT! The use of the superhearing to eavesdrop was great and the superspeed hijack of the laptop was nice too. One of the finest sequences was when clark stopped the bullet and the 'taser' at that insane speed. I don't think he has moved that fast since last scene of "jynx".

Chloe a meteor freak.... interesting. I seem to recall some theorizing that she would somehow become some other hero or someone completely new(now with the "special K") that will make her hero-like for the JLA. maybe se will be able to hack computers with her mind or something neat like that. I think if they go the right way with this it will be sweet.

Lana... while i am not a great lana fan i did like her character tonight. She wasn't as unbeliveablely nosey as last week and i almost believed her when she said... "there is someone who uses his ability for good" Sounds like the clue train may be pulling in for a stop.

Lex wow just as ruthless, evil, manipulative, cunning, and brilliant as we all know him to be. Looks like lional better start watching his back.

[Krypton935]

HOLY KRYPTON!! That was amazing! edge of my seat the entire time! 10/10 no question about it!

[vyperman7]

I am probably one of the only ones on this site to feel this way, but I wasn't really blown away by the episode. I was expecting to be on the edge of my seat the whole time because of all the glowing reviews. I guess my expectations were a bit too high, because I didn't think it was anything extraordinary.

Was it cool to see Clark use all his powers in one episode, in smart ways to boot? Yes.

But that doesn't automatically make for a good episode.

I found the concept of Chloe being a meteor freak to be somewhat lame. There has never been any hinting at this at all, and it seemed completely random.

I enjoyed Lex in this episode. "I swear on the soul of my unborn child" and he flat out lied to Lana's face. That is the evil Lex I have been waiting for. I also suprisingly liked Lana in this episode. Usually I can't stand her. But she was very tolerable in this episode. I also like the Chlana friendship and it is great that we got scenes with Lana and Chloe having fun.

I am not saying that Freak was a terrible episode. But I don't understand why it is receiving all of these glowing reviews, when it was only a decent episode.

I think it deserves a 7 or 8 out of 10. But it is definately not one of the best eps of the whole series, or even S6 for that matter in my opinion. Like I said, I think it is just because my expectations were too high.

[trying2b]

Originally posted by vyperman7
Like I said, I think it is just because my expectations were too high.

They were.

I liked it cause unlike Justice it wasn't cheesy with bad dialogue.

It wasn't far-fetched like Trespass (Clark knocking Lex out and dragging Lana off).

In Trespass if you did what he did,
1. You could have got arrested for trespassing.
2. Got arrested for assault.
3. And last but not least, been arrested for kidnapping.

Why on earth Lex didn't call the police on Clark is beyond me. Now I know that this is Smallville but please lets atleast put some type of infuses (did I spell that right?) on realism.

[Shadowlord367]

Ryan, I think its funny how the guy ahead of you said "edge of my seat entertainment the whole time" and then you give that review lol.

I actually think that coming off of a Hydro all the way to Crimson high, Trespass and Freak were stellar in our minds.

But we may, when we get the s6, dvds pull an almiles and go "what the hell were we thinking!?"

[Angelina2809]

I rate 10!!!
It was a great episode!!!!! The Scene between Clark and Chloe was amazing!!!! As Clark burned Chloe....was she really must trust him!!!! And as Lana found the bullet and showed it Clark.... and the talk between them... Absolutly fantastic!!!!! BAD LEX!!!!
I really enjoyed this episode!!!!

[fox2mike]

IMO, this episode was tied with Justice for best of the season, with Zod close behind.

That closeup of Lex's eyes in the end was one of the most chilling moments this season.

The episodes this season have gotten better and better since the first hiatus. I think the writers got the message that the first half dozen episodes were a little sloppy.

[LanaandPete]

Originally posted by vyperman7
I am probably one of the only ones on this site to feel this way, but I wasn't really blown away by the episode. I was expecting to be on the edge of my seat the whole time because of all the glowing reviews. I guess my expectations were a bit too high, because I didn't think it was anything extraordinary.

Was it cool to see Clark use all his powers in one episode, in smart ways to boot? Yes.

But that doesn't automatically make for a good episode.

I found the concept of Chloe being a meteor freak to be somewhat lame. There has never been any hinting at this at all, and it seemed completely random.

I enjoyed Lex in this episode. "I swear on the soul of my unborn child" and he flat out lied to Lana's face. That is the evil Lex I have been waiting for. I also suprisingly liked Lana in this episode. Usually I can't stand her. But she was very tolerable in this episode. I also like the Chlana friendship and it is great that we got scenes with Lana and Chloe having fun.

I am not saying that Freak was a terrible episode. But I don't understand why it is receiving all of these glowing reviews, when it was only a decent episode.

I think it deserves a 7 or 8 out of 10. But it is definately not one of the best eps of the whole series, or even S6 for that matter in my opinion. Like I said, I think it is just because my expectations were too high.

I agree with you, Ryan(long time no talk btw). I think people are overrating Freak, its an ok episodes, I wouldn't say close to be best of the season though.

[DDR Paladin356]

The episode wasnt that bad. In fact, I liked it. It started off slow, but I picked up the pace. The scene with Chloe asking Clark to use both x-ray and heat vision was awesome! Props to Michael Rosenbaum for directing it.

[Sweetie]

Congratulation,Michael :cool:

Solid episode but,Lana suffered of the bad-continuity of her character AGAIN.Bachelorette's party with only Chloé...What happenned to all the friends that she had when she came home from the hospital after the horse stumping's accident,she always been extremely effraid of freaks suddenly,she's their protector,she understand Clark after being furious at him about his secret throught all the seasons(I'm tired of this charade,make up your mind writters,please!!!).

Chloé & Lex made the episode.They did a great job.

[SBoy]

It was great, among the best if not the best episode of this season so far.

It managed to recapture the feeling of awesomeness of the first sesons IMO, great job, Mr.Rosenbaum :)

[MidgardDragon]

Originally posted by LanaandPete
I agree with you, Ryan(long time no talk btw). I think people are overrating Freak, its an ok episodes, I wouldn't say close to be best of the season though.

Why do people have to be "overrating" the episode? Why can't it just be that *gasp* people liked the episode more than you did, and feel the ratings they gave were deserved?

[KEakaCK]

MR did pretty good job for his first stint as a director...However, this show is getting worse and worse with each passing episode.
If this is the best the writers can come up with, I rather see the series end than to continuously watch them ruin this show, and the story of Superman.
One would think that after 5 seasons, you wouldn't keep bringing in the same story line. Sure, they try to make it seem like it's different but when it comes down to it, it's the same. Clark loves Lana, Clark doesn't love Lana, Lana likes Clark, Lana doesn't like Clark, Chloe likes Clark, Chloe doesn't like Clark. After serving fried chicken for dinner for two weeks, making chicken parmesian doesn't make it any different...IT'S STILL FREAKIN CHICKEN!!!!
Can we please put this Clana yoyo storyline to bed?
And after previous seasons and episodes from this season of Lana not liking meteor freaks and aliens, she's all of a sudden a protector of them?
Now, I can overlook the whole killing GPS devise killing off the meteor freaks because up until Clark pulls that out of Chloe, that was pretty intense scene between Chloe and Clark.
I keep watching the show but it's getting harder and harder for me to keep watching it. The plot lines are too inconsistent from one week to the next...The character development is poor at best since season 2...The writers keep bringing in the same ole materials from previous 5 seasons by window dressing it differently. Do they really think of their viewers that unintelligently? If you hired a chef, you don't him/her to serve you nothing but chicken or beef during their entire tenure and just change up the way they cook it. That's what these writers of Smallville are doing. I can't remember the last time they came up with an original story line. They also must suffer from short term memory loss. The continuity of this show is just getting worse and worse...Topping it off with just poor, poor character development. Does anyone else think that Clark is just too stupid to ever become that greatest superhero that we all know he's supposed to become? I mean, come on, I know Superman isn't the most intelligent being but give the character some credit. So he decides to steal a laptop, and cleverly uses his superbreath to blow the nurses notes away to create a distraction. But, he hides just outside where the doctor is at, under a towel so that anyone who walks up to grab a towel will find it? I think he's fast enough where he can hide it in a closet or some place better. But, obviously, the writers wants up to believe that Clark isn't that smart.
Don't get me started on Lana...All I will say is that she's now protector of meteor freaks, give me a break.
Chloe, I must of missed something...Since when did Chloe and Lana become the best of friends? If my memory serves, other than their brief co-habitation during season 1, they really never showed being that great a friend. Lana would go talk with Chloe from time to time when she had some problems but they conflicted with each other more so then then not...And now, Chloe is Lana's maid of honor? Okay.
I can go on and on but, well, I'm tired.
I'll probably keep pushing myself to stay the path for the rest of the season but I'm deeply disappointed.
I had such a great expectations for season 6 but, like the past, I keep getting dissappointed. Maybe I should just lower the expectation...But, I won't. Why should I? This is Superman for crying out loud. The greatest superhero of all time. Every Superman fan should have very high expectations for anything related to Superman...And they all deserve it. We all deserve it.
Here's to hoping the writers will get it right and get it right soon.l

[trying2b]

The writers have done a great job this year IMO (except for episode 6-2 Wither).

So you liked Lois and Clark over Smallville? I guess to each it's own.

In fact I think this year is probably one of the best seasons of Smallville ever (minus the special effects, that would be the 1st 3 seasons).

[Luthorism]

Not a bad episode but don't deserve a 10 IMFO.

I just wanna ask:
Where the hell is Lionel?? Is he dropped out? I mean i can't remember the last episode he played? :lol:

[whitegold]

I think this was one of the best episodes of all time.

Smallville went through a very poor patch for quite a few episodes of season 5 and some of 6. It seemed very gimmicky and tried to be too '14' instead of PG.

But this episode had excellent writing and characterisation.

The past few episodes have been very good - but this one shined for me. The Lana character and the whole 'when Lex and Lana hug there are lots of lies' is very good. A mature Clana friendship is good. Lex being so manipulative and evil is very good. The oath upon the soul of his unborn was an A+ touch.

I disagree with those saying Chloe was a plot device - she shone as a great character in this episode. I found the Chloe being meteor infected a suprising and nice twist. It opens up more Chloe development which is a good idea.

[Mr. Wrong]

9/10. Losing a point because Chloe was implanted without a mark on her body. She didn't even seem to notice that she had been jabbed in the navel to remove dna. A needle that size would definitely leave bruising at least and the implant would have left an incision. Overall the episode showed imagination and excellent character development. Lex swearing on the soul of his unborn child tells me that the child isn't his. My guess is that he has somehow utilized Clark's blood (dna) to perpetuate this pregnancy. That would definitely make things fall into place. P.S. why hasn't Lana started to show yet?

[RPMSDB]

Okay, I was five and a half months pregnant before I started to show with any of my kids (and I never had to wear maternity clothes). Believe it or not, it sometimes happens. However, because TV is visual you need to let the audience 'see' that she is pregnant.

Anyway, here's what I thought about Freak.

Clark was at the best I think I have ever seen him before. I could see a future Superman in him.
He used most of his powers without hesitation. I do not think he was trying to lie to Chloe about being a freak. Instead, I thought he was trying to protect her. His reluctancy spans the fact of her being taken and everything he knew she was dealing with.

It is one thing to be intrigued with the wall of weird, freaks, and zoners, but to find out you are actually a meteor freak yourself is a whole different story. IMO, Clark took this into consideration when he was with Chloe at the Talon. He was pretty sure it was true, but he was unsure how to tell her. I mean, it’s not everyday you find out someone you are extremely close to is a freak. It was all new to him and to her. How do you tell someone that?

The scene at the Talon was just WOW! The intensity and trust in that room between Clark and Chloe is just so moving. I do not blame him for being reluctant. He had never ever embarked on using his heat vision in such a way. And when it came to using it on the person closest to him . . .
The fact that he knew Chloe’s life depended on him was a bit overwhelming for him, but he came through.

His patching up Chloe’s shoulder was sweet. I also thought his ‘staring’ at her earlier was cute.

Then, the DP scene. The way he came in and pulled a chair up next to Chloe . . . there was something about it. Then telling her he would be her personal bomb squad – it gave me a good feeling inside.

I do not know if there was or was not anything beyond friendship behind Clark holding Chloe’s arm. But, there was something about it that was different on his part than anything I’ve seen before. It did remind me of the time he grabbed her hand in season one. However, there was something much deeper and meaningful this time.

Also, the fact that he just found out Lana would be okay with him being a freak, but not mentioning that or Lana, spoke volumes to me. I do not think that has ever happened before (of course, I could be wrong).

TPTB do have the ability to let Chlark happen. However, it is a HUGE risk. They are fully aware that the Chlark dynamic works. But to take the risk of making it more than just friends is something they cannot and will not take lightly. IF they do decide to go that route, it has to been done at the right time, and in the right way. Once they cross that line (that is IF they do) there is no going back. They risk losing some of their audience and they know it. This has been true for many TV shows, L&C is a good example – once Clois hooked up, the fans’ wishes had been fulfilled and there wasn’t much left for them to look forward to.

Yes, I know there are many people who do watch SV to see Clark’s journey into Superman, including hooking up with Lois. However, there are plenty of people who do not watch it because of that. Believe it or not, people actually enjoy this program because it is an intriguing journey to watch.

