Liked it? Hated it? What did you think of this episode?

[mof123]

How was the episode, Discuss it all here
Don't rate the episode before it airs

[bemyhiro]

I loved it! But is Sylar gone for good now? I'm so confused!

[Ginx]

Have to say 10/10 for me. They got rid of some character baggage and built Sylar up more and left a big ? for him. Hate the way Nathan has turned though but I guess it's best that we know his true colors have always been the type of person he was in S1.

Looking forward to Feb although it's going to be a long wait :(

----- Added 42 Seconds later -----


I loved it! But is Sylar gone for good now? I'm so confused!

To me, no. He's not gone yet. We've already seen that he's powerful and incredibly hard to get rid of. I even think that Ma might have snuck him out or something because she wasn't done with him.

[Lawliet]

10/10 Sylar was just awesome in this episode and they left a giant cliffhanger for him. Nathan should just go off himself, seriously he's just a giant a-hole. At long last Peter is back and it's great they didn't give him back all his powers, so he starts anew. Feb is so far away. Hope 'Fugitives' starts off with an explosive start.

[LeirbaG]

I really liked this week episode ! Sylar VS everyone else was very fun to watch. The only thing i didn't like is that they killed off the marine guy WAY too soon in my opinion. I wish they kept him a little bit longuer. What was the point to give him power for like 10 min max lol. Also i wonder if Hiro will get his power back. I guess not with the formula destroyed and all.

[bemyhiro]

Have to say 10/10 for me. They got rid of some character baggage and built Sylar up more and left a big ? for him. Hate the way Nathan has turned though but I guess it's best that we know his true colors have always been the type of person he was in S1.

Looking forward to Feb although it's going to be a long wait :(


I know, February is too long away, but maybe we'll have so clues on what happened to Sylar. I fetlt so bad for Claire, when she had to let Meredith go. I would never be able to do that :(

[STFanatic]

Worf for President!!! Whoo Hoo!!

[bemyhiro]

Also, Sylar kind of took on the role of Jigsaw, in a way. Or atleast it sounded like that in the beginning.
Just playing a game, to find out everyone's true colors.

[KSiteTV]

I felt like this one was a little flat to me... I loved the Ando/Daphne/Matt/Hiro storyline, and a few other random moments, but Petrellis changing affiliations from bad to good to bad or whatever is so over to me, and I can't say I was on the edge of my seat at all. Not to be a buzzkill, I just think Heroes is capable of so much more.

[warriorrenegade]

Yes! A/D/M/H storylines were fun to watch. But the rest seemed tired and had a been there done that quality to them. And seeing Sylar be Sylar was a drag...cause the whole time I'm watching..I'm thinking "Where was that guy all season?"

[Hopefulsuicide]

the problem with having your heroes show good sides and bad sides, and having your villains do the same, is that everyone becomes unpredictable. but in terms of audience it means there are always going to be some people left unsatisfied

did i want sylar to be a good guy? no, but i was growing to accept that he could be... and then boom, bad guy again

do i want nathan to be a good guy? yes, i truly want to believe he is a good person, because he keeps saving the day... but bam, nope he's the villain now

there just isnt any logical thread as to who's gonna do what next

[Newb]

Wow. I'm amazed anyone would give tonights show a 10. That means there'll be no other episode better than tonights.

[Karafan1]

As with every monday night, I only saw bits and pieces because of WWE Monday Night Raw and the football game, so I can only rate the bits and pieces I've seen so far and I give it a 9. I taped heroes on another vcr and will watch the whole episode soon..

[krpto]

probablly not the best episode of the series but deffinately the best this season so I gave it 9 out of 10

[Karafan1]

Ok, I just watched the whole episode and I'm upping my ranking to 10!!! Nathan turning into a bad guy is very interesting. I wonder how long it will take for him to see the error of his ways..

[spicyblark]

WHOO!!!!!!! This was crazy good.

[Litle bit more bizarre]

I was expecting something more I am angry that Peter must absorb all his powers again because we loose some good abilities like invisibility and phasing but I finaly saw Sylar/Doyle battle so I give this episode 5

[superpal1]

The episode was good. I'm glad Peter got his ability back, about time. I'm also glad that Hiro does not have his. The powers that be kept saying what a crutch time travel was. Now that Hiro is depowered and Peter no longer has the ability. Plus papa Petrelli is dead, no more time traveling. Sylar has been great the last few weeks. Should be good in Feb.

