Better Episode Labrinth or shattered?

[HotRodTE]

i vote shattered, what do you think?

[MidgardDragon]

I'm sure mostly everyone would bote Shattered, but I think this is another one where I need to say I like them equally. The only thing I liked better in Shattered was the ending. (Shattered is the one with "Hurt" played at the end, right?)

[xrayvision]

I voted Shattered, though I thought Labyrinth was close. This episode was the first episode I thought was totally unpredictable. As good as Shattered was, you could sense part somewhat where the story was going. But in Labyrinth, I had no clue where they were going with it.

[Colossus]

I really don't know which one. But I've honestly considered Shattered to be the best episode of Smallville as a whole. However, Labryinth was such...such an amazing episode. By far the best episode of the season. Plus it featured my boy Mr. Jones the Manhunter. I'll see later , which is better when I can watch them both side by side.

[griffyn612]

shattered, definitely. definitely, yeah.

it felt like a turning point, a critical development from boy scout to SUPERMAN.

it's just that since then, it hasn't happened.

*sigh*

[hassenmorad]

Are these even fair to compare? Shattered is much better in quality, but its not like they really can be compared against eachother anyways. A better poll would be Splinter v. Labrynth.

[RedPhoenix23]

Shattered. Hands down. This episode was CRAP!

[angelus666]

My god I haven't seen this yet but if it even comes close to Shatered I will be shocked and amazed.

[LEXander the Great]

this is a serious question? This episode was bad and weak.
And Shattered is one of the best episodes ever.
Who can compare this two episodes at all?
Two dimensions.

I voted on SHATTERED.

[BadToad]

Shattered, since it didn't have Clark move backwards emotionally. Labyrinth, unfortunately, did.

[Coyote]

Shattered. There's no comparison. Labyrinth was pretty good as filler eps go, but nowhere near as powerful as Shattered.

[krypton_gurl85]

Labyrinth was my fav between the two.

[Nightingale20]

Shattered hands down.

[that girl]

It's close, but Shattered just kicked ass in ways Labryinth didn't so I'm gonna have to go with Shattered.

[HotRodTE]

Originally posted by hassenmorad
Are these even fair to compare? Shattered is much better in quality, but its not like they really can be compared against eachother anyways. A better poll would be Splinter v. Labrynth.

Good point, But the Reason i chose this poll it has both Mental Hospital themes. Therefore they have simaliar episodes. looking back on it i should've made Splinter a third choice as it is somewhat similiar.

[D.M.A.]

yea shattered,this was a good epi but it doesn't compare to shattered.Plus I jus luv s3 so tho this was a close 2nd it doesn't holdup to s3 shattered

[Ladyhawk]

Shattered hands down. It still remains one of my favorite episodes.

[Shadowlord367]

Im definately in the minority of people who think that Shattered wasn't the best episode ever. It was great, Im just not crazy about it

[Mysticlies]

I voted Labrinth...loved the episode

[HotRodTE]

man its closer then i thought it would be

[Jill]

Need I say more???

Shattered all the way down ;)

[cazman_uk]

Shattered was a progression for Lex and revealed more of his characters dark side while I enjoyed Labrynth it done nothing for Clark you didn't find anything new about the character you didn't already know.

[CallMeClark]

Labyrinth.

[Nimkong]

Shattered but that was hard to make.Shattered because MR was such a great actor