The last scene with Lex literally sent a chill sown my spine. MR’s portrayal of Lex leaves me in awe most of the time. He is the best Lex I have ever seen.

I’m not sure what is going on between Clark and Lana. I do not understand why they continue to play this cat and mouse game. Why can’t her just tell her the truth? I know she ‘died’ in Reckoning because of it, but still. He needs to tell her already.

IMO, the way Lana spoke in past tense (nor did she look back) was an indication that it is truly over between her and Clark as far as she is concerned. She has given him more chances to come clean to her, but has refused to do so. No matter how much she may love him, she has to move on from something that continues to cause her pain. Unfortunately that something is Clark.

Lana equates love with trust (which is true. How can you truly love someone and have them truly love you back without complete trust – you can’t). Lex knows this and has done everything he can to do to convince Lana that he trust/loves her. Yes, he has played her like pawn. He knows how to manipulate and he has done this with Lana from the very beginning. Slowly, he has won her over by winning her trust.

He may not be good for her, but he has helped her learn to protect herself, depend on herself, and believe in herself. Sure, he’s evil to the core, but he has helped her in the long run.

As for Jimmy, his over-the-top panicking is just another reason of why he is not the man for Chloe (IMO). Heck, Chloe is more of a man than he is. Matter of fact, so is Lana.

Yes, he is good to Chloe. He makes her smile. However, he just isn’t strong enough for her. Please, give Chloe a REAL man.

Oh, BTW, I don’t deny Chloe and Jimmy can be cute at times. BUT, that seems to be the problem. They are cute, but seriously lack passion. If SV was a sitcom, then bring on the cute, but when you’re dealing with a drama, passion is the way to go.

MR did an outstanding job directing Freak. He should do it more often. I think he is truly in tune with the spirit of the show, as well as what the audience wants. He showed Clark being more like Superman than ever before. Chloe dealing with the fact that her life was at risk, and that she is indeed a meteor freak, Lana being okay with the fact that Clark could have been a freak, Jimmy being his panicky self, and Lex becoming more and more evil (not to mention angst free Clana as well as a very touching Chlark scene).

Freak was one of the best episodes this season (I haven’t seen Justice yet). It had everything I wanted and then some.

Oh, one last thing, I think Clark’s actions at the DP was perfect. I know many of you wanted him to do more (like kiss Chloe). But there are times when less is more. This was one of those times. It would have been wrong on both parts if Clark had kissed Chloe. Jimmy is still her boyfriend (no matter how painful that may or may not be), and that is what would have made it wrong for both of them.

Bottom line, Freak was the perfect example of why I always have and always will ship Chlark. There is just something so real and refreshing about their relationship. It transcends any relationship I have ever seen on TV or in the movies, as well as any I have ever read in a book (I have read PLENTY of books).

[SuperFan85]

As great as this episode was, lol I think Clark should start obeying certain laws, like not breaking and entering like he did at the beginning of the episode, when he forcefully opened the front doors to the bowling alley to look for clues. I mean I know he's the future Superman, but c'mon, at least wait until the place opens first, Clark lol.

[GooN]

the last couple of episodes have really im impressed me, this one didnt let me down either.....it was somewhat imaginative and was very interesting to find out that chloe may develop a power or has one without knowing....the lana finding out thing is developing but i hope it doesn't drag too much..

keep it up. 7.5.

[MidgardDragon]

Originally posted by SuperFan85
As great as this episode was, lol I think Clark should start obeying certain laws, like not breaking and entering like he did at the beginning of the episode, when he forcefully opened the front doors to the bowling alley to look for clues. I mean I know he's the future Superman, but c'mon, at least wait until the place opens first, Clark lol.

Superman/Clark Kent has pretty much always broke the breaking and entering laws. They are not as important as saving someone's life.

[Mr. Wrong]

Jimmy and Chloe may not display the passion that fans would like but don't forget they started out passionately so there had to be chemistry in order to entice Chloe into giving up her virginity. Jimmy has already displayed bravery, goodness, and a straight forward, no nonsense, personality. I think its entirely unfair to say he is not man enough for Chloe. He is not larger than life like Clark, Lex, Oliver, etc. but he hasn't had anywhere near the same airtime yet. The minute Jimmy showed up Chloe dropped any ideas of Chlark entering a romantic phase. That caught CK off guard a bit to say the least ,as he was still feeling that kiss from the Zod episode. Regarding Lana being willing to accept Clark if he was rock infected. That does not say that she would readily accept the fact that she lost her virginity to an alien. MR has been exceptional of late! Does anyone elso out there wonder how everyone on the show has the capacity to be thrown clear across the room into a wall and come up without a scratch, continuously?

[RPMSDB]

I'm not so sure it started out as passionately as some might think. No one knows since we've really never been told. However, didn't Chloe say she regretted it or something along those lines?

Anyway, Jimmy is a nice guy. He really is. But, I still do not think he is the right guy for her.

[vyperman7]

Originally posted by LanaandPete
I agree with you, Ryan(long time no talk btw). I think people are overrating Freak, its an ok episodes, I wouldn't say close to be best of the season though.

Hey Chris!

What's up dude?

I personally don't see why so many people are saying this is such a great episode. I don't want it to seem like I hated the episode. It was pretty decent, and definately not terrible. But it doesn't deserve all of this praise that it is getting either.

One thing I see people saying is that a reason it was such a great episode is because of getting to see Clark use multiple powers in one episode. Granted, it was nice to see him use so many powers in one episode, and in creative ways to boot.

But this alone doesn't make for a great episode.

I thought that making Chloe a meteor freak was shoddy and random personally.

Believe it or not one of my favorite aspects of the episode was the Lana/Chloe scene at the beginning. Now I may not like romantic ships with Lana in them. But I have always liked the Lana/Chloe friendship for some reason. I thought it was great getting to see the two of them having fun. Also, Lana was suprisingly tolerable in this episode. It has to be the first time in years I actually found myself liking Lana in an episode.

I like the fact they are starting to go the route of Lana playing a confidant for Clark. She should have already known the secret by now. If they had spent less time on the Clana romantic angst, and more time developing the post breakup friendship between them, Lana might have actually turned out to be a likeable character.

So overall, I can't figure out why so many people LOVE this episode so much. But it definately had aspects I enjoyed. I would probably give it a 7.5 or an 8/10.


Originally posted by KEakaCK
MR did pretty good job for his first stint as a director...However, this show is getting worse and worse with each passing episode.
If this is the best the writers can come up with, I rather see the series end than to continuously watch them ruin this show, and the story of Superman.
One would think that after 5 seasons, you wouldn't keep bringing in the same story line. Sure, they try to make it seem like it's different but when it comes down to it, it's the same. Clark loves Lana, Clark doesn't love Lana, Lana likes Clark, Lana doesn't like Clark, Chloe likes Clark, Chloe doesn't like Clark. After serving fried chicken for dinner for two weeks, making chicken parmesian doesn't make it any different...IT'S STILL FREAKIN CHICKEN!!!!
Can we please put this Clana yoyo storyline to bed?
And after previous seasons and episodes from this season of Lana not liking meteor freaks and aliens, she's all of a sudden a protector of them?
Now, I can overlook the whole killing GPS devise killing off the meteor freaks because up until Clark pulls that out of Chloe, that was pretty intense scene between Chloe and Clark.
I keep watching the show but it's getting harder and harder for me to keep watching it. The plot lines are too inconsistent from one week to the next...The character development is poor at best since season 2...The writers keep bringing in the same ole materials from previous 5 seasons by window dressing it differently. Do they really think of their viewers that unintelligently? If you hired a chef, you don't him/her to serve you nothing but chicken or beef during their entire tenure and just change up the way they cook it. That's what these writers of Smallville are doing. I can't remember the last time they came up with an original story line. They also must suffer from short term memory loss. The continuity of this show is just getting worse and worse...Topping it off with just poor, poor character development. Does anyone else think that Clark is just too stupid to ever become that greatest superhero that we all know he's supposed to become? I mean, come on, I know Superman isn't the most intelligent being but give the character some credit. So he decides to steal a laptop, and cleverly uses his superbreath to blow the nurses notes away to create a distraction. But, he hides just outside where the doctor is at, under a towel so that anyone who walks up to grab a towel will find it? I think he's fast enough where he can hide it in a closet or some place better. But, obviously, the writers wants up to believe that Clark isn't that smart.
Don't get me started on Lana...All I will say is that she's now protector of meteor freaks, give me a break.
Chloe, I must of missed something...Since when did Chloe and Lana become the best of friends? If my memory serves, other than their brief co-habitation during season 1, they really never showed being that great a friend. Lana would go talk with Chloe from time to time when she had some problems but they conflicted with each other more so then then not...And now, Chloe is Lana's maid of honor? Okay.
I can go on and on but, well, I'm tired.
I'll probably keep pushing myself to stay the path for the rest of the season but I'm deeply disappointed.
I had such a great expectations for season 6 but, like the past, I keep getting dissappointed. Maybe I should just lower the expectation...But, I won't. Why should I? This is Superman for crying out loud. The greatest superhero of all time. Every Superman fan should have very high expectations for anything related to Superman...And they all deserve it. We all deserve it.
Here's to hoping the writers will get it right and get it right soon.l

Tom,

I couldn't agree with you more bro. I especially loved your chicken analogy. You couldn't be more right. The show started out on a great path in S1 setting the groundwork. They managed to keep the romance and mythology aspects of the show balanced and effectively develop both Clark and Lex.

