Who's responsible for Jimmy's death???????

[amandaa125]

IMO Davis and Chloe are both to blame, Davis was the one who actually pulled this off, but it was Chloe's blindness (or stupidity) that led tho this event, I don't know whether she's been smoking something with Davis or whatever - he was killing people all over the places they went, Davis even admitted it, but Chloe refused to see this, Clark's idea with the PZ was da best but she stopped him, and it led to the latter events. I don't know what she planned on doing - spend the rest of her life babysitting Davis? Even though she wasn't able to calm the beast anymore!

She chose Davis over Jimmy, not even apologising to Jimmy when it got obvious he was right all along and suddenly in this episode she chose Jimmy - lying to Davis all along, harboring him for no reason as it would appear? Letting him kill innocent people while escaping with him - where? Gimmie a break..

I agree with absolutely everything you just said.

[Dominicus]

I actually think it's Clarks fault Jimmy dies. Afterall, lets not forget, it was Clarks idea to use black k on DD to split Davis from the beast. If that wasn't done, who knows if Jimmy would've died to begin with.That idea was scaped and Chloe was the one to put it into fruition. It wasn't Clark who cause the split, may have been his idea that he never carried out. Think about why the black-k was going to be used in the first place, a last ditch effort because Chloe interferred when they were going to send Davis to the Phantom zone. There's dozen of factors, Davis was the killer provoked by Chloe's at the end emotional light-switch.

[jpfort1957]

You would think after the way things turned out, Chloe would be in a complete state of shock. Instead she's more interested in trying to pick out new curtains for the Watchtower!!!!

[abbaspice1]

You would think after the way things turned out, Chloe would be in a complete state of shock. Instead she's more interested in trying to pick out new curtains for the Watchtower!!!!

Yeah, she wasn't too heartbroken...planning out her future. I thought at least she would feel, I don't know, guilt, if not for Jimmy, at least for all those folks Davis/Doomsday murdered AFTER she took off with him. Or perhaps numbness.

But instead, she is planning out her and the JL future headquarters, while Jimmy's (the man she supposedly loved) blood stain is STILL on the floor.

*shakes head in disgust*

[tmchale1970]

Davis is responsible. I think Chloe thought Davis would be ok once Doomsday left him.agreed the only person responsible for jimmys death was that phycopath davis.i hated that guy from episode 2.:mad:

----- Added 3 Minutes later -----


Yeah, she wasn't too heartbroken...planning out her future. I thought at least she would feel, I don't know, guilt, if not for Jimmy, at least for all those folks Davis/Doomsday murdered AFTER she took off with him. Or perhaps numbness.

But instead, she is planning out her and the JL future headquarters, while Jimmy's (the man she supposedly loved) blood stain is STILL on the floor.

*shakes head in disgust*chloe has seen more death and destruction than lois or lana.we all have coping mechanisms wether youre fictonal or not.

----- Added 15 Minutes later -----


It's technically Davis' fault but I blame Chloe for not just crying on the guy and healing him. For some reason she decided he wasn't worth it. STUPIDshe was in a state of shock and she dosn`t have her healing powers anymore.she lost them when in s7 when brainac probed her,thats why she could not heal the human clark in the s9 premiere.i will defend chloe till i am blue in the face.every other major character has been responsible directly or indirectly for other peoples pain and suffering.clark killed martha`s child went to metrpolis robbed atm machines robbed banks was responsible for pa kents heart attack and death,so no one on the show is whiter than white.:mad:

[x20ArchAngel09x]

I voted Davis, for physically he did kill Jimmy, but ultimately, it was Chloe that killed him in the end.

[jpfort1957]

Only Chloe!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Gan-EL: the last son]

Chloe killed Jimmy. Had she not kept Clark from putting Davis in the phantom zone or lied about him surviving the Kryptonite, or ran away with Davis, ect. Jimmy would have lived.