[DarkClone]

I thought it was a good episode. When I first started watching, I was skeptical about the whole SAW theme with Sylar, but they did a good job with it, showing how demented and twisted he can be, but at the same time keeping him human, and showing a dual nature to the other characters as well.

Peter getting his powers back was cool too. Hopefully we can stop messing around with this nonsense, and they'll finally let Peter be the badass hero we're all waiting for him to be.

[Saber]

I give it a six; all this back and forth is getting old. Now Mohinder is healed and Ando has powers (frustrating). I just want stories that are consist and developed.
Do we really know any of these characters anymore, they have become so interchangeable it’s hard to know who to root for.

[rambo5501]

I gave it an 7-8, I Liked it, but ehh. I don't know it could of been better. Not the way to end the Season, good thing Next season is just a month- month and a half away. Unless a writers strike.. lol

[J.D]

It was alright, the best bit was wehre Hiro punched Tracey, Daphne's expression was priceless:rotfl:

[Cyclops1974]

I really really enjoyed it.
Final 10 minutes made it a 10!!!

PETE'S BACK! WOOHOO!!!


...I'm also glad that Hiro does not have his. The powers that be kept saying what a crutch time travel was. Now that Hiro is depowered and Peter no longer has the ability. Plus papa Petrelli is dead, no more time traveling.

Remember that they can still timetravel with Daphndo. But only when the two of them are together. My guess is that they'll get separated pretty soon.

[HWichita]

Another 7
Action was great and most of the time the characters behavior and use of their powers made sense. But not all the time.
But again some holes in the plot and use of their powers.
Ok Ando getting a power that increases other peoples powers could be a good addition but running back in time. Please don't do that again.
Mohinder does not seemed healed yet even after he took a bath in the Formula (When he got picked up in the car he still had the metal plates on his head)
Peter got his powers back and we saw how he got the scar, Good!
Merideth may not be dead . Don't think she can die from fire.
Loved Sylar in this episode we all know he isn't dead. He will die if/when the new Star Trek movie is a hit and they can't re sign him.
I did not see anything to indicate Peter does not have all his powers. Did you?
Nathan is not Bad yet. Nathan thinks he is doing the right thing. He is more like Bush where Arthur was more like Cheney.
Where did Sylar get the ability to resist the puppit master?
How did Fire guy beat up super strong Mohinder using just his fists?
I had a little problem with Getting strong from other peoples fear Guy killing the Marine so easy. Maybe he isn't dead!
Glad most of the Formula is gone. We know it is not all gone don't we.

[loistickyfingerz]

I'm really happy Peter got HIS powers back. And I really like how Sylar is truly evil again.

[one of the 12]

Another 7
Action was great and most of the time the characters behavior and use of their powers made sense. But not all the time.
But again some holes in the plot and use of their powers.
1. Ok Ando getting a power that increases other peoples powers could be a good addition but running back in time. Please don't do that again.
2. Mohinder does not seemed healed yet even after he took a bath in the Formula (When he got picked up in the car he still had the metal plates on his head)
3. Peter got his powers back and we saw how he got the scar, Good!
4. Merideth may not be dead . Don't think she can die from fire.
5. Loved Sylar in this episode we all know he isn't dead. He will die if/when the new Star Trek movie is a hit and they can't re sign him.
6. I did not see anything to indicate Peter does not have all his powers. Did you?
7. Nathan is not Bad yet. Nathan thinks he is doing the right thing. He is more like Bush where Arthur was more like Cheney.
8. Where did Sylar get the ability to resist the puppit master?
9. How did Fire guy beat up super strong Mohinder using just his fists?
10. I had a little problem with Getting strong from other peoples fear Guy killing the Marine so easy. Maybe he isn't dead!
11. Glad most of the Formula is gone. We know it is not all gone don't we.

Sorry i took the liberty of assigning numbers to each of your comments, but it makes it easier to reply to them individually..

