Saddest Funeral?

[wildcherry]

Do you think Jimmys funeral was the saddest? it was so sad but i kind of saw it coming when clark told him his secret and him and chloe made up, just to make it even more sad. and when you see oliver cry, omg.

[Superman of Krypton]

Ollie as crying at how bad the episode was.

[rebecavaldez]

I really think that they should bring Jimmy back. I know they won't, but still I'm hoping. Man even the tough GA was crying! Of course that was sad!

[superhippie2000]

sad but not the saddest. john kents was.

[nipvillesmlltuk]

It was sad...but Mr. Kent's was the saddest :(

[Minela]

I thought Lionel's was the saddest. IMO

[zorasuperman]

like previous posts said be4 me
jonathan kents was the saddest
but dont get me wrong jimmy's was sad too :(

[LoveHurts38]

It was sad !!

[jcsolcp]

it was sad but i agree jonathan's was the saddest, & then jimmy's. they will have to bring jimmy back if they r goin to even remain remotely close to the superman mythos, & ollie crying was a great touch

[Clark_smallville4ever]

Im going to have to go with jonathons it was so depressing

i had convinced my friend who i got into smallville to watch reckoning before he went to bed after a long day and after watching johnathon die he kicked me out of his house furious because i had just ruined his day :(

[LSF45]

What about Lex's from Season Three's Opener? That was really.... Oh, nevermind. :-)

Frankly, the saddest funeral was Jonathan's, but really it should've been Ryan's. The Episode where Ryan is dying was a tough one to watch. I don't know if I could've watched a funeral scene without a few tears shedding.

[Superman's Princess]

This one was sad but, Pa Kent's funeral was the saddest.

[darkraya]

jonahan's was the saddest funeral on the show so far (possibly forever)

[Kschreck]

Johnathon Kent had the best and most emotional funeral of them all.

[NinaDavis]

ollie as crying at how bad the episode was.

word!!

[redkryptoniteisthebest]

Mr. Kents was the saddest.

[Honey45]

It might have been sad if I wasn't like WTF through the whole thing.

The saddest for me was Johnathan.

[Alicia Chipy]

Pa Kent's was a 4 hankie tear jerker.

[Forney2414]

Well is wasn't the real Jimmy anyways so eh. And Honey45 that avatar is distracting while trying to type :D

[Bizarrolover]

It matches Jonathan's. I loved Jimmy. Except for this crappy junkie arc they gave him, he was always such an optimistic character.

[Ginx]

sad but not the saddest. john kents was.

I agree. That was the saddest one for me too.

[LuckyLois]

Jonathan's was the saddest. When Clark helps put his mothers pearls on, I lost it. Clark is just numb at the funeral and a great Peter Gabriel song is playing in the background with the snow falling and shot in black and white slo mo ,*terrific*

[SnowBird]

Jimmy's funneral was sad but Jonathan Kent's funeral was the saddest.

[clanaluva4Life]

Johnathan Kent's Funeral was the Saddest and nothing can compare. Peter Gabriel's I Grieve wa sperfect, Lana's Hand in Clark's, the slow motion, Martha Kent. sigh. i miss the good ole Smallville days not the crap happening now.. boo hoo poor jimmy the fake olsen. YAWN!

[MrsK]

Jonathan Kent's was the saddest funeral by far. I'll miss Jimmy, though.

[Krypto~Luan]

Mr. Kent, i almost cried. Poor martha. She was the one that got to me. THe widow.

[jedimorton21]

i think Pa Kent and Mr. Lionel Luther was sad.. u knew it was coming.. but you didn't know how it was going to happen

[thehenry89]

Johnathan kent's was the saddest, he's yet another charachter who died for no reason.

[chlarker4eva08]

heck NO johnathans was the saddest.. =[

[chlavisbug]

Ollie as crying at how bad the episode was.

:rotfl:lol- that is so true!

[chobee]

Lex's was the saddest (as in pathetic). The one after his plane crash. Tear jerker is definitely Pa Kent

[damara531]

Tonight's funeral was certainly sad. But not sadder than Jonathon's in my opinion. That sequence from Reckoning was just heartbreakingly beautiful...even if the rest of the episode was bothersome.

[borednow]

Broke my heart...

[lane06]

yeah matches pa kents funeral

[crazy4clois]

It might have been sad if I wasn't like WTF through the whole thing.


Dude, me too! I was like o_0!

I watched it again after the shock went away and it was so sad. Mostly because we won't see AA again. He was the best Jimmy ever!

I agree JK was the saddest of them all! I remember I cried like a baby that night. Then at the end of Vengeance...I can't even watch that ending w/o tearing up...it's the most beautifully sad SV ending ever!

[amalie]

I'll have to rewatch it because I was too incensed to care at the time. I doubt I'll ever be able to watch it without feeling anger therefore it doesn't really class as sad for me.

[Ellsbury]

To me Jimmy’s death is sadder than Jonathan’s! Jonathan had a great and full life, and even though he wasn't that old when he passed away he could at least rest in peace. In Jimmy’s case it's a whole different story! The guy wasn't even 25, he’d never really had the chance to be happy and while he was finally getting his marriage back on track he got everything taken away from him! This death is unfair.

[ginnyfan]

Henry James' funeral was sad, but Johnathan Kent's was more sad.

[KAL-EL10]

Mr Kents was sad, but Jimmy's is sader he was only 22! I am so MAD!!

[SacredK]

2nd saddest...Clark's dad's was the saddest, I cried the episode after too.

[Kika]

Jimmy's funeral sad, common people even the Whitney's dad funeral in 1 season was saddest than this, and we don't know or care who he was, I don't even remember his name, just dad of Whitney.

This funeral was really good, Jimmy deserve to die, He wasn't even the real Jimmy.

[RaniaLovesClois]

It was really sad...:(

Bye, bye Jimmy...:(

[27CDruid]

I wasn't sad. I was just plain confused. I half expected Jimmy's coffin to pop open and he would jump out yelling surprise!

[Sports72Xtrm]

I cried. I have to admit. The Chloe scenes angered me a little bit. And then I saw Iconic Jimmy Olson with his little bow tie. I felt so bad for him I wanted to give him milk and cookies. And then Ollie shed a tear and I broke down.

[Krypto_marcus]

No funeral in Smallville (or TV) can ever be more sad than Jonathan Kent's.

But it was sad though.

[natbug]

It was a toss up for me. Jonathan's was very sad, too. But, I voted Jimmy's as the saddest. I think it was the death with a twist - Jimmy dying in Chloe's arms, their declaration of love for each other, then through the funeral, Chloe giving the camera away, and Diana walking with Chloe that did it for me. I cried more here than at Jonathan's funeral.

[DarkClone]

Mr. Kent's funeral was definitely the saddest, by far

[Ilovebeinglost]

Johnathan Kent's was the saddest, heartbreaking really because we had gone through so much with him.

[Honey45]

Dude, me too! I was like o_0!

I watched it again after the shock went away and it was so sad. Mostly because we won't see AA again. He was the best Jimmy ever!

I agree JK was the saddest of them all! I remember I cried like a baby that night. Then at the end of Vengeance...I can't even watch that ending w/o tearing up...it's the most beautifully sad SV ending ever!

I agree! The song "I Grieve" during Johnathan's funeral and Clark crying at the end of Vengeance really get me. I love to watch those parts but they make me cry so bad.

[erikamichelle614]

I think in order of sadness, its Jonathan Kent, Whitney's dad, Jimmy, Lionel

[wafflles87]

Jonathan;s was.

Question though... Ollie and Jimmy's FIRST scene together was in Beast...

Now, Ollie's shedding a tear for Jimmy, like they were best buds? Offscreensville seems to be getting more interesting than the show itself.

[ginnyfan]

Jonathan;s was.

Question though... Ollie and Jimmy's FIRST scene together was in Beast...

Now, Ollie's shedding a tear for Jimmy, like they were best buds? Offscreensville seems to be getting more interesting than the show itself.

LOL! Yeah. Maybe Henry James bonded with Clark and Oliver at his bachelor party.

[costas22]

Jonathan's was the saddest.What i liked about this one though, was Oliver shedding a tear.A very powerful scene.

[Canary]

Mr.Kent's. But Jimmy's Made Me have tears in the corner of my eyes. Not gonna lie.

But i cry at everything sad xP

[Iluvgreen]

I cried so hard!

[6-Super-Man -5]

It was sad, but not the saddest.
I'll miss you Jimmy!

[Jephael]

I can't help but find it sort of ironic how Jimmy made his debut the season following Jonathan's death. I too felt saddened by both their funerals.

[Canary]

i was like getting tears in my eye when Jimmy figured out his secret, but i also realized he would probly be the one to die now ;/

[Jaderoyale]

Jonathons is by far the saddest.
HOWEVER. Having that shot of Oliver got me.

[costas22]

Jonathons is by far the saddest.
HOWEVER. Having that shot of Oliver got me.

You are 100% right on this. It was a very powerful moment. Justin really sold it well.

[rajman]

It was the saddest funeral, abit like a Romeo and Juliet, with Jimmy and Chloe.

[ColdPlay3r]

it was sad, but .........a lil confusing was mixed in it

[mizchloe]

Ollie as crying at how bad the episode was.
:rotfl: nice.

[dru-zod2501]

Nothing was harder than Jonathan's funeral

[aceofclubs]

Johnathons funeral made me cry legitimately. Jimmy's was sad but I didnt shed a tear till I saw a tear coming down Ollies face... That made me well up a little, such a hunk should never be made to cry lol

[ManOfSteel87]

I still cry when I watch Reckoning and see JK's funeral. I've seen it several times, and it gets me everytime. Jimmy's funeral, I was still in disbelief that he was dead and then scratching my head thinking WTF when they brought in the brother. So no, it wasn't that sad for me.

----- Added 1 Minutes later -----


Ollie as crying at how bad the episode was.

:rotfl:
Awesome!

[lm1212]

Yeah, I was more like WHAT THE HECK? rather than sad. I'm sad now though, realizing that Ashton won't pop up telling me I was punk'd.

[CloisFan17]

no def not the saddest I think for me the saddest one in SV was maybe Jonathens :( I cried on that one it was too sad for me

[devilneedsaride]

I didn't think it was very sad, actually. Not speaking to Jimmy's death, but the funeral scene itself just wasn't very moving.

My favorite funeral was actually Whitney's father's funeral in season one. Now that is a well-put together scene.

[CloisFan17]

I have seen other shows with sadder funerals then this one example Prison Break :(

[Queenrocks77]

Jimmys was sad but I actually shed a few at Jonathans funeral.

[CloisFan17]

^^Me too Joe :)

[Imzadia]

I thought that Jonathan Kent's funeral was the saddest.

I Loved Jimmy especially because he loved Chloe so much. I thought that she was really 'seeing' Jimmy when she once told him that 'he was the best boyfriend any girl could ever hope for'. He had so much patience and tolerated so much where Chloe was concerned. His recent 'addiction' was his misguided attempt to 'cope' with all he'd endured being with Chloe over this past year. Not many would've survived those kinds of trials. Yet, he stuck by her until he couldn't take it anymore. His funeral really was Sad. At least, he died a 'hero' and Knowing the Truth. I'm going to miss him.

And Yes, so was Lionel's, as someone chose. Lex didn't even allow anyone to attend. Clark was the only person who attended Lionel's funeral in defiance of Lex and he mourned him. Now, that truly was sad.

[Formo]

Jimmy's was sad. Ryan's was the most heart-wrenching. And Johnathan Kent's was the saddest.

But I didn't tear up at any of them.. just got the frog in my throat.

What got me tearing up was the episode after Jon Kent's funeral, at the end, when Martha and Clark were watching the home video of young Clark riding with Jon on the tractor, and Jon says 'goodbye' to the camera and smiles. OMG. That was a tough one not to cry at.

[Lilah]

I didn't think it was very sad, actually. Not speaking to Jimmy's death, but the funeral scene itself just wasn't very moving.

My favorite funeral was actually Whitney's father's funeral in season one. Now that is a well-put together scene.

Agreed. But I have to admit I cried a lot in this one. Jimmy's death was just.... ugh. I can't even talk about it anymore...:(

[Melekith]

I have to agree with the consensus and say that JK's funeral was the saddest that this show has seen. I honestly didn't know what to feel for Jimmy's funeral. I was more in shock of the "twist" that was put on it. I guess what makes it sad to me...is that Jimmy was always the "people's voice" of the show. The writers actually gave him some very realistic and genuine things to act/say...and most of the time it represented PERFECTLY what the fans wanted to view/hear.

[kal-el_Girl]

it was random, by the end I was so pissed off that I honestly I couldn't care less. The saddest funeral still is pa' kent's =(

[RedKRules]

Pa Kent was the saddest for me ..... but Jimmy ....*sigh* :(:(

[jpfort1957]

Jimmy was a happy little guy that didn't deserve the cards he had been dealt from Bride till the end.

[Liquid-Prince]

Johnathan's was way more saddening.

[haydenclaireheroes]

jimmy had a big impacy to the story so yes this was a very sad funeral but for me it is tied with jonathans.

[justme_007]

I think that TPTB stole the scene of the death of jimmy from BuFFY ( Angel´s death)... anyone with me?

----- Added 34 Seconds later -----

and to be on topic, saddest funeral was jonathan´s.

[Sweetie]

It was sad but,not the saddest.Jonathan Kent's funerals was :(

[Lavenderlily12]

I believe that Jonathan Kent's funeral was the saddest, but Jimmy's funeral was still extremely sad, for me anyway.

[xanthai]

Not the saddest... not at all!
The saddest was definetly Jonathan's!

[disciples of zod]

It was sad but,not the saddest.Jonathan Kent's funerals was :(

yeah. :(

Jimmy's was a close second though

~K

[SGuthrie27]

I thought it was very sad, but I still feel that Jonathan Kent's was the saddest funeral the show has had to date. Still, I will greatly miss this incarnation of Jimmy Olsen -- the real one, in my opinion (and obviously for so many others).

--SGuthrie ><>' :)--

[The_Promise]

Jonathan's funeral broke my heart.

The one for Whiteny's dad was also very sad.

Jimmy's I didn't think was too shattering, sad but nothing like Jonathan's.

Honourable mention goes to Ryan, whose last scene with Clark in the air balloon and the end with Clark looking at the empty hospital bed made me cry for like two weeks.

Another honourable mention goes to Requiem. Okay so it wasn't a "funeral" but it WAS a death of a 8+ year relationship/love story.

[Clark/Lois-fan]

I thought the funeral for Henry aka Jimmy was sad, but Jonathan's funeral broke my heart, so if anyone is still guessing, that one was sadder :(

[Tatiana]

I thought it was definitely sad, I was teary eyed but I cried like a baby when Jonathan died, that was the saddest to me, it was sad when Lionel died too not only cuz he was dead but because nobody but Lex and Clark were there

[DGirlLois4Clark]

Two words..Jonathan Kent

[haydenclaireheroes]

Two words..Jonathan Kent

ya that was the saddest and the snow had great affect to me.

[EarlTheEradicator]

Two words..Jonathan Kent


ITA to me that was the saddest funeral of the show. JK death seem to have a bigger impact on the characters than any other death.

[Kneel before Zod]

Jonathon Kent's was the saddest. Lionel's funeral was sad because only two people showed up. I was in too much shock over Jimmy's death to feel sad.

[Supermania]

In my opinion, I feel that Jimmy should never have appeared on Smallville. his contributions to the show's plot have hardly been mind-blowing; he's just been on the sidelines, getting involved in that dingy romance with Chloe and getting involved in minor plots or making small appearances in the main ones. Season Eight killing off our Henry James Olsen has only made this more apparent; clearly, he was included to fool viewers into thinking he was the real Olsen and to have more characters of legendary comic book status in the show. In short? It wasn't the saddest funeral. Jonathan Kent's was.

[donnarose]

His funeral was sad, but curious.:\

[x20ArchAngel09x]

It was sad to see Oliver crying, but overall, Jimmy's funeral was not the saddest. I think Jonathan's was sadder than his. But for the saddest, it would have to be the boy named Ryan and Clark just looking at his empty hospital bed.

[amalie]

It was sad to see Oliver crying, but overall, Jimmy's funeral was not the saddest. I think Jonathan's was sadder than his. But for the saddest, it would have to be the boy named Ryan and Clark just looking at his empty hospital bed.


I was too angry during Jimmy's funeral to feel any sadness. Jonathan's was definitely to most heart wrenching for me.

[x20ArchAngel09x]

I was too angry during Jimmy's funeral to feel any sadness. Jonathan's was definitely to most heart wrenching for me.
I was conflicted as to what to think during then too. It was a pretty scene none-the-less. The saddest for me was Jonathan's, but the saddest I thought in context for Clark was Ryan's. :)