Is Caroline Dries redeemed?

[bizzaroboy9]

Since she wrote such an awesome episode tonight, did she redeemed herself from writing the episode Toxic and Sleeper?

I think so. She wrote a fantastic episode!

[pizzahead2490]

she is redeemed

[Tatiana]

Yeah she totally is :)

[Meteror Freak]

NO! SHE CAN NEVER BE REDEEMED! NEVER! NEVER ! NEVER!

Just kidding. I actually loved sleeper (I guess I'm the only one on the face of the planet) Toxic was okay, and I'm still on the fence with this one. It was great but needed a lot more Kara. I still have faith in her writing though. She's awesome at quotes.

[pizzahead2490]

NO! SHE CAN NEVER BE REDEEMED! NEVER! NEVER ! NEVER!

Just kidding. I actually loved sleeper (I guess I'm the only one on the face of the planet) Toxic was okay, and I'm still on the fence with this one. It was great but needed a lot more Kara. I still have faith in her writing though. She's awesome at quotes.

ya i think u were the only one

[Kevin24]

NO! SHE CAN NEVER BE REDEEMED! NEVER! NEVER ! NEVER!

Just kidding. I actually loved sleeper (I guess I'm the only one on the face of the planet) Toxic was okay, and I'm still on the fence with this one. It was great but needed a lot more Kara. I still have faith in her writing though. She's awesome at quotes.

I enjoyed Sleeper too.

[svtwamedfan05]

Yeah have to say she redeemed herself with this one.

[kavalier]

She never needed redeeming in my book. She has written many quality episodes. I think she's just had to do her dues as a newer member of the writing team and take on the filler episodes. But this is the girl who wrote Cyborg, Oracle, Nemesis, Action, Gemini, and Apocalypse. If you ask me, all of those eps were solid. Dont you think?

[REebee52]

I don't know what the hate on Toxic is. I liked that episode, in my mind the weak point of the season was "Plastique"

[Karafan1]

I don't know what the hate on Toxic is. I liked that episode, in my mind the weak point of the season was "Plastique"


I agree..I liked "Toxic" and maybe my dislike for "Plastique" is because I'm tired of freak of the week episodes..

[yosemiteangel]

IDK about redeemed. I don't think she needed redeeming. Sleeper wasn't that bad and Toxic was good, but this episode kicked booty! :D

[kaam]

This episode was great, followed every other episode this season. I am very pleased

[AgentChaos]

NO! SHE CAN NEVER BE REDEEMED! NEVER! NEVER ! NEVER!

Just kidding. I actually loved sleeper (I guess I'm the only one on the face of the planet) Toxic was okay, and I'm still on the fence with this one. It was great but needed a lot more Kara. I still have faith in her writing though. She's awesome at quotes.

I liked Sleeper as well, especially the interrogation scene.

[costas22]

Why sould she need to be redeemed?Writers on this show are presented with a certain plotline from the showrunners.For instance,in Sleeper it wasn't her fault she couldn't use Clark a lot.In Toxic it wasn't her choice to have an episode about Oliver's past.She has also written Oracle which was a similar case to Bloodline.An episode that had to fit in a lot of stories.She did very well in both instances.

[smallvillefreak24]

sleeper wasn't completley horrible and i liked toxic so i guess yes but i dont think she needed redeeming

[baltazor]

That was one of the best episodes so far. To be perfectly honest when i read what this episode would be i was a little disappointed. So i guess she is redeemed.

[alejandrita439]

i like how she wrote this episode :)

[faz]

I enjoyed Toxic too, minus the whole thing where they felt they had to tie Oliver and Tess together through some bogus storyline when Oliver was on the island. Plastique was definitely the low point of the season, but even that episode wasn't by any means terrible.

As for Sleeper, that episode was just awful. The general concept wasn't terrible, but no one buys Jimmy Olsen as some James Bond super-spy character.

[Clana Kent]

I actually liked Sleeper... I thought it was kinda cool that Jimmy went undercover!

This is to everybody who says that Clark didn't have a lot of screentime in Sleeper:
This series is NOT only about Clark, you know.. it's about all the others as well! That's why they called it "Smallville" and not "Clark Kent" or something...

In the alternate universe I'm writing will be a completely Clark-free episode, cool heh :cool:

[4Clana]

NO! SHE CAN NEVER BE REDEEMED! NEVER! NEVER ! NEVER!

Just kidding. I actually loved sleeper (I guess I'm the only one on the face of the planet) Toxic was okay, and I'm still on the fence with this one. It was great but needed a lot more Kara. I still have faith in her writing though. She's awesome at quotes.
I loved sleeper too! It's just people who complain make the most noise. But Jimmy has his fans too, and seeing Jimmy going undercover was alot of fun!

[ClarkyBoy14]

I'm with the ones who feel she didn't need to be redeemed. Yes, "Sleeper" was horrible, but it wasn't all her fault. She's had several good episodes, as well. And "Toxic" wasn't bad, IMO. It just wasn't great.

[skylar]

She never needed redeeming in my book. She has written many quality episodes. I think she's just had to do her dues as a newer member of the writing team and take on the filler episodes. But this is the girl who wrote Cyborg, Oracle, Nemesis, Action, Gemini, and Apocalypse. If you ask me, all of those eps were solid. Dont you think?


All good ones!!

[Iluvgreen]

Toxic wasn't THAT bad... But yes she did. This episode was amazing.