Lana had to have seen that "almost" Clois kiss

[trojan20]

She was right behind them, how could she not have seen them!:confused:

[FinnHarp]

she did seem to be standing in the doorway for a bit before she came in. I think she saw it, she had to have seen it.

[umm]

she did seem to be standing in the doorway for a bit before she came in. I think she saw it, she had to have seen it.


Now, I think she was looking at Chloe and Jimmy, who as much as I hate to admit, did look quite happy together, and would have had a great honeymoon I am sure, had they had a chance to enjoy it!

[solenn]

IA. The first time I watched the scene I immediately thought "But...she doesn't move, she is in the shadow and seems to have been standing on the spot for a few seconds...", I really think she was watching. It seems like she didn't want to interrupt and was hesitating to go in...Ok she didn't seem to be annoyed by the almost-kiss of Clark and Lois if she did see it because she was smiling when entering, but after season 7 we all know that she knows how to hide her feelings (at the beginning of season 7, when she was all so soft and kind with Clark and all of a sudden full of hate and anger with Lionel and Lex-and her voice was like the one of an "angel" when she talked to Clark and the one of a "devil" when talking with Lionel or Lex...it was quite scary IMO,lol).

[FinnHarp]

yeah to me it seemed she was standing there untill chloe spotted her and shouted oh my god or whatever. then she came in smiling. if she wasn't meant to be standing there watching it was really bad editing or directing because she was clearly standing in the doorway.

[Clark-Lois]

i think she did see and didn't want to interrupt but Chloe did gasp and draw attention to her. what was she supposed to do? turn around and run away? i however blame Oliver. if he didn't persuade her to come back, we would have had a Clois kiss.

[FinnHarp]

yeah stupid Oliver, I know he was there to comfort Lois but he wouldn't of had to if he hadn't brought Lana back in the first place. Plus on a side note I don't trust Lana to keep his secret identity a secret.

[alejandrita439]

i hope she saw the ¨almost kiss¨:)

[zHeN_zHeN]

Yup, she saw it. You can see her in the shadows right before THE moment (specifically, under Lois's chin).

Lana was just watching, waiting... to pounce!

Nah, I just think it was bad timing for Chloe to notice that she was standing there in the darkness. And, it was a bit creepy and strange too. She should have just backed away and waited outside then came back in. Hah, if only...

But, Lana definitely saw something.

[Karafan1]

If Lana saw Lois and Clark about to kiss she hasn't said anything to Clark about it....Yet.

[trojan20]

i kinda would have liked to have seen her reaction to it:eek:

[alejandrita439]

maybe in the next episodes we will know that she saw the almost kiss :)

[MAN-of-STEEL]

The scene when Clark's about to lay on Lois, Lois was at the entrance. Cloe was able to see Lana and she was further back from the entrance than Clark and Lois. No way that Lana didn't catch that scene. Probably the reason why she is trying so hard to push Clark away. Please share your thoughts.

[Iluvgreen]

She would have to be blind not to see it. But I really hope she did. I hope they don't make it that she didn't seet them.

[Kevin24]

The scene when Clark's about to lay on Lois, Lois was at the entrance. Cloe was able to see Lana and she was further back from the entrance than Clark and Lois. No way that Lana didn't catch that scene. Probably the reason why she is trying so hard to push Clark away. Please share your thoughts.


She would have to be blind not to see it. But I really hope she did. I hope they don't make it that she didn't seet them.


Yup, there is no way she didn't see them about to kiss. It would explain why she was standing in the shadows in the first place.

[minerva73]

I don't think she saw it. That's just my opinion, though.

Lana wasn't looking directly at Clark and Lois when she walked in. She seemed to stand still for a second and she slowly walked into the room. Chloe screamed before she ran to Lana, so Clark and Lois quickly looked at what she was screaming at. Then at that exact moment, Chloe ran to give Lana a hug. So the most that she would've seen is Clark and Lois turning their heads to look at Lana, but she wouldn't have seen Clark almost kiss her. Also given that the room was rather dark, she couldn't have seen them since Chloe could barely make out Lana's shadow until she started moving.