1. I agree, as the writers wanting to rely less on time travel, the fact that now Hiro has no power and Daphne and Ando have to be together to do it make it less likely to happen an often as it has in the past.
2. I did not see that, it looked like he was fully healed when he looked at his reflection and when they showed him in the car.
3. Peter got his one power back, if he had gotten all back there would not be a scar. Why is everyone so hung up on this scar. It was future Peter that has a scar, and the future has been changes several times over during the show.
4. Possibly, but can she survive the building collapsing on top of her, I am saying no... ergo, she is dead. This helps to further develop Claire's character.
5. More than likely I would guess dead, but yes, it does leave the writers an out if they can't keep him on the show.
6. Yes, he could have used many other powers to put out the fire and or save Nathan. He used the only power available to him, flight which he absorbed from Nathan who was in the same room.
7. I disagree, he seems to be doing this out of spite. He wants to be able to be the one in control of everyone's power, just like his father. If he can't control the source of the power and create his army, he will imprison all those with powers to keep them from using them.
8. It was his telekinesis, the puppet master can only control physical ability, not mental. Basically he fried his brain.
9. I have the same question...
10. Super strong doesn't mean invincible, he snapped his neck like some dried kindling. Kyle is dead, just like the show 4400...:D
11. Yes, true as true can be.

Just my observations and opinions, all open to discussion... By the way, I am giving the show a 9... very positive way to end the current chapter and segue in the next, Fugitives looks like it has potential like we have not seen since volume 1.

[pumpkineater]

If Hiro doesn't have his power, how can he be "rounded up" as a fugitive in volume 4?

[Xanderman]

I give it a six; all this back and forth is getting old. Now Mohinder is healed and Ando has powers (frustrating). I just want stories that are consist and developed.
Do we really know any of these characters anymore, they have become so interchangeable it’s hard to know who to root for.That pretty much sums it up for me too. Hopefully the next volume won't be the flop this was.

[Georgeo8]

I think this episode was not good.Only Sylar was great it was his episode.But i dont understand how Claire can surprise Sylar.It was impossible.And Nathan.Suddenly he wish after power and dont listen his (little)brother.Nathan never was bad guy.I think this is crazy.Last five or 10 minutes absolutely destroy my result of these episode.:mad::confused:

[watubeenmissing]

i dont know i think it was ok .. let leaves you wanting a bit more understanding of whats going to happen next.. with the fact that nathan brother gets his power back.. i wounder if he gets all the same powers or maybe an add-on to what he use to have and more.. ?? well it just makes me wounder.. :rotfl:

[HWichita]

Sorry i took the liberty of assigning numbers to each of your comments, but it makes it easier to reply to them individually..


1. I agree, as the writers wanting to rely less on time travel, the fact that now Hiro has no power and Daphne and Ando have to be together to do it make it less likely to happen an often as it has in the past.
2. I did not see that, it looked like he was fully healed when he looked at his reflection and when they showed him in the car.
3. Peter got his one power back, if he had gotten all back there would not be a scar. Why is everyone so hung up on this scar. It was future Peter that has a scar, and the future has been changes several times over during the show.
4. Possibly, but can she survive the building collapsing on top of her, I am saying no... ergo, she is dead. This helps to further develop Claire's character.
5. More than likely I would guess dead, but yes, it does leave the writers an out if they can't keep him on the show.
6. Yes, he could have used many other powers to put out the fire and or save Nathan. He used the only power available to him, flight which he absorbed from Nathan who was in the same room.
7. I disagree, he seems to be doing this out of spite. He wants to be able to be the one in control of everyone's power, just like his father. If he can't control the source of the power and create his army, he will imprison all those with powers to keep them from using them.
8. It was his telekinesis, the puppet master can only control physical ability, not mental. Basically he fried his brain.
9. I have the same question...
10. Super strong doesn't mean invincible, he snapped his neck like some dried kindling. Kyle is dead, just like the show 4400...:D
11. Yes, true as true can be.

Just my observations and opinions, all open to discussion... By the way, I am giving the show a 9... very positive way to end the current chapter and segue in the next, Fugitives looks like it has potential like we have not seen since volume 1.

Enjoyed your comments and having the numbers does make it easier to follow.

1. I still hope Hiro gets his powers back. Just doesn't use them to go back in Time. Seems maybe he would learn his lesson. Seems like Teleportation and freezing time should be power enough to use.
I just hated the running back in time. Just seemed like lazy writing.
2. I will look again
3. Seems like the scar is a symbol of Peter not being a Dumb woose.
4. We will see. "May not" is the important phrase.
5. Sylar isn't dead yet. We need to see him interact with Lional Luthur.
6. It would not have been the 1st time Peter did not use the Power(s) that would have made sense.
7. We will just have to agree to disagree on this one for awhile.
8. Your right, I missed it.
9. Wonder if the writers watch the show.
10. Just seemed to easy to me. He was a Combat hardened Marine after all. Here's a thought perhaps Killing that one Charactor that quick (from the 4400) was the writers way of telling us they realized the formula was a bad idea.
11. ditto