But the destinies of the characters have taken a back seat to romantic soap opera tactics.


Originally posted by Luthorism
Not a bad episode but don't deserve a 10 IMFO.

I just wanna ask:
Where the hell is Lionel?? Is he dropped out? I mean i can't remember the last episode he played? :lol:

In all honesty, I could care less about Lionel at this point. Lionel USED to be one of my favorite characters when he was the MB. But starting in S4 when he lost his hair, he lost his balls.

He is no longer the character we all know and love.

Lionel is playing this watered down grey area character. I don't want Lionel being the keeper of Clark's secret and a whipped guy hung up on Martha. Mionel is one of the most wrong ships ever created.

If and when Lionel starts to be used more, please make him the way he used to be!

[RedKRules]

10 !!! All the whole scene about getting the GPS out of CHLOE was crazyyyy ....I loved it .....good job for TW and AM, but KK did a really good job too .....there were no ships´ DRAMA ........and Clark used all his powers ......just GREAT .....even better than JUSTICE for sure!!

[Mr. Wrong]

Superman is the future. SV is a newly devised prequel to the worlds greatest superhero. Originally Superman spends over a decade in the fortress being indoctrinated. That is where he develops his smarts. SV is an expansion of a concept of how CK grew to become Superman. I defy anyone to be capable of enough originality to honor the legend properly each and every week. Hence we get fed the old soap aspect far too much for my liking. My feelings were that they would have been far better off to follow a Superboy concept instead of re-inventing CK. With the introduction of a requited love with Lana Lang we saw them throw the book away. They brought on Lois, Perry, and Jimmy over a decade early as well as half of the JLA. Continuity with the original Superman concept is totally compromised now. The writers have tried to re-invent the wheel so to speak and that is a tough row to hoe. While I am disappointed as an avid SM fan, I must compliment all involved for their efforts to keep the episodes entertaining. P.S.. I really like the chicken analogy too!

[Jaded Wolf]

The thing is that is was stated at the beginning that was not to a prelude to the continuity of the comics or the movies. This is a re-invention using the mythos of Superman but making it modern. It's kind of like an "Ultimate" or "All-Stars" rendition of what has come before. It has to have some elements of the soap crap because it is on the CW Network; however, I will admit sometimes they go overboard. Jeph Loeb needs to come back from "Heroes" and remind the SV writers what the show should be about. I mean, "Heroes" covers the angst of romance well and still delivers suspenseful storylines, good action, and all the trials and tribulations of mankind in one freakin' episode. Smallville takes like five episodes to conclude a romance angle, three episodes to show the trials and tribulations of Clark, and maybe one episode every three weeks to show some good action. Something needs to be done or we may have a rushed series finale this year to wrap up all the loose ends. :mad:

[RJLCyberPunk]

Well I'd easily give this one a 5 out of 10. Not exactly the best episode yet but not that shabby either. It is obvious that Lex is heading for a huge downfall that will lead him totally into the dark side he has ventured on...
It is also clear that Lana and Clark will grow a relationship not unlike that of him and Chloe it is obvious now that he can trust her as well wich goes according to canon anyway...

[Mr. Wrong]

Since they weren't planning to follow the canons of Superman lore, why kill off Jonathan? That was taken right from the comics but his absence has led to a very unsavory coupling of Lionel and Martha. This is something that is both distasteful and a disgrace. Pure unadulterated SOAP!!! We've seen the sweet and demure Lana go from being the love of CK's life to a pregnant partner with the worlds greatest villain. Sounds like a plot right out of Days of our Lives.

[trying2b]

Your name fits you well Mr. Wrong. For oldtimers such as myself, Martha and Jonathan both died and were buried together in Smallville cemetary. Of course there was Superboy also who became a man, i.e. Superman. The revamp of 86 is what canon you are talking about I suppose.