I want to make an animation of that scene, but I can't at the moment.

[Iluvgreen]

They were in more light than Lana was.

[clarkcasas]

yeah i think she did see them and they will address it on the episodes that follow

[Kevin24]

I don't think she saw it. That's just my opinion, though.

Lana wasn't looking directly at Clark and Lois when she walked in. She seemed to stand still for a second and she slowly walked into the room. Chloe screamed before she ran to Lana, so Clark and Lois quickly looked at what she was screaming at. Then at that exact moment, Chloe ran to give Lana a hug. So the most that she would've seen is Clark and Lois turning their heads to look at Lana, but she wouldn't have seen Clark almost kiss her. Also given that the room was rather dark, she couldn't have seen them since Chloe could barely make out Lana's shadow until she started moving.

I want to make an animation of that scene, but I can't at the moment.


I see where you are getting at. Judging by where Lana was standing she would be right behind Lois and Clark when they were dancing but since Clark towers over Lois she would be able to see Clark's face.

So, Lana could have saw Clark leaning in lower and lower closer to Lois face and Lana would know that he was going in for the kiss. I even think Lois was standing on her toes a little when Clark was leaning in so just by body language she should know what was going on.

Lana from her vantage point probably didn't see them closing their eyes and parting their lips but she definitely could tell what was going on.

[minerva73]

They were in more light than Lana was.

The room seemed to have the same amount of light until we saw Clark and Lois look at what Chloe was exclaming at (which was probably because the cameras weren't bright enough).

As much as I wanted Lana to see the almost kiss, so she could also say that she wants Clark and Lois to be together, I don't think she did. Especially since she's giving up being with Clark, so she can't just keep that bundled up within her. She should've at least voiced out her feelings then (when they spoke in the loft) if she saw the kiss.

[Kid Collins]

If Lana saw the almost Clois kiss I would think that she would have some sort of reaction on her face. Like surprise. Looked from Clark to Lois trying to figure out what's going on between them.

But the only thing I saw was Lana smiling and having a staring contest with Clark.

[Kevin24]

If Lana saw the almost Clois kiss I would think that she would have some sort of reaction on her face. Like surprise. Looked from Clark to Lois trying to figure out what's going on between them.

But the only thing I saw was Lana smiling and having a staring contest with Clark.


She was trying to play it off like she didn't see anything. Her behavior towards him , at least to me, suggests that she definitely saw the almost kiss. She kept telling him what a great decision she made and how she is a better person because of it.

She is putting a front because she probably thinks he has moved on to Lois.

[Kid Collins]

She was trying to play it off like she didn't see anything. Her behavior towards me , at least to me, suggests that she definitely saw the almost kiss. She kept telling him what a great decision she made and how she is a better person because of it.

No. Because the writers would've made SURE that the audience KNEW that Lana saw the kiss. Just like when Lois first noticed Clark, it wasn't subtle at all, you knew for sure she was attracted to him.

Lana would've reacted to it if she saw it. But nothing.




She is putting a front because she probably thinks he has moved on to Lois.

No again. If you read spoilers you'll guess why Lana is pulling away from Clark. It has nothing to do with Lois.






~I want a Season NINE!~[/QUOTE]

[Kevin24]

No. Because the writers would've made SURE that the audience KNEW that Lana saw the kiss. Just like when Lois first noticed Clark, it wasn't subtle at all, you knew for sure she was attracted to him.

Lana would've reacted to it if she saw it. But nothing.

No again. If you read spoilers you'll guess why Lana is pulling away from Clark. It has nothing to do with Lois.



I don't read spoilers. So I am just going off what I've seen so far on screen and I don't plan on reading any spoilers at all.

So , Lana was just there to prevent the kiss from happening? I think they could have had her enter from somewhere else if they wanted us to be sure she didn't see anything.

It's true that they usually do make a point in letting us know if she saw or not. She would have made a face but I like to think she did :lol:

[All about Clark]

Yeah, I don't think Lana saw the almost kiss. TPTB are famous for making the audience sure about stuff like this and there was no surprise look as someone posted.

[clois_lover10]

She better have seen it... who else can give a Clois talk to Clark with an impact? (I hope...) :D

[MAN-of-STEEL]

It's kinda funny that I started this tread and someone kinda jacked it from me( don't know how they did it, hence bold title! but that's kool.

[SnowBird]

Lana was standing in the shadows watching Clark and Lois. She wanted to come in but was shocked that Clark and Lois were so close. Chloe had to notice Lana and shouted and ruined the perfect moment. Maybe the next L&C attempt, they will be alone so they can have a proper kiss.

[Loisdragon]

Lana Saw that almost kiss. I bet is going to be address later on in episode

[minerva73]

^That's exactly the reason why I don't think she saw it. Why does she have to wait to address it in a future episode? She had the perfect opportunity to do it in this episode, but she didn't (which to me means that she didn't see it). She said, "Lana Lang and Clark Kent aren't meant to be together" and she could've followed up by saying, "But on the other hand, I'm happy that you and Lois are getting closer" or something. She doesn't even have to admit to Clark that she saw the kiss, but the fact that they were on the dance floor together would've been a big enough hint to the audience that she saw it.

If she brings it up in a future episode, then it'll mean that she still misses being with Clark and she's having feelings about it which just started to rage in that future episode. And I'll hate if Lana has to start complaining about that... The writers missed their opportunity to bring up the kiss if Lana saw it, the only other chance they have is if Clark brings it up in the future.

[skylar]

Yeah she saw the almost kiss... and when something goes wrong or
something that she doesn't agree with Clark she will bring it up to see
what Clark will say.

[singingdove]

Logically, she should have seen it from where she was standing, but if so why didn't she bring it up during the Clana loft scene, or later at the hospital? So I'm thinking not...

[Kevin24]

^That's exactly the reason why I don't think she saw it. Why does she have to wait to address it in a future episode? She had the perfect opportunity to do it in this episode, but she didn't (which to me means that she didn't see it). She said, "Lana Lang and Clark Kent aren't meant to be together" and she could've followed up by saying, "But on the other hand, I'm happy that you and Lois are getting closer" or something. She doesn't even have to admit to Clark that she saw the kiss, but the fact that they were on the dance floor together would've been a big enough hint to the audience that she saw it.

If she brings it up in a future episode, then it'll mean that she still misses being with Clark and she's having feelings about it which just started to rage in that future episode. And I'll hate if Lana has to start complaining about that... The writers missed their opportunity to bring up the kiss if Lana saw it, the only other chance they have is if Clark brings it up in the future.


Lana definitely still has feelings for Clark. If she didn't why would she even mention her fantasy about marrying him in the barn?

I still believe she saw them but it's true that she might have mentioned it. I want Clark to be the one to say those things to her and not she telling him that. Clark has to tell her that he is glad she left and all that.

I don't like thinking that if she hadn't left then they would still be together and that makes Lois seem like the rebound girl and I don't like that.

----- Added 2 Minutes later -----


It's kinda funny that I started this tread and someone kinda jacked it from me( don't know how they did it, hence bold title! but that's kool.

Your thread got merged with another thread of a similar topic that was talking about the same thing. The reason yours was merged into theirs is because theirs was made before yours.

[wildcherry]

Someone had to of seen them i mean they were right there where everyone could see. Maybe that camera guy got it on tape , haha

[luvinChlark]

I don't think she saw it, she was looking/smiling at Chloe the whole time. Once she was hugging Chloe her eyes shifted to Clark. Thats just the way I saw it. It really wouldn't make sense to have Lana say something in the next episode about it because Lois won't be around for her remaining episodes. So why bother? If she saw it, I would think they would have Lana say something in Bride, but they didn't. Probably cause she didn't see it... :o

[Jaged]

I wish she saw it but I dont think she did. Lol im bitter about her interuption so i wish pain upon her

[The Icon]

I'm pretty sure she saw it. For one, she was almost directly in front of Lois & Clark (as per the veiwers angle). Two, when her eyes shifted to see Clark while hugging Chloe she knew exactly where to look. Which says to me Lana already knew that's where he was standing. So with that said, Chloe's outburst drew Clark's attention (if you notice, Lois only looked because Clark pulled away) and he maybe moved one step. Lana knew he was standing there just moments before and in those moments he was about to kiss Lois. I'm almost certain she witnessed it.

[Alicia Chipy]

I don't think she saw it,she was focused on surprising Chloe. I would re-watcht it if it weren't so aggravating1

My 500th post,how time flies except when waiting for Jan 15!

[Kevin24]

After seeing the episode again there is no way she didn't see it. They were right in front of her face when the camera panned to her. So, she definitely saw it.

[amberdawn]

I think she definitely did.

[dalbajr]

I'm pretty sure she saw it. For one, she was almost directly in front of Lois & Clark (as per the veiwers angle). Two, when her eyes shifted to see Clark while hugging Chloe she knew exactly where to look. Which says to me Lana already knew that's where he was standing. So with that said, Chloe's outburst drew Clark's attention (if you notice, Lois only looked because Clark pulled away) and he maybe moved one step. Lana knew he was standing there just moments before and in those moments he was about to kiss Lois. I'm almost certain she witnessed it.


That is a good point...
When Lana was hugging Chloe she didn't have to look around for Clark, she looked right at him, because she knew where he was on the dance floor because she saw him and Lois.

[The Icon]

I just don't see any way around it. She had to have seen it. I think the real question is how she felt about Chloe calling her out before Lois & Clark kissed. But I guess that's a discussion for another thread. :)

[trojan20]

i have replayed that scene over and over again in super slow motion and lana's shadow is definitely under lois's chin when she is about to kiss clark, and it does take a second for lana to come out of the shadow when chloe screams out loud so she was probably grinding her teeth in that second it took her to come out of the shadow.:eek:

[scifigirl]

Well, if she saw it, she certainly didn't (at least on the surface) have a strong reaction to it. Although, I agree with trojan that her hesitation in the shadows could be read as her recovering her composure after an emotional punch in the gut.

[justme_007]

I think she did.... i remember the face of lois.. i can´t stop laughting.. i´m sorry

[jules1973]

This may have been covered as have not read all threads. But did she see them as she came in from shadows.

[Mars Investigations]

No. She was focused on Chloe, and I don't think she would have intentionally interrupted it (because of her fresh anti-Clana attitude).

[Cage]

Yes !!!!

[USuperManC]

I would love to say yes, but the fact that as she came into the light he eyes were on Chloe the entire time and did not falter :(

[LoisLaneKicksAss]

haha. i would say no. i mean. its a miracle that we even saw her. i mean, if the lights hadn't come up at that specific time she could have been completely hidden. and once the lights came up lois and clark were no longer close to each other. and i don't think she was spying....and if she had seen the kiss...there is no way that her smile would have been that big. i mean, mine wouldn't have been.

[Bizarrolover]

Lana was in the shadows but Clark and Lois were in an better lit area, standing not far away from her. So, unless she's blind, it's impossible not to notice the tallest man of the party and a woman dressed in a bright orange silk dress when they are right in front of you. If you pay attention to the scenes at the barn, you will notice that Clark always stands out among the crowd. In fact, I think they purposely hired short extras to make him look even taller.

Clark is not the kind of person that passes unnoticed. She saw them, definitely.

[Cage]

Lana was in the shadows but Clark and Lois were in an better lit area, standing not far away from her. So, unless she's blind, it's impossible not to notice the tallest man of the party and a woman dressed in a bright orange silk dress when they are right in front of you. If you pay attention to the scenes at the barn, you will notice that Clark always stands out among the crowd. In fact, I think they purposely hired short extras to make him look even taller.

Clark is not the kind of person that passes unnoticed. She saw them, definitely.

No point in my opinion - it's the same:rotfl::lol:

[Iluvgreen]

She most definately did!

[Wicked Lois]

She saw them ans she was waiting for the "right" time to come in. *pure evil*

lol

I am kidding... Maybe yes, she was right in front of them.

[h-rob]

I dont know how she didn't. She was standing still when the camera turned to her, and it wasnt like Chloe was watching the door. Lana could have been standing there for a while before Chloe saw her. As far as her smile, we have already seen how good at deception she is.

[LoisLaneKicksAss]

I dont know how she didn't. She was standing still when the camera turned to her, and it wasnt like Chloe was watching the door. Lana could have been standing there for a while before Chloe saw her. As far as her smile, we have already seen how good at deception she is.

uh...she definitely was not standing still. when the light came up she was walking in to the barn. chloe would have noticed her sooner if she had come in sooner than that. and she wasn't even looking in the direction of lois and clark. what i saw was that she walked in, the lights came up, and she saw chloe. nothing happened to insinuate that she saw anything.

[Clark-Lois]

i personally feel that she did see them almost kiss. and then we'll find out later that Lana is a CLois shipper :p

[dalbajr]

I think Lana definitely saw the almost Clois kiss.
Here is why:
1. Clois was in her line of sight when they were going to kiss.
2. As she was hugging Chloe she looked right at Clark like she knew where he was.
3. Lana was in the dark but the lights were on Clois and it would have been impossible for her not to see Lois' orange dress.

It has also been said that if Lana saw them then she wouldn't have been so happy.
However, since Lana knows it is over with her and Clark I think she would be okay with him moving on. Let's not forget she was there for Chloe first. :)

[RedKRules]

I don´t think she saw it !!

[SVsleuth]

I re-watched the scene. I see no evidence that Lana saw Clark at all until after she was hugging Chloe & their eyes met from across the room. I think if she was meant to have seen it, the director would have given us a shot of her face, showing her reaction. As is, all we saw was Lana seeing Chloe & reacting with a huge smile.

Seems to me Chloe saw Lana immediately, and reacted with her "No way!" and Lana's attention went immediately to Chloe. Clark thought the "no way" was directed at him & Lois & pulled out of the moment, then looked to Chloe & then saw Lana.

And if she HAD seen it, I think it would have hurt Lana. Lana is still in love with Clark. She's chosen to go do whatever she's doing because she believes it is the best thing for Clark - maybe even for his very survival. She's chosen to give up her own desires, for the greater good of the world. She admits it was the hardest decision she ever had to make, but she believes it was the right thing to do. She's trying to be more like Clark, and do the right thing, rather than the thing that makes her personally happiest. It started when she chose Clark over Bizarro & continues in whatever it is she's been doing (which I believe is all about protecting Clark, so that he can be around to save the world.) So, if she saw it, I believe it would hurt. But, because Lana is now choosing to act selflessly, I think she would be inclined to encourage Clark to find someone who can be there for him to take care of his heart - because Lana sees her role as protector of his life - but Clark needs someone to take care of his heart as well. Lana has decided that she can't fill both rolls in his life, & has chosen to protect his life, since she finds herself in a unique position to be able to do that, & allow someone else to take care of Clark's heart. As a Clana fan I'm not eager to see Lana encourage Clark to move on to Lois, but I'm expecting it to happen.

[SnowBird]

Yes, Lana saw the Lois and Clark almost kiss like the spy she is becoming and didn't come out of the shadows until Chloe noticed her and spoke. Lana's smile was for Chloe but her mind was on Clark and who knows what she could have been thinking seeing L&C together. That could have been one of the reasons Lana told Clark they weren't meant to be together because she saw the evidence that Clark was moving on.

[rebecavaldez]

She had to have seen them I mean she was right there
and it would make it intresting if she tells Clark something about it...

[alejandrita439]

yeah.. that would be awesome..
i can see lana and clark talking about his feelings for lois in the next episodes :D