Mistakes in Wither

[superhippie2000]

Find any put them here.

[RedPhoenix23]

Oops... I don't know about the ep yet, but you spelt "Mistakes" wrong, talk about ironic. :lol: Psst.. Just say you meant to do that, I got your back. ;)

[superhippie2000]

doh....ya i ment to do that ::looks away:: lol

if any mods can fix that please do.

[thehenry89]

i aint seen it yet but 10-1 lana's hand is compltley healed along with lex's shoulder.

[chlarkfan333]

Originally posted by superhippie2000
doh....ya i ment to do that ::looks away:: lol

if any mods can fix that please do.

No, no it's fitting as it stands. :)

[i luv tom welling]

Lex says that he's never asked any of the women he was with to move in with him.

Helen moved in with him (or at least had a key to his place...). I believe Victoria Hardwick lived at the mansion for a short while as well.

[STFanatic]

Clark was impaled through the back with a vine.
The vine is through his blue jacket and red shirt.
We see that clearly. Yes?
Fast forward to the fight with the Zonie.
Clark's clothes have healed along with his body? No hole in his blue jacket or his red shirt now.

[earth-2 kal-el]

I think the biggest mistake what the episode in general

[InLove_with_Chloe]

Originally posted by earth-2 kal-el
I think the biggest mistake what the episode in general

I agree with that one...
:rolleyes:

[Red K 5]

Clark looked pale making him look sick

[Fly by guy]

Setting my recorder for 8:00 on the CW on Thursday was my mistake, everything else was the writers. Yuck. I saw less meadow muffins on the farm then on this episode. Why didn't Clark cook the ranger the first time she trapped him. I guess he can't use his heat vision when he's checking her cleavage. Sad.

[TW1977]

Well, I'm not sure this is a mistake or poor audio editing but I noticed more than usual many voiceover issues! You could tell where they had to edit in a Character's line!

[Ardnas_Navi]

at the end, when lex have his hand on lana's bareback, we see 2 shadows on the left of the screen !

[chloewannabe]

Originally posted by i luv tom welling
Lex says that he's never asked any of the women he was with to move in with him.

Helen moved in with him (or at least had a key to his place...). I believe Victoria Hardwick lived at the mansion for a short while as well.

yeah I did notice this one right away...

[manofsteel30]

All was crap. And yes, Lex has had women living with him and even Lana knows this so it's not just that he's lying or trying to make her feel better. She's a twit yes, but this is one time when she should have called someone on a blatant lie!

[crackur]

yall are too uptight

it was a good episode

[last man of krypton]

Lois telling Ollie he could "do better". Didn't she have to go back to high school, leech off the Kents for a while, and even earned herself the nickname of "muffin peddler"?

[Nightingale20]

Not a mistake but I found it weird when Lana and Lois met at the party. They didn't even acknowledge that they knew each other. Kinda interesting considering that long talk they had in season 5, which was random.

[kazek]

According to the most recent explanation of Superman's powers, Superman derives his super-powers, in part, from the peculiar radiations of Earth's yellow sun. That being said, he is 100% invulnerable as long as he is on Earth. How then were those vines able to penentrate his skin ? And to note that he also passed out....
I know this was supposed to be some weird alien chic but she had nothing to do with Kryptonite. This was not a mistake but I found it kind of odd the way they deviated....

According to the most recent explanation of Superman's powers, Superman derives his super-powers, in part, from the peculiar radiatio

[chloewannabe]

amen...althou in the circumtances surrounding them I don't think any of them were thinking of specifics... and I don't think Lana is a twit at all

[otter]

Okay, my hubby had a problem with Ollie's arrow taking the tab off of the can without knocking the can over. I just told him Ollie's that good! LOL.

[clarkandlana2]

The Lexana sex. HUGE mistake. :mad:

[colt114]

stop worrying about the mistakes and just enjoy the show

[superman's my hero]

Originally posted by earth-2 kal-el
I think the biggest mistake what the episode in general

Me too. The hugest mistake was Lexana sex. ew. I threw up a little after I was finished crying.