[John L. Nerone]

I thought this show was very good. They are starting to show the true Evil Nature of Lex. Chloe and Jimmy back together. But the Lana thing is getting old. And where is Lois at ?? Lois hasn't been on since Crimson, when they gave us all a tease, by finally bringing Lois and Clark together ( by Red K )
I hope the March 15th show brings Lois back LOL

[Imzadia]

Originally posted by kavalier
So far this episode kicks total a##!! Back at Subterannean I thought this season was heading completely downhill, but ever since Hydro it has been turning out to be the best one yet.

:cool: DITTO!! I rated "Freak" a 9. Michael Rosenbaum delivered an impressive first-time outing as Director. I think we received him well, so I've read he plans on doing it again. That's Great to hear! I like long-term series who use certain cast members who have become so used to working together that they know certain directions those characters may venture into. Their familiarity seems to make them better directors, IMO. :D

[Mr. Wrong]

Your name suits you well also, trying. The point that I was attempting to make was that since TPTB have virtually re-written the historionics of most of the characters in the Superman saga. The SV of today is vastly different to that of the comics so why not extend Jonathan's life at least until Lionel was out of the picture. I fear that if TPTB allow Lionel and Martha to hook up in the biblical sense, that will be the end of SV. Superman's mom should never be painted in such a light! P.S. I doubt there is many forumites out there who are older than myself!

[Imzadia]

This is to "trying2b" & "Mr. Wrong"...
I had to laugh when I read what you both had to say about the direction this 'Re-interpreted' version of the Clark Kent/Superman in Smallville canon has taken. You guys know that they can only 'insert' or change what TPTB allow them to. However, I only want to voice how I feel about it, too. I agree that it seems that Clark would've benefitted from having Jonathan Kent live a little longer than what we knew him to live. Especially in the Smallville TV series, because Jonathan & Clark had such a close relationship. I agree, too, that it would be such sacriledge if the Smallville creators are allowed to have Lionel & Martha 'hook-up'. It is 'OK' for Martha to feel some friendship towards Lionel since they did develop a working relationship a few years ago, but mostly, because Lionel seems to want to help protect her son from discovery or exploitation, or harm...even from his own son. However, we all know that she shouldn't trust him completely, and that alone should prevent her from indulging into a romantic relationship with him. All of this also hangs on how much the fans of Smallville know about the original Superman Canon. I have no knowledge that Martha had ever died and was buried next to Jonathan in Smallville. In terms of RL in the DC universe, I'm sure that Clark WILL OUTLIVE everyone he ever knew here on Earth, but Martha should still be around until she's quite old and white-haired. Now, I'll bet that I'm probably older than both of you, but I didn't read all of the Superman Comic books which, I'm sure, is where you've gotten most of your 'canon' info. I only started reading them after the 1st Superman movie came out. I read them for about 10 yrs. The DC comic books were attempting to parallel their stories to compliment the new movies, so I wanted to follow along. Before that, I didn't particularly like DC comics, because they seemed to be too juvenile and the characters too two-dimensional...even Superman. I'm old enough and admit that I used to watch the B/W Superman series on TV in the 50's when I was a young child. I enjoyed it because it was different and fascinating, but typical of TV in the 50's. It was all we had that was BETTER than the other tacky 'space genre' stuff that was offered. I hated the Superfriends! I wasn't impressed with Clark Kent/Superman until Superman the Movie when they made him more human and accessible emotionally. So, in that regard, they have done a magnificent re-telling with Smallville. I'm even admitting to having a 'Martha-mother-hen' attitude toward Smallville's Clark. I feel and believe his humanity. So, I'm a loyal fan and will follow it through until they finish telling their story, their way. Thanks for listening and letting me share.

[Moment4Ever]

Freak was amazingly directed!Very cool.

[ritapat]

where was lois in this episode...and i was watching an old episode..where clark loses his power to this kid gary in sum lightning storm...and it was JIMMY....but in that episode he was someone else??? wierdd

[Mr. Wrong]

This is to Imzadia
Looks like we are of like mind. You just re-iterated the points I was trying to make. P.S. I to grew up watching B/W Superman in the 50's and have enjoyed every representation of Superman since. The latest movie was so poorly written that it was the first time that I haven't been in a hurry to view a Super-pic a second time. SV is an excellent program and I thoroughly enjoy the fresh dimensions that TPTB have injected into the canon. My only concern is that they don't besmirch any characters inappropriately. You must realize that Lionel wants Martha and he knows that protecting Clark is a sure fire way to stay close with her. Also, he is an evil genius who has inside info that his son has not deciphered yet re. CK. One must never forget that they are both Luthors, masters of the alterior motive.

