Who is right for Chloe?

[superman07]

Alright, so we see the love triangle between Davis, Chloe, and Jimmy develop further. Who is better for Chloe, Jimmy or Davis?

[lillie_poo_pod]

No one. I would have put Clark regardless of the poll but he's kinda sorta dead to me right now.

[LookUpDown]

Clark.

[SuperKyptonGirl13]

Clark

[redeem147]

Davis is a genetically engineered killing machine who's just gone a little bit stalkery. Jimmy's a good guy who loves Chloe. Such a difficult choice, but I'm going with Lana.

[lm1212]

No one on the show. Clark's meant for Lois, Jimmy a little 14 year old kid in the head, and Davis is a mass murderer. I like the Chlavis chemistry though :)

[Jade4813]

I'm pissed at Clark on Chloe's behalf and I'm not even a fan of Chlark. At all. But if they were ever gonna try to sell me on it, they just pretty much killed any chance of that ever happening.

*fumes*

I'm not even that much a fan of Chloe and I'm pissed on her behalf right now.

Between Jimmy and Davis, I can't decide. You know, Davis becomes Doomsday, and Jimmy's never really lit my fire. On the other hand, neither of them has ever wiped Chloe's memory without her consent. So, really...they're both faring much better this week in my eyes than Clark is.

[roccanater]

Maybe Jimmy. Maybe no one.

[Poyntz]

Clark ... or hell have her get together with Ollie that might be interesting LOL

[Clana4Life]

Wow, I guess I'm the only one to say Davis. Love Chlavis, although it doesn't seem like Chloe is reciprocating Davis' feelings at the moment.

[kkjdt]

Clark

[LoveHurts38]

Sweet Jimmy

[4Clana]

Jimmy <3

[TWLOVER03]

Oliver!
haha aww I like Davis and Jimmy
hating clark right now though

[Alexander III]

Lana

[Smallville6]

Jimmy! He's so sweet!

[msjade16]

I guess I'm part of the minority too cause I say Davis! I don't even care who he becomes anymore because he's just so frakking..... I don't even have a word. Especially in tonight's episode...... **swoon** I know..... I'm setting myself up for major heartbreak..... again.:(

Jimmy.... just.... NO! I have been here a dozen times, so no need to go there again.

Clark? I don't know anymore. I knew he was gonna do what he did when the spoilers came out, but still, he has NO. FRAKKING. RIGHT! So yeah, I'm gonna go with a no for him, because he's on my sh*t list right now.

So Davis it is!:D

[lois-in-disguise]

Of those two options, Davis. (Not looking at what he becomes)

Because he is giving her choices, and from what we`ve seen of him, he obviously cares for Chloe a lot.

Plus, Jimmy = still a teenager, trying to relive the glory years with the girl he lots his v-card to.

Props to whoever wrote Lana, that was well placed. Even if you were serious it lifted my mood from the one hour of crap I had just watched.

[isagill chlark fan]

clark

[oqllcksmallville]

jimmy + chloe , fit .
their just say homey & right for eacch other .
i think in a way davis could never be .
i love jimmy and i love chimmy ,
true love <3 .

[BOUROUX]

Clark

[Jade4813]

Honestly...I'm not trying to start anything by asking. This is a legit question.

For those people who are voting Clark after tonight's episode, I'm curious to know why. I mean, what he did in this episode was pretty craptastic, actually. Totally wrong. A violation of Chloe's wishes and he KNEW that. And he didn't have to do what he did; it wasn't to save her life.

So I'm curious if other people are able to be okay with what Clark did tonight in a way I'm just not able to be. I don't want to start a fight. I'm just curious, because I think he did a horrible, horrible thing.

[harryandginnyfanatic]

Well, Jimmy never killed anyone.

So he's one up on Davis.

[Dor el]

No like 'em Chimmy!

No like 'em Chlavis!

No like 'em Chollie, but Chollie is better than the other two.

[Jade4813]

Well, Jimmy never killed anyone.

So he's one up on Davis.

:lol: And, really, who HASN'T had to choose their boyfriend based off of who's killed the fewest people! ;)

[harryandginnyfanatic]

She's known Jimmy longer.

The attraction to Davis was because they both had something alien inside them.

[theotherJane]

I'd say Davis. But then again, he's not really boyfriend material since he's a killer. But then again so is Chloe. Yeah, never mind...scratch that. They're perfect for each other. ;)

[morena]

Honestly...I'm not trying to start anything by asking. This is a legit question.

For those people who are voting Clark after tonight's episode, I'm curious to know why. I mean, what he did in this episode was pretty craptastic, actually. Totally wrong. A violation of Chloe's wishes and he KNEW that. And he didn't have to do what he did; it wasn't to save her life.

So I'm curious if other people are able to be okay with what Clark did tonight in a way I'm just not able to be. I don't want to start a fight. I'm just curious, because I think he did a horrible, horrible thing.

I think Clark needs to understand what means Chloe as a secret keeper,
and now he will take this chance

[Meteror Freak]

Please vote for Jimmy!
Nobody treats Chloe better than he does!
Davis has barely known her at all, and he's already being touchy feely with her and putting her through guilt trips. Chloe never felt guilty when she was with Jimmy. She chose Jimmy over Clark, the man of her dreams. That should tell you how much she loves him. Just like she's said before, "Jimmy, YOU'RE my guy." and "Only you Jimmy, forever."

[SpiritedDiva]

I vote neither. Though I would Chlavis first before Chimmy. Pre dooms of course.

[morena]

Please vote for Jimmy!
Nobody treats Chloe better than he does!
Davis has barely known her at all, and he's already being touchy feely with her and putting her through guilt trips. Chloe never felt guilty when she was with Jimmy. She chose Jimmy over Clark, the man of her dreams. That should tell you how much she loves him. Just like she's said before, "Jimmy, YOU'RE my guy." and "Only you Jimmy, forever."


I like Jimmy away from Chloe


my vote over the 8 years has always been Clark

[msjade16]

Honestly...I'm not trying to start anything by asking. This is a legit question.

For those people who are voting Clark after tonight's episode, I'm curious to know why. I mean, what he did in this episode was pretty craptastic, actually. Totally wrong. A violation of Chloe's wishes and he KNEW that. And he didn't have to do what he did; it wasn't to save her life.

So I'm curious if other people are able to be okay with what Clark did tonight in a way I'm just not able to be. I don't want to start a fight. I'm just curious, because I think he did a horrible, horrible thing.

ITA!!!! I feel you 100%!

It was very wrong. A total violation and it very much did go against her wishes. So, no, I'm definitely NOT okay with it. But when those spoilers came out, I just knew it would happen so it lessened the blow a little for me, but he's still on my sh*t list for it.

[Jade4813]

The attraction to Davis was because they both had something alien inside them.

SO many highly inappropriate and more than slightly dirty jokes. SO little time. ;)

[dunkman]

Wow, I guess I'm the only one to say Davis. Love Chlavis, although it doesn't seem like Chloe is reciprocating Davis' feelings at the moment.

I was proud of Chloe for telling Davis off like she did. Jimmy's a great guy, & they'll have an even better relationship now that Chloe is no longer distracted by a guy with superpowers (does she remember Oliver, Victor, Dinah, John Jones, or Bart? That could get complicated). She knows Jimmy's her man & Davis is some guy she just met, & she doesn't even know he's a violent killer!

[double L]

She should go for the bad boy.

[dunkman]

Honestly...I'm not trying to start anything by asking. This is a legit question.

For those people who are voting Clark after tonight's episode, I'm curious to know why. I mean, what he did in this episode was pretty craptastic, actually. Totally wrong. A violation of Chloe's wishes and he KNEW that. And he didn't have to do what he did; it wasn't to save her life.

So I'm curious if other people are able to be okay with what Clark did tonight in a way I'm just not able to be. I don't want to start a fight. I'm just curious, because I think he did a horrible, horrible thing.

I understand why he did it, & I think it does bring us closer to the Superman story, but it was kind of similar to that time when some people in the JLA had Zatanna or somebody erase people's memories, & that made people--Batman & Green Arrow, in particular--pretty cranky! You know what I'm referring to? They might overlook it, but I'm thinking Oliver would give Clark a piece of his mind about Chloe's rights for this one!

[Storm45]

Please vote for Jimmy!
Nobody treats Chloe better than he does!
Davis has barely known her at all, and he's already being touchy feely with her and putting her through guilt trips. Chloe never felt guilty when she was with Jimmy. She chose Jimmy over Clark, the man of her dreams. That should tell you how much she loves him. Just like she's said before, "Jimmy, YOU'RE my guy." and "Only you Jimmy, forever."

I would believe that if I never saw Jimmy being constantly insecure about her relationship with Clark, spying on Chloe, making business with Lex behind her back which landed her in Black Creek as a lab rat, looking at Kara with lust with Chloe right by his side and the list could go on.
I'll add the plastic ring to the list. She deserved better than that.

So I'll choose Davis for now. Simply because unlike Chimmy, the idea of it is sexy, intersting and passionate. And Davis looks like a man.

[SteveS]

Honestly...I'm not trying to start anything by asking. This is a legit question.

For those people who are voting Clark after tonight's episode, I'm curious to know why. I mean, what he did in this episode was pretty craptastic, actually. Totally wrong. A violation of Chloe's wishes and he KNEW that. And he didn't have to do what he did; it wasn't to save her life.

So I'm curious if other people are able to be okay with what Clark did tonight in a way I'm just not able to be. I don't want to start a fight. I'm just curious, because I think he did a horrible, horrible thing.

Replay the episode again, he told you and I quite clearly his reasoning and rationale, accept or not as you wish. Chloe was not in a voting position, she was facing extinction, whether she loves ClarkMan, little Jimmy, or the monster-in-the-making.

Saving lives is what Superman does, so, if Chloe lives happily ever-after, she owes this one to ClarkMan.

[Jade4813]

I understand why he did it, & I think it does bring us closer to the Superman story, but it was kind of similar to that time when some people in the JLA had Zatanna or somebody erase people's memories, & that made people--Batman & Green Arrow, in particular--pretty cranky! You know what I'm referring to? They might overlook it, but I'm thinking Oliver would give Clark a piece of his mind about Chloe's rights for this one!

:lol: I actually almost referenced that in an earlier conversation. I know EXACTLY what you're talking about.

I don't know...I will say I thought it was sweet how worried Jimmy was for Chloe in this episode. But poor Davis with his little broken heart. Awwww...

[KSiteTV]

I think it's not fair that Clark's not a part of this poll, so I'm editing it. :P

[Alicia Chipy]

Between a monstrous mass murderer and a sweet but geeky twerp,I had to go with Jimbo.
Why wasn't George an option?

[SteveS]

Ah, George, forgot about him. Don't be surprised if George reappears by the end of the program.

[savingpeoplething]

I'm pretty sure "Abyss" made Chlark the OTP of the show. They are freaking EPIC and I just don't see how anyone else can compete with that in their lives.

[BadToad]

None of the above? And not because I think Jimmy and Clark aren't good guys. I just don't think they're right for Chloe. And the monster? Not so much.

Can we bring back that George guy for her? Maybe J'onn Jones could introduce them?

And to answer Jade


Honestly...I'm not trying to start anything by asking. This is a legit question.

And I'll be answering as a non-Chlarker bringing a non-shippy POV :D


For those people who are voting Clark after tonight's episode, I'm curious to know why. I mean, what he did in this episode was pretty craptastic, actually. Totally wrong. A violation of Chloe's wishes and he KNEW that. And he didn't have to do what he did; it wasn't to save her life.

For Clark, I absolutely believe he thought he was saving her life. Or, at least giving her back her life, and making things better for her. Was he wrong? Yes, probably. But did his decision come from a place of love and caring for Chloe? I don't know how anyone could deny that.

So, if I were a Chlark shipper, would I just be looking at the action, or would I be looking at the motivation for the action? Would I be asking myself if Clark did this for himself, or if he did it for Chloe? I think one can disagree with the action, be angry that happened, but still understand Clark's motivations, and not hate him for it (I would hope, anyway). It was Chloe herself who told Clark that he might need to play God, and so it came to pass. But was Clark doing what he did from a place of love and caring for Chloe? To me, thats the real question. And if the answer I came to was Yes (which BTW, it would be), then if I believed in Chlark, I'd still believe in Chlark.


So I'm curious if other people are able to be okay with what Clark did tonight in a way I'm just not able to be. I don't want to start a fight. I'm just curious, because I think he did a horrible, horrible thing.

OK, but let me ask you this Jade...you think Clark did a horrible, horrible thing. So, do you think Chloe's cousin should be with someone who would do such a horrible thing to her? If Clark is now unredeemable, and unshippable for Chloe, wouldn't he also be that for Lois?

Again, I'm coming at this as a non-shipper, getting into the head of a shipper. And I can understand why a person would still ship Chlark...if you believe that Clark did what he did out of love and concern for Chloe, and with a genuine desire for her safety and happiness. And I would think you would need to believe the same if you ship Clois.

JMHO :)

[harryandginnyfanatic]

Clark has done everything in his power to make sure Chloe will be happy....with someone else.

He doesn't think of her that way.

Davis has a thing for Chloe and Chloe is marrying Jimmy. Clark is not even a factor in this triangle.

[borednow]

I'm pretty sure "Abyss" made Chlark the OTP of the show. They are freaking EPIC and I just don't see how anyone else can compete with that in their lives.

You mean the whole memory rape thing is romantic?

[lovinredkclark]

imo doomy is right for chloe.
clark is not even an option, he doesn't see her that way, only as a friend.
jimmmy to just to boring for her.
doomy will bring her some excitement.

please dont bombard me with the hate.

[Jade4813]

OK, but let me ask you this Jade...you think Clark did a horrible, horrible thing. So, do you think Chloe's cousin should be with someone who would do such a horrible thing to her? If Clark is now unredeemable, and unshippable for Chloe, wouldn't he also be that for Lois?

I'm not saying he's irredeemable. I'm just royally pissed at the writers for doing this to Clark this year. I think they handled this entire situation badly, so I choose to ignore that it didn't happen.

Of course I recognize that Clark did it out of caring for Chloe. But...it was still wrong, and it makes me mad that the writers did it. I'm not burning Clark in effigy tonight. I'm burning the writers in effigy.

I get that they wanted to have Chloe forget Clark's secret, for whatever reason. But there are a dozen ways they could have done it without having Clark cross the line. Did he do it with the best of intentions? Absolutely. But having the best intentions doesn't mean that you always act as you should. That's why they say the road to hell is paved with just these sorts of things.

I'm mad at the writers, because I've loved how they've written Clark this year, and this just...GRRR! They didn't have to do this! Even having Clark take away her memories, they didn't have to make Chloe make it clear early in the episode that she'd never choose that!

They could have had Clark make that sacrifice without making it be against Chloe's wishes! They could have written it so that Chloe made a choice! But they didn't! And that makes me angry!

Unlike in "Reckoning" I didn't see what Clark did here as being for selfish reasons. I recognize that he did it out of caring and concern for Chloe. He absolutely did it with the best of intentions.

And what he did was still wrong.

It was wrong. And while I recognize that the motives behind it are sweet...again, I've said it before. There are a hundred memories I have that are painful. Hell, every memory of the night my father died. Finding him collapsed on the floor, insensible...when I know for a fact I was the one person he'd never have wanted to see that way. Standing in the hospital room holding my father's hand while he died. Holding the hand that was ice cold. Watching the tears roll down his forehead even though he wasn't there any longer. Watching as he gasped for air when his greatest terror in life was suffocating to death. Those are pretty terrible memories. I'm sure if my brother had the chance, he'd take those memories from me. And if I found out he did so, I'd be livid. I wouldn't hate him forever; I'm not sitting here setting fire to my little Clark voodoo doll. But it would still be wrong, and I'd still be mad at him for doing something he didn't have a right to do. Even if it was for the best of intentions. And those are memories I sometimes wish I could forget - which isn't something I seem to have in common with Chloe!

So I'm furious with the writers for having done what they did, and as soon as I can manage it, I'm going to pretend like this episode doesn't exist.

One can still like a character and not agree with all the choices he or she makes. One can also be angry with a character and not write him or her off.

I don't agree with what Clark did tonight, and I'm mad they had him do it. I think it reflected badly on him, which is something they didn't have to do - even if having Chloe forget his memories is what they were after.

[gogeta]

Clark. The guy is apart of her happy place, enuff said.

[Ayanne]

Sacrifices out of love. Clark! Tonight proves he is her soulmate, as she is his!! WOW!!

[BadToad]

One can still like a character and not agree with all the choices he or she makes. One can also be angry with a character and not write him or her off.

Well, yes, of course. And thats how a Chlarker can still want Chloe with Clark. And thats how a Cloiser could still want Clark with Lois, even if they disagree with what he did here with Chloe.

That was my point.

[Jade4813]

One more thing, Badtoad, that I forgot to mention.

Maybe it's because I've been doing a lot of scholarly research into the subject of duress lately, but the way I view it is that, whatever Clark's intentions and reasons for doing what he did, what he did was still wrong. Maybe there wasn't a right choice. Maybe there wasn't even a good choice. But what he did was wrong, so he made what he thought was the best choice under the circumstances. But now he should have to bear the consequences for that act, whatever those consequences may be.

Life sucks sometimes, it's true. Sometimes people make the best choices they can in a crappy situation, and sometimes there really is no "right" choice to make. It's like...in the paper I've been writing, I've analyzed a case before the ICTY where a guy had a gun put to his head and was told "Kill them or I kill you (and presumably your family)." There's no good answer there. There's no choice that isn't in some way a terrible choice to have made.

Scholars have looked at this, and a number of them have said that there was no good answer here. And that very likely, just about anyone in his situation would have done what he did (killed people who were going to be killed anyway to save his life and his family). But, still, that doesn't make what he did right, and it doesn't mean he doesn't have to bear the consequences of that choice.

I don't think it makes me a non-Clark fan to say that this is how I view the situation in "Abyss." Clark made a terrible choice. Whether he actually had to do what he did...is arguable, I think. That he thought that was what he had to do is less so. But he still did something wrong. And so he should have to bear the consequences of that choice.

Overall, I love Clark this year. But this...what he did...was wrong. And just because I'm a Clark fan, I'm not going to pretend like I think it's right. (I'm not saying you are; this comment is not directed at you.)

In all honesty, if I were Chloe, I'd have a very hard time getting past what was done to me. But, then again, I probably have a different perspective on it than most, as I've had someone take something from me that they didn't have a right to in the past. If I were Chloe, I'd have a hard time getting past what would feel like, to me, a violation. Maybe that wouldn't be entirely deserved, on my part, because Clark did make the choice he thought was right and it was for the best of intentions. But when are emotions ever entirely rational? ;)

----- Added 2 Minutes later -----


Well, yes, of course. And thats how a Chlarker can still want Chloe with Clark. And thats how a Cloiser could still want Clark with Lois, even if they disagree with what he did here with Chloe.

That was my point.

I get what you're saying. I guess I'm having a hard time with the idea just from Chloe's point of view. Not so much from a Chlark point of view, but from a Chloe point of view. If that makes sense. People love their ships, and they tend to love them even when they feel like they've been "ruined." I've seen a lot of posts on this lately. "They can trash ____ but ____ is always going to be my ship!" Perhaps for what it is now; perhaps for what it was; perhaps for what it could have been.

But from Chloe's perspective...I don't know. I'd have a hard time getting romantically attached to a guy who did that to me, even with the best of intentions. That's what I'm having a hard time getting my head around, I guess.

I'm not explaining it well, I don't think.

[marikology]

Still gotta go with Clark. We don't call him the BDA for nothing.

[hemmy]

Its not Clark.

[Mod Edit] .

[BadToad]

Jade, I'm not trying to dispute whether Clark was right or wrong, or any of that. And I'm not insinuating anyone is Clark fan, or not. I get where you're coming from :). All I wanted to address was how I, as a non-shipper (who is getting more militant by the second :lol:), could imagine someone who ships Chlark still shipping Chlark.

Personally, I wasn't a fan of the ep.


We don't call him the BDA for nothing.

And some of us don't call him names at all :D

[Jade4813]

Jade, I'm not trying to dispute whether Clark was right or wrong, or any of that. And I'm not insinuating anyone is Clark fan, or not. I get where you're coming from :). All I wanted to address was how I, as a non-shipper (who is getting more militant by the second :lol:), could imagine someone who ships Chlark still shipping Chlark.

Personally, I wasn't a fan of the ep.

Sorry! Didn't mean to make you militant, dear! :( Just indulging in some discussion that doesn't involve duress and...D'OH!! I can't get away from it! It's consumed my life!

I'm not a fan of this episode either, but I'm hoping that time, distance, sleep, and future revelations help it sit better with me.

[HeartChakraBabe]

Clark, duh. Though, right now I'd like nothing more than to bash him over the head with kryptonite.

[Iolanthe]

Jade4813, just wanted to let you know that your posts are well-written, well-thought-out, and generally excellent!

Great job of describing some of the things I had felt about Clark doing this to Chloe, but wasn't able to express.

Not only that, but you're managing to keep a respectful tone in what's turning into a very impassioned dispute.

Just wanted to give you props for excellent work so far!

[Black Panda]

:lol: And, really, who HASN'T had to choose their boyfriend based off of who's killed the fewest people! ;)

Oh shoot. I guess I should have voted for Jimmy. Oh well it can't be stopped now, Clark it is.

[Mr.Magic]

Davis is a genetically engineered killing machine who's just gone a little bit stalkery. Jimmy's a good guy who loves Chloe. Such a difficult choice, but I'm going with Lana.

:rotfl:

People who root for serial killers need to have their head examined, IMHO.

[Jade4813]

Its not Clark.

[Mod Edit] .

It doesn't have to happen for people to think that two people would be right for each other. Personally, I think Hugh Jackman is perfect for me, but though I sit by my phone with baited breath, the man has yet to call. *sad sigh*

----- Added 42 Seconds later -----


Jade4813, just wanted to let you know that your posts are well-written, well-thought-out, and generally excellent!

Great job of describing some of the things I had felt about Clark doing this to Chloe, but wasn't able to express.

Not only that, but you're managing to keep a respectful tone in what's turning into a very impassioned dispute.

Just wanted to give you props for excellent work so far!

Thank you! I do my best! :D

[BadToad]

Sorry! Didn't mean to make you militant, dear!

Oh no, you didn't. Don't worry. Its just, as a Clark fan, I always see Clark as the lesser half to most shippers, IMO


I'm not a fan of this episode either, but I'm hoping that time, distance, sleep, and future revelations help it sit better with me.

I hope so too :)

[Jade4813]

:rotfl:

People who root for serial killers need to have their head examined, IMHO.

:lol: I don't know...I've...rooted for Dexter before...but only when the bad guy really really deserved it! :o

[ginnyfan]

Right now I still say Jimmy. Despite being the first person she forgot he fought for her. Chloe trusted him and trusted her choice when she went to get the MRI. Jimmy wanted to help her when he thought... it was all over between them.

I ADORE what Davis said to her. I really do. *sigh* It was simply beautiful.

Clark just doesn't love Chloe the way she loves him. Jimmy declared his love. Davis declared his love. Clark and Chloe have a deep, deep friendship. That said... Clark's going to be so lonely now! It was so sad when Chloe didn't remember and he kept trying to jog her memory. She's been his secret keeper for so long. It just makes me teary. :(

[Violet-Shadow]

I voted for Jimmy. Because *sigh* I love Jimmy a little bit (especially after tonight's episode!). I think he's just amazing. *another sigh* I'm not sure how I feel about the Chimmy, honestly, but I want Jimmy to be happy. Plus, he's such a good guy...yeah, he and Chloe having a happily ever after would be nice...

[ginnyfan]

I voted for Jimmy. Because *sigh* I love Jimmy a little bit (especially after tonight's episode!). I think he's just amazing. *another sigh* I'm not sure how I feel about the Chimmy, honestly, but I want Jimmy to be happy. Plus, he's such a good guy...yeah, he and Chloe having a happily ever after would be nice...

I agree. I don't know if it will happen but I'm going to root for them until the bitter end. :D

[Jade4813]

Oh no, you didn't. Don't worry. Its just, as a Clark fan, I always see Clark as the lesser half to most shippers, IMO

Ah...I can see that. And I can see why that would drive you nuts.

Truth be told, I'm a gal who has to generally like both parties to ship them together. I don't always like what Lois and Clark do on the show, but I do still love them, particularly this season. I confess that in prior seasons I didn't like Clark so much...so when I shipped Clois, in my mind I had kind of a slightly older Lois with a slightly younger DCClark...sort of, the way I figured TWClark could be in the future, if he was written well, but not where he was at the moment. It wasn't that I didn't like TW as an actor. I just didn't like what they did with Clark for a while, and for a while, I just didn't see a light at the end of the tunnel because it didn't look like the old regime was even remotely interested in concentrating on Clark's characterization - so they sacrificed it for whatever story came along. They wanted him to act in a certain way, so he did...and it didn't matter what that did to his character. (They did this with just about everyone...*sigh* Poor Martha, but I give AoT props for mentioning how wrong it was.)

But I think TPTB have done a great job this year in letting Clark move forward, which was what I was afraid they'd never let him do. So now, when I ship, it's actually Clois as seen on Smallville. Because, honestly, if I don't like one of the people in the pair, why in the world would I want to see that person with the character I do like? Wouldn't make sense, at least not to me.

[Storm45]

:rotfl:

People who root for serial killers need to have their head examined, IMHO.

Thanks for the advice. Because for me Chimmy is the antithesis of everything I thought Chloe was:Passionate,sexy, adventurous, mature and womanly. At least I have a hint of that when she shares her scene with the monster. I see none of that with the dweeb she's gonna marry.

[lm1212]

The poll's results are ridiculously close :)

[Chiriru]

Clark, the scenes in the Talon said it all incase the fact that Clark was the memory she tried to save didn't.

Jimmy isn't the man she should be marrying who is whining about other men in her life, but Davis isn't suitable either because he keeps pushing his own agenda with her when she clearly doesn't want it.

I think out of the three, Clark is the only one who came out as a good guy - doing the wrong thing, completely, but a good guy. He's not trying to wedding crash, nor make a move on her before the wedding. He's not so uncomfortable with her best friends that he throws a tantrum when her memories are MIA and she needs someone accountable to stand up for her.

He's loosing her, but he's willing to so that way she'll be alive, safe, and happy. And that's heart wrenching, and the kind of guy I think she deserves. He's putting her needs, her happiness, her life above his own wants and desires. That's noble, and it puts him a huge cut above the rest.

[Genevieve]

Right now? After the episode I just saw? No one on that list. It's missing Oliver. :p

But I voted for Clark.

[Arwenstar]

Um. How about we vote for the man that has saved her, been her partner and her best friend? Yeah.

NOT a psychotic villain and a womanizing jerk. What kind of poll is this?

[Black Panda]

I'm pretty sure "Abyss" made Chlark the OTP of the show. They are freaking EPIC and I just don't see how anyone else can compete with that in their lives.
Yeah, it really seems like it laid out the framework for the message that you can't go back on all this history.



He's loosing her, but he's willing to so that way she'll be alive, safe, and happy. And that's heart wrenching, and the kind of guy I think she deserves. He's putting her needs, her happiness, her life above his own wants and desires. That's noble, and it puts him a huge cut above the rest.
All that is lovely but...


You mean the whole memory rape thing is romantic?
I think that crap is supposed to be misguided but noble. Really it's just stupid. They could have done better by Clark, and really should. Speeches about wanting to be a hero are swell, but let's pair that up with thinking things through logically. Superintellect... Any day now.


Jimmy isn't the man she should be marrying who is whining about other men in her life, but Davis isn't suitable either because he keeps pushing his own agenda with her when she clearly doesn't want it.
Jimmy I can forgive. He wants to do right. He's just kind of a jerk. Davis is scary screwed up.

[Storm45]

Um. How about we vote for the man that has saved her, been her partner and her best friend? Yeah.

NOT a psychotic villain and a womanizing jerk. What kind of poll is this?

How about we vote for whoever we want to vote?

Neither of the three choices are really right for me, including Clark as incredible as it may sounds. But as it was originally between Jimmy and Davis,I chose Davis.

I don't think we have to justify ourselves to others who only see their ship as the only one we should choose.

[Mr.Magic]

Thanks for the advice. Because for me Chimmy is the antithesis of everything I thought Chloe was:Passionate,sexy, adventurous, mature and womanly. At least I have a hint of that when she shares her scene with the monster. I see none of that with the dweeb she's gonna marry.

So, you want Chloe to become the Mallory to Davis' Mickey Knox?

Had to look the names up btw. I hate Natural Born Killers.

[Arwenstar]

How about we vote for whoever we want to vote?

I guess we are because the poll favors Clark.

[Jade4813]

From your avi, I would guess...Lex? ;) I don't mean to make assumptions, so if not, I apologize. I know there are some Chlexers on the board, though. *sighs* Ah, Chlex...IMO, it would have been far more interesting than Lexana. I do miss our bald billionaire sometimes.

[chlark-x]

such a difficult decision

after that episode i had to stay true to my one ship so i had to choose clark
but promising enough i think davis and chloe would be quite the couple and as for jimmy and chloe.. if they had to land her with any photographic geek im glad it was at least him

[Storm45]

From your avi, I would guess...Lex? ;) I don't mean to make assumptions, so if not, I apologize. I know there are some Chlexers on the board, though. *sighs* Ah, Chlex...IMO, it would have been far more interesting than Lexana. I do miss our bald billionaire sometimes.

Lex... Not after being soiled by Lexana. I should make a mental blockage of any moments where Lex acted like a puppy filled with Lanalove. I wished that KK left Smallville around season 4 before it happened.

But if he kept himself from kidnapping Chloe (like he did several times in the series) I might have seen it. It must be the alpha-male and alpha-female combo and the opposite attraction formula, that wins me over. I don't know how the writers back then would have handled it. Because I was never taken by any romances in this show.

That's what I think lacks with Chimmy. Its so unequal to me in term of intellect and spirit. I see Chloe with someone who keeps her toes and intrigues her while Jimmy is a more like a good little dog she must pet.


So, you want Chloe to become the Mallory to Davis' Mickey Knox?

Had to look the names up btw. I hate Natural Born Killers.

I think the distinction should be made between Davis and Dommsday. There's Davis, human looking, tortuous man and there's the monster we haven't really exposed to in Smallville. For now I like what I see between Chloe and Davis compared to what I see between Chloe and Jimmy/Chloe and Clark.

I said why I prefer Chlavis comapred to Chimmy. I'll say why I prefer Chlavis to Chlark: Mututal attraction. Chloe after years of being a third wheel, is pursued by someone. You can see Jimmy likes Chloe also but we never saw a real courtship. We heard that Jimmy slept with Chloe, he never called her back, Chloe regretted it, Jimmy and Chloe meet again, Chloe and Jimmy sucks face two episodes after. Not much anticiaption being build there.

[Jade4813]

Hey, nothing says true love like...a felony...? Okay, maybe not. ;)

Anyway, I've successfully managed to remember Lex without any Lanalove taint. Don't know how I've managed it, but that entire storyline just didn't happen in my brain. :D

[msjade16]

People who root for serial killers need to have their head examined, IMHO.

Well check me into the nearest hospital honey because I still vote Davis!:D

[Jade4813]

Well check me into the nearest hospital honey because I still vote Davis!:D

Ironically enough...you just might find Doomedic there! :D

[SalvadorianGirl]

Clark. Without a doubt Clark. There are just no words to describe my Chlarky heart here. No other person will ever be better for Chloe than Clark in my eyes. PS3 can throw me lines and other stuff. In the end, my heart knows that Chlark was the one and only.

[quiet_fractures]

Clark.

[marikology]

Thank you, Craig, for evening up the poll. It didn't take Clark long to catch up. :)


For those people who are voting Clark after tonight's episode, I'm curious to know why. I mean, what he did in this episode was pretty craptastic, actually. Totally wrong. A violation of Chloe's wishes and he KNEW that. And he didn't have to do what he did; it wasn't to save her life.

So I'm curious if other people are able to be okay with what Clark did tonight in a way I'm just not able to be. I don't want to start a fight. I'm just curious, because I think he did a horrible, horrible thing.

I understand what you mean, Jade, but I think the show did a good enough job of selling that it was a really bad, wrong decision. I honestly believe Clark *thinks* he's doing the right thing, that he's not playing God, because he thinks his secret is nothing but a burden, like a cancerous tumor, almost, that he had the opportunity to excise in order to save her life, even if it meant he will be truly alone. I guess I would be more upset if I thought it was permanent, and if I didn't think Clark will probably pay dearly for it.

I was joking in my BDA comment-- I love Clark all the time, warts and all. I don't think he's dumb, but he DOES do things without fully considering the ramifications, and Chloe told him this tonight.

[Storm45]

Hey, nothing says true love like...a felony...? Okay, maybe not. ;)

Anyway, I've successfully managed to remember Lex without any Lanalove taint. Don't know how I've managed it, but that entire storyline just didn't happen in my brain. :D

Lucky you!

Nothing say love like felony? Maybe yes, for Lex. He's twisted :lol:
But if Chloe and Lex were married Lex wouldn't have to go to mcuh leghts to kidnap her and Chloe won,t have to do much to snoop into his business. Its a match made in heaven!

I liked the Chlex scene in Kinetic. Chloe was acting like a bulldozer while interviweing Lex and she saw through his BS. But she became a puddle of goo whe Lex looked at her and said he was lookking forward to resume their verbal judo. He also made a quote and Chloe recognized it was from benjamin Franklin. Charming scene. I see the appeal of this ship. Both smart, literate, same interests, mature, both marrying people who are lesser than they are (Okay, I'll try to forget it).

[MeKa]

For all intents and purposes it's Clark. The memory wipe notwithstanding. I guess it's Clark's turn to let Chloe go. For now.

[chlarkfan333]

Clark, of course. :D

[msjade16]

Ironically enough...you just might find Doomedic there! :D

**Rushes off to hospital to find Doomedic**
**Damn..... stops for directions**

"Excuse me, sir? Can you please tell me how to get to Met Gen? I'm in dire need of a Doomedic!"
"Met what? And what the hell's a Doomedic?"
"Metropolis General..... Doomsday/Paramedic.... Duh!!!!"
"Okaaaayyyyy...... And where's that?"
"Dude are you high?...... Metropolis, of course!" What is he on?
Stranger scratches head. "Metropolis? Like, in Illinois?"
"No! Like, in Kansas! Couple hours from Smallville?" What is this, does he know nothing?
Stranger scratches head some more. "Smallville?"
Arrrgghhh! "Nevermind!"

**Speeds off to find that tv remote repair man from "Pleasantville"**


Uhhhmm..... if only. Though I don't think he'd take any interest in me, since he seems to only have eyes for Chloe. **weeps** (for a sec) then **swoon**:D:p

[davidbrenton]

Wow. I think the love is much more special and meant to be as a deep friendship. I honestly can't understand the Chlark boat on a romantic front.

Davis is my vote.

[Chlois Supporter]

I chose Clark, but not for the reasons some people might think.

Yes, Clark erased Chloe's memories. He did so to protect her, to let her have a life without him, where she's happy and isn't focused on helping him be what he needs to be.

I see this akin to Superman II. Superman removed Lois' memories of his secret identity. He did so because he realized he could never be with her, and her having that knowledge, and having to hold it in everyday for the rest of her life, would have broken her in two. So he made the decision, to take that burden away from her by kissing her and making her forget about his identity.

There is a precedent, in the Superman Mythos for this sort of thing, and while I may not agree that it was right for Clark to do so without Chloe's permission, anymore than it was right for Superman to do so without Lois' I understand why it was done in both cases, and I support both characters in their decisions.

Clark/Superman has always been about putting others before himself. In this case, he placed Chloe's future and well being, again his own happiness. He was happy with Chloe knowing his secret because it gave him someone to talk to, to share himself with, all of himself, without fear. And he made the choice to give up that happiness, because it was hurting Chloe knowing that much. He made the decision every hero must face, the choice to do the right thing, even when it hurts you.

[AgentChaos]

Honestly, all 3 choices kind of suck right now. The womanizing dork who sold Chloe out to Lex, the budding serial killer with stalkerish tendencies, or the mind-raping reckless BDA.

[Bizarrolover]

Jimmy, he's the only human of the lot. :rotfl:

More seriously, I think Clark and Chloe together (romantically) would be extremely boring to watch, they care about each other but there's no passion, just friendship. Just my opinion.

[BabyDee]

Hmm...

I'm hatin' Clark right now for the mindrape, Jimmy is a douche, and Davis (much as I love him!) is a Monster in a Meatsuit. My vote: Oliver!:D

[BadaBingBadaBoomsday]

Hmm...

