PDA

View Full Version : Claire can't get drunk?



shanemak
09-29-2009, 03:48 PM
Claire told Gretchen that she couldn't get drunk, and that she'd always have a designated driver. My only gripe was that Kensei had the same power as Claire, and in feudal Japan, wasn't he quite the alcoholic? Or else he was just in the habit of drinking? Although he looked pretty wasted when Hiro dunked his head in the traugh.

kryptonhero25
09-29-2009, 04:02 PM
I don't know if you watched the episode last year where Claire and Nathan were at some bar and Nathan and some random guys were seeing who could drink the most tequila or something for money and Nathan passed out so Claire went in and just kept taking shot after shot without the alcohol having any side effects.

RedPhoenix23
09-29-2009, 04:15 PM
It might because either Kensei's healing power wasn't activated yet due to suffering the tramautic event of dying the first time that he does later on.

Or Claire's powers are just still in superdrive since Sylar sawed her head open in season three - after that she could no longer feel pain and it became evident that she couldn't get drunk.

Adam/Kensei still seemed able to feel pain (in a manly "must not show it too much" kind of way, lol) so I don't think his are as ramped up as hers because he hasn't had his brains scrambled by Sylar.

----- Added 1 Minutes later -----

But... it doesn't make sense why knock out gas/tranks would still work on her though. Wouldn't she just heal the effects that has on her the same way she heals the effects of alcohal?

shanemak
09-29-2009, 06:22 PM
I don't know if you watched the episode last year where Claire and Nathan were at some bar and Nathan and some random guys were seeing who could drink the most tequila or something for money and Nathan passed out so Claire went in and just kept taking shot after shot without the alcohol having any side effects.

Yea that little stunt goes more to prove my point that the writers' seemed to move the goal posts in the middle of the game. Kensei was a raving lush, and they went to lengths to portray that, yet has exactly the same powers as Claire does, but she cannot get drunk.

superhippie2000
09-29-2009, 06:24 PM
i dont think kensi had the ability to heal think he just had the ability to not die.

shanemak
09-29-2009, 06:26 PM
It might because either Kensei's healing power wasn't activated yet due to suffering the tramautic event of dying the first time that he does later on.

Or Claire's powers are just still in superdrive since Sylar sawed her head open in season three - after that she could no longer feel pain and it became evident that she couldn't get drunk.

Adam/Kensei still seemed able to feel pain (in a manly "must not show it too much" kind of way, lol) so I don't think his are as ramped up as hers because he hasn't had his brains scrambled by Sylar.

That could possibly be why, yet the writers' shouldn't let the audience figure out a glitch like so by offering up alternatives, they need to explain it.


----- Added 1 Minutes later -----

But... it doesn't make sense why knock out gas/tranks would still work on her though. Wouldn't she just heal the effects that has on her the same way she heals the effects of alcohal?

Yea I never understood that one either. The same with Sylar in the season finale. Me thinks the writers' need to do a better job at portraying the characters' vulnerabilities and in-vulnerabilities a little better.

----- Added 1 Minutes later -----


i dont think kensi had the ability to heal think he just had the ability to not die.


Well if you remember in the second season when he found out he said and Hiro acknowledged that he couldn't die from ANY wound. In the next few scenes he was shown cutting his forearm with a sword and healing instantly.

jazzylg
09-29-2009, 07:44 PM
Claire's pain receptors were reset back to normal last season, unless the new writers forgot..oops! :lol:

RedPhoenix23
09-30-2009, 12:25 AM
When was that? Oops, the audience forgot too, lol. :p

superhippie2000
09-30-2009, 08:28 AM
That could possibly be why, yet the writers' shouldn't let the audience figure out a glitch like so by offering up alternatives, they need to explain it.



Yea I never understood that one either. The same with Sylar in the season finale. Me thinks the writers' need to do a better job at portraying the characters' vulnerabilities and in-vulnerabilities a little better.

----- Added 1 Minutes later -----




Well if you remember in the second season when he found out he said and Hiro acknowledged that he couldn't die from ANY wound. In the next few scenes he was shown cutting his forearm with a sword and healing instantly.
ya but that could of been the immortallity power doing the healing.

----- Added 15 Seconds later -----


When was that? Oops, the audience forgot too, lol. :p
:lol:

CompanyMan
09-30-2009, 10:03 AM
For some reason, I've always thought that Adam's abiltiy manifested around the time when he was fataly wounded with the arrows. I sort of wonder if his abiltiy manifesting then had something to do with Hiro (inadverdently) travelling back to that particular time in history. I tend to think that Hiro stepped on a few butterflies, so to speak, and caused Adam's abiltiy to manifest at that time. But that's just a theory, and nothing else. It does bug me that the writers have been rather inconsistent.