Liked it? Hated it? What did you think of "The Eclipse Part II"?

[mof123]

What did you think of "The Eclipse Part II"????
Do not rate the episode until NBC has finished airing it

[Ginx]

closed until the episode starts

[STFanatic]

Oh freakin' WOW.

Another awesome episode!

[superhippie2000]

Oh freakin' WOW.

Another awesome episode!
yup i agree :D

[Lawliet]

Wow amazing, my favorite scenes were the Super Haitian Mind Whammy and Hiro's awesome teleporting scene and then taking Claire leaving everyone dumbstruck. Sheer brilliance, "Best Day Ever" or "I heard from a dude who heard from a dude that..."
Great Episode: 10

[Ginx]

10/10 for me. Lots of info and setup for next week. Like that people keep switching sides and that they're tying things in from S1.

[STFanatic]

I would have loved it if Seth Green had used his Chris Griffin (Family Guy) voice at some point in the show ;)

[Karafan1]

I love reading all these 10's! I can't wait to see the episode later tonight..I taped it on another vcr in the house, but can't watch it until after WWE Monday Night Raw is over..

[FLyxNERD]

I love reading all these 10's! I can't wait to see the episode later tonight..I taped it on another vcr in the house, but can't watch it until after WWE Monday Night Raw is over..

haha yea i was switching back and forth between heroes and raw

[Karafan1]

I did see the very end of Heroes but not much else..

[oldblackmagick]

hiro finally did something useful but why did he not teleport them into the the fiery center of the earth or underground like he did adam?? oh well it was still his best moment for me. hiro at 10 seems smarter than grown up hiro...hope he gains some perspective:p

[Karafan1]

I just finished watching Heroes and I give it a 10! The comic book guys were funny and I like how Sylar is back to his old evil self but I wish he hadn't possibly killed Elle.

[Spirit Detective]

I hate the Sylar lightswitch.

I love the Hiro scenes...especially when he takes Claire back in time 16 years.

[LogicalDisorder]

Not faulting anyone for liking it, but after that ending I'm giving them one week to change my mind and if they don't pull back from Elle being dead, I will never watch the show again. My interest is completely gone if they went and did that.

[Xanderman]

Ugh that was awful... Lamest episode to date and one of the worst episodes of the series. What a truly dumb season of Heroes. It's all over the place. I'll expand on all the lameness some other time, for now I just wanted to get the message out. heh


I hate the Sylar lightswitch. Me too. But it's lightswitchES plural actually (back and forth, back and forth). I wish they'd make up their minds already, I'm tired of Heroes' writers trying to constantly be "clever"/shocking/surprising. It's come to the point where I can't accept anything that happens at face value, or begin to care about a story or character, because it's either completely temporary and gone next week or we're not seeing the whole picture. Whatever it is we believe to be happening, as soon as we start getting into it, quickly turns out to be wrong or no longer matters (or never really mattered, because they were just fooling us/messing with us). But then later on of course, we find out lo and behold it DID matter, but for a completely different reason than we originally thought (or they made us think) the first time. It's ridiculously annoying. This show has become little more than a mockery of itself.

So Sylar seems to be evil again, whoopie, who cares. It's hard to care about anything this show does anymore because it's constantly changing. I mean I like twists and turns as much as the next guy, but not incessantly.


(By the way--Steve that "I want Shelby for Christmas or else" avatar is hilarious.:lol: It reminds me of the time Burns pointed a gun at Smithers ordering him to "hop in" the Spruce Moose. lol)

[Litle bit more bizarre]

Not faulting anyone for liking it, but after that ending I'm giving them one week to change my mind and if they don't pull back from Elle being dead, I will never watch the show again. My interest is completely gone if they went and did that.

I totaly agree if I could give zero for this episode than I do it whithout anything holding me :mad::mad::mad: extremly mad

[Saber]

Ugh that was awful... Lamest episode to date and one of the worst episodes of the series. What a truly dumb season of Heroes. It's all over the place. I'll expand on all the lameness some other time, for now I just wanted to get the message out. heh

Me too. But it's lightswitchES plural actually (back and forth, back and forth). I wish they'd make up their minds already, I'm tired of Heroes' writers trying to constantly be "clever"/shocking/surprising. It's come to the point where I can't accept anything that happens at face value, or begin to care about a story or character, because it's either completely temporary and gone next week or we're not seeing the whole picture. Whatever it is we believe to be happening, as soon as we start getting into it, quickly turns out to be wrong or no longer matters (or never really mattered, because they were just fooling us/messing with us). But then later on of course, we find out lo and behold it DID matter, but for a completely different reason than we originally thought (or they made us think) the first time. It's ridiculously annoying. This show has become little more than a mockery of itself.

So Sylar seems to be evil again, whoopie, who cares. It's hard to care about anything this show does anymore because it's constantly changing. I mean I like twists and turns as much as the next guy, but not incessantly.





Man you so put this in a nut shell for me. I gave it 5 for all of the reasons he said.
This show just goes in circles and goes nowhere fast. Nothing more than a revolving door, it needs a window to open to let in some new stories ideas.

[Novak Fan]

Again , not my favorite episode. Agree about Sylar lightswitch..I mean, he was faking the whole time? he has double personality or what?! I'm tired that he's bad then good, then bad, then good... And I HATE the (maybe) Elle's dead! WHY? I give them some points for Seth Green onscreen time though. And the whole Hiro's plot.

[6-Super-Man -5]

Yeah, wasn't my favorite episode, but overall it was a decent-good episode.

[loistickyfingerz]

I though it was ok. I found the parts with Sylar-sex totally gross, mainly because it is not me.

I liked Hiro's actions. They were purposeful and meaningful and made it feel less like Hiro was just there and needed to be brought into the action somehow.

I'm ready for more.

[Cyclops1974]

Not so good. Pissed me off that Pete still hasn't got his powers back. Ah well, I guess we'll have to wait until Nathan injects Pete.

Liked the Hiro scenes though. But hated that Sylar turns bad again. Gives me headaches.