I'm hatin' Clark right now for the mindrape, Jimmy is a douche, and Davis (much as I love him!) is a Monster in a Meatsuit. My vote: Oliver!:D

Totally agree. Clark obviously doesn't love her if he mindrapes herself of him. I know hes doing it for her own good, but he just cancelled his pulling power on her. Hes no chance now. She even thinks Jimmy is more matcho!:lol:

Davis just gives me the heeby jeebies. My vote for Ollie:D

----- Added 2 Minutes later -----

I think I can officially say Chlark is over. *sob, sob* We have to admit it sometime. His secret was the reason they were so special together. With that gone they're just another ordinary couple.:mad:

[BabyDee]

Totally agree. Clark obviously doesn't love her if he mindrapes herself of him. I know hes doing it for her own good, but he just cancelled his pulling power on her. Hes no chance now. She even thinks Jimmy is more matcho!:lol:

Davis just gives me the heeby jeebies. My vote for Ollie:D

----- Added 2 Minutes later -----

I think I can officially say Chlark is over. *sob, sob* We have to admit it sometime. His secret was the reason they were so special together. With that gone they're just another ordinary couple.:mad:

Oh, I don't think its over. I just don't see how that can be the end of it; there are too many loose ends to consider. But that's a discussion for another thread! :)

[FlashInSV]

Maybe a fourth guy that she'll meet in Offscreenville?

[margroks]

Obviously Clark IS an option since recent events have shown Chloe and Clark have deep feelings for each other and are being forced apart by desperate circumstances. Chloe would NEVER have said yes to JO had she not been mind-raped by Brainiac and it also looked like JO wanted to retract his proposal. Chloe and JO share nothing special and are not a couple who share anything beyond a rather forced friendship; the entire wedding scenario is insane and only the result of Brainiac's machinations and, let's face it, very bad writing.

As for Dooms, honestly, he is a murdering monster who will one day kill Clark; that is not the kind of person Chloe should be with. Any supposed attraction is obviously Brainiac's manipulation of her. Why would I want to see Chloe with the creature who kills people and has his sights set on Clark? That doesn't compute at all for me.

Clark IS the only clear choice considering what we've just seen; nothing else makes any sense to me.

[OliviaB]

After that episode, it's TOTALLY Clark.

Jimmy is her rebound, has been from the very first time they met and Davis is a mirror of Clark, someone she is deeply attracted too.

----- Added 47 Seconds later -----


Oh, I don't think its over. I just don't see how that can be the end of it; there are too many loose ends to consider. But that's a discussion for another thread! :)

I don't think it's over either. You don't send the Legion back a 1000 years and not have Chlark back in that episode. I just think we're going to see how much Clark realizes he needs Chloe in his life after this.

[unex||den||adel]

I don't think it's over either. You don't send the Legion back a 1000 years and not have Chlark back in that episode. I just think we're going to see how much Clark realizes he needs Chloe in his life after this.
yay!! ITA

[Billy Jor-El]

The scene of the childhood kiss only emphasizes that Chloe has always cared for Clark. They could be the perfect couple, if Clark was capable of it. As he's not, I can't vote for anyone on the list; I'll go with Shelby.

[Bizarrolover]

We forgot about the guy from Apocalypse! Chloe really looked happy with him.

[Mummbles]

This episode made me like Chimmy. The reason I hated Chimmy was because Jimmy was so worried about Chloe having feelings for Clark rooted in Chloe knowing his secret, now she doesn't so Jimmy has nothing to worry about. Thus making me like Jimmy, because now we won't get 'U LIEK CLARK' Jimmy and instead get a likeable Jimmy. So I guess Chloe forgetting the secret means that she gets to play happy roles without the weight of the world on her shoulders and Jimmy won't be paranoid about Clark.

I think Chimmy can actually work now. Plus Clark removed the knowledge of his secret to allow Chloe to live happily with Jimmy, if she doesn't then it makes the whole motion meaningless.

[Dor el]

For those people who are voting Clark after tonight's episode, I'm curious to know why. I mean, what he did in this episode was pretty craptastic, actually. Totally wrong. A violation of Chloe's wishes and he KNEW that. And he didn't have to do what he did; it wasn't to save her life.

So I'm curious if other people are able to be okay with what Clark did tonight in a way I'm just not able to be. I don't want to start a fight. I'm just curious, because I think he did a horrible, horrible thing.

I understand where you're coming from and agree to some extent. To a large extent actually. But consider this: I'm Okay with what Clark did. Perhaps it wasn't necessary at that moment in time to save her life, but by doing what he did, Clark hoped to prevent Chloe from getting into a life threatening situation in the future because of his secret as has happened in the past. Had Chloe not known Clark's secret, she would likely not have gotten herself into the position of being Brainiac's vessel. It was kind of forward thinking maybe. Also, someone who is drunk may not want you to take his/her car keys at that exact moment, but in the long run by taking those car keys, the drunk's life may be saved in the near or distant future. I truly do not believe that Clark would intentionally hurt Chloe. He did know that Chloe was Okay with knowing his secret. But, Clark has some rights too. Clark was not okay with Chloe knowing his secret, a secret by the way that Clark did not willingly share. It was stolen from him by Alicia. So, Chloe was kind of the recipient of stolen goods.

Clark tries to play by the rules in most instances. But, where moral dilemmas arise, Clark faces tough choices; tougher choices than humans will have to face. Sometimes, he has to make calls that clearly some of us do not agree with. I have faith that Clark will get it right...eventually.

Everything's good; or it will be.

[Hoshi_Reed]

Honestly...I'm not trying to start anything by asking. This is a legit question.

For those people who are voting Clark after tonight's episode, I'm curious to know why. I mean, what he did in this episode was pretty craptastic, actually. Totally wrong. A violation of Chloe's wishes and he KNEW that. And he didn't have to do what he did; it wasn't to save her life.

So I'm curious if other people are able to be okay with what Clark did tonight in a way I'm just not able to be. I don't want to start a fight. I'm just curious, because I think he did a horrible, horrible thing.

Well, it would be like not voting Neo/Trinity after watching the scene where Neo dies. Each episode is not stand alone, like good story telling, it is just a small piece of the grander puzzle. If Clark were to have an epiphany about his secret and Chloe without having gone through a story arc of realization then it would be a lightswitch.

It is like how in Stargate Atlantis they slowly built the Teyla arc. First they showed she could sense the Wraith, then it moved to her learning why was because she had Wraith DNA, then she got to control a queen, her boyfriend also had the gene and when she was pregnant she was more powerful, until finally a Wraith hybrid named Michael wanted to exterminate humans and wraith and intended to use the baby to do so. All the while, we got the story of Michael and how he was originally a Wraith that got turned human twice by the human Atlantis crew and being betrayed by his own kind and ended up as neither with a grudge against both races.
Each sub-story was a building block to help understand the next outcome and the next.

There is rhyme and reason for the things we see. Trust the story is the Chlois motto and I don't see why I should abandon it now.

[vikingjedi]

I tried to buy into the EdLois but it just isn't right. She's taking Chloe's life. After everything Chloe has been through she's supposed to be with Clark.

[Sweetie]

Jimmy who really loves her and could be trully happy with him.

[AChloeChick]

Most definitely NOT Jimmy. Never has been and NEVER will be.

[Kalista]

Jimmy was a selfish jerk who was still harping on the Clark issue while his fiancee was scared and suffering from memory loss.

She didn't select which memories to lose, yet the jerk is criticizing her saying she forgot him but remembered Clark. Way to show compassion loser.

He is completely unworthy of Chloe.

[ginnyfan]

Jimmy was completely selfless and fought hard for Chloe the whole episode even though he was completely in the dark about her powers and lowest on Chloe's totem pole of men she remembers. If anyone acted selfishly it was Clark. Yes his intentions were good but he went against Chloe's wishes.

[Sue Denim]

Clark.

Thank you for adding Clark in Craig.

[Kalista]

Whatever. I'm not interested in hearing any defense of Jimmy. She was in the damn barn, scared out of her mind and he couldn't stop going on about why she could remember Clark and not him.

She didn't have any say in the people she could remember.

But I totally get why its desirable for Chimmy to be the real deal.

[ms.c.]

I needed another option: Superman.

Jimmy is too demanding.
Dooms is too evil.
Clark isn't appreciative enough.

ETA: Also thanks Craig for adding in Clark at least as an option. No wonder Dooms and Jimmy got 20 votes apiece before Clark was included. There wasn't much competition.

[superman07]

I didn't put Clark as an option because I knew how many people like them together and thought it would make the thread pointless, but alot of people have voted for Jimmy and Davis too and lots of opinions so no hard feelings.

[Iluvgreen]

I'm definately a Chimmy shipper. I'm pissed at Davis right now I cant even think because he kissed her and told her not to marry the perfect person for her. Darn Davis. :mad:

[TWNik]

Clark. That is undeniable, for me.

[AChloeChick]

I'm definately a Chimmy shipper. I'm pissed at Davis right now I cant even think because he kissed her and told her not to marry the perfect person for her. Darn Davis. :mad:

I'm PISSED that Chloe is actually going through with her marriage to Jimmy, despite any lingering questions and/or attraction she has for Davis.

So to me, Davis is very much a hero right now. I feel like he's speaking on my behalf and a lot of others about Jimmy and her marriage to him. I'm glad he laid it on the lie with/for Chloe. As for the kiss, it was an added bonus!

As for who is right for Chloe, IF Davis could be totally separated from anything to do with Doomy, I would say Davis. Heck, I'll say Davis is much better for Chloe than Jimmy ever has been or could be.

Sorry, that's just the way I see it. I hate Chimmy with a passion.

Clark, as much as I LOVE Chlark and think they'd be perfect, Clark is NEVER going to come around when it comes to Chloe. IMO, he such and idiot! His BDA still holds.

[chlo-el]

The thing with Davis even though now he has found out about his orgins he is still a good guy by choice. If he was really a bad guy he would have took advantage of Chloe when she only remebered him. Sigh.

And he was being a stand up guy with Jimmy seeing that he loved Chloe and was ready to back off but when she only rmebered him he saw that he couldn't let her go. Sigh.

Is it still possible that the genetically assembled creature was put inside him or something?

Sigh.

I loved how Davis said he would wait for her. I didn't get Chloe's reasons. All I heard was her saying how amazing he was and then my TV went all fuzzy.

The kiss was awesome.

And for me if not Davis, if he's Doomed to be Doom and only Doom, then I'm going with George you know AU guy from Apocolyse she was engadged to. Because they were both created w/ basically the same idea for her to end up with someone simular to Clark but not quite him.

But Jimmy IDK their cute together. And sometimes I love him and sometimes I hate him but I just don't see them being together forever. I don't see them ending up together. Even though their getting married I still don't get it.

[MetroGirl06]

None of them. Chloe deserves a kick ass guy that a) doesn't use her for a crutch and doesn't wipe her memories, b) isn't a killing machine, c) someone she can easily surpass.

[Vindellavon]

I hate BDA right now, and priabably will throughout the hiatus, but I'd be lying if I said he wasn't the right one for her. Twisted logic. *sighs*

[Krypton935]

Clark all the way!

[lanalang1018]

None of them.

[borednow]

Jimmy! Her choice, her love, the man who makes her feel the like she's special wonderful and worthy of being adored. :D

[ginnyfan]

Jimmy! Her choice, her love, the man who makes her feel the like she's special wonderful and worthy of being adored. :D

Yay! I agree. :D

[Kevin24]

I still can't believe so many people are picking Davis. After last night he went into creepy mode and never left that mode. He was hella weird and scary. I expected him to attack Chloe to force her to be with him.

Am I the only one who was creeped out by his behavior last night?

[ginnyfan]

I still can't believe so many people are picking Davis. After last night he went into creepy mode and never left that mode. He was hella weird and scary. I expected him to attack Chloe to force her to be with him.

Am I the only one who was creeped out by his behavior last night?

He was SO creepy when he was in Chloe's head. She took his hand and I thought "!!!."

Then when she ran to him for help after losing her memories. I thought, "Where's Clark! Even if he has to tap her on the head an knock her out I want her away from Davis!"

Once Chloe was safe, I could enjoy the sexy. :D

[SteveS]

Apparently, ClarkMan is still the choice for Chloe by a wide majority. Good thinking. And of course, the reverse is true, Chloe is the best for Clarkman.

[ColdPlay3r]

none

[Estro-gen X]

I voted Jimmy but I think none of them really fit.

[zHeN_zHeN]

Hmm... none of them.

Clark -- There's no future there (ahem, Lois).

Jimmy -- He's just... blah.

Davis -- well, they definitely have chemistry and they look really good together, but it's not going to work out especially since he's a monster and everything. :p

Chloe should be with that policeman from "Apocalypse". They looked so happy and cute together. I guess she's into the hero types.

Speaking of hero types, I could also see her with Oliver. Maybe she could tame him and become stinking, filthy rich at the same time. Hah. ;)

Anyway, I just hope she finds the right guy. She deserves it.

[Ayanne]

Apparently, ClarkMan is still the choice for Chloe by a wide majority. Good thinking. And of course, the reverse is true, Chloe is the best for Clarkman.

Abyss competely established that. Chlark belong together. He is her happy place, & she is his soulmate.

[zHeN_zHeN]

Abyss competely established that. Chlark belong together. He is her happy place, & she is his soulmate.
Really. How did you come up with that conclusion? :confused:

[Violet-Shadow]

Jimmy! Her choice, her love, the man who makes her feel the like she's special wonderful and worthy of being adored. :D

YES! I completely agree!!!

[Ayanne]

Really. How did you come up with that conclusion? :confused:


I watched the connection established over the past 7 years. Did you not see the flashbacks in Abyss? The SUPERMAN symbol connected to the Vessel kiss.

Chlark are not made of lightswitches, retcons or contrived.

[Estro-gen X]

I watched the connection established over the past 7 years. Did you not see the flashbacks in Abyss? The SUPERMAN symbol connected to the Vessel kiss.

Chlark are not made of lightswitches, retcons or contrived.

or contrived what?
I think you are reading too much into a random S symbol that was one of many shown in that sequence. He will end up with Lois (or Wonder Woman but thats something else way beyond Smallville's scope).
Please don't set your heart on this, I'd hate to see it broken like a lot of other chlarkers on the forum. Personally I never got attached as I only really got 'into' the show in season 5 when Clois was going strong (as far as anvils) but I'd hate to see everyone let down by what seems the inescapable outcome.:)

[dru-zod2501]

I can't say Clark this season, and Jimmy (laughs hysterically before puking).

Davis is the man this season!

even though he's bad, he makes it looks SOOOOO good!! As someone else said elsewhere, I want Davis to kill Clark already, then take Chloe and have lots of angry! sex with her

[Becc]

I voted Jimmy- not because I like them best together (I actually prefer Davis) but the poll said who was better for Chloe and in my opinion that has to be Jimmy he certainly doesn't come with all the excessive baggage that Davis and Clark do.

[KrissO]

Strange isn't it. We all know Clark is destined for Lois... yet the majority, even myself voted Chloe + Clark :D To be honest I hope the Davis / Jimmy things ****s up everything and finally may open a possibility for a Chlark (which we've really never had, only just)

[abbaspice1]

This is soo funny.

One minute people are bashing Clark for allowing Chloe's memories about his powers to remain forgotten, accuse him of MIND-RAPE, then they run over here and proclaim that Clark is the man for Chloe!!!!
ROTFLOL:rotfl::rotfl::rotfl:ROTFLOL!!!!

Actaully I'm not sure if it is vary sad or very funny!

[Billy Jor-El]

Well, if he wouldn't act as a mind-rapist, he'd be the man for Chloe.

Oh, yeah, Chloe and Clark get married. Clark forgets a wedding anniversary, Chloe lays into him...."Dammit, Clark, you forgot our anniversary!!!" **Z A P ! ! ** "Chloe, our what?" "What?" "What?"

[cousteau]

Are we really asking if a genetically engineered weapon of destruction is a good match for chloe? o0

[Vindellavon]

Are we really asking if a genetically engineered weapon of destruction is a good match for chloe? o0

At least the monster/machine loves the pretty blonde. BDA is still in denial.

[cousteau]

At least the monster/machine loves the pretty blonde. BDA is still in denial.

...but he's a kryptonian weapon of mass destruction that will eventually kill her and superman.

[IcedSun]

Chloom all the way!

[cousteau]

Chloom all the way!

...o0 chloom?

[IcedSun]

...o0 chloom?

Chloom/Chlavis whatever :rolleyes:

[cousteau]

Chloom/Chlavis whatever :rolleyes:

...chlavis?

[BlueDiamond]

...but he's a kryptonian weapon of mass destruction that will eventually kill her and superman.

I don't know if he'll kill her. More likely he would try to hold her hostage in his new black Fortress forever.

Even after what he did, Clark is still the best one for Chloe.

[sailordom]

Add me in the column of "wants another option."

Because none of them are good.

I don't want to see Chloe with any of the choices.

OK, fine, I voted for Davis. See how bad it is? The guy with a serial-killer monster inside of him got my vote! :D

[borednow]

Davis scares her
Clark did nothing but make her cry
Jimmy makes her laugh, smile, and believe in herself

Jimmy is the one!

[ginnyfan]

Davis scares her
Clark did nothing but make her cry
Jimmy makes her laugh, smile, and believe in herself

Jimmy is the one!

I agree!

Jimmy was the first to notice and care that Chloe was spending all of her time working or helping Clark with his whatever... He endeavored, successfully, to inject joy into Chloe's life. For that I will always love Jimmy and Chimmy. And I think Chloe will too... come what may.

[Tricky]

Jimmy, although iv never really taken to Chloe and Jimmy, it seems Clark and Chloe's relationship has ventured too far into the 'Friend Zone', and for Davis.....well lets not go there atm, lol.

[Cyn]

I voted Davis, but that was just because there was only Jimmy, Davis or Clark to choose from. I really think Bruce Wayne or Oliver Queen would be better suited for someone of Chloe's intellect.

[dimeo782002]

Alright, so we see the love triangle between Davis, Chloe, and Jimmy develop further. Discounting Clark as an option(Sorry Chlarkers don't hate me) Who is better for Chloe, Jimmy or Davis?

Mod Edit: Not fair that Clark's not a part of this poll, so I'm adding him. Keep in mind that both Jimmy and Davis had 20 votes or so apiece before Clark was added. - Craig

love ya craig ! thats sweet !

in another life chloe and clark should have been. we all know how the mythology of superman is when it concerns love. but look what they did in superman returns. lois is with someone else. so if they can do it in the movies.... anyway my vote is still clark she deserves his love and he desreves hers.

[borednow]

Love, come lighten my load
Love, come lighten my load
An empty heart is the heaviest weight to hold
Love, come lighten my load

Who do you love?
Who do you love?
Ask yourself, free yourself
Every love is one Love...

[zorasuperman]

i also feel that it should be davis. he is someone who would take care of chloe and treat he good. not that jimmy doesnt. he also does a good job. just that doomsday is better.
guess im also in the minority
lol clark is good for everyone; who wouldn't want someone as "honorable, and upstanding as clark kent someday". everyone knows that clark "is worth the wait".

[Lilisullivan]

Chimmy is painful to watch, Chloom only exists because of brainiac, that's why they are attracted to each other, although i have to say the chemistry between those two actors is palpable, so i would have to say Clark or Ollie :)

[luthorian]

def. Davis they fell for each other immediately

[umm]

Davis is a near perfect match, near perfect being the part where he is an evil monster sent to earth do destroy Kal-El and conquer earth!
Jimmy is a sweethart, but a dull sweethart at times and a relationship of any kind and duration with him won't offer Chloe, who is uniquely different and independant of societyconventions, anything what she needs and imagines in a lifemate!
Oliver and A.C have the bagage of being involved with her cousin...
Victor is a computer geek so there would be a connection..., but it's still not a perfect fit, same goes for A.C!
Pete is like a big brother so that's a no-no....
Clark, as his latest actions has proven it, dosn't deserve her, so who else could there be?

Ah yes, Bruce Wayne/Batman, as darkly handsome as Davis, as broody as Clark if not more, but a human hero like Oliver, which thus makes his commitment to saving the world even more greater than Clark's, Victor's, Bart's, or A.C's!
So either Bruce or Gerge the cop, who again is a hero! I mean even in an alternate universe, besides Smallville that is, Chloe is drawn to heros! So why denie her her hero?????

[theartist27]

I don't think any man on this show is the right man for Chloe. I like Jimmy, but I don't believe they're right for each other. Davis is well, definitely not right for her. As for Clark, well he eventually ends up with Lois, so he's not right for her. At the moment, I'd say that the right man for Chloe in the eyes of the writers is Jimmy, but as I've said before, I completely disagree.:\

[Sweetie]

Chlex was always a good match for me.I know he's not there right now but,may be he'll return if there's a 9th season.Jor-El erased her memories may be she'll forget about Lex who has a connection to Clark's secret.

[Black Panda]

One minute people are bashing Clark for allowing Chloe's memories about his powers to remain forgotten, accuse him of MIND-RAPE, then they run over here and proclaim that Clark is the man for Chloe!!!!
One, you need to consider the other options. Sure, I'd pick Nightwing any day (now that he's safe from the writers). He too has done things I think misjudged.

Two, Clark seems to have done it out of misguided love. In general I'm OK with Clark. He just seems a little dumb sometimes. A partnership with a capable woman seems like the best hope to get him on track.

[thehenry89]

IDK someone who's actually interested in a relationship with her, and isn't a blood thirsty montster. :rolleyes:

[borednow]

IDK someone who's actually interested in a relationship with her, and isn't a blood thirsty montster. :rolleyes:

You mean Jimmy? The guy she says she loves most and wants to marry?

... Who'd thunk...

[AndiGirl]

I'm pissed at Clark on Chloe's behalf and I'm not even a fan of Chlark. At all. But if they were ever gonna try to sell me on it, they just pretty much killed any chance of that ever happening.

*fumes*

I'm not even that much a fan of Chloe and I'm pissed on her behalf right now.

Between Jimmy and Davis, I can't decide. You know, Davis becomes Doomsday, and Jimmy's never really lit my fire. On the other hand, neither of them has ever wiped Chloe's memory without her consent. So, really...they're both faring much better this week in my eyes than Clark is.

:lol: oh...I love you Jade! haha. You crack me up.
It's ok...you go right ahead and get mad for us chlarkers! ;)

I agree, what Clark did was shady. I' trying to cope with it, and come to terms with the fact that he was trying to save her in the long run. But then again....it's still there and as low as ever. So I dont know.

I really wish Davis wasnt Doomsday...because he's frankly perfect for her. I would even want him with her more then I would want Clark. It's obvious that if clark hasnt felt the love by now towards chloe he never will. Davis....he wanted her from the start, and he wanted her bad. I want that kind of love for Chloe. One thats on fire and intense...but still sweet and caring at the same time. Jimmy, never had the fire.

So I guess my answer would be none of these men? :\ Unless the writers manage to separate Dooms and Davis...I think none of these guys deserve Chloe.

[Storm45]

Looking at the choices I'll say that there's nothing wrong with being single.

Most of the time I feel that Smallville is pushing the idea that you absolutely have to be someone, anyone to feel whole and happy.
Characters like Lana seems to be unable to spend some time without a love interest, evil or not (''At least Bizarro loved me. Boo hoo''), Chloe because she didn't have a BFfor a while is mocked because of it, Lex thought that getting married once or twice would help solve is major issues (Instead of consulting a good psychiatrist), Lois moans about not finding the right man as if she was in the verge of being an old maid (Instead of worrying about her career-life without diplomas) and Clark moans about not being able to have a soulmate since he's in high school.

Mythos characters who are supposed to be notorious for who they are in the comics are promoted in Smallville as ''love interests'' (Green Arrow and Aquaman for Lois, Jimmy Olsen and Doomsday for Chloe...)

The characters aren't even 25 and they are either angsting about finding the right one, getting engaged, married and divorced.

[Mars Investigations]

It used to be Clark...now it's Davis.

[Nimkong]

before Abyss-Clark hands down!
after Abyss- Jimmy, why not, she has nothing better to do anymore. No reporting, no justice league go to girl, no I'm your best friend and I'll die defending your secret. Nothing, she might as well at least still be Jimmy's fiance'. At least that is something.

[Welling_is_pretty]

I think the best person for Chloe is Clark. Davis is ok in his human form but he's also Doomsday so he's out. Jimmy is sweet and supportive and it's tempting to say him but he doesn't understand her like Clark does.

Clark challenges Chloe, he brings out the best side of her and he is her equal in many ways (and in many ways she's his superior). I've always contended that Chloe is the best partner (romantic or otherwise) that Clark could ever have. That Chloe is the blending of the best of both Lana and Lois into one blond spitfire. That makes her the best for Clark, IMO. But I also believe that he's the best for her.

[SteveS]

I think the best person for Chloe is Clark. Davis is ok in his human form but he's also Doomsday so he's out. Jimmy is sweet and supportive and it's tempting to say him but he doesn't understand her like Clark does.

Clark challenges Chloe, he brings out the best side of her and he is her equal in many ways (and in many ways she's his superior). I've always contended that Chloe is the best partner (romantic or otherwise) that Clark could ever have. That Chloe is the blending of the best of both Lana and Lois into one blond spitfire. That makes her the best for Clark, IMO. But I also believe that he's the best for her.

Good on you, we are in sync.:)

[OneShotClois]

Honeslty in my own opinion, none of these guys are best for Chloe.

[abbaspice1]

One, you need to consider the other options. Sure, I'd pick Nightwing any day (now that he's safe from the writers). He too has done things I think misjudged.

Two, Clark seems to have done it out of misguided love. In general I'm OK with Clark. He just seems a little dumb sometimes. A partnership with a capable woman seems like the best hope to get him on track.

One, I did consider the other options. And Jimmy is the best one, IMO. He is sweet and caring and truly loves her. So don't tell me I didn't consider the other options, okay?

Two, did I name you specifically? Are you one of those who BASHED Clark, called him a mind-rapist (I hate the term rapist. I have a close family member was a victim and I hate how people use that term so loosely around here), and then ran over here to say he is best for her? If not, don't you think that is a bit odd to do? Be honest.

"He let my memories stay gone. People who claim that they love me called him a rapist. Yet they think he is PERFECT for me!" :rolleyes:

[svtwamedfan05]

Jimmy

[SnowBird]

Jimmy...I'm not a big fan of those two together but Jimmy is better for Chloe between the three choices. He really is attentive and does those sweet extras for her. If Jimmy isn't with Chloe in the end, he will still make some lucky girl a good husband.

[disciples of zod]

sorry everyone, i'm 10000% for CHIMMY! GIMME CHIMMY!

~K

[RedKalEL]

Its not Clark.

[Mod Edit] .

agreed

[SteveS]

2-to-1 odds that the Chloe-Jimmy relationship does not last

[Lazy Boy]

Davis scares her
Clark did nothing but make her cry
Jimmy makes her laugh, smile, and believe in herself

Jimmy is the one!

:rotfl:err....no.
Davis - as long he is not being Doomsday, he fine for her.

[Novak Fan]

Looking at the choices I'll say that there's nothing wrong with being single.

Most of the time I feel that Smallville is pushing the idea that you absolutely have to be someone, anyone to feel whole and happy.
Characters like Lana seems to be unable to spend some time without a love interest, evil or not (''At least Bizarro loved me. Boo hoo''), Chloe because she didn't have a BFfor a while is mocked because of it, Lex thought that getting married once or twice would help solve is major issues (Instead of consulting a good psychiatrist), Lois moans about not finding the right man as if she was in the verge of being an old maid (Instead of worrying about her career-life without diplomas) and Clark moans about not being able to have a soulmate since he's in high school.

