Theory about Claire's birth father (spoiler)

[Marvelman]

I suspect that Claire, Peter, and Nathan all share the same birth father. Therefore, making Claire Peter's half-sister. This might explain why the producers say these two will not become involved.

[superhippie2000]

intresting could be something like that. But i think the whole peter and claire not getting together is because peter is like 30 and claire is 17 so there are laws about that type of stuff lol.

Eventually we find out about her birth parents after 3 or 4 more episodes. A lot of the heroes are connected to each other in more then one way so we will see.

[Sharkie]

Yeah, Claire and Peter together is gross.

[chrisxs5]

They did seem to have a strong connection even before he knew she was the cheerleader to save.

[Another-One]

SPOILER!

Claire's father is Linderman....

[Marvelman]

How do you know this? Is this confirmed, or speculation on your part?

[gameface25]

Where does it say Peter is 30? I took him to be 24ish

[i love u tom]

i thought he was in his mid 20s too.

i wont believe that spoiler until its confirmed.

[warriorrenegade]

I think Claires father might end up being. SPOILER-->

Eric Roberts. HRGs assistant.

[Monkeychow01]

Um...got pictures that pretty much show who it is.


Nathan IS her father guys. I got 2 screen caps from the trailer, and the watch/shirt/veins on his hand give it away.


Makes sense, he doesn't want anyone to know he had yet another affair on his wife...and then a wife/kid with super powers only goes worse for his image.

[Marvelman]

Originally posted by Monkeychow01
Um...got pictures that pretty much show who it is.


Nathan IS her father guys. I got 2 screen caps from the trailer, and the watch/shirt/veins on his hand give it away.


Makes sense, he doesn't want anyone to know he had yet another affair on his wife...and then a wife/kid with super powers only goes worse for his image.

I'm obviously missing something here. How does Nathan's watch/shirt/veins prove that he is Claire's father?

(Personally, I like the Linderman theory.)

[Monkeychow01]

check out the screen cap of her "dad's" hand. Pay close attention to the watch and the veins on his hand. There is another picture on this site of nathan sitting in a chair with the same watch / shirt / vein structure in the same place on his hand.

[FUZZYWOOKIEE]

In an interview given to TV Guide, I think, they said that Claire's father was a character who had been around the whole series. That leads me to believe it could be someone we have heard about and not yet seen, such as the Petrelli's father, really dead or not??? Although given Nathan philandering ways it is likely that he could have slept with Claire's mom, yet wasn't it said that her birth parents worked for HRG before she was born?

[CallMeClark]

Well rumors are floating around that it is either Nathan or...

HRG really is her father!

[christian_kryptonian]

I see Peter as an older brother to Claire. I never saw them as a possible item. I thougt it was very good of him to save her and I hope he has a chance to save her again in the future. He is like a good bigbrother, so them having the same birth father is a posibility I suppose. I doubt it though.

[Keyser Soze]

I personally am going for the invisible man. I know he has only been around for a few episodes, but then again how would we know?

[Monkeychow01]

Just want to say "WHAT THEN?"..

Next time I present evidence, take me more seriously.