[jpfort1957]

I hate to say it ....................but at the time Clark told Jimmy to take Chloe and Davis to the wedding present.........he had no idea of knowing if Davis and DD had been seperated yet.

But it was Jimmy that killed himself. When Clark told him to take Chloe and her boyfriend Davis, the guy that ruined his whole life to the wedding present.........Jimmy's response should have been "F Y!!!" and maybe he would still be alive.

[DarkKal]

As much as I want to blame Clark, Chloe or even Shelby (hey where the eff was he at the time?!) it's obviously Davis' fault, He was the one that stabbed Jimmy.

[Degobunny]

Well Jimmy is still alive, but if you are refering to Henry's death then Davis all the way!!! Chloe is not at fault here.

[mcwelling197]

I voted Chloe, one minute she's telling Clark (in Legion) to do what's best for the world, next she undermines him when he wants to send Davis to the PZ.

[alejandrita439]

Chloe!

[Anu]

Def Chloe. And I hated her ever since then! She think she owns Smallville. And owns Clark's mind or something.

[donnarose]

Chloe, however could be accidental,prompts curiosity.:\:\

[Anu]

What I hate with Chloe is that she's not saying that she is sorry that she lied to Clark or even kept him in the basement. I really hate that! People should have some guilt.

[Degobunny]

What I hate with Chloe is that she's not saying that she is sorry that she lied to Clark or even kept him in the basement. I really hate that! People should have some guilt.

Chloe has guilt, she is even keeping the place Henry/Jimmy bought, and making it useful to honor him. No to mention the spoilers for season 9 reguarding Chloe and Henry/Jimmy. Everyone really needs to lay off Chloe, she did not stick the pole through Henry/Jimmy, Davis did.

[KansasKitty]

Why didn't Chole at least try to heal Jimmy with her "meteor power"? Sure, it is unexplainable gone but you'ld think she would have at least tried to fire it back up.

[actaeon]

Chloe has guilt, she is even keeping the place Henry/Jimmy boughtI don't think that exactly shouts "repentance". She befriends the killer who will later murder Jimmy, drives Jimmy away through her lack of faith in him, and in the end... gets to keep real estate?! Some punishment!

Small thing that bugged me no end: at the funeral, Chloe gives away Jimmy's expensive Nikon camera, as a gift to his little brother (the "other" Jimmy...). Thing is, that camera was not her property! Remember when Jimmy "broke into" her (their) apartment over the Talon and "stole" her (their) money? How come Jimmy's camera was community property, to dispose of however Chloe chose, and the apartment was not community property?

[Anu]

I mean yeah she is sorry that Jimmy is dead, and she keeps the montage "Watchtower".

But, she doesn't say that it was her fault that Jimmy died, by keeping that murderer in the basement, and lying to Clark (her best friend) I mean, come on!

And then she wants Clark to go back in time to save Jimmy. And when Clark refuses, she is starting to hate him.

I mean, what's up with that really?! Not a good person in my eyes or ears.

[Joanna]

I love it that even Shelby has got more votes than Clark :)

[actaeon]

Aw... I like Chloe. I think she screwed up, but she's a good person and I really like the character. The show would be lessened without her.

I put her in the same kind of moral category as Ollie. Ollie, who killed Lex. The best characters are the ones who make mistakes, who suffer, who struggle, who bear the conseqences of their mistakes... I don't want them to be perfect!

[Infamous]

How the hell can you blame Chloe when Davis is one of the alternative?!

[Saphira]

Davis. duhhh

and i see that everyone thinks chloe is the guilty. anyway i'm happy with jimmy death. i like her more and more because of that. i don't like jimmy. never liked and when he died i stay relieved. jimmy character and his story was totally boring.