[Loranthius]

I thought that the ball was supposed to be in the evening. After the ball scene clark was rescued from the vines during the day.

[Crumble]

Originally posted by Loranthius
I thought that the ball was supposed to be in the evening. After the ball scene clark was rescued from the vines during the day.

Yeah but if you notice the pinkish orange glow on his face and the same coloured light behind him while on the vine the sun is setting. So there was no mistake. Unless the you know the specific time of the party and what time the sun sets on that day... its not a mistake.

[Luv Clana/Hate Lexana]

Originally posted by superman's my hero
Me too. The hugest mistake was Lexana sex. ew. I threw up a little after I was finished crying.

That makes two of us.

[chlarkfan333]

Originally posted by colt114
stop worrying about the mistakes and just enjoy the show

That's our perrogative :p and they aren't mutually exclusive.

[STFanatic]

Originally posted by otter
Okay, my hubby had a problem with Ollie's arrow taking the tab off of the can without knocking the can over. I just told him Ollie's that good! LOL.

I noticed that myself, the can would have at least wobbled, but I took another mouthful of salt grains 'cause it was GA.
:p

[Lorna]

I think Oliver wears the suit ahead of time. On top of it, he easily gets recognized by Lex. There can be some problems here if Green Arrow intends to have a secret identity.

[jimintn]

The one thing that I COULD NOT get over was how at the hospital, the vine poked into an electrical socket and it only destroyed a small piece of the branch. Yet, later, Chloe kills the whole freakin' bush with a hand-held taser? Not buyin' it!

Also, Lex has cameras watching his cameras, yet he doesn't have one in his greenhouse? But wait, how did he know Clark was there? But wait, wouldn't he see Clark's showdown with the Krypto-chick? Hmm.

Lois as Maid Marian, though, WOW!! :p

[The Source]

dunno if this is a mistake
when the plant gets electrocuted, it turns to black dust (or whatever it is)
so jimmy was infected and chloe saved him, does that mean his body's full of dust?

[krpto]

Originally posted by manofsteel30
All was crap. And yes, Lex has had women living with him and even Lana knows this so it's not just that he's lying or trying to make her feel better. She's a twit yes, but this is one time when she should have called someone on a blatant lie!

Yah I was waiting for us to hear lex thinking
i hope lana doesn't remember all the women that have lived here and lana thinking um didn't lex marry some of theose other women oh well I'll play dumb.

[Kal El, Hero]

Ok so you guys aren't so much complaining about actual mistakes like factual errors...but just thinks you disliked about it, hence making it a mistake? So would keeping Lana in the series just count as one huge mistake, or should I mention it in every episode

[guitarmaster15]

the main mistake in this episode is! LANA SLEPT WIV LEX!! thats like the biggest mistake hehe :P but bout the tops not having any holes in...well he might have gone home quickly n got a new pair exactly the same :D ...maybe...

[otter]

Originally posted by jimintn
The one thing that I COULD NOT get over was how at the hospital, the vine poked into an electrical socket and it only destroyed a small piece of the branch. Yet, later, Chloe kills the whole freakin' bush with a hand-held taser? Not buyin' it!

Also, Lex has cameras watching his cameras, yet he doesn't have one in his greenhouse? But wait, how did he know Clark was there? But wait, wouldn't he see Clark's showdown with the Krypto-chick? Hmm.

Okay, good! That taser comment is great!

To further your comments about Lex and the greenhouse, how is it Lex was able to sneak up on our super-hearing Clarkie? Did he happen to already be in the greenhouse and Clark just didn't see him?

To answer someone else's question about the black dust being inside Jimmy, the vine turned to black dust, not the seeds inside the human's stomach. The electricity de-natured the seeds' enzymes, right?

[supergirl_1095]

Originally posted by guitarmaster15
the main mistake in this episode is! LANA SLEPT WIV LEX!! thats like the biggest mistake hehe :P but bout the tops not having any holes in...well he might have gone home quickly n got a new pair exactly the same :D ...maybe...
*sticks tongue out* Lexana rules! That is NOT a mistake! Go Lexana!

