Open Note to Bryan Q. Miller

[eas]

Dear Mr. Miller,

I have no idea if you ever check K-Site or not, but I figured it was worth a shot. I've watched three episodes written by you and I just had to let my thoughts on your writing come out.

YOU ROCK.

"Committed" was excellent. "Bulletproof" was fantastic. And "Hex" is - imo - one of the best Smallville episodes I've ever seen. (And I've seen every episode since the Pilot.)

I know you're new this season, but can you just write every single episode from now on?

You have this amazing ability to write Clark Kent in a manner that makes me want to leap into the screen and hug him. It makes me grin ear to ear, because I feel like I've just watched the man who would be Superman come to life. Welling always has the potentional to be the best incarnation of Superman EVER, and in your episodes I feel like you really make the best of that potentional. You write a strong Clark Kent who also has this sly sense of humor. You write him as a man who accepts his responsibilities without being overburdened by them. You also write him as a man who has friends who care about him and he considers that one of his strengths.

And Lois? You get Lois Lane like no other... you give Durance such awesome material to work with that she must laughing in happiness everytime she gets a script written by you. Both "Committed" and "Hex" feature a Lois Lane that is sweet and fierce at the same time. We get a glimpse into Lois's psyche and her life in a way that very few writers have touched in the series up to this point. And you do it with just the inclusion of a few lines here and there -- in a completely natural way. Who knew that Lois had weekly poker nights with cops? And, yet, it makes so much sense. And it didn't take much for you to get that point across, either. Just a quick scene - a shot here and there - and we suddenly have this whole door to Lois's opened for us. THANK YOU.

I'd go on and on... about how you also write a great Ollie. How my favorite Chloe moments this season were written by you. I'd also mention how you are great at making a story go from humorous to tense in two seconds flat. Or how you play to every character's strengths... but, I think you get the gist.

Keep doing what you're doing... can't wait to see more from you in S9!!

Sincerely, Sana

[Supsfan]

I have to agree, B.Q. Miller is 3 for 3 in my books(I even forgive him for the crappy ending in Bulletproof because I thought the rest of the episode was a very strong Clark episode).

Here is hoping he gets to write more episodes next year, I am guessing unlike most the people on the writing staff he's actually picked up a comic book. Hell with S&S gone promote him to Executive Producer.

['Tonio09]

You rock bqm!!!

[Dresden]

I would really like to echo this sentiment. Committed is my favorite episode not just out of the entire season but possibly out of the entire series. It was so well written and it portrayed Lois and Clark flawlessly, the way that I always envision them when reading Superman comics. I was a bit apprehensive about the concept of "Hex" but after watching it I realize that I had no reason to worry. The episode was handled wonderfully. You remained respectful and yet did not hesitate to lay down the truth of the series. You clarified who each character is and defined them in a positive light. You even made me like Chloe Sullivan again and I haven't liked her in nearly two seasons! Thank you so much for sharing your talent with the Smallville fandom. I hope to watch more of your episodes.

[SuperheroFan87]

I echo these sentiments B.Q.! Any chance you could write ALL 22 EPISODES in Season 9? Could you also get PS3 to stop being morons?

[-Nora-]

I second all that. Seriously, I'm floored by how amazing this episode was.

['Tonio09]

^ITA!!

[redkryptoniteisthebest]

I agree 100%. Bryan, you did an amazing job! Keep up the phenomenal work!

[cloisthelegendbegins]

Could NOT AGREE MORE. Seriously BQM - let us know what it takes to get you hired to write MORE for SMALLVILLE!!! Where have you been all this time?

THE WORLD NEEDS YOU!!!

[davidbrenton]

Oh, he did write this. I wish he was writing Stilleto. The funny was up to Committed level right off the bat. I love the funny that he brings.

[AgentChaos]

No, Brian Miller didn't write Hex. He's writing stilletto. Which makes his 3 episodes Committed, bulletProof, and Stilletto.

I am going to check now to see if I'm wrong.

Unfortunately, he did write Hex. Which explains a lot.

[latingirl]

i am 100% agree with Sana.... This episode was the most enjoyably, funny in smallville serie... In this Tom could show us a very amazing actoral -comedian work... great job

[Supsfan]

No, Brian Miller didn't write Hex. He's writing stilletto. Which makes his 3 episodes Committed, bulletProof, and Stilletto.

I am going to check now to see if I'm wrong.

Caroline Dries wrote Stiletto

[kelly1142]

This episode might be my favorite of the season.

A fabulous job, chock full of continuity, little glimpses / mentions that progressed characters and relationships so far without needing to dwell on them, and terrific dialogue.

Excellent!

[thehenry89]

You rock dude, keep doing what you doing.

[WickedJenn]

Dear Mr. Miller,

I have no idea if you ever check K-Site or not, but I figured it was worth a shot. I've watched three episodes written by you and I just had to let my thoughts on your writing come out.

YOU ROCK.

"Committed" was excellent. "Bulletproof" was fantastic. And "Hex" is - imo - one of the best Smallville episodes I've ever seen. (And I've seen every episode since the Pilot.)

I know you're new this season, but can you just write every single episode from now on?

You have this amazing ability to write Clark Kent in a manner that makes me want to leap into the screen and hug him. It makes me grin ear to ear, because I feel like I've just watched the man who would be Superman come to life. Welling always has the potentional to be the best incarnation of Superman EVER, and in your episodes I feel like you really make the best of that potentional. You write a strong Clark Kent who also has this sly sense of humor. You write him as a man who accepts his responsibilities without being overburdened by them. You also write him as a man who has friends who care about him and he considers that one of his strengths.

And Lois? You get Lois Lane like no other... you give Durance such awesome material to work with that she must laughing in happiness everytime she gets a script written by you. Both "Committed" and "Hex" feature a Lois Lane that is sweet and fierce at the same time. We get a glimpse into Lois's psyche and her life in a way that very few writers have touched in the series up to this point. And you do it with just the inclusion of a few lines here and there -- in a completely natural way. Who knew that Lois had weekly poker nights with cops? And, yet, it makes so much sense. And it didn't take much for you to get that point across, either. Just a quick scene - a shot here and there - and we suddenly have this whole door to Lois's opened for us. THANK YOU.

I'd go on and on... about how you also write a great Ollie. How my favorite Chloe moments this season were written by you. I'd also mention how you are great at making a story go from humorous to tense in two seconds flat. Or how you play to every character's strengths... but, I think you get the gist.

Keep doing what you're doing... can't wait to see more from you in S9!!

Sincerely, Sana

So much word to that Sana.

BQM, you rock my socks.

[hanemg]

BQM, I'll add my kudos to the ones above. Great work!!!!!

[davidbrenton]

Unfortunately, he did write Hex. Which explains a lot.

Yup. I just checked. I was hoping he'd write Stilleto (And I read it somewhere!!). This episode was funny, but limited what he could do in that Stilleto is going to be the powerhouse Clois episode. I don't really enjoy Caroline Dries stuff, and I wish he wrote this one.

----- Added 1 Minutes later -----


Caroline Dries wrote Stiletto

Thanks. I saw that afterward (And edited my message--sorry, I should have left it).

[AmazSpiderman1]

This episode was a highpoint for this season, and it was a call back to the episodes of past which were often great every single week. They've been hit or miss for awhile, but "Hex" nailed it with the mixing of great comedy with heartwarming moments. That's what should be the main objective week after week and not the drama we're getting used to. Give Lois more scenes, bring Zatanna back, and keep the fun and excitement this episode presented for the next season. That's all I ask for, and I can guarentee you'll get a boost in ratings, good stories, and the SV fans will love you for it.

[ClarkyBoy14]

I agree. I'm glad TPTB added him to their staff this season.

[eas]

i am 100% agree with Sana.... This episode was the most enjoyably, funny in smallville serie... In this Tom could show us a very amazing actoral -comedian work... great job

Yes, the scene on the DP roof with EDChloe and Clark was the highlight of the episode. I could not stop laughing.

I loved how Welling played Clark -- he was adorable and dorky at the same time. You really understood how his future Clark Kent persona will work & I could just see how Lois would handle him in the future. She won't know whether to roll her eyes or give him a hug.

Seeing Welling play that scene made me sad that we don't get more moments like this on the show -- where he gets to play around with his comic chops & we get to see the lighter side of Clark's life. That's what I love about Miller's episodes -- Clark is always a happier person, even with dark stuff going on around him. I see in SVClark what I've loved about so many other Supermans before him.

[celita]

This guy really should write the whole season, he makes everyone likeable and as Tom said, every line has a purpose. I love this writer!

[DigitalKing]

I kind of wish Bryan Miller watched some Smallville episodes at some point so he would know what the storyline is. Chloe and Oliver were pals? Lois is an awesome reporter that everyone loves and cheerily serves? Clark is a douche-nozzle that frames Lois' rules?

Way to ruin every character while showcasing ED's lack of talent. I've never seen Chloe chew her lip like that a billion times. It was like they decided that the "Chloe thing" would be the lip chew, because AM does it sometimes (which she does) so ED decided she'd act like a less strident, (more) clueless LOIS and chew her lip a bunch.

[Amelie]

Yes, the scene on the DP roof with EDChloe and Clark was the highlight of the episode. I could not stop laughing.

I loved how Welling played Clark -- he was adorable and dorky at the same time. You really understood how his future Clark Kent persona will work & I could just see how Lois would handle him in the future. She won't know whether to roll her eyes or give him a hug.

Seeing Welling play that scene made me sad that we don't get more moments like this on the show -- where he gets to play around with his comic chops & we get to see the lighter side of Clark's life. That's what I love about Miller's episodes -- Clark is always a happier person, even with dark stuff going on around him. I see in SVClark what I've loved about so many other Supermans before him.

The Daily Planet scene was my favorite, too. Tom Welling was such a riot!

[theotherJane]

I don't really know much about SV writers, but if this is the same guy that wrote Committed, then I tip my hat to him.

He can write comedic Clois like no other. The script was terrific and the line delivery coupled with comedic timing was greater.

[origin]

BQM's episodes are made of win, Nuff said.

[Night_Hawk90]

no offense but what was the point of this episode so late in the story arc? honestly how many times do i have to bear witness to clark wanting to live a normal life? it is just becoming to repetitive.

[Kschreck]

I agree, tonight's episode was one of the best so far this season.

[Lilah]

He's GENIOUS. He must have sarcasm down to a T in real life lol.

[redeem147]

Yep. Awesome episode, with sparkly writing.

[wingster55]

I find him to be a rather mediocre writer. Such contrived setups and moments in his eps.

[AgentChaos]

I find him to be a rather mediocre writer. Such contrived setups and moments in his eps.

Mediocre is being generous.

[gilliang]

He's anything but mediocre. He's the best writer they have on the show, hands down.

[Night_Hawk90]

He's anything but mediocre. He's the best writer they have on the show, hands down.

That's pretty sad if thats the case

[wingster55]

I find Soulders and Peterson to be better. Also Geoff Johns.

[gilliang]

That's pretty sad if thats the case

In your opinion, not mine.

[singingdove]

I already loved Brian Miller after Committed, and really enjoyed Bulletproof in spite of the Clana rehash at the end. Hex was beyond brilliant - if BQM wrote every episode next season I'd be a very happy girl!

[eas]

I find Soulders and Peterson to be better. Also Geoff Johns.

To each their own, I guess. I didn't really enjoy a lot of the episodes that they've penned. And I thought that "Legion" had a lot of holes and too much focus on Lana.

[cksidekick]

I'm happy to jump on this wagon and ride it through season 9!

3 for 3. Let's do it again!

[AgentChaos]

Committed sucked, Bulletproof was 50/50, and Hex had way too much nauseating Lois worship.

[BriannaWithridge]

Dear Mr. Miller,

I have no idea if you ever check K-Site or not, but I figured it was worth a shot. I've watched three episodes written by you and I just had to let my thoughts on your writing come out.

YOU ROCK.

"Committed" was excellent. "Bulletproof" was fantastic. And "Hex" is - imo - one of the best Smallville episodes I've ever seen. (And I've seen every episode since the Pilot.)

I know you're new this season, but can you just write every single episode from now on?

You have this amazing ability to write Clark Kent in a manner that makes me want to leap into the screen and hug him. It makes me grin ear to ear, because I feel like I've just watched the man who would be Superman come to life. Welling always has the potentional to be the best incarnation of Superman EVER, and in your episodes I feel like you really make the best of that potentional. You write a strong Clark Kent who also has this sly sense of humor. You write him as a man who accepts his responsibilities without being overburdened by them. You also write him as a man who has friends who care about him and he considers that one of his strengths.

And Lois? You get Lois Lane like no other... you give Durance such awesome material to work with that she must laughing in happiness everytime she gets a script written by you. Both "Committed" and "Hex" feature a Lois Lane that is sweet and fierce at the same time. We get a glimpse into Lois's psyche and her life in a way that very few writers have touched in the series up to this point. And you do it with just the inclusion of a few lines here and there -- in a completely natural way. Who knew that Lois had weekly poker nights with cops? And, yet, it makes so much sense. And it didn't take much for you to get that point across, either. Just a quick scene - a shot here and there - and we suddenly have this whole door to Lois's opened for us. THANK YOU.

I'd go on and on... about how you also write a great Ollie. How my favorite Chloe moments this season were written by you. I'd also mention how you are great at making a story go from humorous to tense in two seconds flat. Or how you play to every character's strengths... but, I think you get the gist.

Keep doing what you're doing... can't wait to see more from you in S9!!

Sincerely, Sana

ITA!

You rocked in Committed and was fabulous in Hex.

Keep up the good work!;)

[minerva73]

I completely agree with everything eas said.

His writing style is so unique and all of the characters grow in one way or another by the end of the episode.

[SnowBird]

Great Job! Three very well written episodes and I'm looking forward to seeing more. I love the way you write Clark and Lois. Keep up the good work:)

[superspider02]

Yea i agree his episodes so far this yr have been very good episodes. He does seem to write the characters well. I hope they keep him on board the writing staff for season 9.

[TayLaneBloom]

Hex was my own personal paradise. :P
just like Committed! Lois and Clark together it's just perfection.

keep up the good work!.

[SolaceDream]

Jumping on the bandwagon to say fantastic job. Hex was a fun episode and I had love for everyone! (I also loved "Committed" and "Bulletproof".) Definitely one of the better episodes of the season.

[widgetgirl]

I totally agree. Mr. Miller is a breath of fresh air... All of his episodes are written beautifully. Fans should appreciate how well Mr. Miller uses actual past events are references and throws in a few cute parts.

I hope Mr. Miller gets the appreciation he deserves and more writing time... Perhaps even a nice new golden pen to write us more beautifully written Smallville episodes in Season 9.

The framed, "Lois Lane Rules to being a Reporter" is priceless! It shows great character depth and even shows us insight on the Lois and Clark Relationship... Not Many things can be said from a framed peice of paper, but Mr. Miller pulled it off just right.

I could go on and on with little things and moments, but I'll let others get a chance to share in his greatness. :-)

[kal-el_Girl]

thank you for giving us a great episode, we're going to treasure for a long long time!

[baudyhallee]

Move over Eric Clapton and Lemmy -- B Q MILLER IS GOD!

Bryan, thank you for your knowledge of these characters and displaying it so wonderfully. It is pure pleasure to watch your episodes. They all have given us hope for this incarnation of Clark Kent.

You give Welling and Durance especially the palette to display their incredible talents as actors -- whether it be drama or comedy or the transition between the two -- you and the actors bring such an vibrant life to these characters.

I thank whomever had the wisdom to hire you.

Brilliant work. :)

[akaLane]

I agree, gilliang. I think he's the most on-point writer on the staff. He respects the characters, their histories and their relationships on the show, and actually understands the underlying Superman/DC mythology as well. He makes the characters shine. He writes dialogue so well, makes the show fresh with humor that it often sorely and glaringly lacks, and knows how to pace an episode tightly.

Mr. Miller, if you ever read this, thank you very much for Hex, Committed, and Bulletproof. Even when characters do some things I might disagree with (see: the ending of Bulletproof), you somehow manage to show me why they might actually react that way. These characters make sense and thrive under your pen. I really hope you're more involved with crafting Season Nine and that you write more episodes next year. My hat is off to you, sir.

[abbimorgan]

Thank you! Tonight was Smallville at its best. So many great one liners. You also made Lois and Clark fans very happy and give us hope for season 9. Very much looking forward to what you will write for the show in the future.

[wingster55]

I just prefer the action based episodes with Clark acting like Supes over the shippy ones.

[davidbrenton]

Okay. I get it, it's an Open letter to Brian Miller. In that case, here's my message:

Brian,

I have LOVED your work. I never even was apart of this forum until Committed aired. That episode made me love Lois & Clark, and literally made me laugh out loud with all the (genuinely good) humor. BulletProof was engrosing, and embraced a Superman-type story in a very different, but enjoyable, way. Hex (Was it Lois that gives you the comedic juice....Cuz Oliver & Clark had hysterical lines in this as well) was great. I WISH they gave you a more critical/climactic episode because your talents run so deep you made the absolute most of a decent....address but stall type episode. I greatly look forward to your contributions in Climactic type episodes in the future because your inherent knowledge and articulate depiction of the characters shines through in every line.

Thank you!! Stick with us next year, PLEASE!!!

[tbird4u]

Unfortunately, he did write Hex. Which explains a lot.

Exactly, BM is one of the best writers in smallville history!!!;)

[antx]

Bryan Q Miller is a fantastic writer,this episode was so much fun to watch.It was very well written like committed was.Hopefully he will write more episodes for season 9.

[Jade4813]

Brian,

I just want to say THANK YOU for recognizing that the Arc of Suck had a bad impact on Clark's character and not deciding just to pretend it didn't happen just because it would be easier to write a story that way.

If you keep writing Smallville episodes, I may find myself watching the show again on a regular basis! I've heard very good things about this episode, so Hex is the first episode I'm watching since Clark's character was killed during Power/Requiem!

[Seeya'round Smallville]

Dear Bryan,

You are tremendous. You get all of the characters, you treat them with respect and you treat your audience with respect. You pay attention to the details and continuity, everything is there for a reason and has a purpose. Smallville needs to keep you, promote you and run any and all scripts by you. Hopefully you get that raise soon but right now, the clock says you deserve me.

Sincerely,
Miller Time. :D

In non-clone (Jim Rome) speak, keep up the good work!! ;)

[JennyMoon]

Thank you, Brian!

[clois-destiny-forever]

Thank you for the awesome job you did with Committed, Bulletproof, and Hex! You show a real flair for the characters and a keen insight into the comedy that helps lift this show!

[Lis]

Thanks for opening the thread eas.

And thank you very much for writing such amazing episodes as Committed, Bulletproof and Hex, Mr. Miller.
Great job!

[AgentChaos]

Exactly, BM is one of the best writers in smallville history!!!;)

That wasn't what I meant. I'm sure he would be a fine writer..... on another show. His 3 outings for SV, however, are not inspiring much confidence in his writing skills. Committed was the worst episode of SV since Promise, Bulletproof was uneven, and Hex was 90% unwelcome Lois worship.

[Kal-ed]

Committed sucked, Bulletproof was 50/50, and Hex had way too much nauseating Lois worship.

I think the writing and what the story is about are two diferent things. If you dont like a story that puts Lois as a relevant agent in Clark´s life, its fine but a completely separate issue from BQM´s ability to write.

I think the hero of this episode was Chloe, she figured a lot of the things going on, without it being excessive as it used to be in previous seasons and she was the one that moved Clark into remembering who he was, if anyone was worshiped in this episode, it was Chloe IMO. They even gave her Superman´s most iconic quote, basically in SV mythology its not Superman´s quote anymore, or at least not original, its Chloe´s, if that´s not proping Chloe then I dont know what is... I guess he needs to write romantic Chlark so he can be a good writer :rolleyes:

Back on topic, he got me at Commited, Clark getting himself and Lois out of trouble without the need of his powers or help was awsome, I mean he did use his powers but while he was weakened by GreenK he cooked up a good plan to get the guy close enough to give him a nice headbang, I was so afraid it would be Chloe or GA coming to the rescue I was twice as excited when I saw Clark gettin himself out of trouble.

[davidbrenton]

That wasn't what I meant. I'm sure he would be a fine writer..... on another show. His 3 outings for SV, however, are not inspiring much confidence in his writing skills. Committed was the worst episode of SV since Promise, Bulletproof was uneven, and Hex was 90% unwelcome Lois worship.

What's this? Ahhhh, I see. Agent Chaos has become my mortal enemy....since I'm such a whimp, this does not boad well for other fans who share my passion, and (unfortunately) my gusto.

[damara531]

Dear Mr. Miller,

I have no idea if you ever check K-Site or not, but I figured it was worth a shot. I've watched three episodes written by you and I just had to let my thoughts on your writing come out.

YOU ROCK.

"Committed" was excellent. "Bulletproof" was fantastic. And "Hex" is - imo - one of the best Smallville episodes I've ever seen. (And I've seen every episode since the Pilot.)

I know you're new this season, but can you just write every single episode from now on?

You have this amazing ability to write Clark Kent in a manner that makes me want to leap into the screen and hug him. It makes me grin ear to ear, because I feel like I've just watched the man who would be Superman come to life. Welling always has the potentional to be the best incarnation of Superman EVER, and in your episodes I feel like you really make the best of that potentional. You write a strong Clark Kent who also has this sly sense of humor. You write him as a man who accepts his responsibilities without being overburdened by them. You also write him as a man who has friends who care about him and he considers that one of his strengths.

And Lois? You get Lois Lane like no other... you give Durance such awesome material to work with that she must laughing in happiness everytime she gets a script written by you. Both "Committed" and "Hex" feature a Lois Lane that is sweet and fierce at the same time. We get a glimpse into Lois's psyche and her life in a way that very few writers have touched in the series up to this point. And you do it with just the inclusion of a few lines here and there -- in a completely natural way. Who knew that Lois had weekly poker nights with cops? And, yet, it makes so much sense. And it didn't take much for you to get that point across, either. Just a quick scene - a shot here and there - and we suddenly have this whole door to Lois's opened for us. THANK YOU.

I'd go on and on... about how you also write a great Ollie. How my favorite Chloe moments this season were written by you. I'd also mention how you are great at making a story go from humorous to tense in two seconds flat. Or how you play to every character's strengths... but, I think you get the gist.

Keep doing what you're doing... can't wait to see more from you in S9!!

Sincerely, Sana


Simply brilliant! I couldn't have worded it better myself!

[Sports72Xtrm]

B.Miller, I wish CW can clone you so you can write every episode of Smallville. Your writing is really on par with Comic stuff. You definitely know Superman. Keep up the good work.

[ChlarkerFan]

That wasn't what I meant. I'm sure he would be a fine writer..... on another show. His 3 outings for SV, however, are not inspiring much confidence in his writing skills. Committed was the worst episode of SV since Promise, Bulletproof was uneven, and Hex was 90% unwelcome Lois worship.

I disagree with this. Hex was a great episode for Chloe Sullivan because it established a clear and defined role for her. Chloe is the Watchtower and that is friggin' awesome! That last scene with Chloe rocked so much and I got to see my girl shining and being so confident. I hated seeing her at the beginning all depressed and wishing the life of another. By the end of the episode she was brilliant, wanting her life once again and being quite brilliant. From this Chloe fan, Brian, I say thank you! Oh, and Bulletproof is perhaps my favorite episode of the season just based on the storyline, not related to ships or character. It was just written so well and it was one of those episodes that you didn't want to be over. I also fell in love with the new characters so easily and that's a great thing! Plus, TW in a cop suit? Forget about it! BMQ you are awesome!!!

[Supsfan]

I think the writing and what the story is about are two diferent things. If you dont like a story that puts Lois as a relevant agent in Clark´s life, its fine but a completely separate issue from BQM´s ability to write.

Yeah I agree, that's why I can look past the last 3 minutes of Bulletproof and not blame BQM for it. I am pretty sure he didn't come up with that scene on his own, he was probably given a rough outline that needed that scene there.

[kiariclois]

Mr. Bryan Q. Millar,

You're an awesome writer. It's so rare that the script got the attention more that the other aspect of the show, seriously. I've been in so many board, and the praise for those episodes you wrote mainly goes to the writer. lol. You obviously know each character too well and you made each of them at their best. Heck, even Chloe got what the fans have been yearning for (I'm not really a fan of her being watchtower, but it's really suited her). I hope you'll write more. :D Keep up the great work!

Kiki

[rajman]

Keep it up mr Bryan Q Millar, you do a fantastic job

[Cloisfantastic]

Thank you for writing another incredible episode, Bryan Q. Miller! The characters were all spot on, there is once again
continuity and another huge thank you for making me like Clark Kent again and showing appreciation for Lois Lane,the way she deserves.
I hope you write many more Smallville episodes in the future!

[Darkcook]

Thanks for WatchTower and all the awesome Clois. You're definitely part of the Smallville writers family. I'm always a bit dubious when a new head shows up: how can he/she handle Superman stories and embrace all this universe? You did it. Last year: Don Whitehead and Holly Henderson made a storm in the room, killing Lionel, uniting Bizarro and Brainiac... This year, you flew there, with Lois Lane. :)

[jobookjunkie]

Dear Bryan

Thank you so much for making me laugh like an idiot during Hex. I mean, has there been a funnier episode of Smallville? The episode was excellent and the characters reminded me why I love this show so much. Thank you especially for redeeming Clark from the Arc of Hell. Committed and Bulletproof are two of my favourite episodes in this season - Committed for that admission from Lois, and Bulletproof for the sight of Clark in a police uniform.

You're 3 for 3, Bryan! Hope you get to write loads for season 9, I look forward to watching more episodes that you have written.

[Hakoon]

That wasn't what I meant. I'm sure he would be a fine writer..... on another show. His 3 outings for SV, however, are not inspiring much confidence in his writing skills. Committed was the worst episode of SV since Promise, Bulletproof was uneven, and Hex was 90% unwelcome Lois worship.

To say that BQM's writing skills are poor based on not liking Lois (if thats the case here) isn't a good assessment IMO. I thought he did wonders for Chloe as she was the main focus of this show. Hex to me was an episode devoted to giving Chloe some direction in her life and to helping her move on from the past. I thought he handled that extremely well.

I was thrilled to see an episode that was a throwback to the days whn lighthearted episodes happened a lot more often. We've really only had 2 of those this season with committed being the other. Thank you for a job well done BQM.

[Night_Hawk90]

That wasn't what I meant. I'm sure he would be a fine writer..... on another show. His 3 outings for SV, however, are not inspiring much confidence in his writing skills. Committed was the worst episode of SV since Promise, Bulletproof was uneven, and Hex was 90% unwelcome Lois worship.

i agree committed was absolute garbage imo. bulletproof i actually really liked, and hex would have been better if it was wrotten earlier in this season.

[Krypton935]

hecks yes! your rock bqm

[nic25]

^^I agree.This season has been very dark and a little depressing even.The episode was a great change of pace,refreashing and fun to watch.I think he did a great job.And considering we barely see much of Lois it was nice to have alot of her for just ONE episode.

Also committed is one of favorite episodes of the series,i think ive watched abotu 6 times already!

[costas22]

Thanx to Bryan for the eppie.Thankfully,this will drag the other writers down the same path.I hope the Watchtower angle is something they keep.

[Supsfan]

Thanx to Bryan for the eppie.Thankfully,this will drag the other writers down the same path.

Yeah more light hearted fun and less angst with plots better served for Dawson's Creek works for me

[geminis]

Sana, thanks for this thread and I so totally agree with you.

My sister agrees too, and it is very rare when we agree on something. Bryan Q. Miller, you have two fans. Pathos, comedy, drama, character growth for Clark and Chloe, plus the terrific introduction of a new JL character not at anyone's expense, the twist on Odyssey, Clark mentioning his father in a meaningful way, Clark unwittingly and deliberately talking to Chloe about Jimmy, Oliver, the nascent JL, Lois, who was oh so Lois, there was so much to love.

MORE! MORE! ENCORE!!!!

[Hopefulsuicide]

My top three episodes of the season so far have been 1.Hex, 2. Committed, 3. Bulletproof (even with that stupid clana ending)

And I didn't even realize they all had the same writer!

Mr Miller, you are a very talented man. What i find is that the actors seem to enjoy your scripts and that shows through on screen. They come to life when they are reading your words. And you actually seem to get Superman, in a way that none of the other writers capture.

[DGirlLois4Clark]

Thanks alot BQM. Please stick around for next season..smallville fans need you:)

[Isabel14]

I agree with others..Thank you, Brian..And I hope you will be writing more in season 9..

[supes0]

Dear Mr. Miller,

Thank you!! You are the best writer on staff and I hope you write a majority of episodes next season.

[Rift]

I don't know about "best episodes ever", but I did find all three episodes surprisingly enjoyable and I totally agree with the points regarding how he does a great job with the characters while showing a healthy respect for the iconic roles we have seen sometimes absolutely trashed by the other writers.

Now back to the wackness.

[workshyslacker]

Dear BQM,

Lois and Clark should be always written like this; a partnership of equals, excellent dialogue, witty, yet with an undercurrent of mutual attraction. Episodes like these remind me why I liked this couple in the first place. And I'm grateful for the continuity from "Infamous"; Clark standing Lois up needed to be addressed.

Thank you.

P.s. I found it amusing that Lois' no.1 rule was "always know your source". Not everyone does, but I appreciate that you do.

Sincerely,

Charlotte

[Chlarky]

Dear Brian,

<O:pGreat job on writing such a fantastic episode. Last night's Smallville showed me exactly why I watch this show. You've managed to not only turn the show around from the previous arc but breathed life into the characters once more.

<O:p</O:p
Your writing is so clever that you don't even forget the small details that most writers on the staff seem to gloss over. Brilliant prose! I really hope you come back next seaon with more episodes for you to write and manage. I'd also like to see you direct an episode if possibly as you've become easily my favorite writer this year.

Thank you again for restoring my love back into Smallville.

:)

[newbaggy]

Dear Mr Miller,

When I was growing up in Britain in the 1970s, I used to watch the original version of "Doctor Who". After a while, I started to notice that the stories I most liked mostly had the credit "by Robert Holmes" on them, so I started paying attention to who had written particular TV shows that I had liked. I may not have been able to tell you my favourite pop group, but I knew that anything by Alan Plater was worth a look, and a "Rockford Files" episode by David Chase would probably be better than average (this was long before he was feted as the creator of "The Sopranos").

Many names have been added to that personal list over the last thirty years, and now, "Brian Q. Miller" has joined them. I don't wish to be disrespectful to the other members of Smallville's writers' room, but nobody else seems to be achieving the quality of writing that you have shown with "Committed", "Bulletproof" and "Hex". You've written characters that actually sound like real people, not one-dimensional cliches, you've taken unpromising story ideas and made them sparkle, and best of all, you've given a cast that can look pretty mediocre at times a chance to truly shine.

I know that the most we could possibly expect from you would be four or five scripts a year. However, I hope that the showrunners not only take note of your talent, but aim to bring the writing of all scripts up to the standard that you have achieved.

[bigblueplanet]

Can I just say “Thank you” ?

Because I can’t find the words to praise you enough right now.

[MrZeppo]

I must agree with all the praise here Bryan. You've truly captured the essence and spirit of the characters here and do them great justice. I've loved every episode you've penned and hope you continue to write with the characters voices, because you have a great gift with it.

I love the natural comedy & fun that comes out of situations Clark can be faced with. From "being engaged" to Lois in "Committed" to meeting Danny's son in "Bulletproof". "Hex" truly took the cake though. With how serious & drama filled Smallville can be sometimes, the levity can be so wonderful.

Truth be told, one of my favorite aspects of your writing is showing the true tragedy and difficulty of just being human. That saving someone isn't always about using your fists, heatvision, or weapons. "Bulletproof" did something I have wanted to see for years on Smallville, having Clark deal with very human problems (Danny's). And you spoke about what it means to truly save someone. "Hex" brought it to another level because when Clark was speaking to Zatanna on the roof the longtime fans knew Clark would understand her pain.

Thank you very much Bryan Q. Miller. I am a fan. :)

[amberdawn]

Dear Mr. Miller,

Thank you!! You are the best writer on staff and I hope you write a majority of episodes next season.

What supes said.

[AgentChaos]

To say that BQM's writing skills are poor based on not liking Lois (if thats the case here) isn't a good assessment IMO. I thought he did wonders for Chloe as she was the main focus of this show. Hex to me was an episode devoted to giving Chloe some direction in her life and to helping her move on from the past. I thought he handled that extremely well.

No, it's spot on. Most of his plot setups are somewhat contrived, and his episodes are classic cases of telling rather than showing certain things.

[Night_Hawk90]

dear mr. miller

it would be nice if this show would stop recycling old plots as new episodes its getting kind of ridiculous.

[TOMophilus]

Dear Mr. Miller, you do a great job! Forgive the frustrated and the jaundiced as they will be forever unhappy with anything.

I hope you will belong to the writing staff next season! :)

[Night_Hawk90]

Dear Mr. Miller, you do a great job! Forgive the frustrated and the jaundiced as they will be forever unhappy with anything.

I hope you will belong to the writing staff next season! :)

Oh forgive me for not kissing the man's butt. Im entitled to constructive criticism just because i dont find this episode to be the best ever (as some do), doesnt mean i am unhappy with everything

[Tompouce]

Could NOT AGREE MORE. Seriously BQM - let us know what it takes to get you hired to write MORE for SMALLVILLE!!! Where have you been all this time?

THE WORLD NEEDS YOU!!!
ITA:D
Thanks for the good moments and to give opportunities to actors (especially Tom) for comedy. Hex is a delight:)You are definitively the man for Clois;)(Hex and Committed)
And in Bulletproof, to see Clark using his heart to help a man on the road of redemption (and not only with his powers) was so great !
Thanks again . Clark's character deserves more episodes like you do:)

[mrw66855]

Oh forgive me for not kissing the man's butt. Im entitled to constructive criticism just because i dont find this episode to be the best ever (as some do), doesnt mean i am unhappy with everything

You are allowed constructive criticism and I agree with you about using old plot ideas, but at least this season. They are moving the story along, and we get character development in them them compared to the last several years where they would use old plot ideas, and nothing would happen. I do not think this was the best episode in the world, but it had a lot of good things within it that made it very enjoyable to watch. Hey, look at the bright side. At least they did not do a full body swap like in past episodes. That is somewhat of an improvement. Remember. Just my opinions.:eek:

[SuperheroFan87]

Mr. Miller,

Here's a suggestion, talk with the showrunners and see if you can get on board for ALL 22 EPISODES next season.......your work this season has been phenomenal!!!!:D:D:D "Committed" was pure gold, I give "Bulletproof" a solid 9.5 out of 10 (I didn't care for the Clana at the end..........I just can't stand Lana) and "Hex" was INCOMPREHENSIBLY BRILLIANT!!!!!!!!!!:D:D:D So please, please.........get on board for all 22 episodes next season!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[amalie]

Oh, great thread Sana! I have no idea if Bryan Q Miller has ever visited this forum but I sincerely hope the many messages of admiration reach him somehow. The three episodes he's written have been fantastic, in particular Committed and Hex; I rarely rewatch an episode of Smallville but these two were packed with brilliant humour, dialogue, character and relationship development and have thus I've replayed them many times. I look forward to many more episodes written by him and hope TPTB realise the gem of a writer they have on their hands. :D

[MsCali4Eva]

I didn't even know that Bryan Q Miller wrote Committed and Bulletproof prior to entering this thread, however, I did give these episodes (including Hex) some of my highest scores of the entire season. That can't be an coincidence. It means something.

I also wonder if the producers actually read these threads? They certainly would learn alot if they did. I just wanted to stop in, thank Mr. Miller, and let him know that he is doing an excellent job. I really enjoyed Hex!

[amalie]

I didn't even know that Bryan Q Miller wrote Committed and Bulletproof prior to entering this thread, however, I did give these episodes (including Hex) some of my highest scores of the entire season. That can't be an coincidence. It means something.

I also wonder if the producers actually read these threads? They certainly would learn alot if they did. I just wanted to stop in, thank Mr. Miller, and let him know that he is doing an excellent job. I really enjoyed Hex!

There was a post from Committed's director Glen Winter a while back :D

[liana]

Dear Mr. Miller,

I just wanted to tell you how much I appreciate all the episodes you have written so far for this show. I can't say that Hex is my favorite, considering that I loved Bulletproof and Committed. I just love the way you always write Clark as he should be written: heroic, seeing the best in everyone, and lovable. Your Clark is everything that Clark should be about: a decent, honest, honorable guy that happens to be the most powerful man in the world.

Thank you a lot for that.

Liana

[marcella]

Mr. Miller:

You rock!!!

I wish you wrote all episodes of the show

[Farm_Girl]

Dear Brian Miller

I think the only problem I have with your writing is that you have set the standard so high for the rest of the writers that now I won't be able to excuse the mediocre writing that Smallville often suffers from.

Are you a big comic book geek or LnC fan or something? Because I see the enthusiasm for Superman mythology in your writing. I don't think any writer on the staff right now gets the hang of how a Superman story should be written except you. I am so glad that we have got ourselves a writer who knows the core and basics of this story and the relationship between Lois and Clark.

I absolutely love the way you write Clark and Lois both. The end scene in Hex showed what Lois and Clark's relationship is all about and how it should be written. Beautiful!

What makes you even wonderful is that unlike a few other writers whose personal preferences and biases show on the episodes they write, you actually strike a perfect balance. The Lois and Clark moments were beyond perfect in Committed and Hex but Chloe, Oliver and Jimmy were written fantastically as well. The Chloe/Clark scene in Hex was wonderful (although I don't get why Clark didn't confront Chloe about not telling him right away while he was giving those sexy looks to her thinking she's Lois). It showed how great their friendship is. I loved Zatanna too.

A wonderfully well written episode and great performances by Tom and Erica.

PTB, if you are seeing this. You need more writers like BQM on your staff who know what this story and characters are all about.

I think I can rave all day about how much I loved both Committed and Hex and that I am a great fan of your writing but I guess I'll stop here.

Thanks for Committed, Hex and a lot of other wonderful stuff we'll see from you in future.

Farm_Girl

[Jack-El49]

Dear Brian Miller

I think the only problem I have with your writing is that you have set the standard so high for the rest of the writers that now I won't be able to excuse the mediocre writing that Smallville often suffers from.

Are you a big comic book geek or LnC fan or something? Because I see the enthusiasm for Superman mythology in your writing. I don't think any writer on the staff right now gets the hang of how a Superman story should be written except you. I am so glad that we have got ourselves a writer who knows the core and basics of this story and the relationship between Lois and Clark.

I absolutely love the way you write Clark and Lois both. The end scene in Hex showed what Lois and Clark's relationship is all about and how it should be written. Beautiful!

What makes you even wonderful is that unlike a few other writers whose personal preferences and biases show on the episodes they write, you actually strike a perfect balance. The Lois and Clark moments were beyond perfect in Committed and Hex but Chloe, Oliver and Jimmy were written fantastically as well. The Chloe/Clark scene in Hex was wonderful (although I don't get why Clark didn't confront Chloe about not telling him right away while he was giving those sexy looks to her thinking she's Lois). It showed how great their friendship is. I loved Zatanna too.

A wonderfully well written episode and great performances by Tom and Erica.

PTB, if you are seeing this. You need more writers like BQM on your staff who know what this story and characters are all about.

I think I can rave all day about how much I loved both Committed and Hex and that I am a great fan of your writing but I guess I'll stop here.

Thanks for Committed, Hex and a lot of other wonderful stuff we'll see from you in future.

Farm_Girl

Dear Brian,

Ditto. Farm_Girl said it all.

Jack-El49

[LadyLar]

Dear Mister M,

Your kick more @ss than Chuck Norris.

Another greatful Smallville fan,
Corrine

[Meteror Freak]

Miller is awesome for bulletproof and hex!!! What else has he done???

[LadyLar]

The one an only Committed.

[Supsfan]

Your kick more @ss than Chuck Norris.

lol that made me laugh

[ClLaLeChFAN01]

Thank you Mr. Miller!

[sunset]

Totally agree with all the positive posts.

Thank you sir for Committed and Hex. Truly loved and enjoyed the dialogue; specially those of Lois and Clark!! You are so gifted with insight into their character! Again, thank you and looking forward tour episodes in S9. You're the best!!!

[cksidekick]

Mr. Miller,

I'll go out on a limb and say I can't wait to see what you do in season 9!



I find myself having Superman conversations (especialy in regards to this show) and there are certain "particulars" that I just can't get people to see. I can tell people about Superman's personality while watching a cartoon or Smallville. I can explain Clois to people durring the course of an episode, or I can pop in a B.Q. Miller episode and just let them watch! Then all I have to say is THAT is Superman and Clois and on and on. You get it, Sir. And I for one am happy to have you on board.

[baudyhallee]

Bryan,

Don't know if you are aware of it or not but HEX is #1 of most popular episodes on Amazon Unbox. Not only do we praise your writing but we put our money where our mouths are. And in television, cash is king.

Thanks for your awesome episodes -- and keep the bar set--we might be pleasantly surprised that other writers take the challenge.

[hero`s passion]

Amen to that:))))

[Minela]

You are one of my absolute favorite writers on this show. I thought Legion was gonna be good, but boy, each and every one of your episodes toped it. Keep up the good work. I wish you were writing the season finale.

Here is hoping you'll write S9 premiere. :D

[marcella]

Bryan, you rock!!!

[petitemimi]

What is there to say that wasn't already been said? Anyway, congratulations on a job very well done, and I hope to see more of your writings in Smallville!

[Supsfan]

http://dcublog.dccomics.com/2009/05/08/more-on-batgirl-but-not-everything/

interesting tidbit on Batgirl



But, we can give you the lowdown on who the creators on this new ongoing will be. First up, the series will be written by Bryan Q. Miller, who is no stranger to superheroics, having done some writing for a little show called “Smallville.” Miller will also be penning a three-issue arc of TEEN TITANS, starting in July (http://www.dccomics.com/dcu/comics/?cm=12093).


I guess that explains why I love all his episodes so far, he is an actual comic book writer and actually gets how the show should be

[bigblueplanet]

^^Thanks for the info, Supsfan!


LOL! @ "having done some writing for a little show called Smallville.”

But has he got the opportunity to write superhero comics because of his work for SV? Or vice versa?
In either case, I bet he is a real fanboy. :D

Congratulations, Bryan!!! I never picked these two titles before but I might check out your comics. :cool:

[FlashInSV]

Dear Brian Miller

I think the only problem I have with your writing is that you have set the standard so high for the rest of the writers that now I won't be able to excuse the mediocre writing that Smallville often suffers from.

Are you a big comic book geek or LnC fan or something? Because I see the enthusiasm for Superman mythology in your writing. I don't think any writer on the staff right now gets the hang of how a Superman story should be written except you. I am so glad that we have got ourselves a writer who knows the core and basics of this story and the relationship between Lois and Clark.

I absolutely love the way you write Clark and Lois both. The end scene in Hex showed what Lois and Clark's relationship is all about and how it should be written. Beautiful!

What makes you even wonderful is that unlike a few other writers whose personal preferences and biases show on the episodes they write, you actually strike a perfect balance. The Lois and Clark moments were beyond perfect in Committed and Hex but Chloe, Oliver and Jimmy were written fantastically as well. The Chloe/Clark scene in Hex was wonderful (although I don't get why Clark didn't confront Chloe about not telling him right away while he was giving those sexy looks to her thinking she's Lois). It showed how great their friendship is. I loved Zatanna too.

A wonderfully well written episode and great performances by Tom and Erica.

PTB, if you are seeing this. You need more writers like BQM on your staff who know what this story and characters are all about.

I think I can rave all day about how much I loved both Committed and Hex and that I am a great fan of your writing but I guess I'll stop here.

Thanks for Committed, Hex and a lot of other wonderful stuff we'll see from you in future.

Farm_Girl

Dear Mr.Miller,

I totally agree with the above. :rolleyes:

[newbaggy]

Maybe this isn't entirely appropriate for an "Open Letter To..." thread, but the following quotes come from an interview with BQM that Comic Book Resources have just put up - and it is the nearest thing to a reply that we have at the moment.



You were credited as the writer on three episodes of “Smallville”, this past season, including “Hex,” which introduced Zatanna to the show’s mythos. Was that a lot of fun? The episode certainly was a hit with fans.

The fans are there for us through thick and thin, and I really couldn’t be more thrilled and humbled by the response “Hex” has received. Zatanna was really a heap of fun to write. We could have played her huge, but in this case, going for a more modest arrival worked in the show’s favor – it let us play her as being just a smidge shy of the Zatanna we all know and love from the comics.

Are you returning to the show next year, if it’s back?

The show is definitely back, and I’m definitely still along for the ride.

Any other TV or film projects you are working on?

I’m only just starting my career, so there’s more to come.

[amalie]

Maybe this isn't entirely appropriate for an "Open Letter To..." thread, but the following quotes come from an interview with BQM that Comic Book Resources have just put up - and it is the nearest thing to a reply that we have at the moment.


Wow, he's "Just starting my career" and here was us all thinking he had secret experience that wasn't being displayed on imdb. I love this man and I'm so glad he's with us next season :D

[Supermania]

You mean he wrote those episodes? Wow, they were, like, some of Season Eight's high points definitely! He does Lois & Clark like no-one else can. I especially loved Committee, because it forced Lois to reveal her feelings for Clark under pressurizing circumstances and I reaaly liked it when those two are pretending to be engaged in the jewelery shop. Good times! Keep going, Miller. You're doing a fine job!

[mse63]

I just joined these boards officially, and I decided to land my first comment here in this thread. ;D


I think that it's pretty obvious that almost all of the fans are very much contented with Mr Miller's work. I must say, that despite being a starter in Smallville the last season, he definitely was my personal favorite writer this year. I did have my objections at a few parts of those episodes, but believe me when I say, I had much more problems with other episodes and their scripts. Right now, I only can remember 2 things like this in the case of Miller: the Chloe/Jimmy scene at the end of Committed - that was a little but too much for me despite the fact that I actually like these two; and in Hex the picture of Lois with the Dalai Lama(though I'm not sure, if it was actually Miller's writing, or just the director's idea) - again, it was quite an exaggeration for me. I've also read at places, that some people didn't like your episodes because they weren't really part of the main arc - but that's the thing which I don't agree with. Even Hex being there where it was in the season's timeline(between Turbulence and Eternal - 2 quite dramatic episodes connected to the Doomsday storyline), I guess that most of us were relieved to see such a light and humorous episode between some pretty dark and depressed ones. It was a nice change and an excellent entertaining piece! ;D

Being said that, now that I'm finally over with the negativity and all, I'd like to point out Miller's(or, going into the open letter style - "your") greatest achievements:

1.Writing Chloe in the way she should have been in this whole season - supportive, funny and absolutely lovable. I personally didn't have that much problems with her character as others, but still your episodes made even those like again our little blondie!;D She was again Clark Kent's best friend, understanding, sarcastic just in the right measure and always standing out for him. Also she was committed to Jimmy, and supportive to Lois - you actually were one of those few writers this season who gave some respect and fun to these cousins, and you have all of my love for that!;D

2.Getting Clark in the line, portraying him as a hero and - most importantly - giving him some FUN;D Seriously, Bulletproof was an excellent episode for Clark, and probably my absolute favorite of all this whole Lana arc. Excellent ideas, great lines - you gave him what all the fans so desperately wanted!;D

3.Writing the season's most memorable(actually funniest) lines. I guess I'll never forget the Hex "I'm Chloe.......Jor-El, Fortress, Brainiac Chloe!" line ever!;D Just like I still fall off my chair every time I watch that Commited scene in the jeweler's store with Clark, Lois and Oliver. Priceless and full of humour - you absolutely bought me off with those!;D I'm really looking forward to seeing more of those kind of scenes...;D

And there are thousands of other things that I could write here. You handled every character with a certain respect, and depths, and not just Clark and Chloe but Lois(actually especially her ;D), and everyone else. Despite of being a "filler writer" you still managed to write some excellent episodes, and entertained everyone(I'm sure that for moments, even those who were only interested in the main plot could forget about their objections, and really, just enjoy a scene. That's a rare talent to be able to do some quality work like this;D). And despite of being a "starter", you still obviously had the right knowledge of the background of the show, and do justice for not only Smallville, but for the Superman fans. So we can only be grateful for that.;)

I actually believe that you managed to please most of the show's different fan groups. No matter if someone's a shipper or a fan of a certain character, anyone can find something to love in your episodes.

So dear Mr Miller, thank you for being in Smallville, and keep up your good work;D I hope that this season you'll get some actual "main plot" episodes too, for not anything else, then just so you could please another group of fans here.:lol:

[wingster55]

Bryan Q. Miller: Stop destroying all that is CHlark