Mythos characters who are supposed to be notorious for who they are in the comics are promoted in Smallville as ''love interests'' (Green Arrow and Aquaman for Lois, Jimmy Olsen and Doomsday for Chloe...)

The characters aren't even 25 and they are either angsting about finding the right one, getting engaged, married and divorced.

Ones of the best comments I ever seen. I agree with you %100, I hate that almost all the time the roma stuff takes over from the Mythos. I started to watch Smallville because I'm a Superman fan dammit :\ I want more of that. Though to answer the question, I still don't know if "who is right for" is the right question but from the three guys I'll chose Jimmy hands down.

[KEGZilla]

Clark is the best for Chloe...she has always wanted Clark.

[Novak Fan]

I'm talking in general here,but sadly not always the person you want is the right for you :\

[borednow]

^ Ain't that the sad sad truth...

[mysticalweather]

Davis...well, knowing he's Doomsday inherently puts a crimp on any potential for romance they could've had.

As for Clark... as much as I like his friendship with Chloe, I just don't think they would make a good romantic couple. Their history has not always been a bed of roses. She betrayed him to Lionel, he admittedly kept her on the back burner in case his relationship with Lana didn't work out, ect... And IMO...she has coddled Clark waaay too much and she hero worships him. And to me these are things that just are not conducive to a strong romantic partnership.

I voted Jimmy. I think he really truly cares about Chloe, and she deserves someone who loves her wholly and puts her first.

[disciples of zod]

I voted Jimmy. I think he really truly cares about Chloe, and she deserves someone who loves her wholly and puts her first.

THANK YOU! SOMEONE FINALLY AGREES WITH ME!

~K:D

[Kal-El 2005]

Clark

[borednow]

THANK YOU! SOMEONE FINALLY AGREES WITH ME!

~K:D

I've been agreeing with you from the start of this thread! :lol:

[Inkpen23]

Clark, is the right person for Chloe. Clark really cares about Chloe and he wants her to be happy. He loves her deeply and he would do anything to make her happy. She brings out the best in him and he gives her a sense of purpose. He may be a big dumb alien, and use poor judgement at times, but deep down Chloe knows he's a good guy and a good man. So, yeah the right guy for Chloe out of the choices in the poll is Clark. Looks like the majority seems to agree that.:D

[kal-el_Girl]

clark all the way!! it has to be *keeps repeating in her head*

[SacredK]

When I think of personality I will go with Jimmy. Although I used to hope for Chloe and Clark. Minus the doom in Davis, I believe Chloe and Davis could work. There seems to be enough chemistry. However, how long would Chloe and Davis work for? Seems like Chloe and Jimmy have what it takes for a healthy and long lasting relationship. Who knows...

[Bizarrolover]

It's hard to chose because all this ships are unbalanced. Jimmy is completely devoted to Chloe, Chloe is devoted to Clark, Clark loves someone else, Davis is infatuaded with Chloe, Chloe likes Davis (though she barely knows him) but is engaged to jimmy. None of this relationships goes both ways with the same intensity.

As much as I like Jimmy, in my opinion, Chimmy, unfortunately, is doomed to fail, because Chloe can't cut with her obsession/devotion to Clark. She's more loyal to Clark than to her future husband. If given the choice, Chloe would go after Clark and leave Jimmy. The proof is what happened in 'Identity', when she stood by Clark's side instead of Jimmy's. When you are married, your husband comes first. I'm not saying that Chloe should expose Clark's secret, but, at this point she should ask him to keep her out of it before it damages her relationship with Jimmy. But it's obvious that that is never going to happen, so, in a way, Clark relieved her from that weight when he erased her memories about his true self. Right or wrong, he gave her the chance to live a happy life with her husband without the burden of his secret standing in between them.

Chloe's memories will return, I'm almost sure of that, so Chloe will have to try to make her marriage work and balance things between Jimmy and Clark. Ufortunately, I don't think that will be smooth ride for the newlyweds because, in my opinion, Chloe is not ready to give up on Clark and fully commit with her husband.

[superman07]

Here's my thoughts

Jimmy-he's probably best for Chloe as far as he loves her unconditionally, can take care of her, accepts her power, and does not put her in danger.
Clark-The one problem being that she is always endanger with him, hence the reason he erased her memory. Eventually that kind of stress would catch up with her and not be healthy. Besides I'm a Clois fan:)
Davis-If he were not Doomsday, I would like to see them together.

[Welling_is_pretty]

Clark-The one problem being that she is always endanger with him, hence the reason he erased her memory. Eventually that kind of stress would catch up with her and not be healthy. Besides I'm a Clois fan:)
See, this is usually the reason given why Clark never got involved with Lois in the comics "oh he'll put her in danger!". As many a fan pointed out she was already in danger because of her friendship and percieved relationship to Clark. Same reasoning stands for Chloe. She's already been through so much just as Clark's friend and didn't even get any smoochies (ok, maybe 1 a year!). If she is going to be in danger anyway she should at least get the girlfriend status too!

[Eurynome]

None of the above. I would say her cop finance in Apocalypse in right for Chloe. She seemed really happy even if it was Jor-El making stuff up.

Love the Davis-Chloe interaction, but he's a mass murderer. Chloe deserves better.

Jimmy is too fickle. One little thing doesn't go as planned, and he just dumps her and calls it quits then changes his mind when he can't find anyone else.

Chloe is over Clark. Beside, I'm mad at him for erasing her memories.

[ledzepfan23]

davis would be good if he wasnt a killer

[Firebunny]

Jimmy-he's probably best for Chloe as far as he loves her unconditionally, can take care of her, accepts her power, and does not put her in danger. I have to disagree with this. Jimmy does not love Chloe unconditionally. He got pissy when Chloe lost her memories of him before she lost her memories of Clark. (The poor girl had amnesia and he had to get mad at her about it.) He is not faithful to her (Kara, Maxima). He tried to get out of their engagement on two seperate occasions (Odyssey and Committed).

Jimmy is in no way shape or form the right guy for Chloe.

[alejandrita439]

i think the right boy for chloe is George, that one that appeared in the AU in Apocalypse :)

[rehana/chole]

amm still i am all for clark every thing he did was 2 make her better it heart breaking but i think i would have done the same 2 protect her he showed his love for chole an her best intrest come first he nev did that a lois or lana 2 protect then he rather leave then 2 there own death

[redheadluvgoddess]

Clark.

Is is even a question that needs to be asked? O_O They are the dynamic duo and bring out the absolute best in one another. All I could think when I watched this episode was how integral they are to each others' lives and how beautiful their relationship is.

Chlark FTW.

----- Added 6 Minutes later -----


I think the best person for Chloe is Clark. Davis is ok in his human form but he's also Doomsday so he's out. Jimmy is sweet and supportive and it's tempting to say him but he doesn't understand her like Clark does.

Clark challenges Chloe, he brings out the best side of her and he is her equal in many ways (and in many ways she's his superior). I've always contended that Chloe is the best partner (romantic or otherwise) that Clark could ever have. That Chloe is the blending of the best of both Lana and Lois into one blond spitfire. That makes her the best for Clark, IMO. But I also believe that he's the best for her.

Ummm... I love you. :) Your last paragraph reads like it came from my head. The first paragraph? Eh, nothing about Jimmy is tempting to me. But, since you came to the right conclusion in the end, yeah. You're awesome. Hehe :D

[Ayanne]

Clark & Chloe are each other's touchstones.

[koryaunka]

Jimmy! Jimmy is someone who Chloe can trust not to hurt her, because he has no hero complex, he's just a regular guy who she can grow old with. It's really cute how Jimmy treats her and talks about her. CHIMMY 4evr!

[disciples of zod]

Jimmy! Jimmy is someone who Chloe can trust not to hurt her, because he has no hero complex, he's just a regular guy who she can grow old with. It's really cute how Jimmy treats her and talks about her. CHIMMY 4evr!

i will second that! w00t w00t! :cool:

~K

[Clois4eva89]

I vote me

[battlecat403@yahoo.com]

Eh, I would have gone for "other" but I guess I'll stick with Jimmy even though I don't like what they have done with him this season. He was much sweeter and nicer last season, IMO.

[isagill chlark fan]

clark they belong together

[boredlittlestudent]

well... i am dissapointed with the way the chlark relationship has been going in the show... that was really the reason why i just couldnt vote for him... sorry... It is sickening that he still has a lana obsession... and i think not even lois lane can cure him of it... if it continues on like it does in the show...

then, sorry... but i dont like cute and cuddly... and that really is the reason why i didnt vote for jimmy... i think he is better suited with kara... for some reason alien women really did him... so I'm willing for him to be together with kara, but not chloe...

the truth is, i believe she needs someone who is just like her... not really 'ordinary', who shares her passion for helping people, and who knows at least some of her secrets... so really that was the reason why i voted for davis... that and his unbelievable shirtless scenes... *drool* ermmm... yes...

so i guess that really was my explanation ... davis!!! and i dont care that he becomes doomsday... in my happy little world, he doesnt... he is together with chloe, and they live happily ever after... now if only the SV writers would also understand that... *smirk*

[kal-el_Girl]

I can't help it, i love Chlark!

[Lori]

None of the above, Jimmy loved her more than she loved him and she always put Clark ahead of him, Davis turned out to be a murderer and Clark never loved Chloe the way she loved him. In short not one of these relationships were of equal balance.