And the Luv Clana/Hate Lexana, you can hate Lexana, which is getting together for the first time, yet love Clana, which has been going on/off on/off forever and is totaly annoying? Seems strange...

[redraven]

^ That doesn't make any sense. Just because Lex and Lana are getting together for the first time, and Clark and Lana have been on and off, doesn't mean that it's strange for someone to like the latter. And if they love Clana I really doubt they thought it was annoying like you do :rolleyes:

Anyway, I also had a small problem with Lex telling Lana he's never asked a woman to move in with him and the fact that she believed him, how could she not remember Helen or I think Desiree Atkins?

[ClarkLovesLana]

Is it just me or did Lana ignore Lois in the party?

[Pesk]

^ Perhaps their costumes were so good, they didn't recognize each other? :)

[Lex Dance]

Originally posted by kazek
According to the most recent explanation of Superman's powers, Superman derives his super-powers, in part, from the peculiar radiations of Earth's yellow sun. That being said, he is 100% invulnerable as long as he is on Earth. How then were those vines able to penentrate his skin ? And to note that he also passed out....
I know this was supposed to be some weird alien chic but she had nothing to do with Kryptonite. This was not a mistake but I found it kind of odd the way they deviated....

According to the most recent explanation of Superman's powers, Superman derives his super-powers, in part, from the peculiar radiatio
You're right that Earth's yellow sun gives Clark his powers, but this only makes him invunerable to dangers from this solar system (and I guess others like it). Clark comes from a solar system with a red dwarf at the centre where the density of gravity is much greater. I suppose we have to assume (even though we are not told) that the weird alien chick comes from somewhere similar, in which case her powers and the powers of her plant will be heightened under a yellow sun. Don't forget, kryptonite isn't the only thing that can harm Clark on Earth. If other Kryptonians can, then it's safe to assume other aliens can too.

[psycosis]

Originally posted by Lex Dance
You're right that Earth's yellow sun gives Clark his powers, but this only makes him invunerable to dangers from this solar system (and I guess others like it). Clark comes from a solar system with a red dwarf at the centre where the density of gravity is much greater.

You know too much! :p


Originally posted by kazek
According to the most recent explanation of Superman's powers, Superman derives his super-powers, in part, from the peculiar radiations of Earth's yellow sun. That being said, he is 100% invulnerable as long as he is on Earth.

Superman does get his energy source from our sun (which in turn charges his powers) though it does not make him totally invulnerable to everything within our system;

Magic is probably the main weakness of Superman (not including outside elements remember), which we have seen in Smallville (Spell).

Also Clark has been hit around a fair bit by FOTW's and aliens alike, proveing shear strength can be enough to hurt him too.

Objects also can be sharp enough to cut Clark, though they tend to fall under the magic or alien type - it still proves he can be cut.

Now we don't know much about the woman's origin, though most prisoners it's safe to assume broke Krypton law at some point, so must have been on Krypton or a neighbouring planet - so they could quite easy have some Kryptonite like qualities/powers.

I think it’s safe to assume the woman’s powers and vines fall under one or more of the above weaknesses of Superman/Clark. But in any case it would have been a dull battle if Clark was able to over power her too easily.

[Lex Dance]

Originally posted by psycosis
You know too much! :p
Haha! I've been reading up - gotta try and keep up with comics experts like yourself! :lol:
I've found Dorling Kindersley's Ultimate Guide to the Man of Steel very enlightening.

Originally posted by psycosis
Also Clark has been hit around a fair bit by FOTW's and aliens alike, proveing shear strength can be enough to hurt him too.
Of course! I forgot about the meteor freaks - whoops!

Originally posted by psycosis
I think it’s safe to assume the woman’s powers and vines fall under one or more of the above weaknesses of Superman/Clark. But in any case it would have been a dull battle if Clark was able to over power her too easily.
To be honest, it was fairly dull anyway! :lol: