Who did better Erica or Alison?

[Bre723]

Who made the better performance, Erica Durance as Faora in "Bloodline" or Alison mack in "Legion"?

[Routh]

You're just asking for trouble.

[LastSon1027]

Erica all the way!

[Dustmite]

Maybe this thread should just be closed. We don't need threads to pit the girls against each other when it happens frequently without any prompting.

[blink2matrix]

oh this is hard. they were both evil and fun. i'll side with Erica

[pizzahead2490]

this was really hard. they both did a wonderful job imo. erica did it just a little better. i am not saying it cuz i am a lois fan i am just saying it cuz she did it a little better.

[marcella]

I think ED was better.AM did a great job also

[davidbrenton]

Erica sold me on it more and exhibited more POWER in her performance. AM's performance seemed a little more docile, but it could be contributed to the fact her "muscle" was her brain. But, as a threat, and alien being, Erica won that for me.

[Mickey_Bickey]

I actually voted Alison, because she had a much bigger character to play in Chloiac than Erica had with Faora. I believe both did well, but I was more impressed with Alison's performance as Brainiac. Her eyes, body movement, gestures and voice were so much different than her usual Chloe character.

Good job, Alison!

However, I love both Erica and Alison for the record as well as the characters they play!:)

[loislanefan15]

Erica is the best!

[Alania]

You're just asking for trouble.


http://img89.imageshack.us/img89/5117/hillariousbh8.gif For the first time today, i had a laugh. Thanks, Graham. But, to answer the question, i think both did an amazing job, can't really say which one is better.

[Bre723]

I think they both did really well.
I really liked how chloe spoke just like brianiac.

[ClumsyGRL]

i'm a die hard clois, but why there has to be always a competion???i love both of them, cause both of them were acting differents caracters(brainiac and faora)......so it should have a third option!!

[marcella]

^^I agree

[AndiGirl]

You're just asking for trouble.

Definitely...

[obsessedwithsv]

Oooh, this is a hard one. I would go for ED 'cause she sold Faora to me a bit better than AM did BrainIAC but maybe that's because we've got James Marsters to compare her to, whereas there was nothing to compare when it came to Faora. Oooh, I don't know, neutral vote.

[Seeya'round Smallville]

Routh is right. It's apples and oranges anyway. Erica was playing a character that she basically had to make up because there was never a Faora on the show, and Allison essentially had to try to be James Marsters' Brainiac. Two different things.

[Timester]

Different characters.

[LuthorKent90]

Sorry, there's never any competition. Allison will win everytime.
I like Erica and all, but she just isn't as talented an actress.

[AndiGirl]

Routh is right. It's apples and oranges anyway. Erica was playing a character that she basically had to make up because there was never a Faora on the show, and Allison essentially had to try to be James Marsters' Brainiac. Two different things.

I couldnt agree more.
We had never seen Faora before...so there was nothing to compare her to. But Brainiac....those are some big shoes to fill.

I think both women did an amazing job, but it is like comparin apple's and oranges. No where near the same thing.

[lostmyway]

I think both of them did a great job in these two episodes. However, I think I enjoyed Allison's performance more than Erica's.

[Eurynome]

I can't make up my mind. They both did such an awesome job! I loved both of their performances.:D

[Becc]

This thread is just asking for trouble.

[DGirlLois4Clark]

None!
Only joking..both did great:)

[ekoo]

I think AM did a wonderful job... she was creepy!

[zorasuperman]

yes i do agree above. braniac was big shoes to fill.

[Kreukie]

I'm not blind with bias that I can't see straight for either girl and I gotta say, after watching Erica's clips online from Bloodline, I wasn't as impressed as I was with Allison in last night's episode.

So I choose Allison.

[biggkoz]

Chloe trying to be evil was just a bad idea.

[DGirlLois4Clark]

I'm not blind with bias that I can't see straight for either girl and I gotta say, after watching Erica's clips online from Bloodline, I wasn't as impressed as I was with Allison in last night's episode.

So I choose Allison.


And those with a different opinion are blind by bias. purlease:rolleyes:

[kal-el_Girl]

allison did a superb job! loved it...

[Minamostaza]

This thread is just asking for trouble.

Agree....

[kal-el_Girl]

you guys choose erica because you think she's hotter BUT allison was great since she had to mimick masters and erica was more of a "comic relief" phantom.

[Jaderoyale]

This thread is screaming for arguments, so i'm going to be fair and say this;

Both characters are completely different. Both actresses are completely different.
Erica did a MUCH better job at Faora than we all expected. As did Chloe as Chloiac, she freaked me out.
We've NEVER had Faora before on the show, ED had to technically "make her up", whereas AM had the talents of Marsters to try and perfect, which IMO is hard, because Marsters is an excellent, captivating actor. In the way he speaks and acts. But AM did the best she could and better than i thought she would do.

I like BOTH actresses and admire both their efforts. Thats why i'm respecting them both and not voting.

[alejandrita439]

both :)

[melissan02]

This thread is trouble, just asking for edits all around!:lol:


It's apples and oranges if you're asking me.:\

[Kreukie]

And those with a different opinion are blind by bias. purlease:rolleyes:

That's not what I said. What I'm saying is someone like yourself who's a fan of Lois is more likely going to vote for Erica...likewise with someone who's more of a fan of Chloe to vote for Allison.

But me, who isn't a fan of neither character or actress, in my unbiased opinion, since I don't favor one over the other, liked Allison better in her role. The End.

[devilneedsaride]

I think they both did great jobs, but I personally voted for ED. Allison's BrainIAC was creepy, but for some reason I couldn't really seem to forget that she was acting, whereas ED just sort of disappeared into the Faora role.

[loislanefan15]

you guys choose erica because you think she's hotter BUT allison was great since she had to mimick masters and erica was more of a "comic relief" phantom.

[mod edit]

[Alania]

That's not what I said. What I'm saying is someone like yourself who's a fan of Lois is more likely going to vote for Erica...likewise with someone who's more of a fan of Chloe to vote for Allison.

But me, who isn't a fan of neither character or actress, in my unbiased opinion, since I don't favor one over the other, liked Allison better in her role. The End.

That's not what it says your avatar. Anyway, JadeRoyale is right, that kind of comparision is not called for. Maybe if it were between Faora and Chloiac, it would have been less of a disaster.

[KSiteTV]

I'm going to close this thread before it becomes a bashing war.

Seriously, don't create threads just to bait people.