:D

[Nimkong]

Chloe.Shes retated enough to belive that doomsday had good in him.If was her then i would have blown his brains out a long time ago

[Dominicus]

How the hell can you blame Chloe when Davis is one of the alternative?!
The same way a contractor is blamed for hiring a hitman. Davis pulled the trigger, but Chloe provoked the shooter and is responsible for what lead to Jimmy's demise. Knowing Davis was emotionally unstable and dependent upon her with deranged fantasies in his head and feeding into that psychosis. In other words she conjured a devil and asked him to behave. Davis was a wounded snake she took care of that ended up biting his savior. Chloe had no illusion, and took some of the blame in season 9

[Supsfan]

The same way a contractor is blamed for hiring a hitman. Davis pulled the trigger, but Chloe provoked the shooter and is responsible for what lead to Jimmy's demise. Knowing Davis was emotionally unstable and dependent upon her with deranged fantasies in his head and feeding into that psychosis. In other words she conjured a devil and asked him to behave. Davis was a wounded snake she took care of that ended up biting his savior. Chloe had no illusion, and took some of the blame in season 9

I don't look at it that way, I look at it more that Clark had a great idea what to do with Davis that would have fixed the situation, but Chloe ran up to the FOS and stuck her nose where it didn't belong. If Clark did what he wanted, Davis would be in the PZ and Jimmy would be alive.

Worse then Jimmy being dead to me is Clark looks like an idiot for listening to Chloe and not going with his gut. They basically put him in a lose-lose situation where if Chloe was right, he looks bad for not thinking of that solution and if Chloe is wrong he looks bad for trusting her.

Terrible writing basically.

[litafanforlife]

Davis. Chloe gets far too much blame in this.

[kneel4justice]

Davis is to blame. He KILLED Jimmy. Sure Chloe may have trusted him a little to much but in the end she did not Kill him.

[fulfillingdestiny]

It's Davis that actually was the inhumane one who decided to murder Jimmy. Chloe did it to try to save Davis, and in addition, she probably had a few feelings for him too. Clark wanted to preserve him through black k because of his values and ethics to destroy only what is necessary- in this case, the demon side of Davis.
Too bad to see that that demon side remained with him after he had been separated from the Beast and couldn't get over Chloe truly loving him.

[bbiz20]

Chloe is DEFINITLY the one to blame. She trusted a psychotic serial killer over her own husband. For the sole reason of 'she found him hot.'
She STOPPED Clark from sending Davis to the phantom zone when she knew FULL well he was a dangerous threat.
So yes, she was the one to blame. Davis is obviously the one to blame for physically killing him but if Chloe hadn't put all her trust in Davis that would have never happened.

[babilon]

You are correct, Chloe is partially to blame. For driving Jimmy away, hiding a murderer, not telling Clark about Davies (a dark mark on the character that never got fully addressed and resolved, like so many things on the show).

But you're completely wrong about her stopping Clark from throwing Davis to the PZ.
The whole "do not kill" business in Superman mythos is not about killing per se, it's about the character not being Judge Dread - the law, the judge and the executioner - no matter the sentence. You don't see Superman in comics throwing all his enemies to PZ, deserted island, other planets, black holes etc. (though that would be a smart thing to do).
If Clark had send Davies to the PZ, he might have just killed him then and there, wouldn't make a difference. He would made the law, pass the sentence and deliver the punishment. Complete negation of what Superman stands for. Not that the writers didn't make Clark do exactly that, which they later mocked in Zod's words when he pointed out something to the effect that Clark made himself the god who sends enemies to the PZ for whatever reason he chooses.
In the terms of saving what Clark's character should stand for, Chloe was absolutely right when she stopped him. Not that this completely exonerates her from her multiple mistakes that season.

[Vintage]

Chloe and Davis are fully responsible. Why is Clark even on this poll?

[mirandalynn22]

Brian and Kelly are responsible for Jimmy's death. Boo! Those whores.

[toflyup]

Brian and Kelly are responsible for a lot of things on this show. It did make Chloe look bad as a wife tho.

[KneelBeforeSmallville]

DAVIS!! Oliver, Chloe, Bart & Dina. Hated how Clark put it all on his shoulders, They all made mistakes and thats one of the darkest aspects to the show. Doomsay was the Day of Doom.