[MAYANSUPERGIRL]

this episode was an amazimg one. the clana scenes were great! i rate this episode a solid 10!! chyaeh:rotfl: :p :rotfl:

[Imzadia]

Originally posted by ritapat
where was lois in this episode...and i was watching an old episode..where clark loses his power to this kid gary in sum lightning storm...and it was JIMMY....but in that episode he was someone else??? wierdd

Since I see no one else has answered your query, I thought I'd give you the 'heads up'. "Lois" isn't in EVERY episode...usually. She has a Credited recurring role, however ED is also busy filming a movie. She does have a couple of upcoming Smallville episodes where she'll be quite prominent in, but don't worry, she's around. I watched that old, 1st Season episode, too, where Clark's 'powers' are transferred into a fellow student while on a field trip via an Electrical Shock & Kryptonite. The actor who played the other student was Shawn Ashmore who is Aaron Ashmore's TWIN brother. Aaron Ashmore is the one who is currently playing Jimmy Olsen on his recurring role on Smallville. Did that clear up some of your questions?


Originally posted by Mr. Wrong
This is to Imzadia
Looks like we are of like mind. You just re-iterated the points I was trying to make. P.S. I to grew up watching B/W Superman in the 50's and have enjoyed every representation of Superman since. The latest movie was so poorly written that it was the first time that I haven't been in a hurry to view a Super-pic a second time. SV is an excellent program and I thoroughly enjoy the fresh dimensions that TPTB have injected into the canon. My only concern is that they don't besmirch any characters inappropriately. You must realize that Lionel wants Martha and he knows that protecting Clark is a sure fire way to stay close with her. Also, he is an evil genius who has inside info that his son has not deciphered yet re. CK. One must never forget that they are both Luthors, masters of the alterior motive.

Hi, Mr. Wrong...
Thanks for responding to my 'input'. YES, it seems we ARE on the same page with our concerns about the direction Smallville is going with our beloved characters. Lex IS becoming that evil 'so & so' of Superman legend, and Lionel Luthor makes me nervous. He CAN NOT be trusted. Supposedly, we'll find out a bit more about his ulterior motives real soon in a couple of the new episodes coming up. I am having a great time participating in this online forum & certain Fandoms overall. It's nice to see that I'm not the only "old timer" out here interacting with the kids who have caught Superman/Clark Kent fever. It,s a fun hobby! :D ;)

[Mr. Wrong]

Hi Imzadia,
Yes its a blast interacting on the Forum. I think it actually allows us to get more out of the show. We senior fans have an advantage as we have Superman ingrained into our being to the point where we can be considered meteor freaks ourselves. Unfortunately, that makes me resistant to any major changes in the storyline but TPTB have done an excellent job keeping the strings in tune with the core philosophy of the Superman canon.
I look forward to reading more of your input. Cheers!

[Imzadia]

I agree that this forum is the perfect place for self-expression among those who have similar interests, or wild enthusiasm particularly about Clark Kent/Superman. Mr. Wrong, you've given me another perspective..."Us 'oldtimer' Supes fans as 'meteor freaks'" !!! LOLOL!! :rotfl: :rotfl: EXACTLY!! :rotfl:

[Mathys Welling]

hi!!!! here in argentina it is the last episode we've seen. I have to say that it was great, i really loved it, it let us a lot of specultions, with mystery, drama and accion, AND clana's scenes, that lana has riskied her life (twice) for savinf the secret of clark is the best that i can get from smallville now.

[ignitesmyveins]

i <3 <3 <3 chloe. amazing episode. i can't wait to se what her power is!!!

[Vovkulak]

I loved this episode, and how it revealed that Chloe was a "meteor Freak". Definitely my favourite episode of season 6.

[smallville0001]

I have just watched it, i am slowly watching season 6 on dvd so i don't have to wait for ages for the next season to come out!

Great episode and i can't wait to find out what Chloe's ability is!

[Nimkong]

It was a great episode but not on my top.Liked the plot,the FOTW was tight, and chloe being a metor freak was tight

[hadezown]

Wow I felt like I just watched a movie. The dialog was mature and the story had depth, progressing everyone's character. I kinda love this season. Gotta keep the tape rolling, I hope MR directed more.

[Raistlin]

For the most part I liked this episode, but I wasn't wild that they made Chloe meteor infected. The only good thing about that was it gave her and Clark a great scene together near the end. Lex is really a MB in training.